Do you think metal models should be phased out?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Oronare
  • Start date Start date
  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I'm with Bug and Dark Sheep on this one.

I prefer metal above plastic any day.

Don't get me wrong. Yes they do a fine job with the new plastic range these days. But somehow metal figures, for me, give that something extra/special.
Plastics give me that 'disposable-feel'.
I know, plastics are great for conversion. But on the other hand where has GW's input gone? They're producing plastics in large amounts to press the costs for them. From an economic perspective that's fine by me. However we are still paying too much this range.
Back in the old days they made an effort to make the modles look fine. Nowadays I have the feeling GW is just massproducing things.

Also, though I prefer metal I'm not entirely happy with the new metal range. GW doesn't seem to bother anymore to properly finishing their miniatures - mould lines and the like.

Moreover, where are the dynamic looks. Grave guards, skellies, corsairs, ghouls. Although they may be quite detailed, they are all in the same - boring - position. It's like they have found a few pennies on the floor.

Yours
B
 
Bug, still only an opinion what you think looks good/bad. Of course individual metals will look "more detailed" since they are unique. However looking at the new plastic kits(daemon prince and the 40k csm termie lord for example) you cant really deny those are a pretty well sculpted. The level of detail of the dwarf minis though, I will concede, isnt the best. Still they look like dwarfs should. Beards, beer and armour!

Though a question to those who complain about static poses, have a look at the old metal regiments. Atleast we dont get the same 3 clones repeated over and over. You can do enlessly more with for example a box of GG today than before and the new skeletons look a whole lot better. No matter which way you go if wont find diversity in regiment boxes as the regiment in game would be very confusing. There is a reason even though they can make them more varied they stay roughly the same. So, the question. Do you think metals would improve on this and in what way?

As for the phasing out part, I dont particularly care. I just hope GW continue to produce quality plastic minis for me to rip apart and convert into my own image.
Looking forward to the skaven release, gonna get me a box or two to create some skaven/ghoul clones.
 
Danceman said:
Bug, still only an opinion what you think looks good/bad.

Absolutely. But the OP wanted opinions..

Of course individual metals will look "more detailed" since they are unique.

Yep!

However looking at the new plastic kits(daemon prince and the 40k csm termie lord for example) you cant really deny those are a pretty well sculpted. The level of detail of the dwarf minis though, I will concede, isnt the best. Still they look like dwarfs should. Beards, beer and armour!

But that's still only an opinion on what you think looks good/bad. ;)

Though a question to those who complain about static poses, have a look at the old metal regiments. Atleast we dont get the same 3 clones repeated over and over. You can do enlessly more with for example a box of GG today than before and the new skeletons look a whole lot better. No matter which way you go if wont find diversity in regiment boxes as the regiment in game would be very confusing. There is a reason even though they can make them more varied they stay roughly the same. So, the question. Do you think metals would improve on this and in what way?

Metals, in the mid 80's and early 90's were, on the whole, very individual sculpts allowing you to create characterful and diverse units. If people wanted uniformity for a unit then they would buy 2-3 of the same figure for the entire unit. If people wanted less uniformity then they could buy 30-40 (depending on the range) individual sculpts for a unit.

You only have to see the few of us on here who own a lot of figures from the mid 80's and all of our armies look completely different to each other even though we cross over using the same figures from the old Undead range.

In the mid 90's "red" period we started to get very samey sculpts in both the metal and plastic ranges for core units. E.g. 4th/5th edition DE/HE warriors with spears. On the whole they were very average sculpts in both metal and plastic.

Because GW are deliberately phasing metal units out with plastic it becomes harder for people to use GW metals to create varied units using merely the metals. Obviously 6th edition saw GW cut the variations of metal figures down to 3 variations for a core unit. (I will say is that the 6th edition metal DE Corsairs are wonderfully characterful sculpts that capture the feel of the unit far better than the current plastic DE Corsairs that have some really badly sculpted heads!)

Anyhow, what I'm rambling towards, and I think this is what you're aiming for me to say, is that the plastics offer you the customisation and the metals offer you the detail. So you pay your money and you take your choice.

As for the phasing out part, I dont particularly care. I just hope GW continue to produce quality plastic minis for me to rip apart and convert into my own image.

Fair enough! I prefer detailed figures over figures that I might convert.

I really think that this would be much more easy to discuss in person down the pub! :)
 
Yepp, I agree. Often you end up talking past each other on forums.

My point on opinions was that even though the may look good/bad they still, even if plastic, got a high level of detail. And with ghouls even though not possessing a whole lot of detail they are adequete as far infantry boxes go.

But yeah, lets just be happy we've got the option to buy both kinds(although damn you GW for not making the out blood knights plastic!... wait nevermind, I'll just use chaos knights! :P )
 
Why don't they just sculpt the same metal models, in plastic?! are they still just too detailed even now?

i'd love come plastic Blood Knights but in the same mould :D would be amazing!
 
I don't mind metal models to be honest, yeah they're a pain in the ass, but they've got some very good detail. I like to mix and match my scratch built characters with metal And plastic (metal to the bottom), so they don't fall over when I'm finished with them ;) Saying that, metal prices means I use scrap pieces of ancient models. Nothing beats a servitor leg for extreme bionics on a Chaos Space Marine Lord! I'm mainly a converter so I'm alright with most metals (EXCEPT Ork deff dreads *Shudder* Worst model ever cast)

My plastic wish-list:
Black knights
Fell Bats (Just coz I Love the idea!)
More zombies. Maybe that should be first :P
Great Unclean One
Nurgle Heralds
Seekers of Slaanesh
Old Daemonettes in plastic form (Coz they so kicked the new ones asses)
Abaddon the Despoiler (he needs a new sword, claw and pony tail)
Heavy weapons on CSM
Plague Marines
Daemon princes (And Hive tyrants - terrible model to make)
Commissars
Primaris Psykers

Rant over!
 
Oronare said:
Why don't they just sculpt the same metal models, in plastic?!

They can't due to the differences in how the metal is cast and the plastic is moulded. That said GW did release, for an extremely limited time, a metal Necromancer model that is the same sculpt as the plastic Heroquest equivalent (the HQ plastic is a horrible cheap plastic). I'm sure there are other examples.

are they still just too detailed even now?

I can compare a metal figure from the mid 80's that has more, sharper, detail than the best plastics I've seen in 2009. Again this is due to the differences in casting and moulding the models.

What GW have done is remove detail they think that most people won't notice or miss. A lot of people don't notice or miss the detail and wonder why people like me go "But the detail is missing!". We do it because we noticed amd miss the detail!

But then I wonder if that depends on whether people are more into gaming than painting. I.e. gamers tend to say "Well they're good enough" and painters tend to say "Ick! They're a bit crude detail wise!".

i'd love come plastic Blood Knights but in the same mould :D would be amazing!

The problem with that is GW wouldn't make much money from a unit people would only buy 5 figures of in plastic. I'd prefer to see expensive units like this in resin but I seriously doubt that GW would ever do that.
 
Though a question to those who complain about static poses

Well, I'm looking at my 6th ed skelllies - plastic ok. Now, I'm looking at my 20 7th ed skellies. Also plastic. Dynamic??? Probably magicly disapeared.
With the 6th ed skellies we had about 3 to 4 positions. With the new ones...only one. I.e. leaning forward, picking up a penny or whatever. Okay, there is a bit more detail involved now, armour, belts etc. But tell me, how do I convert legs to have a skelly leaning backwards, taking a arrow, parrying a sword or whatever? This was quite possible with the 6th ed skellies.

In regards to the money-argument. Paying 30 euro for a zombie regiment is quite expensive regardless. The same counts for the 10-man box of skellies/GG. Overpriced! If I pay that amount of money for a unit I want it to look good. So, conversions are an extra not a necessaty.

Yours
 
How about we do this: all those who are saying that metal is superior go out and buy an all-metal army... let's say 150+ models. Now take note of exactly how much money you have left for... I dunno, food maybe?
Now assemble and paint it, and play with it exclusively for about 3 months. After all that wonderful time gaming with those beautifully boring metal models, now look at them and take note of exactly how much paint is left on them.
Now look at the army, an army you have spent to much for and now have painted twice. Take note of exactly how much you love those beautifully boring metal models now.
 
It can be hit or miss sometimes. I prefer the previous Dwarfs over the current ones. Yet, I'm a fan of the current clan rats (I also like the new clanrats too). I feel old clanrats are better for spear-rats, the new ones better for hw/sh rats. I despite the current Empire state troops, and I loved the previous ones. I like the new Temple Guard, and Marauder Cav.

The new Cold One Knights for Dark Elves are some of the best sculpts, in my personal opinion. They are part of what got me to do a Dark Elf army!

Metal models fall down a lot more, and are harder to convert. Yet I still don't think they should be phased out. I think they have a place. Though I do think all CORE troops should be plastic. Plaguebearers, Dark Riders, and Horrors, for example, should be plastic. As should Stormvermin. I'm glad they made Temple Guard , Ghouls, and Corsairs plastic too.
 
Vekarin, i don't think i'll ever get bored of lookng at/playing with my Blood Knights, Black Coach, Konrad, Vargulfs, Wraiths.

I do have to admit though, i got bloody pissed off with those metal Ghouls, their skulpt is FAR superior, but just to save the headache of trying to transport all that metal, and the constant chips in the primer, AND parts coming off because the metal at that size is so brittle (And to play in GW stores obviously) I got them in plastic.

I have to say that I am a semi-convert, I love my Rare/Hero figures in metal, i'd have it no other way, but the core/special i can make do with in plastic :D if only GW could make some plastic Black knights that are as dynamic and individual as the Bloods, we would have it made.

One small tip I do have for people with metals, and the primer coming away. Once you prime, prime it to where you would normally do, one or two coats, let it dry obviously. You would normally go and paint from this stage, but THEN add one more coat of primer, so the model is a deep black and very smooth looking, this is the perfect one.

I re-primed my Blood Knights and wow, what a difference, since handling them through painting I have not had any of the primer come off or any of those annoying silvery spots, but all the detail is still there.
 
That is not necessary Oreo. While Oronare has indeed been banned the discussion could still be kept up if anyone have more input to give. ;)

Edit: Right? I'm still awfully new to this whole moderating experience...
 
The Dark Lord Mr Fluffy said:
I know its a little off topic, but what just happened there?

An unfortunate situation that spiralled out of control, ending with the departure of a member. :grave:

Anyway, I actually have a certain appreciation for the metal miniatures. I can't really explain it but it just feels right to have a few of them in your army. :)
 
While plastics are easier to glue and don't require the extra care that metal does...
It would feel a little off for me to lift up Vlad and feel no heft or weight. He'd be knocked down easily, limbs could be snapped, etc.
I say NO! I refuse to allow a mighty metal character like Vlad be blown over by a gust of wind!
Glued metals tend to break from joints so they can just be glued right back. :thumb:
Plus, characters wouldn't be lovingly cared and handled anymore :'(
Buying a tiny box with a single plastic model inside, costing me $15 - $20 just isnt the same as buying the satisfying metal blister pack.
Setting down a hefty character on the board with authority and the sense of,"This guy is going to crush your puny plastics!:vampire2: is just a feeling that plastics will never touch.
Though an exception would be like a Hive Tyrant and the highly customizable ones etc.
But be my guest and bring on the plastics for the rest!
 
I just realized that I love those rare models who have parts in metal BUT are mainly plastic. They're heavier, more exclusive, and are detailed and nice.

Perfect mix of metal and plastic, but I still prefer plastic only.
 
Looking at the new skaven and the plastic doomwhell I can honestly say that model would simply not have been possible in metal. It would be a complete nightmare to handle both in game and the modelling aspect. Just look at it and then compare it to the Hellcannon...(a model alot of people had problems with).

I can understand the appeal of metal models though, the extra weight and texture has something to it. This isnt enough for me though as I quickly remember how much easier and durable my plastic minis are. Not once had to repaint my plastic minis because of paint chipping off it.
 
I have to agree about the doomwheel. It seems like it is an excellent model (which I'll get), and looking at it I can't help but think that the plastic technology has taken a huge step forwards since last time. The clanrats and stormvermin looks great as well, and they wouldn't be that good if they were metal, but the new characters are the best models and do in fact fit better cast in metal.
 
In short answer of the topic : NO.
The day they cast character models in plastic is the day I'm gonna stop playing Warhammer. Err.. no no I mean that's the day I'm going to stop buying character models from GW.
Plastic, specially the newer ones (including our own skellies and GG) are very nice indeed. Chaos Marauder Horsemen and DE COK must be added to the list as well. I haven't see the new Skaven in person but they're looking good indeed. The only thing I don't like about plastic is that you usually end up with so many bits that you don't need.
Let's be fair, metal models do have their own strong points. Plastic, for all its goodness, do have some limitation as well. To be frank, some other manufacturers outside GW produced much better looking (and detailed) models and they're all done in metal. Of course it's silly spending years to paint 200 very detailed zombie minis for your army, but I think we do want very high quality cast for our character models.
So I'd say keep it the way it is. Plastic for regiments and metal for characters.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu