Glittering Scales and Ogre Blade questions

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

TeflonTron

Skeleton
Apr 7, 2010
58
Zombies
50
I see quite a few people advocating the use of Glittering Scales for the -1 to hit (or maybe it is my imagination and nobody is, I just don't know), but do people think that not getting hit in the first place is worth giving up a decent save for? Glittering Scales and shield is only a 5+ and even with a Ward Save 5+ then 4+ seems quite squishy. It also precludes taking a decent offense as even an Ogre Blade will take you over the points limit.

Talking of Ogre Blades (segue music), I prefer a 5 Attacks at St7 for my Lord but most that I see are using a Sword of Strife and a Potion of Strength for 7 Attacks at Strength 5 and a one turn boost upto a Popeye like Strength 8. Obviously it depends on what you are fighting, but the Sword of Strife seems to be a far more popular choice. Thoughts?
 
Str 5 is good enough for me most of the time. Regular units are getting wounded on 2+, elites on 3+. I would rather have more attacks. Btw, if you have Glittering scales on a ZD lord, with the ZD's minus 1 to hit in cc, does that mean people need sixes, and then 4's to hit you if you are double or more their WS? AS long as you get into some action before a canon shoots you, it could be a possible build.
 
Doesn't the enemy hit you on 7s if they fail there fear test? Because hitting on 5+ minus 1 for the dragon and -1 for glittering scales, meaning that if they fail there test they can't hit you t all???!!
 
I´d personally go for the ogre blade. Increased strength allows you to wound most things (even big beasties) on 2´s, making that all so popular red fury count. Incresed strength also has the upside that it modifies enemy armour save a lot more, making him equally effective vs highly armoured foes.
 
All that getting a "7+ to hit" does for close combat is negate magic items/abilities effects like the +1 to hit blade or our Banner of Barrows.
 
TeflonTron said:
I see quite a few people advocating the use of Glittering Scales for the -1 to hit (or maybe it is my imagination and nobody is, I just don't know), but do people think that not getting hit in the first place is worth giving up a decent save for? Glittering Scales and shield is only a 5+ and even with a Ward Save 5+ then 4+ seems quite squishy. It also precludes taking a decent offense as even an Ogre Blade will take you over the points limit.

Talking of Ogre Blades (segue music), I prefer a 5 Attacks at St7 for my Lord but most that I see are using a Sword of Strife and a Potion of Strength for 7 Attacks at Strength 5 and a one turn boost upto a Popeye like Strength 8. Obviously it depends on what you are fighting, but the Sword of Strife seems to be a far more popular choice. Thoughts?

Redfury + extra attacks (sword of strife/ sword of bloodshed) = massacred enemy rank and file troops.
Taking +str does not grant you as many chances for attacks the second time around from red fury. This reduces your characters overall potential # of wounds to deal in close combat.
Say oh you don't get as many unsaved wounds vs knights or other heavily armored troops, but the shear number of attacks (with possible rerolls from our new magic lore) are overwhelming. If you have a vamp lord with sword of bloodshed+red fury, thats a potential 16 kills max. in one round of combat. That is potentially 6 more kills than 5 attacks with +3 str.

I mean seriously, what happens when you wiff 3 of 5 attacks on the first wave of attacks from your vamp lord. you get significantly less from red fury, as you would if you had 3 more attacks from the sword of bloodshed.
 
Thats where the buffs come in ;). Almost everybody has quickblood on their vampire lord and he has higher initiative than most things in the game, thats re-rolls for you. Both options are viable, but I want my lord to be able to handle other things than rank-and-file aswell.
 
Not to mention what happens when you DO go up against knights, and they save 4 of your 5 Str5 wounds? You get 1 extra attack... Whooptie do. No, with Ogre Blade... You still probably killed 4 models. Giving you 4 extra attacks... Probably another 2-3 dead.
 
I personally go for the Ogre Blade with Red Fury because of the armies I fight against most often: Bretonnians, Chaos Warriors, Dwarfs, and Orcs. I like the additional negative modifier to their armor saves as well as being able to wound even T5 lords on a 2+. I also use the ever-popular Quickblood so I can reroll misses against most models, Chaos Lords being the exception.
 
drmooreflava said:
TeflonTron said:
I see quite a few people advocating the use of Glittering Scales for the -1 to hit (or maybe it is my imagination and nobody is, I just don't know), but do people think that not getting hit in the first place is worth giving up a decent save for? Glittering Scales and shield is only a 5+ and even with a Ward Save 5+ then 4+ seems quite squishy. It also precludes taking a decent offense as even an Ogre Blade will take you over the points limit.

Talking of Ogre Blades (segue music), I prefer a 5 Attacks at St7 for my Lord but most that I see are using a Sword of Strife and a Potion of Strength for 7 Attacks at Strength 5 and a one turn boost upto a Popeye like Strength 8. Obviously it depends on what you are fighting, but the Sword of Strife seems to be a far more popular choice. Thoughts?

Redfury + extra attacks (sword of strife/ sword of bloodshed) = massacred enemy rank and file troops.
Taking +str does not grant you as many chances for attacks the second time around from red fury. This reduces your characters overall potential # of wounds to deal in close combat.
Say oh you don't get as many unsaved wounds vs knights or other heavily armored troops, but the shear number of attacks (with possible rerolls from our new magic lore) are overwhelming. If you have a vamp lord with sword of bloodshed+red fury, thats a potential 16 kills max. in one round of combat. That is potentially 6 more kills than 5 attacks with +3 str.

I mean seriously, what happens when you wiff 3 of 5 attacks on the first wave of attacks from your vamp lord. you get significantly less from red fury, as you would if you had 3 more attacks from the sword of bloodshed.

You sir, must like playing Empire and Skaven. Personally, with 5 attacks, s7 is the way to go most of the time. Why? Because at that point he fears virtually nothing. Everything in our army can deal with peasants and slaves and the run of the mill. Very few units can effectively deal with WoC, Monsters, Ogres, and generally anything that is either really tough, or has a great armor save.

And I say this not without good reason. One SoM game, I gave a dawnstar sword to a vamp on a TG (previous edition, obviously), and he was charged by 6 knights, one of whom failed his dangerous terrain test and died. I was in combat with them, auto-hitting and wounding, for over 4 turns because the TG was whiffing like a baws, and he was passing his 3+ armor saves (after being hit by s5) like a baws. Yeah, I won combat eventually, but it sucked, really hard, and all because my lord didn't hit very hard, he just hit a lot.

But then, what is the purpose of your lord? Is your aim to smash rank and file (More attacks), or deal with cav, heavy armor, and monsters (better str)? Both do one well, one does the other much, much better.
 
I always gotten alot more out of sword of bloodshed. I take challenges on my champ and usually kill 11 rank and file. This edition calv is not as popular except for brets. I do also use a strength potion for that odd calv unit or warriors. Strength 5 is just fine for almost any combat and 8 attacks is pretty boss. At tournaments around here and at every ard boys ive been to, the armies that do well most often are high elves, dwarves and Skaven. These armies maybe have one or two things that are even worth using the strength potion on (dragon princes, dwarf lords, skaven warmachines/monsters). Dwarves almost always use 2H weapon (and they should) so even their armor is usually pretty bad except for lords. So unless you really need a character killer(not counting mages as they are already killable) I believe that +attacks are better. Even in situations where they have a really sweet character knocking out ranks to negate steadfast and getting massive combat resolution has always been preferable in my opinion (there are a few situations that are different but part of being a good general is knowing these).

Lastly id like to talk about re rolls from ASF, a few people have been saying that this makes the str choice more appealing. In reality the more dice you roll with re rolls the better it is. You gain more marginal benefit. This also applies to hellish vigor.
 
Vortaine said:
drmooreflava said:
TeflonTron said:
I see quite a few people advocating the use of Glittering Scales for the -1 to hit (or maybe it is my imagination and nobody is, I just don't know), but do people think that not getting hit in the first place is worth giving up a decent save for? Glittering Scales and shield is only a 5+ and even with a Ward Save 5+ then 4+ seems quite squishy. It also precludes taking a decent offense as even an Ogre Blade will take you over the points limit.

Talking of Ogre Blades (segue music), I prefer a 5 Attacks at St7 for my Lord but most that I see are using a Sword of Strife and a Potion of Strength for 7 Attacks at Strength 5 and a one turn boost upto a Popeye like Strength 8. Obviously it depends on what you are fighting, but the Sword of Strife seems to be a far more popular choice. Thoughts?

Redfury + extra attacks (sword of strife/ sword of bloodshed) = massacred enemy rank and file troops.
Taking +str does not grant you as many chances for attacks the second time around from red fury. This reduces your characters overall potential # of wounds to deal in close combat.
Say oh you don't get as many unsaved wounds vs knights or other heavily armored troops, but the shear number of attacks (with possible rerolls from our new magic lore) are overwhelming. If you have a vamp lord with sword of bloodshed+red fury, thats a potential 16 kills max. in one round of combat. That is potentially 6 more kills than 5 attacks with +3 str.

I mean seriously, what happens when you wiff 3 of 5 attacks on the first wave of attacks from your vamp lord. you get significantly less from red fury, as you would if you had 3 more attacks from the sword of bloodshed.

You sir, must like playing Empire and Skaven. Personally, with 5 attacks, s7 is the way to go most of the time. Why? Because at that point he fears virtually nothing. Everything in our army can deal with peasants and slaves and the run of the mill. Very few units can effectively deal with WoC, Monsters, Ogres, and generally anything that is either really tough, or has a great armor save.

And I say this not without good reason. One SoM game, I gave a dawnstar sword to a vamp on a TG (previous edition, obviously), and he was charged by 6 knights, one of whom failed his dangerous terrain test and died. I was in combat with them, auto-hitting and wounding, for over 4 turns because the TG was whiffing like a baws, and he was passing his 3+ armor saves (after being hit by s5) like a baws. Yeah, I won combat eventually, but it sucked, really hard, and all because my lord didn't hit very hard, he just hit a lot.

But then, what is the purpose of your lord? Is your aim to smash rank and file (More attacks), or deal with cav, heavy armor, and monsters (better str)? Both do one well, one does the other much, much better.

Good guess, I play vs skaven and dwarf mostly. I find that neither of them have much to offer in the way of high toughness models. Even the HPA is only T5, and regen isn't effected by STR modifiers anyway. My dwarf enemy usually runs a runelord for good reason, so he is usually a pushover in a challenge anyway. I suppose my opinion my be bias based on my opponents armies.
I don't run a lord on a monster, which is when you really do need your character to have the extra str.

The redfury + sword of bloodshed combo is usually my answer to steadfast enemies and to actually winning combat with zombies or skeletons.
 
I see people are using the what if you run into knights/mosnter scenario, hence the afore mentioned strength potion. With redfury, 8 or 7 attacks at str 8 with quickblood, those knights or monster will not be around since most of the times they are to expensive to field in units of more then 10.

Otherwise use your graveguard to cut the knights down. :D

Sword of strife, potion of strength, talisman of endurance, dragonhelm, heavy armor, shield, quickblood, red fury, and beguile
3+, 5++, with fireproof, reroll to hit him most of the time, 7 str 5 attacks for rank and file and those serious situations have 7 strength 8 attacks that can easily turn into 14 str 8 attacks for the turn.

That round of combat will be horrifying for your opponent as his high point monster or expensive elite troops just got either wiped out or reduced to small change.
 
5+ Ward makes me feel nervous though! I'd like the Potion Of Strength more if it lasted for a complete Turn (ie, two rounds of combat).
 
TeflonTron said:
5+ Ward makes me feel nervous though! I'd like the Potion Of Strength more if it lasted for a complete Turn (ie, two rounds of combat).

Yes 5+ is not as comforting as a 4+ is but once you get past the idea of your character has to be protected or has to take magic items, or even has to be a lord. You find that without those you can take more core or special or even rare units that usually have a bigger impact on the game.

Our characters its hard to do that though since we need one or we die.

Potion of str is only one turn but depends on your opponents, most of the time someone wont even have more then one tough armored unit of cav or big scary monster. Unless your tomb kings or brets. As i mentioned that one round should be utter massacre for the enemy 7 attacks can easily turn into 14 wounds making 1+ turn to 6+ plus regular attacks from guys.

Oh another note if you are going against Ogres take Konrad, 6 attacks with multi-wound 2 and hatred. His 6 attacks will spawn 12 additional attacks which can cause another 24 wounds!
 
Actually, if you need 7+ to hit something in CC, you can't hit at all. How convenient. There are actually no rules that say otherwise. Therefore, as you can't roll a 7, you miss.
 
Scarr Reincarnated said:
Actually, if you need 7+ to hit something in CC, you can't hit at all. How convenient. There are actually no rules that say otherwise. Therefore, as you can't roll a 7, you miss.

A natural dice score of a 6 ALWAYS HITS and a natural dice score of 1 always missis in close combat, but you can auto-wound with the right setup and the help of a spell
 
Zombilly said:
Scarr Reincarnated said:
Actually, if you need 7+ to hit something in CC, you can't hit at all. How convenient. There are actually no rules that say otherwise. Therefore, as you can't roll a 7, you miss.

A natural dice score of a 6 ALWAYS HITS and a natural dice score of 1 always missis in close combat, but you can auto-wound with the right setup and the help of a spell

Show me where it stands specifically. Page? If you find it, yes I am wrong, but I am pretty sure on this one. Combo's have been used before to make units unable to hit you. Orcs have done it.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu