Ghouls vs Skellies

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

dudeson

Zombie
Nov 27, 2010
2
Zombies
3
Hey guys.

I recently heard from a friend of mine that statistically skellies die faster than ghouls, simply because ghoul's Thoughness 4 is better than the armor/ward save skellies can get from their light armor, sheild and hand weapon. If that is really the case, i don't see the point in having skellies at all. Ghouls have ws 3, 2 attacks and poisend attacks, which means they will kill much more than than skellies even if the skellies got spears.

Are skellies in reality useless?
 
Skeletons aren't exactly worthless, but they tend to perform all-round worse than Ghouls would do against most opponents - for the price that you pay for them, at least. Skeletons can give you some much needed standards for the Blood & Glory scenario (as well as being able to bring some hidden magic banners to the field), but the general line of thought where Skeletons are defensive and Ghouls are offensive is a bit flawed - when it comes down to it, Skeletons really aren't all that hot on the defensive side either.

That's not to say that they can't perform some tasks for you, though. There are several spells from the new rulebook lores that will augment both Skeletons and Ghouls to completely new heights, and in different ways. That one Metal spell can give your Skeletons a healthy 3+ armour save (with a 6+ parry save as well, potentially) which will be a strong defense against most regular opponents, whereas the Ghouls would still be stuck with a practically non-existant defense outside of their Toughness value.

All in all, Ghouls would often be the better investment if you're looking for a purely bang-for-your-buck purchase. They have lots of little perks to place them ahead of the Skeletons in most situations, but they have their own shortcomings too. Neither unit type is perfect in its own right, and I think that they could work decently well together.
 
I think skeletons and ghouls are roughly equal because with ghouls having absolutely no armor makes them a handgun/magic missle magnet however If you do manage to get them into combat in good health though prepare for some carnage. skeletons armor is very helpful and im planning to run 2 skeletons for every ghoul.
 
Rising Necromancer said:
I think skeletons and ghouls are roughly equal because with ghouls having absolutely no armor makes them a handgun/magic missle magnet however If you do manage to get them into combat in good health though prepare for some carnage. skeletons armor is very helpful and im planning to run 2 skeletons for every ghoul.

hand guns and most magic missiles will ignore skeleton armor completely, ghouls are better then skeletons in every aspect, especially in this one.

I take skeletons because I like the way they look and still have a job, that and the assurance that I have blood and glory missions won. I run no ghouls.
 
Skellies will cost 4 points in the TK book. I still think its a little much. Thats how good I think skellies are.

Ghouls are about right with 8 points.
 
Ghouls are easily the more 'competitive' choice simply because they hold up better against the other typical tournament attendies...
With lots of lizzies, WoC, dark elves, high elves & skaven running about, the T4 means alot more than a 5+/6++. The added attacks, plus the poison also means the ghoulies can take on alot of the more dangerous stuff - especially big monsters like multiple hydras & hellpits!

Skeletons still have their place though; they're usefull as bunkers and for providing an extra banner or two to your army for certain senarios (blood & glory). Plus, I personally think our skellies look absolutely ace - it would be a shame not to include them in any army!

I think the biggest fix that's needed is twofold;
a) skeleton pts *must* drop to bring them in line with our TK cousins. (if our skellies are more expensive, it'll simply be because someone in the studio hates VC's!!!)
b) make ghouls skirmish again.
Doing both of these puts the skellies back in the spotlight, and gives them a well defined role in our armies, which they currently don't really have... (ie: ghouls do 99.9% of a skeleton's job much better!)

Cheers!
 
I just run both in my list. Skeletons have a purpose, and I seem to always roll well for parry saves (although I whiff all of my 5+ armour saves). They just work differently. I've found that, against small elite units, Skeletons are an excellent defensive block, able to hold up opponents for at least one vital turn. Ghouls on the other hand have formidable offensive abilities, which makes them the perfect compliment to the Skeletons.
 
If you invest a bit of points in making ghouls more powerful, they can be a truly devastating force on the table.

Here's how:
-2 bricks of 40+ in horde formation in the center of your battleline
-vamp with ghoulkin power somewhere
-a vdm or two and you dont have to worry about them getting shot at- they'll be in combat by turn 2 (maybe even 1 depending on the scenario).

Using a combo of fighty vamps in the front ranks, a bsb with Strigoi or The Hoff
and bunkered necro & casty vamp spamming VDM & wearing the Helm of Command all significantly
bolster the ghouls into dangerous opponents on the battlefield.

I use ghouls with that combo in every battle I fight and they have rarely let me down.
 
I'm also much in favor of ghouls. But I recently did some quick maths which showed me that skellies should be a bit better on the defensive side against S3/4, but their lower I and WS make them take more hits earlier which evens it out against most of these low-strength units. Also the higher number of attacks of the ghouls means you roll more dice and get more statistically average results. And my skellies seem to be jinxed, they never do anything. They have yet to make a parry save and armour saves are only passed against stone throwers :D
They make a good bunker though and provide a vital standard for blood and glory. I recently played a bunker with full command and a vampire with helm in there in a tournament and the performance was quite good. I had a safe standard besides BSB and grave guard behind the front line, musician allows for swift reform to get out of the way of possible overrun moves or to turn your front towards small units that want to hunt down the bunker (dark elf riders, marauder horsemen, scouts), skellies save the damage of these units while the vampire whittles them down.

As far as combat goes I prefer ghouls for damage output. In combination with the helm and a character and maybe even VDM they can dish out a lot of pain to any unit, be it infantry, cavalry or a monster.
 
Ghouls are much better than Skeletons. First of all, the Ghouls have better T, A and Ws (Ws makes a big difference compared to Skeletons if opponent fails fear test). Ghouls have poison, too, which is very good against T4+ creatures (the new T8 Tomb King Sphynx for an example). Finally, Ghouls have Ghoulkin, which is awesome.

Skeletons, in the other hand... Even Goblins have better stat line than Skeletons. o_o Ws2 is disappointing, as Skeletons are hit on 3+, even when faced things like Clanrats or humans! If the opponent fails the fear test, they still hit on 4+ Skeletons. Yeah, Skeletons have light armor and shield, but there's so much Str4+ things going on that they usually save a couple of Skeletons from a dozen wounds. T4 Ghouls, yes please! Skeletons get musicians (rubbish IMO, swift reform isn't that good for Skeletons) and standards. Magical standards are not too good either, maybe Warbanner. But if your army needs cheap standards for Blood & Glory, I'd take 20 Zombies with standard.

Ghouls are superior compared to Skeletons if you want competitive games (like I do). In fluffy games Skeletons might be okay if you have some hard-hitting units like Grave Guards or Wraiths, but otherwise Ghouls are the way to go. Skeletons might work as a huge anvil units, but 8 points from a Skeleton is just too much so it seldom is worth of it. This is kinda sad as I have ~ 150 Skeletons on my shelf waiting for the new VC army book...

- Cheers, Skarsnik. :thumbsup:
 
"But I recently did some quick maths which showed me that skellies should be a bit better on the defensive side against S3/4, but their lower I and WS make them take more hits earlier which evens it out against most of these low-strength units."

Not sure how you did your math init shouldn't be a factor since you'll have enough guys for stepping up, but against WS3 units, skeletons are more defensive at Str 3 and lower, tie with ghouls at 4, lose to ghouls at str 5 and then tie again from str 6 and on (parry save counteracts the WS difference.) So low stat line units, skeletons should be more defensive (due to armor save being 5+) than ghouls, but at high str units, ghouls and skellies are on par due to higher WS offering protection just as the parry save. Of course, losing the parry save or fighting WS4+ units change all that but you get the picture.

A great use for skeletons is being creative with banners to create specialized niches for them (flaming attacks for example).

Generally, I find myself against heavily armored Ws 4+ units with higher str so the skeletons fit my needs much better than ghouls (parry save is amazing against Str5-6 attacks :D). They either serve as a bunker or hold a combat vamp inside. Their job is just not to lose CR for all the thrall's attacks. they get a +2 static CR usually (warbanner) and plus all the parry saves add up as "saved" CR (since the enemy is not getting CR from that wound). I figure skeletons give about 3 CR when compared to ghouls, accounting for one parry save. The way I look at it is will the extra wounds generated by ghouls equal or be greater than the static CR + extra saved skeletons (3 is the number I use)? Against many of the opponents I want my thrall to fight, the answer is no (ghouls won't generate much CR against bret knights for example) so that's just one perspective.
 
I haven't thrown down a unit of skellies since 8th came out. They just don't just make the grade. Now if they would drop them to 4 points like TK skellies they would be an option again.
 
I have been in the mindset that ghouls are just better than skeletons and I dunno, maybe they are.

Recently though I have started wielding a unit of 25-30 skeletons five wide and they have been quite good in tarpitting the enemy and surviving long enough that something heavy can come to the flank and help them out. If the enemy is something like rats or elves (spear) they can deal some damage back too.

I have changed my attitude towards using them more, even planning on leaving my ghouls home on some future games to see how that works out.
 
As I don't have ghouls models, and only skeletons as core, I need to field them. But I used to spend the minimum of points necessary to make my list legal (25%), with HW/Sh, FC, two units of 30. They were crap, didn't kill anything, the parry save didn't help at all and they seemed like a waste of points.

So I thought: as I'm already fielding skeletons anyway, I'm going to make them worth it. I began to field them in two units of 40 skeletons each (7 wide) and with spears to maximize attacks (22 attacks). My Vamp Lord (who always goes in the GG unit) is equipped with Fencer's Blades and Crown of Commandment to give them WS 10, and Lore of Beasts to use the +1S +1T spell on them.

I also field a Necro in a Corpse Cart behind them (equipped with Wristbands of Black Gold and Black Periapt) to cast VDM so they will have ASF and re-roll hits. The Corpse Cart is there to protect the Necro, it's not meant to see battle (it's like a bunker) because the Necro in a unit will surely be killed in the first round of combat. I can also use the cart's abilities like miasma, balefire, etc. I think it's better than a bunk of skeletons or ghouls because it allows me to move from one unit's back to another unit's back (and run away from danger) much more easily with its Monster movement.

And... guess what! All of the sudden my skeletons are an elite unit (well, not always). It makes 22 St4 attacks with ASF, re-rolls to hit, WS 10 (enemies will hit them only on 5+), T4 and a 5+ Armour Save. They are ItP, unbreakable, cause fear, and I can alway summon more of them as they die!!! My opponent had a good CC phase and killed 10 skeletons? It doesn't matter, there are still 30 of them, negating Steadfast, with full ranking bonuses, banner, and full attacks with all those buffs still working.

The guys I play with used to look at them as if they were a very easy unit to deal with. Now I made them change their minds! :vampire3:
 
That's the big problem though with skellies... They absolutely need buffs to be viable. Ghouls don't.

I also use skellies exclusively because I play a themed army. (and ghouls don't fit my theme at all)
I've found that in 8th, if the winds roll low for my magic, my skellies are pooched. If my spells are all dispelled and/or fail to cast, my skellies are pooched. If my supporting character's attacks wiff, my skellies are pooched...
That's just far too much randomness for a sub-par unit to deal with in a more competitive environment, and thus, has led to what seems like 99.9% of VC lists all shifting towards large ghoul blocks.

The huge pts-hike we're now paying for a (near) useless ability in fear means our skellies are now one of the game's worst troops for their cost. The only unit in the game that's even more woeful are zombies!

It basically comes down to; Skeletons are iconic & good fun an all, but ghouls FTW when it counts! (ie: any kind of tournament play)

Cheers!
ps. it's utterly shamefull too, since our skeleton models are so awsome and I feel that almost all VC players really do want to use them if only they were worth it!
 
I wish they were better...as it is,I only use them as a bunker.They are better at this than ghouls IMHO b/c the musician allows you to swift reform and redeploy more easily behind your battle line.
They'll eventually improve them or reduce them in cost (fingers crossed).
 
Skeletons for bunkers, Ghouls for doing stuff.

However, I have recently been very unimpressed with my 40-strong ghoul horde. They have managed to kill one Chaos Knight over two games, both times being utterly wiped out by the very same Knights. Just one wound! :slapface:
 
i would feild roughly an equal amount, ghouls are very offensive, but skeletons can be pretty decent with full command and having a magic banner, there pretty equal depending on how you use each unit, i find ghouls dont survive too long because they are a priority target and magic tends to be aimed at them often which they dont stand much of a chance against
 
I think in the new VC book everyone's buzzing about (purely because another Undead army got one and "surely it'll be us next") the skeletons will be given a nice healthy buff.

Or at least I hope so. But don't eliminate ghouls cause I have damned 40 of them. xD
 
I am fairly certain that the Ogre Kingdoms are the next army in the que for a retrofitting. That being said I intend to use all Skeletons once I round out my Greenskin horde. I mean Ghouls, in my mind, were never meant to be a staple core choice. They started out as skirmishers and by god that is what they should be!
 
Heres basicly everything everybody here said but in simple form (yes, allright, might miss something out)
Skelletons- fail at combat, even clanrats are better because of higher innitiative and movement. Can be given banners though, which ghouls dont yet have, so might have some weird upgrades. Parry save 6+ and armour save 5+ theyre not really a tough unit to kill. only one attack BUT good looking models
Ghouls-powerful close combat for points value. 4 toughness so High Elves will have it hard trying to wound them. better weaposkill BUT models look like the wrong end of a dog, well.....basicly.

Both undead so terror, fear doesnt work on them (immune to pschycology)
Both same points value.
Its obvious-if you want to win, go with ghouls. If you want a golden deamon winning army go with skeletons. :) simples
:smash:
 
I saw in the army list Forum most of the army list they use Ghouls more than Skeletion but for me i knid like skeleton more xD
 
I'm a ghoul man, however I got myself into a bit of trouble with the scenario based on amount of standards in the army. I've had to do a bit of balancing since then, just in case that one comes up.

-aki
 
I miss the skirmish Ghouls and skeleton based VC armies... much more in the spirit of VC as I see it (prolly also because that's how it was in the begining for me)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu