Forbidden Lore

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

groedius

Zombie
Jan 17, 2014
11
Zombies
14
So am I right in thinking that if I took a Level 4 Vampire Lord with Forbidden Lore I could take any lore other than Light so he would not have to take lore of the Vampires ?

Main reason I thought it would work like this was as per the FAQ question here or am I just completely wrong ?

Q: If a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to choose the Lore of the
Vampires as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example)
but is still the Wizard with the highest Leadership in the army, must
he still be the army’s General? (p26)
A: Yes.

What do you guys think ?
 
Except forbidden lore just lets the lord select other lores in addition to the lore of Vampires, so he would still have to pick lore of vampires
 
A Vampire Lord with forbidden lore is still able to choose the vampire lore right? and therefore has to since he is the general right?

I see it like this,
* according to the armybook the general has to have the vampire lore.
* according to the rulebook the general have to be the charakter with highest ld.

Therefore the only possible way for a vampire lord to ever use another lore than "lore of vampires" is if theres another vampire lord in the army who has it and therefore is the general. Atleast thats the way i see it.

:) <- that smiley really look like hes up to something...
 
You are mistaken on the wording of forbidden Lore.

Forbidden Lore: The Vampire can generate his spells from any of the lores in the Warhammer rulebook, except the lore of life.

The lore of Vampires is not in the Rule book hence he cannot select the Lore of Vampires so this means that an Level 4 Vampire General could have any lore barring Lore of Vampires and Lore of life.
 
You could also argue that with Forbidden Lore, a vampire lord:
May use spells from one of the following:
- Lore of Death
- Lore of Shadows
- Lore of Vampires
AND
May generate spells from from:
- Any one of the lores in the rulebook except lore of life.

Basically allowing him to pick spells from two lores at once: Lore of Vampires and something else.

The flavor text is not part of my argument. I just include it for the flavor...
To learn several path of magical teaching is beyond most men, but time is of little concern to any undying scholar.
 
eggsPR said:
groedius said:
Forbidden Lore: The Vampire can generate his spells from any of the lores in the Warhammer rulebook, except the lore of life.

can <> must

Well what I was assuming as it says he can generate any from the rule book that would overwrite the lores available on his profile and allow him to only use one of the rulebook lores however I suppose it does not say that it does ... So I guess he could still select Lore of Vampires :S.

For some reason originally in my mind I thought it was pretty clear cut argument that he could now take a different lore but now I realise that this is a can of worms argument as it could be interpreted either way. I guess we wait for an GW FAQ answer.
 
groedius said:
For some reason originally in my mind I thought it was pretty clear cut argument that he could now take a different lore but now I realise that this is a can of worms argument as it could be interpreted either way. I guess we wait for an GW FAQ answer.
The phrasing is pretty clear, so don't hold out for a FAQ on this any time soon.
 
yeah its pretty clear. just pick one Lore of Vampire spell and the rest in your lore of choice, and you are good to go as general.
 
Am I correct in assuming that you could with a lvl4 pick say 2 spells from one lore and 2 spells from another?
 
I can't belive this topic surfaces again and again every couple months ...

A vampire lord with Forbidden Lore still has to select LotV by default if (s)he is the armies general (which is very likely, no ?) !!

So, yeah, should you be playing a game large enough to actually have a second vampire lord, then that dude(tte) could make use of Forbidden Lore freely.

And that's why you're very likely to see Forbidden Lore almost exclusively on hero level vampires.

And no, you can't generate spells from multiple lores simultaneously, except when you're either a bad-ass Druchii witch riding a dark pegasus (I.E. Morathi), or some hillbilly high elven brat (I.E. Alarielle). Or some other future special character allowed to do just that ... oh, and Mannfred, but his lores are pre-determined anyways.
 
yes, but of course your first two spells must then come from one of the following:
- Lore of Death
- Lore of Shadows
- Lore of Vampires
while your next two spells must come from one of the 7 schools (no life)
 
Smogg said:
yes, but of course your first two spells must then come from one of the following:
- Lore of Death
- Lore of Shadows
- Lore of Vampires
while your next two spells must come from one of the 7 schools (no life)

West was correct. You must choose and generate from one and only one lore unless you have rules specifically stating otherwise (like Grey Seers)

If you generate from LoV, you generate all 4 spells from LoV
 
RarerMonsters said:
West was correct. You must choose and generate from one and only one lore unless you have rules specifically stating otherwise (like Grey Seers)
I was correct. The granted school of choice from Forbidden lore is in addition to the initial school selected by the vampire.

Forbidden lore does not say "instead of" anywhere. Since special rules are added by default, both rules apply.

When you can select spells from Lore of Vampire AND Lore of Metal then it works like Morathi. You can pick from both.

When you can select spells from Lore of Vampire OR Lore of Metal then you need to choose which school. You have to pick one.

This is a case of AND since both rules apply. So yes, you can pick spells from two schools at once.


The flavor text is not part of my argument. I just include it for the flavor...
To learn several path of magical teaching is beyond most men, but time is of little concern to any undying scholar.
 
Smogg said:
RarerMonsters said:
West was correct. You must choose and generate from one and only one lore unless you have rules specifically stating otherwise (like Grey Seers)
I was correct. The granted school of choice from Forbidden lore is in addition to the initial school selected by the vampire.

Forbidden lore does not say "instead of" anywhere. Since special rules are added by default, both rules apply.

When you can select spells from Lore of Vampire AND Lore of Metal then it works like Morathi. You can pick from both.

When you can select spells from Lore of Vampire OR Lore of Metal then you need to choose which school. You have to pick one.

This is a case of AND since both rules apply. So yes, you can pick spells from two schools at once.


The flavor text is not part of my argument. I just include it for the flavor...
To learn several path of magical teaching is beyond most men, but time is of little concern to any undying scholar.

You might want to go re-read spell generation in the BRB before you say stuff that is so incorrect. you can only choose 1 lore to generate spells from, Forbidden Lore increase the number or lores you can select from, but in no way allows you to generate spells from multiple lores at the same time
 
I am well aware of the rules for spell generation. Special Rules override the rules in the BRB, so it does allow you to generate spells from a second lore.

Example.
I make a Lvl 4 Vampire Lord with Forbidden Lore
I pick 2 spell from Lore of Vampires since my rules say I "can use the Lore of Shadows, the Lore of Death or the Lore of Vampires"
I pick 2 spell from Lore of Metal since Forbidden Lore let my vampire "generate his spells from any one of the Lores in the warhammer rule book, except lore of life"

My first 2 spells are valid because of the first rule.
My last 2 spells are valid according to the second rule.
Special Rules overrule the BRB rules.
Unless otherwise noted, the effects of multiple special rules are commutative.
My vampire lord has both rules therefore both selections are valid.

It would seem my vampire lord now knows several paths of magic.

The flavor text is not part of my argument. I just include it for the flavor...
To learn several path of magical teaching is beyond most men, but time is of little concern to any undying scholar.
 
You obviously arnt well aware of them
"To randomly generate the Wizard's spells roll a D6 for each of his Wizard levels and consult the chosen lore to see what spells have been generate"

You have to choose a Lore in order to generate spells from that lore. there is nothing in forbidden lore that lets you bypass this ruling
 
With forbidden lore, I end up with two seperate rules, each allowing me to pick one school to generate spells from.
1+1=2.

The flavor text is not part of my argument. I just include it for the flavor...
To learn several path of magical teaching is beyond most men, but time is of little concern to any undying scholar.
 
First off, you're citing flavor text.

Second, it doesn't say that the vampire generates from Vampires AND the lore. (The word you're calling attention to)
It says you can generate from these lores in addition.
You have a list of lores from which you can pick one. THAT is what is being added to. Increasing the list of available lores doesn't add to the spells from which you are generating.

Compare how explicit every character/hero that DOES have the ability to generate from multiple lores is.

There's no reasonable way to assume that such a slight vagueness of grammar is enough to challenge a fundamental rule of the game.

Third, you're citing flavor text.
 
I'm not sure how much clearer everyone can make this for you, old boy.

Forbidden Lore increases the number of Lores from which you may chose your single Lore from three to eight - but you must still choose one single Lore from which to generate spells.

If the character with forbidden Lore is the general, the one single Lore you must choose is the Lore of Vampires.
 
It does not need to say that you can generate from both. If you have two special rules, then both rules apply. It is not standard to write in each special rule that it is cumulative with another special rule since special rules are cumulative per default.

Forbidden lore says nothing about increasing the list of lores. That's something you are making up now. Besides that would make no sense since Lore of Shadows and Lore of Death are already available.

And thank you for drawing attention to the flavor text. It's not part of my argument but I do like to quote it just for the flavor...
To learn several path of magical teaching is beyond most men, but time is of little concern to any undying scholar.
 
Smogg said:
It does not need to say that you can generate from both.
Yes it does. It entirely does. Because the general rule is that you can't.

If you have two special rules, then both rules apply. It is not standard to write in each special rule that it is cumulative with another special rule since special rules are cumulative per default.
You don't HAVE two special rules. You have access to the lore of vampires, and one special ability that changes your available lores.

Forbidden lore says nothing about increasing the list of lores. That's something you are making up now. Besides that would make no sense since Lore of Shadows and Lore of Death are already available.
It increases it from 3 to 7. And they probabaly didn't write that since it's cleaner to say every one but life. The fact that you could already choose Shadow and Death wasn't addressed because the redundancy didn't create a conflict.

'Forbidden Lore: "can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the Warhammer rulebook"'

It doesn't say "And Lore of Vampires." It doesn't specify that you can generate from multiple lores. Compare this to the last edition, where it went out of its way to specify you still had IoN, and didn't give you Loremaster in addition to your 4 other LoV spells. It doesn't imply that these spells are an additional generation (which goes against the basic rules of magic generation).

You're hanging your entire argument off the fact that "they didn't NEED to specify it". That's not nearly enough to justify what you're asking for.
 
Hm, didn't someone say that we don't need an FAQ for this? ;)

And really I have no idea which is correct. I think it SHOULD be that we can generate from two lores but I have always played it generating from one.
 
Smogg said:
I am well aware of the rules for spell generation. Special Rules override the rules in the BRB, so it does allow you to generate spells from a second lore.
[/i][/color]

Hahahahahahahahahaha
 
Mr. West said:
And that's why you're very likely to see Forbidden Lore almost exclusively on hero level vampires.

That's how I intend to use it. A lvl 1 vampire hero with forbidden lore: beasts and just default to wyssan's for glorious S5 on the charge, T4 wolves.

And S6 T5 vargheists.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu