TVC II OOC General OOC Discussion

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think its less an issue of the undead being evil, and more an issue of them being unnatural and grotesque reflection of the living. It could be less of a hate for the raised dead, and more of a hate for the necromantic force that raised them and forcing people to do things against their will when they should be left to have their eternal slumber in peace.

Now then... whether or not Kavok is a nice guy... While that is a possibility, that may not be the whole story... He may have a bit of a soft spot for the ladies... Which will likely prove to be a very bad thing... Being a mortal stuck between two female vampires is probably not that great if he is wanting to stay in one piece...
 
goulking88 said:
anything that exists only to cause harm is evil.

That's some pretty narrow minded, maybe even arrogant way of thinking. With this logic, a sword would be evil since it's created to cause destruction.

Dhar and most undead aren't sentient. Thus they don't know what they're doing. Since they lack any sense of morality or conscious, they can't be evil or good. They don't understand what they're doing, they don't understand that it's wrong. It's not evil, it's dangerous. They are as evil as a poisonous snake or a rabid dog.

Besides, necromancy is also used to create. It heals and envigors undead, or negative energy based lifeforms (for lack of a better form). It's harmful to positive based lifeforms, but the lore of life is harmful to the undead and beneficial to the living. Does that make it evil in the eyes of the undead?

The world is primarily life force oriented. However, if the world got suddenly blasted by a wave of dark magic and everything alive died, plants and animals, ad everything that survived mutated into a negative energy based lifeform. The world continues for several centuries or thousands of years and it evolves new "unlife". Now "death" creatures are the primary "lifeform" on the world. Any force of life magic would cause harm to the undead. Would it be evil?

And what about humans? We eat babies too, you know, but babies of other species (cows, horse, etc). Vampires regard humans the way humans regard lifestock. To say that vampires are evil because they need to feed on something that's alive, is to say humans are evil for being omnivores. There is little difference, than the fact that we, humans, think that we are more important than other animals, which is an observers fallacy. Ofcourse we think that. Anything that causes us harm is dangerous. It would be easier to accept it as evil, but it isn't necassarily objectively evil.

If you're a vampire, and the only harm you've ever done to a human is feed. And some adventurer kicks in your door, steals the wealth you accumulated legitimately over centuries, kills your servants and tries to bash in your skull with a hammer, who is more wrong?

It's undeniable that vampires, undead and dhar magic are dangerous, but objectively evil, that's hard to claim.
 
:frown: I'm a little offended by that Dark Wolfen I'm not arrogant or narrow minded I just know the difference between right and wrong, a sword isn't evil but the guy holding it could be a sword can also be used to protect people.Dhar is evil becuse it comes places where bad things happend like murders and graveyards it is chaos at its most pure it is the stuff that makes Daemons Dhar only corrupts warps and destroys everything it touchs it shouldn't even exist and Necromancy was the creation of a monster and mad-man and becuse of that it is tainted and is rightfuly shunned undead are like chaos they have no place in the natural world and need to be killed with fire, Snakes arn't evil they just need to be treated with respect, and rabid animals need to be put down becuse their suffering its a mercy killing.


Necromancy isn't natural to the warhammer world, as I said all it does is cause harm, while the lore of life is natural it just happens like the moon or the sun Necromancy is man-made.


and why does everybody try and go all animal rights about eating meat eating meat is fine as long as the animal is butchered right (you kill the animal as painlessly as possible) when a vampire feeds on someone it enslaves the person to the Vampires will that is evil plus Vampires don't need to feed on the living they can exist on the blood of animals and dead people just fine hell they don't even need blood they only need magic to patch the hole in their soul. killing to live isn't evil however needlessly inflicting pain and making someone love you while you hurt them is evil which is what most Vampires do.
 
Both arguments are valid, however, we have gone a little off-track. Furthermore, the point this whole argument arose over was that MORTY said that Leoncoeur was arrogant, not that Leoncoeur was arrogant. It's an RP, not a statement, and Morty has always had controversial opinions; I don't think that one is out of his character.

So, back to the fact that this story needs a kickstart? Shall I enforce one (I've got some in mind)?
 
It's the general discussion about the roleplay. If you just want to talk go in the chat rooms for topics like these, there's usually a few people in there
 
Guys, I think we have come to a good stopping point for that particular discussion; I would prefer for people to not get insulted as was, potentially, close to happening.
 
It ain't over until the big bunny sings! :tongue:

Back to seriousness. I will do something to speed up the plot in a week unless somebody stops me within a week or someone better speeds it up first, purely to stop the RP from dying.

Any suggestions, or is everyone OK with this? I will leave a week's window of oppurtunity of open just in case any modpowers want to stop me, and will delete posts if they mention this to me after I've posted. I'm just doing this to help the RP, so don't take it personally.

P.S. nasty arguments don't happen on 'noctem. If you wanna have an argument, go to Warseer or some other troll-infested, inferior forum! :tongue:
 
That is probably good, but I think we should get on with it in the wastes to. GoW, do you want to make a post of everyone getting out of the portal?
 
the hidden one said:
That is probably good, but I think we should get on with it in the wastes to. GoW, do you want to make a post of everyone getting out of the portal?

If you wait til tommorrow I shall, I dont have time to post atm but dont want to hold people up so Ill make time in the morning
 
The Dread King said:
I will do something to speed up the plot in a week unless somebody stops me within a week or someone better speeds it up first, purely to stop the RP from dying.

Any suggestions, or is everyone OK with this? I will leave a week's window of oppurtunity of open just in case any modpowers want to stop me, and will delete posts if they mention this to me after I've posted. I'm just doing this to help the RP, so don't take it personally.

I've left my window of oppurtunity open (it's within a few hours of closing). If nobody's kickstarted by 10.11pm tonight, I will enforce a kickstart tonight or tomorrow, unless a modpower stops me. This is for the good of the TVC II.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu