Do you think metal models should be phased out?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Oronare
  • Start date Start date
  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Love the plastic skellies and zombies and grave guard.
Hate the new plastic ghouls. I loved the previous ones more and am glad I have my unit of 25 of them.
I love the Blood Knights, just not the Blood Knight price. :-\
As for characters... Special Characters by their very nature should *never* be in plastic. On the other hand, I wouldn't mind having a kit for generic characters in plastic with lots of bits. However, I think they should still leave available some metal figures for generic characters as well, even if only in the Collectors/ Classic range. Options for everybody I say.
 
When talking about characters and plastic, I'd love to see a plastic character conversion kit released. Something with lots of bits for all types of characters. Mages could have staves, scrolls, books, potions and various other arcane items. Warriors could get all kinds of weapons; swords, axes, hammers, bows (and preferably magic looking), pouches, plain shields and banners and so on.

Thus most of the character models could still be in metal while at the same time being slightly customised.
 
I think all models should be plastic, exept characters as i like to feel the weight(literaly) of expectation.
But the monsters really should be plastic and charcters on mounstrous mounts, such as VampLord on zombie dragon should rather be plastic than metal. Same goes for trolls,varghulf, giant rats, bone giants krxigors and ordninary giants. And proably more too.
But keep at least some of the characters in metal.
Special character could be metal and other should be plastic I think.:vampire2:
 
Metal feelsgood.

Plastic looks good.

Gah. Plastics seem to be more detailed. But GW standards don't win against some other miniature producers ( *cough* Rackham *cough*).

I really fear pinning. I guess that big creatures could turn plastic in my opinion.
 
Master Vampire said:
I really fear pinning. I guess that big creatures could turn plastic in my opinion.

Likewise. This is where plastics wins out because once you glue it in place it will stick there to the end of times. Even big items like wings and such, once dry it will stay in place.

I guess you could call me a lazy modeller but I never actually bothered with learning how to pin properly and went straight to plastics. While it was restrictive it forced me to be more creative in my works. So yeah, yay for plastics :thumb:
 
I think all of the "supremely awesome" units need to be metal. Specifically heroes, individual monsters (for the most part, maybe plastic wings), etc.

I do not see this "humongous difference in level of detail." I mean, granted, I see it in some things, but I saw someone compare some of the mid 80's models to the plastics of today, and I have to disagree! When I hear that, not sure if this is accurate, but I think of this model.

Old Carnifex

Anyway, I'd say for typical units, I prefer plastics. I also don't see why ghouls are horrible, Bought a box of 'em, even though I don't play VC (Girlfriend does) just to paint her some of 'em. I thought they were fine. I really liked them.

I agree that plastics chip way less. However, I don't make a habit of dropping models regardless of their material. I think of some of the miniatures from the ranges, such as the Gorger from OK, the Goblin on Giant Spider from O+G (pretty sure he's metal?), the Wood Elf Dragon Rider, and my personal favorite miniature of all time: THE OGRE NINJA MANEATER!!! (hah). These need to remain metal. I can't imagine them being plastic.

Then I also look at Chaos Knights. They look awesome! And they're plastic! The New Skaven look sick. The New Temple Guard are awesome. All plastics. My only complaint is, as cheap as plastic is, I should be paying half as much as I am for the box sets of plastics. Blood Knights need to be plastic (they're SO EXPENSIVE!)

Anyway, I kind of like the way GW has it: Unique models (basically non-core) metal, whereas the rest is (primarily) plastic.
 
Great Maw said:
Blood Knights need to be plastic (they're SO EXPENSIVE!)

Blood knights are already out of production btw.

To me, all models that exist in units of three or more should be plastic. I even made my own Wraith unit and they actually turned out pretty cool. Ugly as hell, but still cool. I just don't have the money to go buy all metal models. Although I do strongly hold to the principle that all characters NEED to be in metal. If I don't have a metal model to use as a character, I don't use the character.

As for the feel: I do strongly believe that metal models have that extra feel. To the chipping subject: for starters, don't be clumsy and use a carrier. GW makes some darn good cases. Just too bad my coach was on the bottom (at least my dad payed for the damage and now I ride to battle with two of em, just for fun). second, have you ever heard of vernish? It makes the paint more durable as it acts as a form of glue that is on top of the paint, keeping all the paint in the coat. If you don't like the vernish, what the hell is wrong with you? There is shiny vernish, but there still is the non-shiny vernish too.

And the new ghouls look awesome :p
 
Heh, that's what I said to. They're at $90 US, the same price as an entire Battalion.
I could get 20 skeletons, 10 Ghouls, a Corpse Cart and 20 Zombies for the price of 5 Blood Knights. That's insane.
 
Yea, I don't even buy the Butcher/maneater models (besides the Ninja which is AWESOME!) Just convert 'em out o'bulls! :)

I'd have to do something like that with those Blood Knights...
 
That's what pretty much everyone does, I think I have seen myself and about two other members with the actual Blood Knight models. I do echo the sentiments that characters should be in metal and other things in plastic, even though I do actually prefer the older metal skeletons zombies. It's just the price of buying 20 metal figures for a unit that is just so off putting.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu