Game against HE... Cheating

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Swordmasters, white lions and phoenix guard champions can have magic weapons too (sister´s champion cannot).

And frankly, for me all of this sounds that the HE player was right with most of the things he do, and you were the one wrong, prejudiced against him.

I don´t wanna sound rough, it´s not my intention at all, but think about it: YOU were the one doubting his rules, wich were all the time right along: 2+ ward against flaming due to the fireborn, the griffon can buy an upgrade to get ASF, high elves still having ASF in the army (so phoenix guard with their halberds can reroll to hit), and so on...
 
HugoMac said:
Swordmasters, white lions and phoenix guard champions can have magic weapons too (sister´s champion cannot).

Actually, yes. They can. A High Sister is allowed to select a magic weapon.

And frankly, for me all of this sounds that the HE player was right with most of the things he do, and you were the one wrong, prejudiced against him.

I don´t wanna sound rough, it´s not my intention at all, but think about it: YOU were the one doubting his rules, wich were all the time right along: 2+ ward against flaming due to the fireborn, the griffon can buy an upgrade to get ASF, high elves still having ASF in the army (so phoenix guard with their halberds can reroll to hit), and so on...

In my humblest of opinions, both players involved need to get to know their rules better, both army wide special rules as well as basic rules. At least it seems like it to me.
And from what the OP posted, it seems as if the opponent did indeed try to cheat on the magic resitance, sorry.

But see the little example regarding the High Sister above in regard to game knowledge ?
Oftentimes, we all are bloody sure to be 100% certain about something, only to learn we had a tiny error in there ourselves.
It happens to us all, we're only human, and this is still a game we play for fun.
 
HugoMac said:
but think about it: YOU were the one doubting his rules,

in fairness, why shouldn't he? if you don't know someone very well and know nothing about his army its pretty hard to say "oi! that cant be right!" every five minutes.... or you can, but it will be the longest game ever :P this may be why the OP let the game run on and queried the rules after :)

if you don't have ready availability to the army book, how else can he find out without asking and voicing those doubts, now he knows better and will know how to counter it, not everyone has the money to buy every army book or is cheeky enough to download them :)
 
I have been in the game for a loooong time, starting out in the 90's so I have played allot of opponents, although not allot of 8th edition. What I am trying to say is that, yes there will be rules, concerning other armies mostly, that I know nothing about. BUT, I know allot of characteristics in gamers and that was what started all this. Picking up dices very fast without letting your opponent getting a clear overview over the rolls and making hard rolls happen when his back is turned and then picking up dice wihtout him ever seing the roll are characteristics I have seen in cheaters I have played before, and that was why I got suspicious. I then later went home and made his list on army builder only to find out that I was at least 150p above. I then started to look deeper into his units and mechanics as they were written on army builder which let to a few mistakes on my part, like the dragon armor for instance, which only came up as a 6++ there.

I cant say how much of this is simply from a lack of knowledge on his part, but I happen to know that he goes to tourneys quite often, so it would suprise me if thats the case. There is also the situation with his lord on a griffon covered earlier. I am about to race through it with 7 hexies, only for him to be "sporting" and let me know that the model has a 2++ against fire. It was still stupid of me not to question why the griffon would benefit from its riders ward save, I cant really hope to play on a higher level myself and not question those kind of "rules". Still, its first time we played and as Zully so wisely puts it, it can seem like bad manners if you question his every rule in what is supposed to be a friendly game. Im quite certain, that IF I had questioned that thing, then he would have replied that ofcourse he only meant that the rider would get the 2++. So that is more a question of him being a bit smart in the way he put it, and in my humble opinion unsporting. Edit: After reading this through it can seem like I simply misunderstood him, and I cant be 100% sure about that, but if you had heard the way he put it, im pretty sure most of you would have understood it the same way I did. Not because it made sense, because it didnt, but because that was just the way it sounded. Like, "hey before you make that huge mistake, im going to help you a bit since you dont know allot about HE. You see, it has a 2++ ward save against fire".

I have chosen to take this as a learning curve and devellop those parts of my game that deals with the opponent. Not his army, but him as a person. For instance, me and my best gaming buddy have talked about trading lists after the game and then count your own victory points. It deals with people fidling with their list in a nice way in my opinion. It has also highlighted how strong you need to be in ALL army books if there is a chance you might run into gamers that dont mind being a bit unsporting to win.
 
Xivigg... Yah, but this was supposed to be a friendly game. Human nature never seize to suprise me :lol:
 
Perhaps don't judge him too harshly. A lot of the things you were worried about were actually correct, and the issue with the Phoenix Guard ward save was more likely a mistake on his part, since Magic Resistance is a common rule and not the kind of thing you could pull over on someone.

As for the "Advice", it's a very odd kind of cheating to warn your opponent that a ward save would negate all hits to the rider. As he specified it came from Dragon Armor, it would follow naturally that it applied only to the rider and not the mount. You should ask questions to verify that.

Part of sportsmanship is giving opponent's the benefit of the doubt. I know that the ETC breeds a cutthroat kind of player, but it's better to be allowing and aware than fall into the same traps. If you're ever in doubt, be communicative. Ask questions about their rules, and ask that they leave the dice where you can see them. There is no ill will in that, because it's something we can all fall into.
 
RarerMonsters said:
ask that they leave the dice where you can see them.

So many times I've been rolling dice and at the last moment, my opponent turns away or ducks under the table to fetch a book or put some models away, and doesn't actually witness the dice hitting the table. Then I have to just kind of stand there, not touching them, and hope he isn't going to think I was tampering with the dice while he wasn't looking.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu