General as a BSB

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Alabaster427

Minister of Thriftiness
True Blood
Dec 9, 2013
1,315
Zombies
1,063
Can a vampire be the general and the BSB? Nothing in the AB suggests that it can't be, but I think the BRB may; I just can't seem to find it. Anyways, I asked some other players and the consensus seems to be that the AB would have to specifically state that the general can also be the BSB. If that is so, then the answer would be no. However, the AB seems to imply that it can be done.

My logic is that you take a vampire BSB. If you take no other heroes or lords, then he automatically becomes the general according to the AB. Even if you take a Vampire Lord as the BSB and a lesser wizard, the AB dictates "the wizard with the highest LD must be the general."
My second reason is: Let's say that the Vampire BSB is not the general, but the general is then slain. If the BSB is the only other wizard, then he would automatically become the general according to the AB. I know that the secondary General no longer conveys the extra point value, but he would allow units within 12" to march, which a non-general vampire cannot do.

Thoughts? How would this change the Vampire meta?
 
A few misteps.

A Vampire Lord is not offered the option of being upgraded to the bsb. The Slann used to/I guess still does (?) have the option, but not Monsieur Vampyr.

I guess a Hero Vamp bsb could also be the General, assuming no other casters. Correct me if I'm wrong.

When the General dies, the next Lore of Vampires caster down the line doesn't become General, he stops the Crumbling. He does not confer March bubble or Inspiring Presence.

Hope that helps your train of thought some.
 
Ok. Assuming a VL can't be a BSB (have seen some debate on this), let's say that a Vampire hero is the BSB and knows LoV, but there is also a Necromancer that does not know LoV. The AB would then default the Vampire as the general.
 
On page 107 of the BRB under Battle Standard Bearer there's a small line that says "unless specified otherwise, the model that carries the battle standard cannot be the general".
 
Oh so in that scenario I think it would be illegal. If the vamp was the BSB then the necro would need to know LoV. However as the vamp is no longer general it means he can instead know shadow or death.
 
The VC AB on page 88;

"One Vampire or Wight King may carry the Battle Standard for 25 pts. ...... though a Vampire may still choose Vampiric Powers"


The Vampire referred to here is the hero Vampire. This is nothing to do with the Vampiric special rule
Therefore only Vampires (as described in the AB) and Wight Kings (as described in AB) are allowed to take the Battle Standard.

Vampire Lords and necromancers (both Master and normal) can never be a BSB, nor can named characters.
and idd p107 BRB states that a general can never be a BSB unless specified otherwise.


So in all:
- if your general is a Vampire (hero slot) he cannot be the BSB.

Vamplord (general) + Vampire-BSB or WightKing-BSB -- Valid
MasterNecro + Vampire (general) + WightKingBSB or Vampire-BSB -- Valid
 
My beef with this is that the AB changes the rules for having a general, so it should inherently change the rule for having a BSB.

I understand that having Vampiric doesn't mean they are considered a Vampire, but the VL says "Vampire" in its name and the BSB option doesn't say it has to be a hero, just "Vampire or Wight King."
 
Mmm ,the Vampire Lord is called: 'Vampire Lord' and is classified in the Lord section.
The Vampire is called 'Vampire' and is classified in the Hero section.

The part that talks about the BSB is in the Hero section and states that a 'Vampire' or 'Wight King' may take a Battle Standard and thus be BSB.

This implies that a 'Vampire Lord' cannot do so since he is not called 'Vampire' sure he has Vampire in his name but that is not his name. 'Vampire Lord' is not 'Vampire'
 
I am curious about your idea. You ask how it changes the meta, but i feel you have some other idea with this. I might be wrong :)
Have I missed something obvious good to have the lord as a bsb more than he carries static combat res and one less crumble where he is.
You save points in your armylist for not having to pay for a hero vamp, but that also means infinite crumble if the lord dies.
I think it would suck (in the bad non vampiric way) to only be able to buy powers to your lord and miss out on all the fun weapons and armors.
 
Vampire Lord cannot be the BSB. It'd be great if it could, but it can't. Page 88 in the VC Army Book at the bottom, is under the HERO section, not the Lord section. When you refer to a Vampire, its the Hero level. The Lord is called a Vampire LORD to specifically distinguish between the two. Just trying to save you a little trouble here, as it appears yet another thread has popped up with someone who wants to argue the point based on their interpretation of a commonly accepted rule. I mean no offense but honestly, just accept this and move on. In your own local group, hey, knock yourself out if you want to change this. Nothing prevents that. In official games, either with players who like to stick to the rules as closely as possible, and certainly in any organized tournament setting, a Vamp Lord will not ever be allowed to carry a BSB. If this was an option, it would say so under the VL section and the Lord section of the book as an upgrade. It doesn't. It only refers to it on the Hero section, because those two options are the only options.
 
I haven't played it this way and won't. I am just always looking for new ways to deploy my army and often in ways enemies wouldn't expect. I only provide my reasoning to show that it's not just wishful thinking and see if I am crazy or maybe their is ground to my train of thought. I guess the primary argument comes down to the rule change for who the general is in the AB. Wouldn't it be great if we could take a WK as the General? It just feels like the Army command unit (general, BSB) for VC is much weaker and costs more (disproportionately) than most other armies because of the AB rule for having a general.
 
I dont fully understand what you mean with that AB rule that changes who the general is.
Are you referring to the fact that our VC general must be a wizard?
I can tell you that our Army command unit, as you call it, is definately not weaker than other armies.
Go look at any regular Lord option in almost all of the armybooks and you will see that both the characteristics and the options for tooling up are less than a Vamplord. s5, t5, 5 attacks, high initiative, high weaponskill, ld10, options for ASF, RF, Beguile.... its nearly unrivalled.
What makes them really expensive is the lvl4 caster upgrade.
If you decide to keep him as a lvl1 theyre suddenly a lot cheaper for the combatoutput it represents.

Ive done it quite often, blenderlord lvl1 backed up by 2 lvl2 necros with at least 1 Mortis engine with the tome.
Saves quite some points, allows for a dispel scroll and another item like Book of Arkhan and your still casting as a lvl4 with the necros and lvl3 with your Lord.

Putting a BSB on the lord would make him even more of a prized target. He already is target nr1 since killing him not only gives ALOT of victorypoints, its also pretty much decisive for the game if he dies. Imagine a lord with BSB is worth 100 points extra. I, for one, would not want to risk him into combat anymore.
Having a wightking BSB (always my choice) is alot safer. Neatly tucked away in some bunker, the standard can do what its supposed to, safely guarded by a t5, 3 wounds hero (t5 and 3 wounds on a hero? try finding that in another AB).
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu