Ghoul King or Vampire Lord?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

LSK

Zombie
Dec 3, 2012
3
Zombies
3
Hello all, new to VC and new member of your fine forum!

I've been banging out a few theory lists too see what I feel works, and what I like. The only problem I'm having is I can't quite decide between the Ghoul King or A vampire lord.

I'm in love with the raw killing power of the SGK, but the fact that a Vampire lord is more survivable, and more utilitarian seems to balance that well.

The builds I've been looking at are;

SGK
Red Fury
Beguile
Aura of Dark Majesty
Dread Knight
Giant Blade
OTS
Dragonbane Gem
Which comes out at 440

Or
Vampire Lord
Heavy Armour
Shield
Red Fury
Aura of Dark Majesty
Beguile
Ogre Blade
OTS
Talisman of preservation
Level 3 Wizard
Which comes out at 489

I need the expertise of more experienced denizens of the night here. Or perhaps neither of these builds is any good? :tongue:
 
Welcome fangling! Hope you'll like your stay here :konrad:

Your builds are rather good, but they are both trying to be too much. Your SGK is a cheap fighting machine... keep him as such. Drop Dread Knight, AoDM and Beguile.

Your VL only need magic levels if you don't run a Master Necromancer. If you don't then give him 4 levels(you need that +4 to dispelling and casting). Also I would drop Beguile here, it seems alot of new players really like Beguile, but you don't want your vamps stuck in challenges.


Wether to go SGK or VL is really up to your list. The SGK is as I said a cheap fighting machine where as the VL can be built in different ways(you'll often see him mounted in a Cavalry deathstar).
 
Thanks a lot for the advice! The only reason I took Beguile/Aura was because of the fragility of the SGK against Lords (even some heroes) So I figured I could at least neutralise that in part with those two.

Would the Killy GK be decent if I had him backed by a cadre of necromancers, then? The balance between damage output and magical support seems too be much more of a finesse skill than I had anticipated!
 
It is tricky, I must admit. I advise checking a lot of other lists and comparing them to battle reports- then try a few games with different variations, see which ones you prefer. In the end it comes down to your style of play- there is no " only option".
 
Welcome to the forum, young vampire. The men's room is down to your left and the little ghouls' powder room is on the right.


LSK said:
Would the Killy GK be decent if I had him backed by a cadre of necromancers, then? The balance between damage output and magical support seems too be much more of a finesse skill than I had anticipated!

Absolutely. Having a level 4 necro and a level 1 would be a decent idea. Put a scroll on the hero.

I prefer running a level 3 VL backed by a level 1 necro and a vamp hero in most of my lists. The SGK is too vulnerable not having any armor and only the 5+ regen save. Killing Blow attacks are becoming more and more frequent with every new army book so he's rather susceptible to dying early on.
 
The Sun King said:
Also I would drop Beguile here, it seems alot of new players really like Beguile, but you don't want your vamps stuck in challenges.

I have to disagree. Beguile can be useful even if you're not in a challenge. An enemy character only needs to be in BTB with your lord to attack him so, even if your not in a challenge, it can still be useful protection.

In addition, assuming that the model fails the Ld test, then it must reroll any successful to-hit rolls, regardless of who it attacks. So, especially if you end up against a monster of some kind, beguile can also be useful for minimising damage to the Lord's unit.


As to the VL/SGK, it would probably depend partially on what points you're playing:

2000: I'd probably go with a Vampire Lord. You can make a decent blender lord, who is also a Lv3/4 wizard. Whereas, whilst a Ghoul King might be slightly better in combat, he'll also be more fragile and will give very little magical support.

2500: I'd try a Ghoul King, backed by a Lv4 Master Necromancer. The Ghoul King is still fragile, but now he at least has strong magical support, and can concentrate on mincing squads.

You could also consider replacing the GK with a Lv1 Vampire Lord. He'd be more survivable, but not as strong in combat.

3000: I'd consider a Master Necromancer, with a Vampire Lord as your general. At this level, you can fully kit out your vampire lord, and still have plenty of points left for 1 (possibly even 2) master necromancers.
 
Ghoul Kings are imo the better on foot choice. Built in saves and built in rerolls makes for a cheap combat lord. Magic support comes from Master Deathcro
 
Aye, and you might consider Quickblood for your Ghoul King. I8 is already pretty badass, and Quickblood might be a bit overkill, but there are always those nasty Highelves who will strike first with their Great Weapons ( if I'm not mistaken) and you really want to hit first if possible

Ow yeah, welcome to the Coven mate! :thumbsup:
 
Elbisrever said:
Aye, and you might consider Quickblood for your Ghoul King. I8 is already pretty badass, and Quickblood might be a bit overkill, but there are always those nasty Highelves who will strike first with their Great Weapons ( if I'm not mistaken) and you really want to hit first if possible

Ow yeah, welcome to the Coven mate! :thumbsup:

I'd be more inclined to use quickblood on the vampire lord (instead of Aura).

However, I'll add that I've used Quickblood on a Ghoul King on a few occasions. It does feel a bit wasteful when I'm writing my lists. However, I also face quite a few enemies with ASF, I9/10 etc., and in those cases I'm always very glad to have ASF. It also helps a great deal against things that bestow ASL on my units, or spells that reduce initiative.

Not a necessity by any means, but I would consider it if you have the points.
 
Wow, you responses have been a fantastic help, and you have definitely given me a lot too think about.

Judging by the timely and helpful responses here, I can see this forum was a more than worthwhile choice xD
 
I like VLs with a nice armor save PLUS a 4+ ward (with VC if your general has anything worse than a 4++ youre just asking for trouble). In addition, a ward save stacks with MR, so a hero carrying MR2 for the unit gives your VL a tasty 2+ ward against magic. Regen does NOT stack with MR :(. Finally, going back to armour, u give the VL the charmed shield so that one time when you fail your look out sir from that rock lobber/cannon, on a 2+ your VL lives.

SGK has no armor and only a 5+ save... not very scary if u ask me. Yeah SGK is cheaper than a VL, but there's a very simple reason why he's cheaper - he dies easier than a VL flat out. Though if was rocking a Mortis Engine I'd consider the SGK, but I'd try my hardest for him to NOT be my general.

Sorry to all the SGK lovers :)
 
for some reason i have had better luck with fencer blades and str potion over a ogre blade and ots on my sgk, smart players know to put everthing into the gk to kill him :( but when you need 5 it is another story:tongue:
 
Unless you are playing games over 2500 points, you're probably only going to have one or two lords if your taking a VL or a SGK. In that case, you don't want your army to crumble. SGKs die too easily so probably, you'll either have a weak master necro as general or an easily killable SGK. Opponents will try to exploit this weakness, and your army could end up suffering from serious crumbling. VLs are much better at surviving so will be a more reasonable choice at that points level, though SGKs are very fun to use.

In larger games, use SGKs, but not as your general. They can even be fielded just so you can fit anoteher terrorgheist into your army.
I have just had a thought for large games: spam SGKs? It would be funny to watch your opponent desperately try to kill them all before they reach his/her lines, and inevitably fail. I have not thought this through much tactically, but it would be enjoyable at the least.
 
This "SGK's die easily" thing is a bit overblown. They're T5 with 3 Wounds and 5+ Regen - they're as tough as a Crypt Horror while having a smaller frontage, better WS, and being orders of magnitude more dangerous offensively. I don't think that qualifies as "dies easily".

Personally, it depends on what type of list you're going for. I'm of the opinion that the strongest lists VC have to offer are Cavalry Star and Scream Spam, and each prefers a different kind of Lord (Vampire Lord for the Cav Star, Ghoul King for Screams). If you make me pick one, though, I give the nod to the Ghoul King for being cheaper and because I don't have to worry as much about gearing him up defensively.
 
I almost never loose my king unless it is too a miscast. People who throw him into a unit with killingblow are just asking to be disappointed by him.
 
Johnny-Crass said:
I almost never loose my king unless it is too a miscast. People who throw him into a unit with killingblow are just asking to be disappointed by him.

Sometimes you don't really have the luxury of choice in that regard though.

I've faced a Khorne army where every model had killing blow. So, I either send him in and hope that they won't roll a 6, or I hide a ~400pt combat character and risk losing because he isn't there to tip the scales.
 
I have just had a thought for large games: spam SGKs? It would be funny to watch your opponent desperately try to kill them all before they reach his/her lines, and inevitably fail. I have not thought this through much tactically, but it would be enjoyable at the least.

I did that once in 4th edition, where 'the Strigoi' was still a bloodline. I would buy 1 Lord and 3 Hero's, give them all flying and put them in the front rank of a big unit of whatever. Back then, the Strigoi could not buy any mundane or magic items, but his bloodline powers were pretty good, and their inherited abilities made them stock killing machines. They would charge out of the unit in turn 2. Good times! xD

So yeah, for a fun play ( or a very themed list) you could go SGK spam :) It would certainly make me nervous as an opponent to face 3 of these monsters :P
 
I have no idea how you guys(other than Johnny and awesome-Rothgar) play your SGK's but I have never lost mine. Beguile is worthless since there is SO FEW characters who can go toe-to-toe with a kitted SGK(he will utterly murder anything short of Chaos Lord or Greater Daemon).
 
kevin.hopkins7 said:
I found out the hard way that a doombull can also kill one :( luckily I somehow still won the game though!

Given the doombull's stats is all 6s and 5s that much should have seemed obvious :P


Unless it's for certain lists, I prefer to have a Vampire lord over the SGK+ master necro combo. While I've never lost the SGK (ignoring silly lists like riding a terrorgheist) I'm a fan of versatility in as many units in my list as possible, and the SGK has absolutely no versatility.
 
Yeah, beware of the Doombull, especially if he's using the Rambull build - he's as good as any combat character out there. I think that the SGK is easily a top-3 combat character in the game, though - he'll definitely make anyone who fights him sweat it out.
 
If you're running a Death MN, lets not forget the VL's Ld 10 which makes Spirit Leech scarier. Testing to redirect charges using this instead of a SGK Ld 9 helps as well. This is important bc BSBs are becoming more rare in VC lists.

Did I mention you can mount a VL on a barded nightmare or hell steed?

I must've mentioned at least 5 ways the VL is superior to the SGK. The only pro to the SGK is that he's cheaper... However...

You get what you pay for, and I don't go to Wal Mart for my General :).

Though if he's not seeing combat, a SGK is fine (see Johnnys Mindrazor list)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu