Ghouls or Skeletons?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Generic vampire 1 said:
The only problem with Ghouls is they die easily especially against ranged. Some good spells can over come this but it requires magic that could be used other places.

Ghouls have a Higher Toughness making it likely that you would take less wounds making it equal to or better than a lower toughness and a crappy AS
 
Um...not really, Generic Vampire.

Let's take a standard unit of 20 archers for this example. They will have BS3, and their bows are S3. For the purpose of this example, I'm not going to factor in any to-hit modifiers. They will hit on 4+.

If the first two ranks of 5 open fire, that's 10 shots fired. 5 of them will hit. Now:

Against Skeletons, half of the hits will wound. This makes 2.5 wounds taken. Now for the 5+ armour save, which blocks 1/3 of the wounds. This means that your Skeletons will suffer 1.67 wounds. And there is no 6+ Parry save against ranged attacks.

Against Ghouls, the S3 arrows will wound on 5+ this means that only 1/3 of the arrows will wound. That means the Ghouls will take 1.67 wounds. Yes, that's exactly the same.

The real advantage of Crypt Ghouls comes in the close combat department. Each Ghoul in the first rank dishes out 2 poisoned attacks, and the next rank gets 1 poisoned attack each. That's 15 attacks to the Skeletons' (with HW+Shield) 10. The Skellies also only have WS2, which means that they will allow more hits against them than the Ghouls will (in most cases). Even if the 6+ Parry and 5+ AS wind up saving more wounds than the Ghouls' T4, the Skeletons still take more hits in the first place.

This, I believe, is their downfall. Ghouls are better both offensively and defensively. It's a real letdown for those of us who believe in a "Skeleton backbone."
 
an additional point for skellies:

tomb blade: if a hero with the tomb blade joins a unit of skellies, then the unit is very resilient and even gets more models summoned without wasting dice on IoN...unlike ghouls who will need help after a turn or 2. if you want to use a horde of skellies with a vamp, then this weapon will make them alot more resilient
 
Who would put the Drakenhof banner in a unit of Ghouls? Those belong in things like Grave Guard, Black Knights, Blood Knights, and... uhh... more Graveguard.
 
True, thats kind of a points sink if you add it to ghouls...

The only thing that might make sense doing is if the unit of ghousl is a horde of at least 40...then maybe, but still probably isnt worth it since our core arent meant to win games on their own.
 
The Red Warden said:
Who would put the Drakenhof banner in a unit of Ghouls?

MEEEEE!!!!!!


It f*cking rocks, watch them get back up again! Hell loads of attacks, good save, and with vanhels.... chomp chomp chomp! saves the vamp in there too.


Ghouls every time, I took a horde of skellies to a tournament and they just got eaten, the measly save isn't worth it. They killed sod all.

Saying that I need about 60 more ghouls... I played a small game of 1500 each doubles last night, I took two necros, bsb, vamp lord, 35 ghouls, 35 ghouls, 25 ghouls... spammed the lot out first few turns...and then BAM! I love vanhels.

Only had the first couple of rows actual ghouls though, proxied with anyone from my army who fancied a go...hehe... GG, skellies, zombies, wraiths all filling a slot
 
Actually, they get just as many attacks as a Skeleton horde does. Skeletons w/ spears get to attack in four ranks if they didn't charge. Ghouls only attack in 3 ranks, but they have 2 attacks per model on their profile. The first row gets 2 attacks apiece, effectively the same as an extra rank.

Plus, they can charge and still retain their extra attacks, unlike the Skeletons who would have to wait until the next CC phase.
 
It's so worth going horde is you're going to be something like 7 wide anyway. The wider you are the more attacks they're going to get, so you may as well get more back on them too.
 
Tinkering with spamming blocks of 21 Ghouls, ranked 7x3 to support 2 units of Grave guard. The idea being they'll devour any light flanking units and at least tie up/ weaken any medium-sized units or weak hordes/ steadfasts whilst the Grave guard go for the enemies toughest stuff. Whatever finishes first supports whatevers tied up...

Skellies are my bunker unit for the command options and to resist the urge to use them offensively! lol
 
skeletons with spears 10 wide 4 ranks deep. Just like having a old pikeman unit out of dogs of war. They even redemeed themselves vs 5 chaos knights not long ago. I fully believe that anyone fielding knights gotta go more then 5 no matter what they are now. But anyways im just going on may sigmar die and long live the dead. Skeletons be my choice.
 
Yeah, mathwise ghouls are better, they kill more and they are harder to kill (yes even with the 5+ AS and 6+ WS of skellies) the only exception is against oponent with WS of 4 or more AND Str of 6 or more, not to mention that if someone is pathetic enough to fail the fear test they will hit ghouls with 5+ and skellies with 4+, yes, skellies deserve to be cheaper :(
 
I think it's pretty conclusive - Ghouls > Skeletons > Zombies...

Personally I'm working on 3 hordes of 40 Ghouls each for a massive battle some mates and I are having soon. 5k per person - 5 people per side - and 120 Ghouls to lead the way!
 
Wintermadness said:
Yeah, mathwise ghouls are better, they kill more and they are harder to kill (yes even with the 5+ AS and 6+ WS of skellies) the only exception is against oponent with WS of 4 or more AND Str of 6 or more, not to mention that if someone is pathetic enough to fail the fear test they will hit ghouls with 5+ and skellies with 4+, yes, skellies deserve to be cheaper :(

Or ghouls deserve to cost more.

Skeletons have more survivability against anything that hits more than once with S3, and WS4 or more. Or as some other mentioned, WS4 with Strength 6.

What do you want? Skeleton with a character or a Ghoul Unit to grind your enemy down? (I cant see how a skeleton unit works without any character these days)

You must also look at the buffs that you might give to your core units, what benefits the most out of the situations that you end up with. As the other day I managed to give my skeleton +5 scaly skin against Frenzy Corsairs, they where 7x3, 29 Attacks against +3 armour and +6 parry. I did win the fight.
I agree that Ghouls are the best overall and give you the best close combats without any though about it. But I think skeletons are much more enjoyable and tactical for it purposes. Don't send them off in any direction without a plan ready for them.

How do YOU enjoy playing your games? To win? For the social entertainment with beer and food over a game of Warhammer with your closest friends. Maybe just some random games at your local Warhammer store, or to meet new faces and play their armies.

Play as you think is the most entertaining for yourself, this is what I am after. Perhaps this will change in the future or right before Tournaments :O
 
Ghouls can still require tactical acumen to use properly though, their lack of musician means no free reforms, so they're still manouvering like 7th ed., whereas Skellies have a fair few more options there.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu