Ghouls or Skeletons?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Jul 12, 2010
377
Colchester
Zombies
218
I really cant decide which of our rubbish core is better to use? now that we have to have atleast 25% core im finding it hard to choose. I have played a few games with a block of skeles both with and without spears and they did sod all and got dusted pretty quick, and i played a few games with block of ghouls and they also did nothing and got dusted prety quick, so i am thinking just stick to the skeles in horde because atleast they have a command. what is other peoples opinion on this? what do you all use for your 25% core?
 
stevielash said:
...Skeletons are better at not getting killed.

I don't think it's that clearly cut, really. Skeletons can benefit from their armour and parry save, true, but the T4 and WS3 of the Ghouls goes a long way of providing them with a rudimentary defense as well. Skeletons do have the perk of carrying standards though, which can literally make or break your game if a certain scenario is rolled. ;)

Edit: Regardless, I still prefer to use Skeletons. I just plainly like them better, despite how well or not they perform in comparison to those creepy ghoulies~
 
Since I own both units I use both units. It all depends on the deployment. Skeletons work excellent against other simple RnF and ghouls work wonders against big things and things without armor save (Poisoned attacks!). I hate my skeletons for their sucky WS and I hate that I have to remove a ghoul for each wound my opponent does with no saves at all (I atleast want some of the deaths to be on my hands aka me rolling crappy dice). I love my Ghouls for their 2 attacks that are poisoned and I love my skeletons for being just awesome and so totally "vampire" that I must field atleast one unit of the buggers.

Hope it gives some insight (most likely not ;))
 
Ghouls:
WS 3 > WS 2 -> Ghouls will usually need a 3 or 4 to hit, Skeletons will need a 4 or 5 to hit
INT 3 > INT 2 -> Ghouls have a chance to rolloff to attack first with MOST models as opposed to be guarenteed to go last
2 Poisoned Attacks -> 2 Poisoned STR 3 Hits is infinitly better than 1 STR 3 Hit
Tou 4 (vs 3 = 5, vs 4 = 4, Vs 5 = 3) as Opposed to Tou 3 (Vs 3 = 4, Vs 4 = 3, Vs 5 = 2)
Works well in 5xWide (15 Poisoned Attacks), 7xWide (21 Poisoned Attacks), and 10xWide (Up to 40 Attacks)
Effective against units that need large amounts of attacks to wound

Skeletons:
5+ AS -> You only get an AS if its STR 4 or lower, because STR 5 is -2 AS
Musicians -> Swift Reform before movement or after combat instead of Overrun. Used in ties in Combat.
Standard Bearer -> +1 CR, but the ghouls are much more likely to get 1 more wound than an equivilent skeleton group
Spears or 6+ Ward -> Spears can give extra attacks that can the skeletons be more offensive. 5xWide (15 Attacks).
The Ward save is situational in that it only works in CCB against other Infantry.
Only effective in 5xWide
Can take a Magic Banner up to 25 Points (Flaming Attacks, Warbanner) However Skeletons dont do well against Monsters that use regen ie) Hydra, Hellpit ect.

Being Harder to Wound > Small AS on low STR attacks
Ghouls can do ANYTHING that skeletons can do but much better

I personally think Ghouls are substantually better and the stats prove it. The only people who think skeletons are better are the people that dont like the ghoul models. Hopefully this puts the question to shame.

Oh no I cant swift reform my ghouls! Well guess what in 7th edition you couldnt swift reform anything and you still found a way to stop them from getting flanked.
 
I've always had better success with Ghouls. The thing most people compare is the Ghouls' T4 vs. the Skeletons' 5+ AS and Parry. What lots of folks forget to factor in is that, while both WS2 and WS3 will both hit a good amount of things on 4's, WS2 is virtually always hit on 3's, as opposed to the decidedly average WS3. Skeletons just take too many hits for their saves to be effective. Sure, you could buff them with the HoC...but you could do the same with Ghouls.

This is why my "Next Armybook Wish List" includes upgrading Skellies to WS3, even if they have to increase the point cost. I love my Skeleton models, but right now I'm playing the these-guys-aren't-actually-Skeletons game and using my Skelly models as Ghouls. :(
 
Bah, I really. Really Dislike the ghoul models.

And that is a viable argument. :innocent:

But anyways, really, I think the ghouls are probably better at combat. They just look like crap and don't fit my fluff. I only run Skeletons, GG, Wraiths, and the black coach.

But I do have to say, in my personal opinion, skellies come out on top when used in conjunction with the Helm. Especially spear skellies.
 
Ghouls for 40 as horde or 21 (in 7x3) formation for flanking duties. Skellies I use as a bunker as the extra banner comes in handy in the blood and glory mission.
 
I forgot to mention that actually. I virtually always use Skeletons as a bunker for my casters, simply because there's a lot that you can do to keep them alive. A Vampire with the Tomb Blade is actually quite nice because you can keep them coming back in both your and your opponent's turn, while simple IoN spamming can only raise Skeletons from the dead during friendly Magic Phases.

Not that I'm advocating getting bunkers into combat. But it's a nice safeguard that I employ if I have the points for it.
 
I find it funny that people are still arguing that skeletons are a good choice. There vastly inferior to ghouls in EVERY way, even the AS arguement is redicous because the TOU 4 will save as many ghouls from low STR shooting as a 5+ AS would. Whining about the models is so redicous, this thread isnt about how you dont like the models, get over it. This thread is about which core choice is best.
 
I agree with Yanda.

The only thing Skeletons got going for them are that they allow you to have another banner and depending on the list you're using more fluffy. I'd like to say differently but this is just way it is at the moment.
 
Well i was just gonna ask what core i should bring against DE but thx for the AWESOME break down about ghouls and i no longer require an answer lol. I already have one!
 
Yanda said:
I find it funny that people are still arguing that skeletons are a good choice. There vastly inferior to ghouls in EVERY way, even the AS arguement is redicous because the TOU 4 will save as many ghouls from low STR shooting as a 5+ AS would. Whining about the models is so redicous, this thread isnt about how you dont like the models, get over it. This thread is about which core choice is best.

Hey hey. Lay off my skellies bro. They so killed Teclis once or twice. Spear to puny elf face.

But yes. Mathammer says ghouls are better. But hey, I play the game to have fun, even if fun means losing droves of cool looking models. Dieing in droves is what I'll do.

"Is that a 10x10 block of skellies?" "Why yes. Yes it is. With a tomb blade, and drakenhof." "Why?" "Because I can." :innocent:

All our core units are.. well..... complete rubbish. But Tactically, and for game winning:

Ghouls
Skellies
... and those things that do nothing... uhh... ohh yeah, zombies.

But for coolness factor, choices, and variability:

Skellies.

Disclaimer: Any views displayed in the post are probably biased and mayyyyyy be incorrect, and in no way reflect actual tactical usage.
 
I'd say gouls i put a necro that has the points for raising them and go i find they are so much better. today i played a game where the poison attacks in two turns took out an entire unit of chaos warrior rider guys i forget the name in one turn 4 were dead. ive seen that unit due to heave upgrading(as in toomany upgrades it's illeagal o use them but he refuses to play them base) run an entire game against empire and brettonia killing handgunners swordsmen and pesentbowmen units wit only 1 casualty. in that game and i also had a unit of skelatons(20 of them) all they did was serve to protect my vampire as he spammed gaze of nagash.worked well but that was down to awfull rolls for the lead belchers.

now i've tested them both out id say ghouls every day only redeeming fact for skellies is the armour save.
Also the baners are nice 6 strength on skellies is verry nice combine that with a hord unit with helm of commandment and spears if you have spare points and bam thats one strong unit.
 
I would definitely agree that Ghouls are probably a better all-comer unit - but it all depends how you build your army. As a devout user of the Lore of Metal, Skellies with a 5+ Scaly Skin (i.e. a 3+ save) are probably a lot better, since I only ever sit in my deployment zone unless theres stuff behind me (or if I roll watchtower, although I don't even move them forward until turn 4 at the earliest).

As you guessed, other than the fact that it fits with my strategy a lot better than Ghouls, I only ever use Skellies as my all-comers, defensive unit.

If you're going to a tourney: play a very specific tightly organised strategy, or use Ghouls. No questions asked, really.
If you're playing friendlies: use whatever you like the most - if you're enjoying yourself you might do better. Always works for me :)
 
Though I would like to chime in for comped tournaments where skeletons are just as viable as ghouls but overall, if you plan to enter tournaments such as 'Ard Boys or UKGTs, or any similiarly structured tournament, then you'd better bring the most optimized list you can. That said, this doesn't mean you have to go with something conventional. However, skeletons and ghouls are very similiar units(ie, both pretty much do the exact same job) but one does it better than the other.

And to defence to fellow Strigoi vampires, Ghouls aren't just picked for their competitive nature!
 
The only problem with Ghouls is they die easily especially against ranged. Some good spells can over come this but it requires magic that could be used other places.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu