Death necro and LD query.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Thindol

Grave Guard
Oct 16, 2010
204
Hamilton, Ontario
Zombies
120
OK. So I thought of something that I don't know if it is a legal play.

Level 2 death necro and a wight king inside a skeleton unit with the banner of discipline.

My understanding is now the necro has a LD of 10; 9 base for the WK and +1 for the banner. Am I playing this right? I read the BRB and under Characteristic and Leadership tests it says to use the highest leadership in the unit, pg 10. (Pg 10 in the small rule book anyways.)

I am using this as a secondary snipe unit as my general is mounted and I want to run him about.
 
The Wight King is LD 9, but the standard makes that 10. The Necromancer is in the unit and so has a modified LD of 10 too.

However the Death spell states to use his unmodified LD which is 7.

However, this sounds like something that has been FAQ'd so someone else might have a more positive answer for you. Otherwise, mini necro death snipers aren't all that great?
 
The FAQ messed up what unmodified leadership should logically be.

Q: When taking a Leadership test, sometimes you have to take it on your unmodified Leadership. What is your unmodified Leadership? (p10)
A: Your unmodified Leadership is the highest Leadership characteristic in the unit. So the Leadership from any characters in the unit itself (but not from outside the unit, from
Inspiring Presence for example) with a higher Leadership can be used unless specifically stated otherwise.


So you can use the Wight King's Ld9 for Death sniping. Not sure about the banner, but since it's also part of the unit, it should count towards "unmodified" leadership. Either way, that's better than the necro's base Ld.
 
you can use genearls inspiring presence for Spirit leech, so if you hav e avamp lord near by, your baby necros would have ld 10 aswell,

Its in the FAQ
 
Using the banner and WK work, as you use the unit's LD, which would then be 10.

But, as Prince said, if you just are w/i 12" of your Lord you can use his/her 10 as well.
 
Bane said:
Using the banner and WK work, as you use the unit's LD, which would then be 10.

But, as Prince said, if you just are w/i 12" of your Lord you can use his/her 10 as well.

This is sadly wrong that would be an actual modification, I know they (GW) by now has totally dismantled what unmodified Ld is but this does not fly. :(

Q: When taking a Leadership test, sometimes you have to take it on your unmodified Leadership. What is your unmodified Leadership? (p10)
A: Your unmodified Leadership is the highest Leadership characteristic in the unit. So the Leadership from any characters in the unit itself (but not from outside the unit, from Inspiring Presence for example) with a higher Leadership can be used unless specifically stated otherwise.

Q: Do units benefit from their General’s Inspiring Presence for the purposes of spells that use Leadership, such as Spirit Leech or Okkam’s Mindrazor? (p107)
A: Yes.

The first states that it is the highest Ld characteristic in said unit which does not include the banner or other Ld modifications. The second is from the newest FAQ, contradicts the example made in the first but just states that IP can be used for Spirit Leech and Okkam's Mindrazor..
 
Bullhax said:
This is sadly wrong that would be an actual modification, I know they (GW) by now has totally dismantled what unmodified Ld is but this does not fly. :(

Q: When taking a Leadership test, sometimes you have to take it on your unmodified Leadership. What is your unmodified Leadership? (p10)
A: Your unmodified Leadership is the highest Leadership characteristic in the unit. So the Leadership from any characters in the unit itself (but not from outside the unit, from Inspiring Presence for example) with a higher Leadership can be used unless specifically stated otherwise.

Q: Do units benefit from their General’s Inspiring Presence for the purposes of spells that use Leadership, such as Spirit Leech or Okkam’s Mindrazor? (p107)
A: Yes.

The first states that it is the highest Ld characteristic in said unit which does not include the banner or other Ld modifications. The second is from the newest FAQ, contradicts the example made in the first but just states that IP can be used for Spirit Leech and Okkam's Mindrazor..

You might want to read all of the FAQ instead of just part of it,
"So the Leadership from any characters in the unit itself (but not from outside the unit, from Inspiring Presence for example) with a higher Leadership can be used unless specifically stated otherwise."

And it specifically says you can use IP for the purpose of LD in spells, it does not contradict, it follows the rules set out by the first one.
 
But the original question was regarding the banner of discipline which doesn't let you use IP; secondly the banner would be modifying the LD of the WK. However as his LD unmodified is 9 and the highest in the unit the death necro would use 9 as his LD. Right? Are we all saying the same thing but in different ways?
 
You are allowed to modify the LD all you want as long as it is not from a source outside the unit, IP for spells being the exception. So since the banner is inside the unit the WK LD is modified to a 10, but because its not from an outside source the necro can use the LD 10 as its unmodified.
 
TinTip said:
You are allowed to modify the LD all you want as long as it is not from a source outside the unit, IP for spells being the exception. So since the banner is inside the unit the WK LD is modified to a 10, but because its not from an outside source the necro can use the LD 10 as its unmodified.

You are contradicting yourself. Adding +1 to leadership from any source, in this case the banner, is modifying the leadership so it cannot be unmodified.

The banner will not work if testing on unmodified leadership because its changing his leadership value
 
geordieclubba said:
TinTip said:
You are allowed to modify the LD all you want as long as it is not from a source outside the unit, IP for spells being the exception. So since the banner is inside the unit the WK LD is modified to a 10, but because its not from an outside source the necro can use the LD 10 as its unmodified.

You are contradicting yourself. Adding +1 to leadership from any source, in this case the banner, is modifying the leadership so it cannot be unmodified.

The banner will not work if testing on unmodified leadership because its changing his leadership value

Except its from within the unit, which is all that matters for unmodified, so the banner does apply. Nothing in my previous statement contradicts itself
 
In the beginning of the rulebook adding or subtracting from a characteristics is described as a modification. So while you can discuss a lot about using another model's leadership characteristic or not, you cannot apply actual modifiers (+1 or -3) when testing against an unmodified characteristic.
Therefore things like Banner of Discipline or Doom and Darkness would have no effect.
 
Games Workshop has completely boinked the meaning of the word "unmodified" for Spirit Leech.
With their most recent FAQ'ing on the subject they've created even less clarity about which or what leadership you may use.
In my eyes, unmodified means "as represented on it's profile", but no, things has to be over complicated.

If you were to field a Wight King BSB with Banner of Discipline and have a Necromancer General with LD7 in the same unit, his inspiring presence would be LD10, right?
As per FAQ, you can use the General's inspiring presence when using Spirit Leech, so going by the same train of thought, why couldn't you use that same Wight King and
put it in a unit full of LD7 Death Necromancers and have them benefit from the Wight King's LD10 (with the banner).

As per the new(er) FAQ'd up RAW, some things have become even less clearer than they were, so going by "what makes sense" I'd say you can use the Wight King's LD modified with the Banner in the same way as you'd use a "Modified" inspiring presence from your General.

HOWEVER:
If we're going to further look into this matter, a Vampire BSB wearing the Banner of Discipline would modify it's OWN leadership if it's running alone outside of the range of the General.
There are no sources to get an otherwise better leadership that his own other than the Banner, which would mean he'd test against his own unmodified leadership on his profile.

Inspiring presence or using the highest leadership in the unit do not provide "literal" bonuses to an attribute, it only adds the benefit of being able to use a different leadership than your own.
Or at least, that's how I interpret it, my 2 cents, feel free to disagree.
Me and friends have stumbled upon the Spirit Leech shenanigans way too often and have dug shallow and deep in order to find the best way to interpret "unmodified" as far as the FAQ goes and we've found that what I've mentioned above works best for us.
 
Smogg said:
In the beginning of the rulebook adding or subtracting from a characteristics is described as a modification. So while you can discuss a lot about using another model's leadership characteristic or not, you cannot apply actual modifiers (+1 or -3) when testing against an unmodified characteristic.
Therefore things like Banner of Discipline or Doom and Darkness would have no effect.

The FAQ about unmodified only states that "Your unmodified Leadership is the highest Leadership characteristic in the unit."
can you please point out what part that says you cant use modifiers from inside the unit
 
Sure, whem I get home to my book I will be happy to point out why you cannot use any modifiers at all no matter if they are inside or outside the unit.
 
On page 7 they explain modifying die rolls. Modifying is described as adding, subtracting or multiplying.

And I could further argue that the FAQ does not overrule this. Using the highest Leadership characteristic refers to the printed stat, and that this is further confirmed by the naming... Unmodified Leadership

So I could just as well ask you to print out the part that lets you modify your Leadership characteristic.

When they write Unmodified Leadership, its a given that you cannot modify your leadership by adding, subtracting or multiplying it. However using another model's leadership is not necessarily a modification. Using another model's leadership is what GW has tried to resolve in the FAQ, and they failed completely.
 
I always treated it as "highest printed LD in the unit," meaning LD9 for the Wight or 10 for a VC Lord, without using the Banner for the extra +1.

- Larry
 
I think Smogg has written it the clearest, for me at least.

However, there are still views that disagree, which reaffirms the importance of discussing certain things before a game. Saying that, It would be impractical, so something like this I would hope if debate still raged on my opponent would agree to roll for it...

Shall we roll for it?
 
Smogg said:
On page 7 they explain modifying die rolls. Modifying is described as adding, subtracting or multiplying.

And I could further argue that the FAQ does not overrule this. Using the highest Leadership characteristic refers to the printed stat, and that this is further confirmed by the naming... Unmodified Leadership

So I could just as well ask you to print out the part that lets you modify your Leadership characteristic.

When they write Unmodified Leadership, its a given that you cannot modify your leadership by adding, subtracting or multiplying it. However using another model's leadership is not necessarily a modification. Using another model's leadership is what GW has tried to resolve in the FAQ, and they failed completely.

its right here
"Your unmodified Leadership is the highest Leadership
characteristic in the unit"
no where does it say your highest printed Leadership characteristic in the unit, simply the highest characteristic.
Im not arguing that the banner doesn't modify the leadership, it does, however it does it within the boundaries the GW has allowed to measure unmodified leadership.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu