WHFB - 7th Gem of Blood Order of Events

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Grish

Liche
True Blood
Oct 11, 2007
5,319
Winnipeg, MB
Zombies
2,624
Hi,

Had this come up in my first VC game.
I had a Wight King with Gem of Blood. I charged a unit of Sword Masters head on (not a tactically wise decision, I know; my friend called me on and I had to respond...)
Their Champion challenged my Wight King. With ASF, he swung three times, wounding once. I failed my AS, and so the Gem of Blood went off and killed the champion.

So the question is, do I get to attack the now dead champion? If not, can I attack the unit or is the challenge ended at the end of the close combat round?

Thanks,
Grish
 
Good question, sensibly speaking I would say the Wight king misses out on this round of combat however the rules are not always sensible, it may be the fact that you can still attack top claim overkill - not much help really am I o_o
 
Passing a ward save does not prevent you from attacking. The challenge is still there even with the opponent being dead. You now try to gain overkill.
 
I'm not so sure the rules support this...

pg 77 Fighting a Challenge:
"Once a challenge is underway no further challenges may be issued from that combat until one character is slain or flees from combat."
...
"If a character is killed in a challenge and it's mount (monster or chariot) still had no chance to attack in that turn, work out their attacks as part of the challenge. The challenge is then over."

pg 34 Who Strikes First
"... if a model is slain before it has a chance to strike, it obviously cannot fight back"

pg 32 Which Models Fight?
"Models can fight if they are in base contact with an enemy model when it is their chance to attack."

pg 36 Removing Casualties
"Also, models that have been removed before they have had the chance to attack may not do so..."

I know how everyone I know plays it. But from what I read of the rules, this is not correct by RAW. There is nothing saying a challenge lasts the entire combat round. It ends when a combatant is dead. When they are dead, they are removed. When they are removed, you can no longer attack them as they are not in Base contact anymore. However the challenge is ended immediately as soon as one combatant is slain so as long as your challenger is in base contact it seems he could attack rank and file.

It may not 'feel' right but from what I read, that's what is supported by RAW.
 
I disagree Grish.

All of those rules suggest that if you die you cannot attack. None of them suggest that if you are alive you don't continue if the opponent is dead.

Now look at the monsterous mount one. Despite the fact that the character involved in the challenge is dead the monster may still attack. So as you see, only the dead guy can't attack. The challenge does not end immediately with the death of one of the participants. It continues untill all attacks are resolved. The only exception being you may not attack if you have been killed.

None of the rules you submitted actually contradict this in any way.


P.S.

Furthermore you are forgetting the overkill rule. The winner does not stop untill all his attacks are finished, despite the fact that the first one may have killed his opponent. ie the challenge doesn't end immediately with the death of one of the participants.
 
Being dead means being removed as a casualty and thus is not in base combat correct? Can you die and not be removed?

Here's a question: If I have a vamp with Blood Drinker that is not in a challenge, can I repeatedly attack the champion of a unit (who is also not in a challenge) for extra wounds? If he's not removed from base contact this would seem to suggest you could; that he would just lose the ability to attack back and you could wail on him as you like. If you cannot, is the ability to be dead and not be removed reserved for challenges?

I think you are 'dead' when you are removed as a casualty. You cannot attack because you're removed. I see nothing to suggest that when you are dead you are still in base to base contact. In challenges, it expressly tells you to move the challengers into base contact.

The mount has a special rule of when the combat ends. Reading as RAW, if both you and your opponent had a monstrous mount, but his had a higher I, and you killed the challenger, by RAW his mount would attack and then the challenge would be over. It doesn't say anything about your own mount, just the challengers. It is speculated that the same rules apply to your own mount, but that is speculation, I don't see any rules to apply.

Rules cited: pg 36 Removing Casualties:
"Close combat casualties are removed in the same way as shooting casualties."

pg 31, Shooting, Removing Casualties:
"...for each wound suffered, one model is removed as a 'kill'."

Everything I read seems to suggest that a dead model is a removed model and a removed model is a dead model. I don't see anything anywhere that a model can be dead and still be in base contact.

Edit: The example in the Overkill pokes large holes in my argument. In it, a Lord level character on a dragon is fighting a champion. It says nothing about initiative orders, but both get to attack in it. Assuming they are not simultaneous, it does seem to imply in an overkill you can beat a dead body. The champion had an original wounds of 1, so it was a regular RnF champion and not a hero. This raises even more questions.
 
grishnakh99 said:
Being dead means being removed as a casualty and thus is not in base combat correct?

Here's a question: If I have a vamp with Blood Drinker that is not in a challenge, can I repeatedly attack the champion of a unit (who is also not in a challenge) for extra wounds? If he's not removed from base contact this would seem to suggest you could; that he would just lose the ability to attack back and you could wail on him as you like.

No, you can't.

but page 77 points out that the reason for this is that they are "discounted because all the effort of these attacks goes into fighting the character"

So the effort of the attacks at leas ARE being directed at the champion. The champion is still there on the ground, not discarded somewhere in a army case lol.


I think you are 'dead' when you are removed as a casualty. You cannot attack because you're removed. I see nothing to suggest that when you are dead you are still in base to base contact.

Well I see your point and I guess it is valid. However, I believe the corpse/model is not removed when it is dead, but rather when the challenge is over. This actually ties in with the monsterous mount argument a little. If you look at the specific wording of that section:

".... work out their attacks as part of the challenge. The challenge is then over"

As you can see the challenge is not over when the character dies. Now this is obviously a special rule for the mount senario, however I believe it is true in all situations. The character continues to be pummled even after he is dead thanks to the overkill rule. The mount continues to fight despite the character being dead. See what I mean? the standard fare is that the challenge continues.


The mount has a special rule of when the combat ends. Reading as RAW, if both you and your opponent had a monstrous mount, but his had a higher I, and you killed the challenger, by RAW his mount would attack and then the challenge would be over. It doesn't say anything about your own mount, just the challengers. It is speculated that the same rules apply to your own mount, but that is speculation, I don't see any rules to apply.

This is an interesting point, I personally believe that the intent is to merely allow the challenge to continue after the death of the character. However, as you say, RAW suggests it is over as soon as the 1st mount attacks. Interestingly the mount may kill the other character with those attacks hehe.

However this is specific to the mounts in question. I would argue that the standard rule is that the challenge continues until the round is over, and only in this situation does it end early (and only because the devs were too silly to see this situation).


Consider this senario:

1. Blood Gem kills a character mounted on a monster.
2. Character who owns the blood Gem has higher I than monster. So he gets to attack before the monster right?
3. monster attacks
4. challenge ends.

In this situation the character gets to attack. Surely it isn'y just because there was a mount involved?

As I said I believe that mount rule is a special case of when the challenge ends early, NOT a special case of when it continues longer than normal.
 
The Dead of Night said:
grishnakh99 said:
Being dead means being removed as a casualty and thus is not in base combat correct?

Here's a question: If I have a vamp with Blood Drinker that is not in a challenge, can I repeatedly attack the champion of a unit (who is also not in a challenge) for extra wounds? If he's not removed from base contact this would seem to suggest you could; that he would just lose the ability to attack back and you could wail on him as you like.

No, you can't.

but page 77 points out that the reason for this is that they are "discounted because all the effort of these attacks goes into fighting the character"

So the effort of the attacks at leas ARE being directed at the champion. The champion is still there on the ground, not discarded somewhere in a army case lol.

Interesting. In a combat, you can still only inflict as many wounds as the model has wounds. pg 77 Overkill: "However, any excess wounds scored when fighting a challenge do count towards the combat result (up to a maximum of +5), even if they are not actually inflicted.

This implies to me that if you have Blood Drinker and are in a challenge, you can only gain as many wounds as your opponent has.



I think you are 'dead' when you are removed as a casualty. You cannot attack because you're removed. I see nothing to suggest that when you are dead you are still in base to base contact.

Well I see your point and I guess it is valid. However, I believe the corpse/model is not removed when it is dead, but rather when the challenge is over. This actually ties in with the monsterous mount argument a little. If you look at the specific wording of that section:

".... work out their attacks as part of the challenge. The challenge is then over"

As you can see the challenge is not over when the character dies. Now this is obviously a special rule for the mount senario, however I believe it is true in all situations. The character continues to be pummled even after he is dead thanks to the overkill rule. The mount continues to fight despite the character being dead. See what I mean? the standard fare is that the challenge continues.


Speculation, but I would buy this argument.

Consider this senario:

1. Blood Gem kills a character mounted on a monster.
2. Character who owns the blood Gem has higher I than monster. So he gets to attack before the monster right?
3. monster attacks
4. challenge ends.

In this situation the character gets to attack. Surely it isn'y just because there was a mount involved?
Speculation, but I agree.

As I said I believe that mount rule is a special case of when the challenge ends early, NOT a special case of when it continues longer than normal.[/color]

It seems models in challenges have the special rule of not being removed when they are dead. Does this apply to all combats or just challenges? If this is applied to all combats, then we have some real thinking to do about multiple combats (I can draw examples...).
 
grishnakh99 said:
Interesting. In a combat, you can still only inflict as many wounds as the model has wounds. pg 77 Overkill: "However, any excess wounds scored when fighting a challenge do count towards the combat result (up to a maximum of +5), even if they are not actually inflicted.

This implies to me that if you have Blood Drinker and are in a challenge, you can only gain as many wounds as your opponent has.

I agree. The wounds aren't actually inflicted, you're just hacking up meat.
 
You mean you actually get to fight in challenges?

Man, round these parts it's just a clear passport for a character to hide at the back of a unit. You want that character dead, place attacks on them. I've only ever fought a challenge when both players agreed it'd be narratively appropriate...
 
I believe the answer to this question is more to do with 'overkill' than anything else - the Wight Kings return attacks could be taken the same way as if he had struck a killing blow, meaning he would have killed the enemy then kept going.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu