Forbidden Lore, FAQ and... General?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Skittelz1981 said:
Isnt this the exact same thing?
You take an item (character defining) that makes him a lvl2 wizard (why make him a lvl4 if he is going to wear the hat?) It then says it ´can use a randomly chosen lore´
In the arguments ive seen against my pov, people just say: No, he must choose LoV since he has the choice anyway. The hat allows him to choose randomly but it still says ´can´ not implying he must (like Rarer is trying to make us believe)
Isnt that the exact same wording as FL?
Correct me if im seeing this wrong but its pretty much the same, you take a skill (character defining) that says you can generate from BRB....

How is the sequencing of chosing any different then? If the faq then states that its possible... (the hat is only used as an example, not excluding other similar situations)

Well like I said, I can definitely see your point, you have made it very clear. The problem as Rarer pointed out is that the Vampiric Power FL has not been specifically addressed by the FAQ.

I think the issue here is intent. My point with WH was how the intent behind it seemed to be there is no choice in the matter. Wizard is level 2 and he can only use a random spell lore.

You have to consider the probable intent of FL. Did GW intend for a VC General to beable to use FL and pick something other than LOV? IMO if your general could use FL like that, it would be explained in the description. It would say something in regards to it being an exception to the VC general rule.

Because there is any contraversey at all surrounding this, you just have to wait for this to be officially addressed in a new FAQ before making the assumption.
 
RarerMonsters said:
This rules forum has seriously lost a huge amount of its quality recently, it is becoming more of a design debate forum than a rules discussion.

This. And only this.



Skittelz1981 said:
Sure, be a prick.
Its so bad in quality that it actually proved you wrong on the Terrorgheist issue. Great going.
Sorry rarer, the only one losing in quality atm is you.

Dafuq ... ? :O :thumbsdown:
 
Mr. West said:
RarerMonsters said:
This rules forum has seriously lost a huge amount of its quality recently, it is becoming more of a design debate forum than a rules discussion.

This. And only this.



Skittelz1981 said:
Sure, be a prick.
Its so bad in quality that it actually proved you wrong on the Terrorgheist issue. Great going.
Sorry rarer, the only one losing in quality atm is you.

Dafuq ... ? :O :thumbsdown:



Irrelevant post MrWest, holding grudges belongs in Bugmans Brewery
 
I think it was an issue with the "be a prick" bit, but there doesn't seem to be any moderators, so I reckon we might as well just slog it out. No touching of the hair or face though.
 
There are mods and they are paying attention. Skittelz1981, insulting people is not an appropriate way to conduct yourself.

I have not intervened in this thread thus far because it's pretty clear that this is an issue that is dear to a lot of people and, for the most part it has been reasonable discussion however it's been slipping. I would request that everyone here refresh your view on how to conduct yourself on this forum, you can find the rules here:

https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-Carpe-Noctem-Forum-Rules

I would like to see this conversation conducted civilly, and without circular arguments or falling back on reiterating previous arguments instead of responding to current ones. If that cannot happen, then this thread may end up being locked.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu