Female models in Warhammer

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Menkeroth is referring to the system by which the nations conscript warriors for their armies. In the Middle Ages (which Warhammer is a fictional, fantasized version of) women were not conscripted into military service. Men were. Hence, the fact that all (or most) of the models in the Empire army are men. The women are at home.

So they actualyl don't have levies, he is just basing it on our worlds medieval timeline? That makes more sense even if its just a weak argument.
 
I'm not sure exactly how the Empire gets their army together, whether it's via a conscript (draft) service or volunteer (maybe a little of both?), so I'd let someone more versed in the Empire's lore address that.

But since the Empire draws a lot of inspiration from real-world human civilizations, it's a logical assumption that they don't select women to fight. Same as if you look at a US Revolutionary War, or Napoleonic army, it will be all men. The same principles they used for recruiting soldiers are likely used in The Empire.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
The.balance could be propagated by more female special characters. E.g. for Empire a female witch hunter or BSB hammer bearer wouldnt go amiss. I love the idea that all demigryph knights are women, maybe fluffwise because demigryphs react negatively when bonding with male riders.

Elspeth von Draken is a good example of a female empire character but is forgeworld and as such relegated to relative sideline of knowledge.

It is not surprising that so many female gamers i know head straight for dark elves or wood elves with their relatively high female representation. It is disappointing though that when given a well female represented army in terms of model count... they're all half crazed mainly naked neckbeard fantasy material.
 
I don't believe there is a set timeline of exactly how long it's been since the end times, for ages things were so consumed by chaos that time certainly had no meaning, but here's a brief sequence of events:

The world was consumed by the rift and destroyed, while the world's iron core was flung through the void, with Sigmar clutching to it. It is implied that this was the state of things for a long time. Eventually, the orb is stopped by some sort of giant space/warp dragon thing, which befriends sigmar, and they go on a buddy movie road trip tour of the cosmos. This is also implied to have taken a long time.

Eventually they find the remnants of the old world, which have coalesced into 8 separate demi-planes, each themed to one of the winds of magic. Some of the incarnates survived as gods over these infant realms. Sigmar laid claim to the realm of heavens and built a city there, and forged pacts and built a peace with the other gods. This ushered in a new age of prosperity where civilization boomed across the lands. This period of peace is implied to have lasted a long, long time, long enough for the old world to have already passed into myth and legend.

In time the attention of the chaos gods is drawn back to this new realm, but they are unable to cast it down while the new gods remain united. Unfortunately, that is not the case. The orc god breaks off, discontent with Sigmar's Order. Nagash attempts to usurp power. During this chaos Tyrion breaks with Sigmar to invade slaanesh's domain and kidnap the chaos god, quite possibly opening the door for chaos to get into the realms in doing so. The alliance breaks apart, chaos floods in, and a new age starts of all out warfare.

It's not clear how long this period lasts, it could be years or it could be centuries, but eventually the new gods are beaten back by a united force of chaos led by Archaon (seriously, are any of the really important characters in this game going to be new faces?), until they hole up in their personal final bastions - Nagash in the underworld, Sigmar in his golden city, etc - where chaos can't get to them, at least for a time.

So begins an entire age of chaos dominance where generations of people live and die for the amusement of the dark gods, while their own gods wait it out. During that time Sigmar decides to build a new army capable of fighting the dark powers, and commissions a dwarven god to forge armor and weapons from the core of the old world, while sigmar collects the greatest human heroes to wear them and infuses them with his own power. The setting opens with Sigmar unleashing this new army on the unsuspecting servants of chaos who had grown complacent in their tyranny.

So we have 2 to 3 entire ages, including a golden age of civilization that fluff just skipped right past, one that lasted long enough for the old world to pass into legend before it ended, and that has been gone long enough to pass into legend itself in turn. So while we don't have a specific chronology, yeah, we're talking millennia since the old world, not decades or even centuries, and are in the middle of an age of ceaseless and inescapable war, where everyone must fight to survive.

So whatever pseudo-medieval justifications there were for how gender rolls worked in Warhammer Fantasy, they do not and should not apply to Age of Sigmar.


More importantly, age of sigmar is a game in the real world, where it is 2015, and girls and women are a growing part of the hobby gaming community and geek community in general, and while I'm not up in arms over it, I kind of wish GW had taken that into account with the age of sigmar box, since this is the time and that was the product best positioned to do so.
 
Last edited:
It is not surprising that so many female gamers i know head straight for dark elves or wood elves with their relatively high female representation. It is disappointing though that when given a well female represented army in terms of model count... they're all half crazed mainly naked neckbeard fantasy material.
Well, I can't agree...
56991c40f1871917eb38351583571013.webp
1c22191beb6fdd722cd3dbda6bd18da6.webp
8a942b0d63286d599a82e6e375f64be2.webp

Lots of great models, both units and heroes. And yes, it's not for women to fight, they have to stay at home and tend to the domestic issues.
 

Attachments

  • 56991c40f1871917eb38351583571013.webp
    56991c40f1871917eb38351583571013.webp
    6.4 KB · Views: 97
  • 1c22191beb6fdd722cd3dbda6bd18da6.webp
    1c22191beb6fdd722cd3dbda6bd18da6.webp
    5.1 KB · Views: 99
So whatever pseudo-medieval justifications there were for how gender rolls worked in Warhammer Fantasy, they do not and should not apply to Age of Sigmar.

The gender rolls in AoS are whatever GW, as the creator, decides they are.

More importantly, age of sigmar is a game in the real world, where it is 2015, and girls and women are a growing part of the hobby gaming community and geek community in general, and while I'm not up in arms over it, I kind of wish GW had taken that into account with the age of sigmar box, since this is the time and that was the product best positioned to do so.

You are presuming to tell the creator who the audience for their art should be. Art* or any form of entertainment, simply IS, and the audience for it is whoever happens to enjoy it. If that's not you, or him, or her, that's not the creator's affair. They are simply putting out a product for people to enjoy; the intended audience is whoever enjoys it.

*Whether or not Warhammer is art is a subject for another debate, but in this sense the fictional stories written by a creative team, and illustrations and sculpted avatars of the people and characters in those stories could be considered "art" in the same way a comic book and the sculpted figures of its characters is art.

The ratio of male to female characters in the Warhammer lore is not a conspiracy to keep girls out of wargaming, it is simply the setting that GW has created. If someone wants more female models in their army, they have the liberty to convert, and create them themselves along with whatever back-story they like, but it's not the creator's responsibility to attempt to diversify their audience by altering their artistic vision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
The.balance could be propagated by more female special characters. E.g. for Empire a female witch hunter or BSB hammer bearer wouldnt go amiss. I love the idea that all demigryph knights are women, maybe fluffwise because demigryphs react negatively when bonding with male riders.

Elspeth von Draken is a good example of a female empire character but is forgeworld and as such relegated to relative sideline of knowledge.

It is not surprising that so many female gamers i know head straight for dark elves or wood elves with their relatively high female representation. It is disappointing though that when given a well female represented army in terms of model count... they're all half crazed mainly naked neckbeard fantasy material.

I completely agree, when I first started warhammer I started High Elves from Island of blood but if I could have chosen without monetay limitations I would have started with VCs because A) I like undead but B) (which is actually a major point) For the female vampire models. Even now I've taken to using lots of wood elf parts to convert female necromancers and vampires. and for 40k when I started, the only army that I actually liked for a long time was sisters of battle. So I actually think making females better represented in warhammer would help a lot, particularly in getting other female gamers into it. Especially when in the 8th and 40k rulebooks and in introductory games they said the general is supposed to be an avatar of the player which is kinda difficult when you're a girl and there are only male models for characters at least. It isn't toooo much of an issue (I am still a player of course) but it is still off putting at times. And I definitely agree with a post earlier in this thread that stated they would have likely bought the sigmar box if it had some female models (sorry I can't remember who it was, but I'm half asleep so please forgive me) and back to my point, it would certainly be beneficial to gw if nothing else.
 
The gender rolls in AoS are whatever GW, as the creator, decides they are.



You are presuming to tell the creator who the audience for their art should be. Art* or any form of entertainment, simply IS, and the audience for it is whoever happens to enjoy it. If that's not you, or him, or her, that's not the creator's affair. They are simply putting out a product for people to enjoy; the intended audience is whoever enjoys it.

*Whether or not Warhammer is art is a subject for another debate, but in this sense the fictional stories written by a creative team, and illustrations and sculpted avatars of the people and characters in those stories could be considered "art" in the same way a comic book and the sculpted figures of its characters is art.

The ratio of male to female characters in the Warhammer lore is not a conspiracy to keep girls out of wargaming, it is simply the setting that GW has created. If someone wants more female models in their army, they have the liberty to convert, and create them themselves along with whatever back-story they like, but it's not the creator's responsibility to attempt to diversify their audience by altering their artistic vision.

I do not believe it is a conspiracy, so am in perfect agreement with you there. However I do believe it is neglect of a massive demographic of potential customers. If there's one driving force behind AoS it was to make the game more accessible (to everyone, with a certain focus on youth). When you're trying to sell a product, why would you NOT try and make something that has a potential appeal to as many people as possible, including a further fifty percent of the population represented by women.

Of course you have the liberty to model women, which many do with their restricted limitation of various female torsoes, just like you have the liberty to take your army to a tournament. But as someone who enjoys tournaments, you would feel better cared for and supported if gdubs actively supported the tournament scene, just as women would be encouraged if gdubs promoted their gender a little more.

Sisters of battle are another example of such neglect.

You may argue that women are not their target audience but if they as a company are trying to draw in more customers, why shouldn't women by part of that? Huge potential for revenue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oppenheimer
What conspiracy? Nobody said there was a conspiracy, or any sort of deliberate snub going on. What I sad it was is a a reflection of old timey thinking by some old time game dudes who might benefited from stepping outside and seeing the now. If that was taken to mean deliberate exclusion, then I apologize for my failure to communicate. What it was meant to be is a statement that the box content decisions seem to me to have been made without thought to the existance of potential female players, or to the idea that even male players these days may expect or want to see some female representation in their toys. That the idea simply never crossed anyone's mind in the development process. Which is sadly very common, and even if unintentional is not something that should really be let pass without comment.

As for the integrity of the art - an artist's decisions are not without moral relevance or cultural context, and are certainly not above critique. Divorced from relevance and shielded from critique, art becomes useless, meaningless, and impotent. It ceases to be art.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Oppenheimer
When you're trying to sell a product, why would you NOT try and make something that has a potential appeal to as many people as possible, including a further fifty percent of the population represented by women.

One wouldn't try to make a product appeal to as many people as possible if doing so changed what the creator intended the product to be in the first place. Like when a movie distribution studio gets involved in the process and enforces changes on a writer/director, to the point that the film doesn't represent the story or vision that he's trying to create.

A great example is The Phantom Menace. George Lucas didn't have any interference, but he tried to make the movie appeal to as wide an audience as possible. It has baby-level humor, a kid for other toy-playing-aged kids to relate to, graphic violence and slavery themes (I guess for a more mature audience) and pretty dresses, presumably for girls and women to be interested in. The film is a mess with no real heart or direction, and none of those elements fit together tonally.

"Trying" to broaden one's audience is artificial because any changes made to the original source material are only assumptions on the part of the creator as to what the perceived audience might want. Generally, a good creator just creates what he wants and the audience decides if they like it or not. A good artist is known to be good because they consistently put out material that people like. But those people don't get to have any input into the design process because they are not the artist. The artist shows them what he wants to show them, not what they think they want to see.

the box content decisions seem to me to have been made without thought to the existance of potential female players, or to the idea that even male players these days may expect or want to see some female representation in their toys.

Again, "who might play the game" is irrelevant to what the creator wants the game to be. If they want to sculpt muscular dudes in armor, a potential customer saying that there's not enough women in it doesn't change the fact that "more women" doesn't fit with the creator's intended design of "muscular dudes in armor," so arguing in favor of it is kind of pointless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
I do not believe that was a conscious decision, and if it was than it was a poor one. Freedom of expression is not freedom from critique.

Also, you are far, far out of date on your art theory. Unidirectional monolog? Cult of personality? Especially from corporate collaborative pop / commodity art? This is 2015. Not 1915. In a post-post modern, information-economy world, the dialog between creator and audience, conversation within the audience, that is the art. The physical object, if there even is such a thing, is a medium for that conversation, and the direction and nature of that conversation simply isn't something the artist gets to dictate. Neither is the makeup of their audience.

Again, 'art', divorced from relevance and shielded from critique, ceases to even be art. What the creator wants ceases to be the defining feature of a work the minute it leaves their hand, and the creator who seek to dictate meaning to their audience rather than create it with them is failing as an artist altogether.
 
Last edited:
And yes, it's not for women to fight, they have to stay at home and tend to the domestic issues.

How unbelievably backwards. How can you even think like that in 2015? Women are just as capable as men, if not more so in many ways. How many men are like Madonna, for example? If I were you I'd think next time before you make yourself look like a backwards misogynist.

Games Workshop have produced some very nice female models imo, but i think they could really do with creating some new female factions or sub-factions. We have the Sisters of Battle in 40k, but when you actually look at them they are simply servants of a higher, masculine power which is a bit silly, but then it's 40k so it fits with the setting anyway, and the Sisters are just as crazy as the rest of the universe.

Elves and Eldar are both quite feminine, or at least androgynous, and there are plenty of female vampire models, and if you really want to you can easily convert your vampires to be female, that's what I did with some of my Blood Knights anyway, I gave them female heads I found from other retailers like Hasslefree miniatures who do a good selection of female models (admittedly half-naked ones, but I use them for their heads which I snip off and pin to my Blood Knights). Alternatively you could use the Lahmian vampire heads that come with the Coven Throne.

Also a lot of the perceived sexism of GW comes mainly from their settings being based in worlds that are inherently dark and unjust. The whole point of the settings is to provide a stark contrast to how we live today - there is no compassion, no understanding, only killing and cruelty. Women being subjugated and excluded in these settings makes sense, however, Age of Sigmar is not WHFB, and they really should strive to include more female models. I would love to see some female Sigmarites, without Boob-Plate of course.

If you REALLY want to you can easily find a way to convert your models, like Malisteen said the setting is dark and unjust and that's the vision GW have for it and I respect that. Females might not be represented as well as a lot of us may like but they at least allow the creativity to flourish where you can convert the models yourself and write your own background and character stories.

Where there's a will there's a way, as they say.
 
Last edited:
No I thought it was just sarcasm too!

The problem is when GW do make female models they tend to let the sculptors be a plastic surgeon and give enhancements which aren't really needed.
I'm all for equality in the war place, but if they did start making more inter gender kits is expect them to hike the prices as a result of given this extra level of detail.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
This is why I think Sisters of Battle is actually a fairly decent representational army for women wanting to get into the gaming scene. With the exception of the Sisters Repentia, the majority of sisters are fully armour clad, and yes they do have boob plating but its better than actually having cleavage on show. The Cannoness is also a fantastically badass model.

The female wood elves in the core infantry archer box are also a decent example, they're not overly sexualised.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
No I thought it was just sarcasm too!

The problem is when GW do make female models they tend to let the sculptors be a plastic surgeon and give enhancements which aren't really needed.
I'm all for equality in the war place, but if they did start making more inter gender kits is expect them to hike the prices as a result of given this extra level of detail.

Well if it was sarcasm then he can come out and say it was but until he does i'm taking it at face value since this is the internet and in general the rest of his posts were quite anti-females-in-muh-manly-setting anyway.

The truth is that most if not all miniature wargame sculptors are probably men, and straight men at that. There are probably very few women or homosexuals (or transgender people for that matter) involved in the whole process of designing the models, and as such the models represent the ideas held by a core of men.

Also many of the models probably sprang up, conceptually, from conservative beliefs common in western society, especially the Daemonettes, which are obviously modelled after the stereotypical idea of what a transvestite or homosexual person is like (an evil, promiscuous sex fiend). The reason they stand out is that they are the only obviously trans-styled models in Warhammer and there are no positive models to compare them to.

It's all a bit cringeworthy really, but fortunately the good parts of the hobby more than make up for that small nitpick.
 
Last edited:
The 1930s called, they say they miss you.
:P Say to them I'm a bit busy now but I won't forget ;)
How unbelievably backwards. How can you even think like that in 2015? Women are just as capable as men, if not more so in many ways. How many men are like Madonna, for example? If I were you I'd think next time before you make yourself look like a backwards misogynist.
Well, fair point, but... Did you ever think to stay and think my words over? Imagine all the population went to war. Who is at home supporting the life of the country? Women have to. Not must, not are to. Just have to. Because we fight and somebody has to do all the rest, and they are the best at this. Do you prefer all women go to war and die instead of you? We are supposed to die, protecting them also. Do you wish to be it vice verse? Or that your wounds will be tended to by a pretty maid? Think it over ;)
I hope it's sarcasm :)
And it was. It's as obvious as the sunrise. And yes, there're lots of female models in WHFB of great quality - not only elvish but many others. It really does the trick.
 
Also many of the models probably sprang up, conceptually, from conservative beliefs common in western society, especially the Daemonettes, which are obviously modelled after the stereotypical idea of what a transvestite or homosexual person is like (an evil, promiscuous sex fiend).

Wow, so heavily disagree. I do not for one minute believe that the sculptors were thinking this.

Far more likely they were given a brief on Slaanesh, who encompasses both masculine and feminine qualities, and that he/she/it is the god of excess, most commonly explored through the theme of lust and debauchery.

"which are obviously modelled after the stereotypical idea of what an evil, promisicuous sex fiend is like." is a sentence I could agree with.

@Menkaroth: Why can't women fight? This is 2015, women's rights and equality? The "women are (generally/on average) physically weaker than men" argument is invalidated by the fact that they are no longer required to physically overpower their opponent in hand to hand combat. Female marathon runners and weight lifters are evidence that with training (which they would undergo in the army anyway) women have just as much strength and endurance potential as men.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oppenheimer
@Menkaroth: Why can't women fight? This is 2015, women's rights and equality? The "women are (generally/on average) physically weaker than men" argument is invalidated by the fact that they are no longer required to physically overpower their opponent in hand to hand combat. Female marathon runners and weight lifters are evidence that with training (which they would undergo in the army anyway) women have just as much strength and endurance potential as men.
Are you really not able to read what is written? They can, and in WHFB there're lots of them of different sorts and kinds. They just must not, and certainly not above the existing level of that in WHFB now. Do you really want all of them fight instead of you? Maybe you want to sit at home and tend to the domestic issues and they will fight instead of you, but in this case you're lost to the world forever. Honestly. They have lots of great models, nobody did such female models anywhere (especially like Sisters of the Thorn or the Brides of Khaine), and that's enough.
 
I guess that wasn't sarcasm then... at least the Elves don't believe their women should be "tending to domestic issues"...
 
Are you really that stupid? There are already LOTS of female models and that's more than enough. MORE than you could digest. WH SHOULD not be turning female and I believe it will not. You personally can sit at home instead of your woman and let her fight instead of you, but in the normal world it's nonsense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu