TVC II OOC General OOC Discussion

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm being objective here, neither agreeing or not, but I'd like to point out that 5 is average for Vampire Lord, right? The best of the best? If I'm wrong - which I'll check now - by all means ignore me
 
Harland said:
Allow me to present a counterargument.

As it says in Roland's bio, he is an exemplar even among examplars when it comes to knifework and killing. Surely such a man would be able to go toe-to-toe with your average vampire?

If you're talking about untrained vampire younglings who are not much older than an actual human would be, then yeah. But your WS and Agility values are nearly on par with the better fighters on the Council like Peter. And as Malochai said, 5 is the average value for a Vampire Lord, one for whom 'weekend picnic with the family' actually takes ten years and involves 5 million skeleton waiters. A dandy and a ponce he may be but he'll still whoop Roland's arse and finish in time for tea and crumpets.
 
I would argue that the fight would not be as one-sided as you might think. I think that with sufficient talent and training (and by sufficient I mean a helluva lot), a particularly exceptional human (i.e. nigh unparalleled) could fight off a vampire lord.

Also, from a plot point of view, it is also important that Roland can hold his own. He is Faust's protector. Faust gets blown over in the morning wind. Faust is not a fan of other vampires. If Roland can't defend him, then he'll get pasted within a day.
 
Harland said:
I would argue that the fight would not be as one-sided as you might think. I think that with sufficient talent and training (and by sufficient I mean a helluva lot), a particularly exceptional human (i.e. nigh unparalleled) could fight off a vampire lord.

Also, from a plot point of view, it is also important that Roland can hold his own. He is Faust's protector. Faust gets blown over in the morning wind. Faust is not a fan of other vampires. If Roland can't defend him, then he'll get pasted within a day.

Actually this is true. I know that the Emperors champions are actually able to stand toe to toe with most vamps no matter how old and powerful. Though veryyyy rare individuals of course.
 
Harland said:
I would argue that the fight would not be as one-sided as you might think. I think that with sufficient talent and training (and by sufficient I mean a helluva lot), a particularly exceptional human (i.e. nigh unparalleled) could fight off a vampire lord.

Also, from a plot point of view, it is also important that Roland can hold his own. He is Faust's protector. Faust gets blown over in the morning wind. Faust is not a fan of other vampires. If Roland can't defend him, then he'll get pasted within a day.

And that's where I fundamentally disagree with you. I find it highly implausible that a human, no matter how well trained, can beat an average vampire lord in straight up CQC. That's not to say that a human can't beat the average vampire lord at all, but certainly not in that department.

As for the latter, I don't know what we'll be fighting at the moment but it seems as though the only vampire we'll be (eventually) facing is Vekarin. But at the end of the day, if you can't accept the possibility of Roland being able to hold his own(can't say for sure yet), then you'll need to think of some way around Faust's inhibitions.
 
Sweeney Todd said:
Harland said:
I would argue that the fight would not be as one-sided as you might think. I think that with sufficient talent and training (and by sufficient I mean a helluva lot), a particularly exceptional human (i.e. nigh unparalleled) could fight off a vampire lord.

Also, from a plot point of view, it is also important that Roland can hold his own. He is Faust's protector. Faust gets blown over in the morning wind. Faust is not a fan of other vampires. If Roland can't defend him, then he'll get pasted within a day.

And that's where I fundamentally disagree with you. I find it highly implausible that a human, no matter how well trained, can beat an average vampire lord in straight up CQC. That's not to say that a human can't beat the average vampire lord at all, but certainly not in that department.

As for the latter, I don't know what we'll be fighting at the moment but it seems as though the only vampire we'll be (eventually) facing is Vekarin. But at the end of the day, if you can't accept the possibility of Roland being able to hold his own(can't say for sure yet), then you'll need to think of some way around Faust's inhibitions.

Um... its fairly obvious that theres a lot of cross purpose talk. Harland says that a human can beat a vampire in a fight, you say that no human can withstand a vampire lord pummelling them (with exceptions).

Both things of what you say are true even assuming that all vampire lords are your average uberlord of night. A highly skilled human can very easily use slight of hand, really sharp blades and dodging skills to avoid any direct hits by a vampire, but a direct hit or two by the vampire on the human will probably wipe the floor. It also depends on how the vampires attributes are aligned: in the novels, vampires can be really fast, or really strong, or maybe a half-way house, but not generally both awesome. Therefore there must be some leeway in the possibility.

Also, inhibitions is the wrong word. You mean inadequacy.
 
The Archivist said:
Sweeney Todd said:
Harland said:
I would argue that the fight would not be as one-sided as you might think. I think that with sufficient talent and training (and by sufficient I mean a helluva lot), a particularly exceptional human (i.e. nigh unparalleled) could fight off a vampire lord.

Also, from a plot point of view, it is also important that Roland can hold his own. He is Faust's protector. Faust gets blown over in the morning wind. Faust is not a fan of other vampires. If Roland can't defend him, then he'll get pasted within a day.

And that's where I fundamentally disagree with you. I find it highly implausible that a human, no matter how well trained, can beat an average vampire lord in straight up CQC. That's not to say that a human can't beat the average vampire lord at all, but certainly not in that department.

As for the latter, I don't know what we'll be fighting at the moment but it seems as though the only vampire we'll be (eventually) facing is Vekarin. But at the end of the day, if you can't accept the possibility of Roland being able to hold his own(can't say for sure yet), then you'll need to think of some way around Faust's inhibitions.

Um... its fairly obvious that theres a lot of cross purpose talk. Harland says that a human can beat a vampire in a fight, you say that no human can withstand a vampire lord pummelling them (with exceptions).

Both things of what you say are true even assuming that all vampire lords are your average uberlord of night. A highly skilled human can very easily use slight of hand, really sharp blades and dodging skills to avoid any direct hits by a vampire, but a direct hit or two by the vampire on the human will probably wipe the floor. It also depends on how the vampires attributes are aligned: in the novels, vampires can be really fast, or really strong, or maybe a half-way house, but not generally both awesome. Therefore there must be some leeway in the possibility.

Also, inhibitions is the wrong word. You mean inadequacy.
I think with what Sweeney is getting at is that a human is not going to be able to match an average Vampire Lord (The Older and more Powerful of their kind) in pure strength, speed and (if the vampire has spent centuries practicing) his fighting skill.
Sure a human might still beat a Vampire Lord in a straight up fight through a trick, luck or using vampiric weaknesses against them but they'll be at a disadvantage.

The main thing to remember is that many of the Council are centuries old (so they have centuries of experience and training plus the increased power than comes with age) and are for the most part not low generation.

Also as Sweeney says the only vampire we might have as an enemy anyway is Vekarin and he'll smash Roland alongside half a dozen Blood Dragons at once with annoying ease :tongue:

I would imagine WS, TS and Agility at 4 would still represent an exceptionally skilled human.
 
Sweeney Todd said:
And that's where I fundamentally disagree with you. I find it highly implausible that a human, no matter how well trained, can beat an average vampire lord in straight up CQC.

Why do you find this so implausible? Let us look at this analytically. A vampire, Lord or no, has three natural advantages over a human:
  1. Magic
  2. Speed
  3. Strength

As we are considering close combat, magic is effectively irrelevant. Therefore: Speed and Strength.
A vampire's innate speed of movement and agility is of course greater than those of a human. However, I don't see any reason why an exceptional human with exceptional training would not be able to mach this. Allow me to take an example from the real world:
[video=youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hujvVmuLuoM[/video]
I highly doubt an average vampire lord could do this.

Strength, however, is another matter. A mundane human would never be able to match a vampire for strength. However, the fact is that strength isn't anything. Roland's style of combat barely involve strength, but much more often using his opponent's strength against them. He matches strength with skill and dancing blades.

In conclusion, I do not think that it is anywhere near as implausible as you make it sound that a human like Roland could match an average vampire lord.


EDIT: Another thing to point out about Roland's fighting style. He would never, under any circumstances, simply slug it out in hand to hand combat. He ends his fights quickly with stealth and deadly skill. If he were to clash with Vekarin, he would aim to daze, discombobulate or distract him and then quickly make his escape. The 5's represent not only his incredible skill at killing, but also his ability to do this.
I would not say that 4 is exceptional, at least enough. 3 is average, so 4 is very good.
Finally, neither of you seem to understand what I was talking about when I mentioned Faust. His nature could put him into possibly violent clashes with the other vampires quite often. I am not talking about some mythical enemy, but the other characters. There's no rule that we all have to get along like sheep in a luscious meadow, is there?
 
Harland said:
The 5's represent not only his incredible skill at killing, but also his ability to do this.
I would not say that 4 is exceptional, at least enough. 3 is average, so 4 is very good.
Finally, neither of you seem to understand what I was talking about when I mentioned Faust. His nature could put him into possibly violent clashes with the other vampires quite often. I am not talking about some mythical enemy, but the other characters. There's no rule that we all have to get along like sheep in a luscious meadow, is there?
5's represent incredible skill amongst vampires, it represents the fact they're survived centuries and honed their skills over that period. That they've stepped up into a new level of power.
4 is exceptional amongst humanity, 4 is very quick and skilled for a man, 3 is a strong human
Also you could consider doing a bracket skill to show higher ability against vampires, specialized training geared towards defeating them.

We simply disagree however and that's fine :) I'm going from what I recall was said during TVC so I could be mistaken.
I'm sure a GM (DoN or Simon will comment on this at some point anyway and give us our definite answer :thumbsup: )
 
I propose a solution: We keep the stats where they are. However I acknowledge that, in a duel between Roland and a vampire lord with equal weapon skill and agility, Roland would likely lose.
This is due to strength and toughness. Although Roland's skill would usually compensate for his deficit in strength, against someone with equal or greater skill it would certainly tell. In addition, when fighting Roland usually aims to dispatch his opponents as quickly as possible. Against someone who would not be killed by anything short of decapitation, this would not work.
Against a vampire lord, as I have said, Roland would likely not attempt to win, but to escape - say, by making a distracting blow to the face, then scarpering.

I hope this is amiable to all concerned.
 
Well, like Get says, at the end of the day it's the GM's decision, so of DoN or Simon say something, then fine, if not, it should stay as it is :)
 
Sainna said:
Malochai said:
Pretty much, there was a battle but you don't need to know about that, and then we all went into the hall. After a bit more arguing, it has been decided we're going to split into two groups; one going to Silver Pinnacle to petition Neferata for her aid, and the other going to the Wastes to attempt to gather information on the gathering Chaos army, which has been said MIGHT be lead by Vekarin Banespike.

Oh, yeah, and we all hate Morty :clown:

Oh, dear god send the ones with brains to Neferata or there she will do head ripping :(

Morty's going there, he's brains enough, but he is going to have to work hard to resist Neferata's aura. I think he'll manage it, but I'm planning on a comical scene with his baby necro losing control. xD

Somehow, I get the feeling that Morty and Faust are NOT going to like each other...then again, when does Morty get on with anyone? :tongue:
 
Harland said:
Why do you find this so implausible? Let us look at this analytically. A vampire, Lord or no, has three natural advantages over a human:
  1. Magic
  2. Speed
  3. Strength

You forgot a fourth advantage elder vampires have, one that is perhaps more important than the ones you listed: time. Roland has lived for merely several decades, but the average vampire lord has had centuries of time to spare for training and practice. This is not possible for any human, no matter how talented, to replicate because they don't live nearly as long as that. What the guy in the video you posted did can be done by an average vampire lord, not to mention the ones who choose to specialise in that field.

The 'bigger' warrior types on the council, GM characters notwithstanding(Peter, Kraskor and Shah come to mind) have been fighting for centuries or even millenia, and so my main issue is that a 30-something year old human can somehow approach their level of expertise and agility.

Oh and sure, we all get along...if you discount Morturion pissing everyone off all the time, and Nekhlior almost directly attacking Morty in front of the whole Council, and Simon and Kraskor trading cheap shots, and Graveclaw yelling and bawling as though he was a wannabe Giant, and Alastor throwing tantrums, and the vampire twins shrieking their lungs out, and Graveclaw hulking out, and the copious amounts of tactical facepalm, and...
 
Sweeney Todd said:
You forgot a fourth advantage elder vampires have, one that is perhaps more important than the ones you listed: time. Roland has lived for merely several decades, but the average vampire lord has had centuries of time to spare for training and practice. This is not possible for any human, no matter how talented, to replicate because they don't live nearly as long as that. What the guy in the video you posted did can be done by an average vampire lord, not to mention the ones who choose to specialise in that field.

The 'bigger' warrior types on the council, GM characters notwithstanding(Peter, Kraskor and Shah come to mind) have been fighting for centuries or even millenia, and so my main issue is that a 30-something year old human can somehow approach their level of expertise and agility.
Studies have shown that to be an expert at something, you require 10,000 hours of practice. After that time, practice does not hone skills nearly as much, but rather maintains them. So these centuries of practice would not linearly increase the skill, but simply keep them in good condition.


Oh and sure, we all get along...if you discount Morturion pissing everyone off all the time, and Nekhlior almost directly attacking Morty in front of the whole Council, and Simon and Kraskor trading cheap shots, and Graveclaw yelling and bawling as though he was a wannabe Giant, and Alastor throwing tantrums, and the vampire twins shrieking their lungs out, and Graveclaw hulking out, and the copious amounts of tactical facepalm, and...
bahahahahahahahahahahaha
 
Sadly, that will just make those who like integers dissatisfied, and the GMs will get cross because then everyone will use 1.9999 recurring for a stat and that's not allowed...

Long story short, you can't please everyone. Unless you're an expert diplomat, that is. xD
 
Alrighty, GoW TO THE SUPPLEMENT CAVE

batman-transition-thing-a-s.gif
 
My mortal character is a specialist and he makes do with fighting and technique stats of 4. His technique increases to 5 only when fighting vampires.

It is highly unlikely that a mortal can match a vampire of great age. Maybe one that only just been sired but not one thats been around for centuries except by luck and we don't have a stat for luck.:cool:
 
Simon von Carstein said:
It is highly unlikely that a mortal can match a vampire of great age. Maybe one that only just been sired but not one thats been around for centuries except by luck and we don't have a stat for luck.:cool:

I readily admit that Roland would likely be outmatched by a vampire lord, but not for lack of skill. I don't see why a human cannot match a vampire in actual skill (as opposed to strength, toughness etc.). It's not as if the blood kiss suddenly bestows you with a proficiency for learning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu