Deadliest Battleline!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Demian

Vampire Count
True Blood
Oct 28, 2011
1,245
Zombies
1,274
So I couldn't resist and wanted to know which of our Battleline units is the deadliest. I wanted to see if a numerous army with almost no pricey units and some Heroes could make for a lethal formation that would inflict as many wounds as possible while using our lowest troops.

So... here are my findings:

CONSIDERATIONS: These results are for MAX model count per unit and as many buffs you can give them WITHOUT Danse Macabre, since all Battleline units can benefit from it. I took into account Spell buffs and Command Ability Buffs as well, as many as I could give them. Also, I included in my calculations their "self-buffs" which they gain for being near a Hero and their other own abilities.

--------------------------------------------------
40 Skeleton Warriors with Spears
Self-buffed
~30 wounds before SAVES costing 320pts
~40 wounds with Lord of Bones / Blood Feast (+1 attacks), ~420pts
~46 wounds adding Righteous Smiting to +1 attacks, ~540pts

~39 wounds with My Will be Done (+1 to Hit), 420pts
~52 wounds adding Righteous Smiting to +1 to Hit, 540pts

~45 wounds with Dread Knight (re-rolls to hit) at 720pts
~52 wounds adding Righteous Smiting to Re-rolls to hit, at 840pts (INNEFICIENT)


A Wight King or a Vampire Lord are marginally better than a Tomb King when buffing them, however, once we add Righteous Smiting (the only Spell that can buff the unit, besides Danse) their damage output increases significanlty.

Settra's Curse

~52 wounds while buffed with Settra, at 680pts
~67 wounds while adding a Tomb King's extra command ability at 780pts
~98 wounds while also adding a Liche Priest's Righteous Smiting at 900pts

Most impresive. Almost twice as deadly for almost twice the price of a traditional Deathrattle Army setup, while bearing in mind Settra's Command Ability affects every DEATH unit nearby, which makes Spirit Hosts viable and other Deathrattle units such as Grave Guard / Tomb Guard and Necropolis Knights become deadliest of all the elites without even needing a buff from another Tomb King.

-----------------------------------------------------
60 Zombies
Self-buffed
~26 Wounds before SAVES costing 360pts
~32 wounds with a Corpse Cart nearby, 420pts
~65 wounds adding Blood Feast (+1 attacks) and the Cart, at 560pts
~38 wounds adding Dread Knight (re-rolls to hit) and the Cart, at 820pts

With limited buffs, but the support of a Cart and a Vampire Lord, Zombies need no spells to increase their damage output by a ton... the problem is, they may not all get to attack a target, due to their small range and hughe model count. Still, if you manage to tag your enemy's entire army with them, they'll have to save some 65 wounds and that is quite a lot considering you're just using 560 pts.


------------------------------------------------------

40 Crypt Ghouls
Self-buffed
~34 wounds before SAVES costing 400pts
~46 wounds when a Ghast uses his Trophy Hunter ability, at 480pts
~46 wounds with Black Hunger is cast by a Ghoul King, at 500pts
~58 wounds with BOTH Trophy Hunter and Black Hunger, at 580pts
~87 wounds with the above AND Feeding Frenzy cast on them, at 980pts
~69 wounds with Black Hunger, Trophy Hunter and Blood Feast (as many +1 attacks as possible), at 720pts

~104 wounds with all 3 extra attacks given, and Feeding Frenzy cast at them, for a total of 1,120pts

A Ghast Courtier and an Abhorrant Ghoul King is your standard-sized army, which deal quite a lot of pain for only 580pts, which is just below the Zombies's ~65 wounds at 560, and yet you need to trigger Trophy Hunter and that is going to be a problem. However, Ghouls's dmage output can skyrocket once you decide to add yet another attack to them with Blood Feast using a regular Vampire Lord as your general, which seems not a bad idea, at 720pts with the same problem of Trophy Hunter.

Only a madman would like to use these many conditions, AND still cast Feeding Frenzy, making Ghouls hit the hardest of 104 wounds with their Maximum amount of buffs they can, but at 1,120pts.

Will soon add Skeleton Chariots and the like from Tomb Kings, however, with our "original" Battleline units, now you get an idea of how much pain can they inflict... so don't hesitate to make Vanguards taking this into account!

Skeletons - are the most stable and have the BEST formation for 40 models, thanks to their spears. They would've fared a lot better if you used Swords, but they would fail to concentrate attacks at single units and would lose efficiency in combat. They only need 1 Command Ability and 1 Spell to maximize their damage. Tomb Kings > Wight Kings when using Righteous Smiting

Zombies - need a huge amount of models, and by that logic, they can deal more wounds than Skeletons. The best part? they don't need any Spells to function well above others without spells.

Ghouls - have the most variety of buffs to be cast on them, saddly, this makes them very hard to combo, but can deal insane amounts of damage with only 40 models. They need 1 Command Ability and up to 2 spells plus a Ghast killing something before they do to deal so much damage Archaon will Die, Ressurrect and die immediatelly die again, before he dares challenge the Ghoul King's rule.


NOTE: I did not take into account SETTRA and several Tomb Kings + Righteous Smiting... that should be fun! haha.

That is all for now! Feel free to check my "math" and make corrections to this!
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure its right to leave danse aside. Yes, it affects all of these units in basically equal ways so it isn't really a vital comparative choice, but it's also pretty much the strongest buff we have available, which means you want want to have a necromancer around, and that will affect your list.

For instance, with skeletons, the buff from a tomb king is better than that from a wight king if and only if you're using a liche priest to cast righteous smiting on them. However, in 1,000 point vanguard lists you may not want to buy both a liche priest and a necromancer. If you're only getting one or the other, then you want the necromancer, and if you're not fielding a liche priest then you'd rather have the wight king than the tomb king


Also, in my experience, you're not going to get much more than a dozen models from a given unit into combat, not quite twice that with reach. This is relevant for, for example, ghouls. Without outside buffs, 2 units of 10 ghouls may put out more attacks than one unit of 20, if being in separate units lets you get more into combat. With unit-targeted buffs, of course, fewer attacks coming from a single unit will again be superior, but if you're trying to fill battle line requirements cheaper, minimum strength units aren't always the wrong way to go, particularly if spending less on smaller ghoul units lets you spend more on a larger horror or flayer unit that you can then target with your buffs instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oppenheimer
I'm guessing morgasts or blood knights would probably be the most powerful but I know they don't really count in this example.
 
I will make these examples with all units, both Min and Max unit sizes!

I wanted to post Battleline units because they seem lik the most underrated, hehe.

As for engaging units in combat and models:

Both Skeletons and Zombies have Musicians, which can make every model move up to 6'' while charging, allowing them to easilly surround any unit (think a... 20-man, or a 3-man Monstrous Infantry. Yeah that is from 8th ed, I don't care haha)

Each tiny model can fight in 2 ranks with their 1'' attack range, and Spears can fight in 3!, It is very easy to tag at least half your unit against something that tiny, and something that tiny (Crypt Horrors, if you like) will die by sustaining ~20 wounds from skeletons with Lord of Bones. Easily.

Ghouls are the problem here, but they have so many attacks each, you can form them 12-wide and 3 deep, allowing for them to pile in and maybe get the last line to hit.

A standard Cavalry unit of 5 models will get surrounded with a 6'' or more charge move + pile in easily. Also, if you happen to charge more than 1 unit, you won't be losing so many attacks, I think.
 
Morgasts and bloodknights are battleline if you take the right faction. But, I'm glad to see the always battleline units get some more detail :-)
 
We just have to consider that, with their Max unit, those models are quite big and, as Malisteen says, not all of them will be able to attack, save for a large unit as well.

I am not considering Danse Macabre, but looking at the points, fitting a Necromancer in any of those lists should be a piece of cake, specially the Skeleton ones with only 540 pts spent out of 1000, with another Zombie unit plus a Necromancer, they would be at 720 with all Battleline tax filled, 3 Heroes and enough points for fielding Necro Knights or even Morghasts.

Or a Casket of Souls, or a Catapult + Necrotect if you want to harass things and wait for them to come to you.
 
Considering that the minimum distance between hostile units that are not already engaged in melee is 3", 6" is, in fact, not a terribly great distance at all, and in no way guarantees that you're going to be able to surround anything in my experience, and piling in, while slightly helpful, is not very effective at surrounding enemy models due to the requirement that each model piling in must end their move closer to the specific enemy model which they were already closest to when they started their move. Not closer to the nearest enemy unit, but to the specific model. A model in your back rank simply will not be able to move around to the outside to get to the flank of an enemy unit.

You can stretch out wide, in the hope of enveloping enemies that way, or at least meet wide fronts that way, but this opens you up to two critical weaknesses. The first is that your wide front can end up fighting multiple enemy units, which can severely hamper the number of attacks you can direct at any one particular target.

The far more serious threat is that you can end up out-maneuvered and engaged on a flank. If this happens, much of your unit won't be able to reach the enemy with a single pile in move. It might take 2 or even more moves. And the issue of your own models getting in the way due to the 'must end closer to already closest enemy' gets even more severe.

In fact, a wide strung out unit engaged in the flank may find that its far flank is closer to some entirely unrelated non-engaging enemy unit, in which case those furthest models may not be able to pile in towards combat at all, since pile in would require them to move AWAY from the combat, and the whole unit must maintain coherency during pile in or else NONE of your models may pile in.

A variant of the second threat is a pincir attack, where your long strung out unit is engaged on both flanks, and all the models in the middle are unable to strike AND unable to consolidate towards either combat without breaking coherency, and thus at least one string of models from one combat to the other cannot consolidate at all.


So your choices end up being - blob up and risk getting in your own way, or spread out and risk getting engaged in a severely one sided combat on one or both of your flanks.


The right way to go with large units will depend on the opponent (does he have fast or numerous enough units to force a flank combat), the terrain (can you wall off flanks with some impassible obstacle), game objectives (can your unit hug a board edge, or will you be forced to the center), etc, and within the same list may vary from game to game, but in general big units are expensive and slow to maneuver, and if you're fielding bigger units than your opponents, then there's a fair chance that your opponent is fielding more units than you, or faster ones, and blocking up to keep your flanks from being a major weakness may be necessary.


This on top of the fact that getting the most out of big block units inevitably revolves around unit-targeted buffs, at least in Death armies, and those buffs generally come from fragile characters. If you're faced with strong shooting attacks, well, you're kinda boned anyway (heehee), but support heroes that are merely behind your line are vulnerable to ambush (think tomb scorpions) or outflanking/flying opponents. The safest place for such support heroes will often be in the middle of a big blob of infantry wide enough on all sides to prevent enemy units from engaging the hero (by necessity with an opening to let the hero move back into the unit after the unit moves), which cannot be done if you're spreading wide to try and maximize forward attacks.

My experience remains that you can't really reliably place more than a dozen or so infantry models of a unit in combat, or 20ish with reach, assuming that you're either using current base sizes or approximating them, and that you aren't standing models on each others' bases.
 
All my models are on square based but I can usually manage to get 30 of my 40 skeletons (with spear) in combat against a large enough unit... much less against smaller unit though.
 
I understand!

Using large units of ~40 models is not an a point and click unit as Deathstars used to be in 8th. You need to plan ahead and ensure you charge and position your troops exactly the way you need them to be, and that requires you having a flanker unit (Necropolis Knights or even Black Knights) to block any attempts to bait you into a one sided combat that you can't win.

If ever you find that you're being picked appart and can't fight properly, retreat! Not many people wish to relent their assault and re-form when they have this kind of fighting power, but as you say, if your oponent has faster units and is trying to engage you in two flanks, you really need to reform, regroup and turtle. That way he has to charge at you with your combined force grouped an ready to slaughter 1 of their units.

Plus, if you tag 2+ enemy units and have a chance to strike at all of them, it is not such a bad idea, to hurt all of them before each gets to strike. If you somehow end up against an elite unit and kills many of your troops, you can remove models that are engaged to others, leaving them without an enemy by the time they get to strike. Not foolproof, but one must attend to all quirks of handling a large unit!
 
The square bases are technically legal for now, but are significantly smaller than the current round base sizes, allowing you to fit many more models of a large unit into combat, and gaining a significant mechanical advantage. As time goes on, using the old bases will become less and less acceptable.
 
Well the rules state that it's the model that count, not the base so while it's annoying, it's perfectly legal to overlap your round bases to get more model into attack range. Square bases just make it easier to do it.
 
I understand the core rules count only the model, and even so, some models like Archai can easily reach almost anything without being remotely close.

However, as we play it, we count the base size, since it makes much more sense to us, and looking at round bases, you get the same amount of models in contact, with 25mm round bases, which is 1 mm short of the 1'' attack range, and thus, you get to attack in 2 ranks, exactly as you'd do with 20mm square bases and 25mm square bases from the former Warriors of Chaos and other "big normal infantry"

If you're using spears, you ALSO get to strike with the 3rd rank as 2'' attack range is barely but noticeable beyond the two 25mm round base's length. Even the former Orcs would still get to attack in 3 ranks with weapons that have a 2'' range, so there is abslutely no reason at all for you to change the mechanics of the game based on round or square bases.

If you were to encounter an opponent that says otherwise and you absolutely can't prove this information right, you can interlock your round bases and get the same amount of attacks out of a formation:

OOOOO
.OOOOO
OOOOO

Crude, but necessary in times of need.
 
Double Posting here to inform you all that Settra has been taken into account in the Deathrattle battlelines, and he seems quite a force to be reckoned, and his Army may even be one of the deadliest we can muster, including Him, a Tomb King, a Liche Priest, a Necromancer and Skeletons as Battleline, leaving the "rest" for all of our elites, such as Grave Guard, Necro Knights and even Spirit Hosts, having a very reliable recursion from the Deathrattlers, while also having the speed to go and pummel those gunlines in the face with torpedo charges from the Incantation of the Dessert Wind, as well as a Battleline that can take on anything and Elites that almost auto-hit and wound mercilessly and a Righteous Smiting activating on a 4+. This is cheesy, but well-deserved for our most seasoned and experienced general (aside from Vlad, who I worship hehe)

Would you like to see how he would perform in other sub-factions like Flesh-Eaters and Deadwalkers?
 
Double Posting here to inform you all that Settra has been taken into account in the Deathrattle battlelines, and he seems quite a force to be reckoned, and his Army may even be one of the deadliest we can muster, including Him, a Tomb King, a Liche Priest, a Necromancer and Skeletons as Battleline, leaving the "rest" for all of our elites, such as Grave Guard, Necro Knights and even Spirit Hosts, having a very reliable recursion from the Deathrattlers, while also having the speed to go and pummel those gunlines in the face with torpedo charges from the Incantation of the Dessert Wind, as well as a Battleline that can take on anything and Elites that almost auto-hit and wound mercilessly and a Righteous Smiting activating on a 4+. This is cheesy, but well-deserved for our most seasoned and experienced general (aside from Vlad, who I worship hehe)

Would you like to see how he would perform in other sub-factions like Flesh-Eaters and Deadwalkers?

I would, I would!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu