Malisteen said:Remember, it's not a ward save vs. regeneration. It's armor + the option to buy a ward save vs. regeneration. If you can take a mounted vamp lord (not always possible, since you then need to take a cav unit to put him in), then you can get a 2+ armor save without spending any of your power or items allowance, and even an infantry vamp lord generally will have a 4+ armor save at the minimum. That's what should get compared to the ghoul king's 5+ regen. And then on top of that starting level of defense, the vampire has the option to take additional defenses that the ghoul king just has no access to, and imo that's where the vamp lord pulls ahead on the competitive end. Yes, vamps spend points on defense, but that's because they want to, not because they have to.
If ghoul kings could buy magic armor they would, and the fact that they can't is a strike against them, not something in their favor. They don't have more points for offensive kit because they have adequate defenses 'built in'. They have more points to spend on offense because they aren't allowed to buy the kind of defensive gear that most serious melee character would consider compulsory, and with good reason. A horde of S6 great weapons, not an uncommon sight in my area these days, has pretty decent odds of offing a ghoul king in a singe round of combat. Yeah, you can heal him if he's hurt, but not if he's dead.
Frankly, in my mind both the Mortis Engine and the dragonbane gem are downright compulsory if you're running a ghoul king. Thankfully the gem is cheap, and the engine is a good unit anyway, though I wish it fit a bit better with the ghoul king thematically. I mean, it's not a bad fit, but not as good as terrorgheists or varghulfs, but oh well.
Even if you're going for a 'cheap' vamp lord, you can still get something more survivable and just as killy out of the vamp lord than you can out of the ghoul king
I still love the ghoul king as a concept and a model and a unit, even. I'm having fun converting my own (I'm giving the ghoul king that came with the terrorgheist model a more upright, lordly pose), and I look forward to fielding it. But it doesn't seem like a competitive choice next to the vampire lord even before you consider the vamp lord's potential magic abilities - which can be a big deal in an army as magic-dependent as ours.
I agree entirely, and to be honest it's one of the reasons I don't build my Ghoulking as a unit killer:
Maydrek the Deformed 450pts
Powers - Curse of the Revenant, Beguile, Aura of Dark Majesty
Items - Scabscarth, Dragonbane Gem, Other Tricksters Shard
He screams and challenges. Getting a +5 CR shouldn't be too difficult and he does some damage to the unit with his scream as well.
The way I see it, this is the most survivable I can make a Ghoulking. +1 Wound, 2+ ward against flaming, a good chance of making the enemy re-roll successful hits (combine with Graveguard and the screaming banner to make the enemy WS1 for even more fun!) and a load of damage potential.
He is also useful against large targets and monstrous infantry where you will have less models in BtB.
Also, a horde of S6 models shouldn't kill him in 2 rounds (18 attacks) IF he has either a successful fear test or a Mortis engine in support. though I think the moral of the story is the Ghoulking may have to be a little choosier about his targets. He will hard-counter some units and get rolled by others.
EDIT: Also, I don't tend to see the armoursave as a deciding factor between the 2 options as a mounted vampire lord is an unattainable option for a Strigoi so if you wanted your lord on a steed there is only 1 option (As stated in my opening post I believe). Unmounted a 4+ save is of mimimal use against units that would threaten a Ghoulking or a vampire lord (strength 5+ as lower have a hard time wounding) and to increase it further will take magic items and it will thus fall into the same catergory as Wardsave VS Regen essentially. I probably should of said "Armour/Wardsave VS 5+ regen".