Dispel Scroll: Yes or No?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Hey Guys,

your very favourite zombie has a question to all experienced bloodsuckers out there.

As i browse army lists here on CN, i noticed only few lists run a dispel scroll. In the group i play with, its a given in every list.o.o
Is a dispel scroll vital nowadays or can other bits n pieces cover for its abscence?

Cheers for all commentsxD
 
I don't know if you really have to take one. Typically, people will just take a Necromancer as a "scroll caddy" because you don't want your Vampires to waste 25 points on a one-use automatic dispel.

However, I just don't like to run Necromancers. I prefer to stock my list with Wight Kings for extra combat power and let my Lord do the casting. There are plenty of arguments for taking a Dispel Scroll, but I just don't like to. It's a personal choice, and I'm sure you could make a substantially powerful army list with or without one.
 
In 7th it was one of the first things to go in my list. In 8th it's something I take if I have points to spare.

I would definitely recommend taking one before you start adding "toys" in, but at the same time I've found I can often get away with not having one. The chances are if somebody REALLY wants to cast a spell, they will find a way to cast it with iresistable force. Of course, this doesn't mean you shouldn't take a dispel scroll if you are able to, only that you should bear in mind that it can't always stop a crucial spell getting off.

The main problem with taking a dispel scroll of course is that you either have to sacrifice space on a vampire or take a necromancer to carry it. Neither is a particularly attractive option, but I would personally go for the necromancer and give him danse macabre as a fall back caster.
 
i take them alot out of habit, but with the winds being more random, i find i dont take them as much anymore.
 
I don't. Sometimes I wish I did, but a lot of the time the Black Coach is sufficient. In fact, the only time in recent games where I really truly regretted not taking a dispell scroll is my last game against Warriors of Chaos and he played with Vilich.
 
Lord Fear said:
Every list, every time, without question, for me.

I concur with this as well.

People used to be able to take as many as they had space/points for. Taking 3-4 scrolls was quite common in tourneys.

So, FOR SURE I'm taking the one that I'm allowed to take... every time!
 
me too every time unless playing dwarves. i like to put it on my secondary wizard (necro if playing vc's). i found i used to bring it and then never think the spell was worth despelling incase a better one came along but now i think screw it i have a get out of jail free card and i am going to use it! so it gets used in every game.
 
I'll throw in a yes.

It never hurts, it's always worth it, and it's always useful, as long as your opponent has any magic. There's a lot worse you can do with 25 pts.

For the record, I don't take it in every single list, but I often regret it when I don't.
 
I would take it yes. There is generally that critical spell that you need to stop just at the right point. For 25pts, there is not much else you can get that can be so game changing.
 
I always take one on a Necromancer(not played many games so far).

Seems like a must have item to me, as I don't build list for individual games but have a single list to be used vs whatever.

IMHO all wargames would be better if people didn't tailor list to opponents armies.
 
I rarely take a dispell scroll, if there is any spell i am worried about not being able to dispell, it is probably going to end up being irrisistable anyway, this is if you are taking a level 4 however
 
If I can fit it in without messing with my other battle plans I will, I dont like taking a necro caddy just to carry a dispel scroll, its an expensive addition for little to show. I also usually cut my heros down to the essential until I get to about 2500, I only take 1 vamp and it has my helm of commandment so cant fit the dispel scroll in, and my lord is usually trying to take earthing rod to save is arse.

The only time I really take a dispel scroll is when I dont have Vanhel's in my list at all so taking the necro is worth it and might as well equip him with a dispel scroll.
 
i mostly play against magic heavy armies, so its allmost in every list.
i allso feel that the fact that we dont get alot of extra dispell dice from anywhere, makes it even more usefull.
 
Dispel Scroll allows you to take initiative during your opponent's turn, and as such it is of great value.
Also a "NO" at your disposal worths more than a mere 25 points. If I could I would buy a second one too
 
Nepenthe said:
Dispel Scroll allows you to take initiative during your opponent's turn, and as such it is of great value.
Also a "NO" at your disposal worths more than a mere 25 points. If I could I would buy a second one too

There's a reason that people use to take 3+ scrolls in previous editions. In a tourney I went up against someone that had FIVE scrolls!! I couldn't believe it! It's not like I was magic heavy either, using my Brets. With only 2 hero casters, I simply couldn't get anything through at all!

I fully intend on taking 2 with my Brets next time I play them (well, one dispel scroll and the silver mirror).... simply because I can!! :D
 
counting the yes and no's it seems that most people take I dispel scroll. I also take take a dispel scroll in every battle as well as earthing rod.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu