WHFB - 7th Dwarf Miner Blasting Charges

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Grish

Liche
True Blood
Oct 11, 2007
5,319
Winnipeg, MB
Zombies
2,624
Hey everyone,

I have no rulebook on me so apologies if I get stats or names incorrect.
I was trying out my friends dwarves the other day, and one of the units I used was Miners and I equipped them with their Blasting Charges (I think thats what theyr'e called). For 30 pts, it was a thrown weapon that can only be used in a stand and shoot reaction. It did 1D6 S6 flaming hits. My question is, is it a thrown weapon for the entire unit? I took it to mean the hits were automatic. But my friend said they counted as a thrown weapon, so would need to roll to hit. Now, Dwarfs have a BS of 3, and if only used in a Stand and Shoot would mean they have a 33% chance of working for 30 pts. Is this right? I didn't think so because is it a thrown weapon for the group, with one roll, or does each miner have a roll to hit? it seems too expensive for such a low chance of working item.
 
No you don't have to roll to hit - there is one "explosion" from the blasting charge that inflicts d6 s6 hits on the incoming unit.
 
Do you have any page number or anything? I read it myself and there was emphasis on it being counted as a thrown weapon which implies that you need to roll to hit with it. I'll get the book at home and post it all up here...
 
I have encountered Dwarfs who play them both ways!

It does say use them 'as a thrown weapon'

Thrown Weapon is a type of attack on page 55 of BRB.

I believe that there is a 'to hit' roll. 6 - 10 automatically hitting d6 S6 hits is rather a lot for 30 points, even for a one use weapon.
 
The blasting charges do not need to be rolled to hit. Its done as a stand and shoot reaction and all the RULES say not the fluff is it does D6 S6 hits on the charging enemy. I know the fluff says its the miners throwing theirs charges at the enemy but due to the explosions they dont have to be that accurate just get tehm in the right area


Personally i find them a waste of points and not that useful as if you use miners right they shouldnt get charged - in the rear or side of the enemy ;)

Hope that helps
 
That's exactly how I read it Firmshaft. But it was some interpretation, and could have been written much cleared. They should hire some guys from Wizards of the Coast to lay out what they mean. They know what they're doing.

Now I have to convince my group that's the way it works. Points I'll bring up is that it's a cost per unit, not per model, implying they don't all have a blasting charge, the unit does. That it does D6 Hits is the only point I can bring up that the hits are automatic, and the throwing is just in there for range of when charging troops get hit (in case they panic).

Any other points I can bring up to convince them this is the way it works? It's pretty useless otherwise. And yes, its not that great of an item, but against expensive, frenzied troops or a treeman it would work pretty good (khorne knights?). I believe Khorne knights would have a 5+ AS against it.
 
the thrown weapon thing is probably just there to give it a range, or perhaps you have to hit with the bomb and then it does a further d6 automatic hits.
I haven't read the description
 
Tell them to go to Bugman's brewery and ask the Dwarves in there. Also since they cant "shoot" with them in any other way than a stand and shoot says a lot about their role really doesnt it
 
I think that the 'stand and shoot' provides the when (if charged, with the chargers being at more than half their charge range).

I have a question on stand and shoot, that I will post separately.
 
I have actually had this same exact debate with my gaming group. we could not come to an agreement so I emailed GW explaining all of our arguments, and they said: The miners have to roll to hit. end of debate.
 
Da Crusha said:
so I emailed GW explaining all of our arguments, and they said
That was your mistake. GW is well known of inconsistent, dumb, and even blatantly wrong answers when you do that. The people answering those questions know less about the rules than the guys that write the rules, and the guys that write the rules repeatedly demonstrate they have no clue what they've published.

Blasting charges are a waste of points. Might as well give them the best rules interpretation, because they are a piece of junk anyway.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu