Doubts about Line of Sight, shooting and so on..

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

kalidor

Zombie
Mar 14, 2013
12
Zombies
15
Hello guys, these question may seem quite stupid to you but i'm really confused about a couple of points in the rulebok:

1: can archers or warmachines (ei bolt throwers) shoot past a building? The rulebook says: "the shooting model must be able to trace a line of sight to the target". Theoretically no, however in the chapter "covers" it adds: "if the majority of the models in the target unit is obscured from the shooter's model's view by other models or by terrain then an additional to hit modifier is applied".
This said, are these archers able to hit even if their LoS is blocked by a building (then counting as a hard cover).

2: issues concerning Hills.

-2a: units on a hill "are more likely to be able to trace a line of sight past other models on lower level...". The rulebook speaks about models, it does not say "past buildings".. so can our usual archers now placed on a hill shoot against models hidden behind a building, with LoS blocked by the building (if it actually does block it)?


-2b: if, behind these acers on a hill, we place another unit of archers or a warmachine (ie, our usual bolt thrower) on the same hill, is the line of sight of the latter blocked by the allies standing just ahead of them?


I'll try to explain myself better with this image:
Can the gray archers shoot the necromancer? And the red crossbowman?


http://i.imgur.com/ODFvLsw.jpg?2

(the book underneath is pretending to be a hill)

Thank you so much!
 
To answer your question, no. You need to be able to draw line of sight to the target from your shooters. In the picture you showed it looks like the necro is obscured by the building so you cannot draw LOS. If you could see part of the model or part of a unit (i.e. half the unit was hidden say) then you apply the modifiers. The unit behind the other unit usually takes a modifer too for shooting through a unit (a -2 to hit).
 
Thank you for your answer!
I'm not sure i understood the final statement of your answer: in the case there was no house, could the red xbowmen shoot to the necro?

A guy i play often with would say they could "because in warhammer hills are supposed to be spherical, therefore the unit placed behind is always able to drow LOS as it is placed in a higher position".
(There's no mention about this feature in the rulebook :silent: )
 
In the current edition of Warhammer Fantasy Battle, the 8th edition, the line of sight rule has changed from theoretical to 'true line of sight'. The book states that if you lower your eyes to the level of the models and you see the target then the model can see it too. As opposed to 7th edition and earlier when even if you saw a tall model behind a hill it was still considered out of sight unless either party had the rule large target. And you basically had to rule beforehand which elements were considered tall enough to obscure the view.

Hope this clears it a bit, if not - just ask and somebody will try to rephrase it.
 
Alppikutka has it. It sounds like your friend is still hung up on 7th edition rules, unless you guys are in Europe or something and playing under some comp pack (tournament rule system) that actually uses those rules. Their are tournaments tht still do, in which case, nvm your friend is right ;)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu