Ghoul King or Vampire Lord?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
The Sun King said:
I have no idea how you guys(other than Johnny and awesome-Rothgar) play your SGK's but I have never lost mine. Beguile is worthless since there is SO FEW characters who can go toe-to-toe with a kitted SGK(he will utterly murder anything short of Chaos Lord or Greater Daemon).

As someone who managed to lose mine in all but one game, there are quite a few characters who can go toe to toe with one... :'(
 
The more eggs(get the pun Eggspr? :) ) you put in one basket the easier you lose the game. The guys who can take out a SGK can also take out a VL so I don't find that point valid at all. Also someone stated that a SGK is not versatile... come again? By splitting up your Hybrid VL and getting a Master Necromancer AND a SGK you have far more versatility instead of dumping all your points into one character. Plus with SGK+MN you can have level 4 Death, and that my dear friends win games :)
 
Ha!

I'm not saying all eggs in 1 basket, I'm comparing both as if they were lvl 1 casters. Both can have a lvl 4 Death MN.

Many ppl in my group always run Death, and of they saw me rocking a SGK as my general its game over for me - they'd spirit leech caress and fate him before he'd get a chance to make way and kill redirectors. 5+ ward without an engine.

SGK
5+ ward against magic snipes without an engine or MR3. Then all those extra points u saved on your lord that were put into your army will crumble. If a SGK's unit gets Whithered, lets say a bunch or spearmen try and take him out. Say the SGK takes 3-4 wounds, he's saving maybe 2 of them on his 5+ regen for that round of combat.

VL
4+ ward with 45 point item. With MR2 or MR3 in his unit u have a 2+ ward against magic snipes. If the VL gets withered, he takes the same amount of wounds, but he saves them all on a 3+ AS and 4+ ward.

U were saying the VL is just as easily killed as a SGK? ;). Math says you're wrong, unless you're talking about a flaming attack Scar Vet.
 
Ahhh ok I thought u meant guys as any guys.

SGK does work better against other tricksters shard as u don't have to reroll regen. There's a benefit to your boy :)
 
Sorry if I was too unclear Eggie :D

Fencers are rather good defensively but when I field a SGK I field them to stomp infantry, and in that department Sword of Bloodshed rules supreme. Dreadknight is a bit tricky since you have to issue and accept challenges which means that the SGK won't do his job(killing inf in this case) properly.

But both Fencers and Dreadknight is viable, you just have to know why you're fielding the SGK that way and how to utilize it.
 
A challenge isn't such a bad place for a SGK in the first round of combat. Keeps him fairly safe from tons of attacks, and like many said earlier he can rip apart most characters. There's overkill against a unit champ, and after any champs or chars are gone, he's getting hit on 5's.
 
Definitely do not make a SGK your general...he's a target for being a SGK already, if he's your general too, your opponent will be sniping him, and he will die.
 
Ummmm highest ld is general so you must be running a vampire lord or second king to make him not your general. Also he is really not fragile. Sit him in the corned of a unit and he will be fine.
 
Man, people here just do not give any love to Skabscrath. That bad boy is reason #1 to run an SGK in my opinion - you can counter Regenerators with it without exposing a whole unit to get hosed by a 5- or 10-point item, you get another Scream (and we all know that's useful), and most of the time it works out to be +2 Attacks anyway. The problem the Vampire Lord with Skabscrath faces is that his defenses take a big hit - not so for the Ghoul King.

And yeah, your Ghoul King is going to be the General in any game played under 4000 or so points - but to be honest with you, that's not a big deal. I've seen Master Necromancers die much more often (to miscasts or mage hunters) than Ghoul Kings, so I would have opted for that anyway.
 
I'd much rather run VL than a SGK; SGK is fragile because he will be targeted by your opponent. VLs can take targeting, SGKs don't absorb damage half as good as the VLs do.
 
rothgar13 said:
Man, people here just do not give any love to Skabscrath. That bad boy is reason #1 to run an SGK in my opinion - you can counter Regenerators with it without exposing a whole unit to get hosed by a 5- or 10-point item, you get another Scream (and we all know that's useful), and most of the time it works out to be +2 Attacks anyway. The problem the Vampire Lord with Skabscrath faces is that his defenses take a big hit - not so for the Ghoul King.

Personally, I've never been a fan of Skabsrath. The extra scream is nice (but only marginally better than the one available on a banshee), but makes the weapon feel more like a gimmick - something to use in one, very specific list, and never in anything else.

Frenzy is often annoying, rather than helpful (especially since it forces you to reveal your weapon), and isn't likely to last more than 1 turn. Devastating charge is ok as a built-in bonus, but not as something I'd ever want to pay for. Flaming attacks are nice, but I'd rather have more strength, since I face far more enemies with good armour than with regeneration. Essentially, I just feel that 75pts is a hell of a lot, considering that you're getting a scream, and not much else.
 
It's all about the ghoul king with skabscrath on terrorgheist :konrad:

Sure it isn't the best tactical choice, but it's hella fun!
 
The Dread King said:
I'd much rather run VL than a SGK; SGK is fragile because he will be targeted by your opponent. VLs can take targeting, SGKs don't absorb damage half as good as the VLs do.

Everything with only three wounds is fragile. That counts for the VL as well. The big differnce is that if your SGK dies you have lost a lot less points. And I honestly never lose my SGK, don't know how you guys play yours but mine are pretty safe and wrecks face in every close combat.
 
The Sun King said:
Everything with only three wounds is fragile. That counts for the VL as well. The big differnce is that if your SGK dies you have lost a lot less points.

The VL is still fragile, a 4+ ward save and a decent armour means he's not as fragile as a ghoul king.

Also, whilst you might have lost fewer points if your SGK dies, you'll still suffer the unpleasant effects of a general's death. Personally, I'd rather go for the less fragile one, and hope to avoid that eventuality altogether.
 
Yep, I think in most smaller games a VL is the way to go. That's not saying that SGKs can't exploit potential in larger games; in big games, take a VL AND some SGK(s). You get the best of both characters that way.
 
In my case, the experience is even more hands-on, as I am usually playing against Vampire Counts and I can tell you the damn SGK is a pain in the neck to kill.
 
Played a 50+ tournament a couple of weeks ago, with a SGK. Only lost him once in five games, and then only because I had to salvage some points as the rest of the army was quickly going down. Charged him alone into some ironguts with slaughtermaster and BSB. He killed the champ and both characters in challenges before receiving charges from the big cannon monster thingy on one side and some maneaters on the other side, sending him yet again to die. But he had managed to give me a few battle points before dying at least. And if I just would have had some luck I could have broken that irongut unit...it wasn't that far away, actually.

He is tough, really tough. Kills like few others, and can take a punch or two too. Really like to use him. Even more so equipped with wings, as that is a surprise worth quite a lot. In all but one game he was flying around all by his lonesome some of the time, killing monsters, characters, small units, and war machines with a great smile on his - and my - face. Just make sure he can overrun into new enemies and he'll be fine.

I ended up in eight place, in a very competitive tournament, with quite a few hard armies - even though it was using the Swedish comp-system.

That said, I'm still a bit unsure if the VL wouldn't be the better and safer choice. But it wouldn't be half the fun, that's for sure.
 
Baron Samedi said:
Played a 50+ tournament a couple of weeks ago, with a SGK. Only lost him once in five games, and then only because I had to salvage some points as the rest of the army was quickly going down. Charged him alone into some ironguts with slaughtermaster and BSB. He killed the champ and both characters in challenges before receiving charges from the big cannon monster thingy on one side and some maneaters on the other side, sending him yet again to die. But he had managed to give me a few battle points before dying at least. And if I just would have had some luck I could have broken that irongut unit...it wasn't that far away, actually.

He is tough, really tough. Kills like few others, and can take a punch or two too. Really like to use him. Even more so equipped with wings, as that is a surprise worth quite a lot. In all but one game he was flying around all by his lonesome some of the time, killing monsters, characters, small units, and war machines with a great smile on his - and my - face. Just make sure he can overrun into new enemies and he'll be fine.

I ended up in eight place, in a very competitive tournament, with quite a few hard armies - even though it was using the Swedish comp-system.

That said, I'm still a bit unsure if the VL wouldn't be the better and safer choice. But it wouldn't be half the fun, that's for sure.

Reading this reassures me that making my Strigoi with wings was cool idea xD
 
Yep wings is a fun upgrade. But I prefer to put it on a baby vamp, as a certain way of taking out cannons and artillery.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu