For he who passes the gateways always wins a shadow...

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Dimreapa

Skeleton
Oct 27, 2013
75
Durham, UK
Zombies
167
Hello all, Dimreapa here. I hail from Durham in the UK, although I'm probably more at home on the internet. This will probably be long-winded, but that's pretty common with me. Those who take the time to get a mini biography and reflective have my thanks.

This is undoubtedly a controversial comment, but I'm not the biggest fan of WHFB. I see it as similar to the relationship between PC gamers and Console gamers, and I'm more of the console inclination. That said, I like it enough to dip my foot in, and it has improved somewhat of late, although I can't say my opinion has improved significantly.

I'm not overjoyed at who wrote it, firstly. But there are some parts that are interesting and fun. The random charge lengths, well, I have yet to encounter a situation where I felt they helped the game, and particularly tactically, I've found it has made the game more linear, and yet failed to numb the "its for real mans as it's more tactical" spiel I get from the average WHFB player. The price of things is verging on the ridiculous, and frankly, I've had no real love for the company for quite some time. My attachment and affiliation with it at all could probably be described best as an addiction.

Until very recently, the last 4 or so years are probably the lowest I have ever been in the hobby, and it hasn't always been such plain sailing at the best of times. I find the direction of many of GW's decisions virtually appalling, and I've been cynical indeed about pretty much everything. Ward has reached a level of prominence that if I were in charge he wouldn't have even got through the front door after his first 3 months with the company. Now he's writing rulebooks and the lion's share of WHFB army books. I'm not exactly thrilled, but at least he's not writing for 40k too much, but rumours are he's writing Orks (the true love of my hobbying life), and thus it's a miracle I'm contemplating new armies, because for a while the prospect of rage quitting everything GW at the mere conformation of his writing it isn't far from still being a distinct likelihood.

But recently, I've tried a new approach. I've decided not just to concentrate on the bits of the hobby I care about, but to try to learn to enjoy the whole thing again. As part of that, I've started armies I've always wanted to with wanton abandon after years of jittery heel turning. I particularly enjoy modelling projects, and of late also painting projects. My main 40k army has for years been a Rebel Grot force, which is pure conversion every time I do something new. It gets tiring after a while, so it's nice to mix in a bit of stock here and there. Still, recently I started doing that Genestealer Cult army I've been dying to do since I shelved my tiny 2nd Ed one, although I have used a fair bit of third company stuff to achieve it.

WHFB has always been a tougher nut to crack. For the majority of the 18 or so years of my WHFB gaming I have played Dark Elves, an army for which I am woefully ill-suited. They are quite a finesse army, and whilst I can do that fairly successfully (I do also play Cryx and Dirty, Dirty Dirz) I can only do it in systems where it actually works really well. WHFB is not one of those systems. Memorising meta-game rubbish and fighting Warseer list after Warseer list is not finesse gaming.

I swapped with a friend, gained his Skaven and he gained my Dark Elves, then Ward redid them, and I have never felt more vindicated, even if a little saddened at how pretty and positively 5th Ed chic the new releases are. I am enjoying Skaven, but let's face it, it's not my army. It's a sizeable amount, with most of the things I want, and aside of starting to add more Stormvermin, I have little to do. I will add some personal touches, but I've always fancied just doing an army simply for the purposes of making it as stunning as I possibly could.

So, Undead has been slowly seducing me for the last two decades, and since the recent update they have become more and more appealing. I've always had a fondness for Krell (as a character and miniature) and the idea of a graveyard horde has always appealed to me. I've been tempted to buy the new Krell model several times, but, well, there is nothing, aside of Mat Ward that I loathe more than Finecast in the world of GW. Nevertheless I overcame the prejudice. I haven't exactly been rewarded for my change of heart but I do still love the model.

My primary interest in Undead, well Vampire Counts (3 editions hence and I'm still not used to the title) is definitely skeletons. Vampires aren't a massive interest (I prefer other parts of the gothic), and I really want to explore the the whole raided tomb thing, and the old school Undead feel (which is why the Nagash projects on your forum look so exciting), although I will probably avoid Zombies. I know this is a bit of a gaming faux pas, but the very pretty ranks of Skeletons are too fun to pass up, even if it's going to cost me more to build the ranks.

I suppose what ultimately sold Undead to me is the new Wight King model. Firstly, it's plastic (non of that overpriced resin nonsense), and secondly, it's a very lovely model. I picked it up as my entry for my local store's little painting competition. It was held on Saturday, I tried some new techniques (particularly wet blending and a wet palette) and somehow I won. Got the Eavy Metal Set thing Brush for winning. It was a tricky model to paint, but I haven't had that much fun painting a model in ages.

I'll get some pictures taken for it, and share it shortly. The pictures wont be great (my good camera is out of it at the moment), and it's a pretty modest introduction to the site, but I'm particularly keen to refine my techniques. I would like this army to be the most stunning army I've ever fielded, and I'd like to push my abilities to the limit. As such I'm really hoping for loads of C&C, and as an upshot, and payment for the no doubt excellent advice I will get, I'll contribute what I can.

I don't know how far I'll get into it, as I've said, my relationship with WHFB has always been a little tenuous, but I've always liked the WHFB models, and the lore in certain places (and Undead is definitely one of those). The older I get, the more I'm warming back towards WHFB. I still don't buy the idea that WHFB is so much more tactical than GW's other cores (and to be honest I don't think any of GW's games are as tactical as they used to be or aught be), but I definitely find it largely a more maturely played game. I've enjoyed the sportsmanship of my recent games, although it's not quite to the level of some of the non-GW games I used to play.

I'm not a massive powergamer, which I don't think helps, really. I much prefer themes and modelling projects. That's my primary attraction to GW games. In this they are still unrivalled, which is a shame, considering the other areas where they are dropping the ball massively, and unnecessarily. But I know GW are capable of better. They didn't get to their position by being rubbish. I'm hoping to see an improvement. I think I already have, and at least at the local level, the local Staffer manager is easily one of the best Staffers I've ever encountered.

I'll close with a little more about me. I've been in the hobby for about 20 years. I'm largely a cynical and grumpy vet/neckbeard type, but I've been trying to shake off that part of me. I play a lot of games, and I view myself largely as an all-rounder in the hobby, but probably my least competent (and lowest interest) area is definitely the gaming aspect. I enjoy writing, both rules and fluff. Mostly it's confined to my real passion, 40k Orks, and particularly Gretchin. I have recently written a series of long articles on misconceptions about Orks (there's a lot of em), a fan-Codex for Rebel Grots, and I've been working on a novel about Orks, as well as converting Dicken's A Christmas Carol into an Orky tale (hopefully in time for Christmas).

Reading wise, I largely dislike Black Library (I'm a literary snob), and I read predominantly Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, Pratchett, Robert Rankin, Gaiman, Philip K. Dick, Tolkein and Lovecraft. I am a fan of Gothic literature (mostly Lovecraft and Poe) but since Uni I haven't read much of it, although jumping back into Undead I hope will rekindle the flame a bit more.

I'm a Support Worker (basically a carer with a less medical and more physical leaning) by trade, but I also write (as I've totally not mentioned already several times[/sarcasm]) and would like to be published as an author.

I play a lot of other Wargames, although not as often as I'd like. Certain transport and work issues has forced me more to attend GW's, rather than gaming clubs. I'm an old Rackham refugee, but I never did get to do as much Confrontation as I would like, and although the Acheron faction seduced me (hence the Bogeyman image), my collection of Acheron is pathetically low. I play Warmachine (Cryx, which for a long time sated my Undead Tooth), and I also dabbled in Specialist Games, my main passions being Necromunda (Delaques, Scavvies and Goliaths) and Gorkamorka (Rebel Grots). Other games include Lord of the Things (marvellously underrated classic), Strange Aeons (recommended to those who like Lovecraftian and Gothic horror) and I dabble in a bit of FUBAR, Tomorrow's War (but not massively successfully) and others. I also write systems, at the moment my main writing effort is for a Zombie Survival game in 25mm. I'm also a fanatical collector of miniatures. I don't mind owning pretty models, which is a sod for space, especially after discovering crowd-funding sites.

Other interests included computer gaming (I think my recent foray into Diablo 3 aided the jump to WHFB Undead, especially the desire to do a monstrous Nagash with a big mace...), writing stupidly long forum posts, trivia, linguistics, science, mythology, etymology and thinking too much about utterly trivial things.

I also managed to quit smoking, and I've been cigarette free for 3 months now. So I don't doubt that my renewed vigour and slightly cheerful outlook probably coincides with that success. Anyway, thank you, if you managed to get through all that. I'm afraid I do this quite a lot, but as I've not refined down entirely what I'm going to contribute, I have a lot to say generally until I can find my bearings.

What a great forum... I really must stop typing and get back to reading and exploring. I will hopefully speak to you all again soon!

P.S. 100 points to anyone who can identify the story and author the thread title is from, and finish the quote!
 
Quite a lengthy read, though that's not a bad thing! :thumbsup:

Welcome to the forums, I hope you find it suits your needs. We have all sorts of people here from people who are everyday gamers to those with no interest in WHFB at all :P

Unfortunately for GW, it's becoming an increasingly uncontroversial opinion to dislike their games. I myself actually quite enjoy 8th edition. Although i will admit it's quite flawed, i think it was definitely an improvement on 7th edition where those new to the game were severely punished for it and created a meta where everyone just sat around, not doing anything for fear of giving your opponent an advantage.

I congratulate you on playing themed armies. Although I don't play one myself, i pretty much always shake up my army lists every few games to keep things fresh and I'm not a big fan of the WAAC list attitude either. I look forward to seeing your skeleton army grow!

If you haven't noticed, we also have a writing section, so feel free to post up any of the stories you wish to share and they are bound to get a gander.
 
Welcome to the forum, and hopefully we'll be reading your stories soon.
I'm creating a themed army as well (Undead Dark Elves), which should be interesting.
I have to disagree with your view on GW, as all my experiences with them have been good, and I do like their books. However, I will not get into a big debate. Just know that I have no problem with them, and I like their Black Library books.
 
Thank you for the welcome Lynks and Count Vashra!

@Lynks: I definitely agree that 8th is an improvement on 7th, although I find that the Army Books were far more to blame than the ruleset, and the ruleset was radically changed anyway. I'd be a lot happier if some of the flaws weren't central, but that's what GW gets for promoting Ward above his station. I'm increasingly missing Rick P and Andy C at this point.

It was 7th that largely had a hand in my opinion of WHFB. It very heavily tainted it, and whilst I don't have a problem with losing, seeing my army destroyed constantly contributed to a lot of taunting, and also knowing I was getting beaten by people with a strong army list and considerably less tactical ability. I still don't think that fundamental flaw has been improved enough, but more armies are getting a fairer crack of the whip these days.

I have found the writing section. That will definitely get some entries.

@Count Vashra: Well, I must admit I'm a bit surprised you have no problem with them, but I fully understand that a lot of people don't share (at least fully) my views on GW. I would say my standards, if you can call them that, are ridiculously high, but so too are their prices. That's how I look at it.

I am not wholly against GW, or else I wouldn't be here. But they're far from being the good company they were with excellent creative talent. I would be generous to say they don't have as much of that. But my views on pretty much everything are mixed, it's just the negatives are more important because they affect my enjoyment. I've been trying to concentrate on the positives, but it's not easy. My biggest pleasure in the hobby is modelling, but it's getting far harder to do (and in a positive way less necessary).

Regarding Black Library, there's nothing wrong with it largely, although most of it is little more than pulp (which does have it's charm, but with my book collection I have far too many better alternatives), but the real reason for my dislike is when the head of Black Library declared that GW "has no canon", which to me reads as "there's no point reading any of our fluff because we don't care about it", so I don't.

As I've addressed those here, I can hopefully leave them here. I am still a fan, but I'm not the happy fan I was. The honeymoon period ended years ago. Now I'm on the brink of divorce. Perhaps the renewed vigour will extend and revitalise the relationship, but it's too early to tell. In the mean time I can have fun with the pretty miniatures. One thing I don't complain about (aside of pricing, occasionally, i.e. boxes like the New Witch Elves) is the quality and standard of GW's plastic kits. The plastic kits for VCs are irrefutably stunning.
 
Let me join the welcome bandwagon as well! I hope this forum improves your dim view of reaping :D

That aside, I'm probably in the minority when I say that I don't really enjoy 8ed more than 7ed. I'm more of a gamer than anything else, there are aspects of the ruleset I greatly dislike, and the meta(especially when uncomped) was just as bad for me.
 
Sweeney Todd said:
I hope this forum improves your dim view of reaping :D

Quoted for brilliantness xD

I don't think I've ever truly appreciated an edition of WHFB fully, but my favourite was 6th, just because I managed to mostly enjoy the game. To be honest I don't really like any of the current Cores, but I can't be bothered to turn my nose up at them any more. At least for me, 7th had too much magic domination, but now, I'm trying hard to get a WHFB game where it doesn't revolve around the act of moving as fast as possible directly forward until combat occurs and then finding out which of you has built the better unit. I don't remember it being much better in 7th, I just remember getting absolutely annihilated far more often.

Maybe it's just me. But at any rate the miniature quality has improved drastically, and cores in particular are finally getting the long overdue treatment, if only GW could resist the urge to half the content and up the price...
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu