Grave Gaurds

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Devourment

Zombie
Jan 9, 2012
5
Zombies
5
Hi guys

im knew to Warhammer, bit unfamilier with the rules to be honest.

i have some Grave Guards and i am about to assemble them, what i want to know is, does it matter if i have some with sword / shield and others with the 2 handed weapons ?

what are the benifits / dissadvantages of both ? do i hav to have a whole army of either one or the other or can i have say the musician and banner, then a few with 2 handed weapons and the rest with shield and sword ?

thanks
 
Everything in the unit has to have the same equipment. You normally run GG with GW, as they are that go to unit to handle the tough jobs. I guess if you are playing against elves or something else with t3 and low armor you could get away with HW and shield, but the +1 to armor and parry save don't have the same effect as +2 strength from the GW do. Therefore I (and most people here) would recommend decking all your GG out with Great weapons :thumbsup:
 
Jacques Dauger De Cavoye said:
Everything in the unit has to have the same equipment. You normally run GG with GW, as they are that go to unit to handle the tough jobs. I guess if you are playing against elves or something else with t3 and low armor you could get away with HW and shield, but the +1 to armor and parry save don't have the same effect as +2 strength from the GW do. Therefore I (and most people here) would recommend decking all your GG out with Great weapons :thumbsup:


Cheers mate !
 
I'm a new VCer, just re-started the hobby after a 4-year break and don't have any GG at all, yet, so I'm not exactly an authority here. But I suggest you read through a few of the threads that have cropped up in the last couple of days about this sort of thing. With the new army book, the sword-and-board versus great-weapon debate seems to have shifted a bit.

A lot of people here have mentioned modelling their GG half-and-half, i.e. half with great weapons, and half with handweapon and shield, and then putting the relevant ones in the front. Seems like a good idea to keep your options open at this point.
 
The half and half thing is definitely a great idea, As you generally only see the front two ranks or so anyway. I personally prefer great weapons though.
 
Your asking at a bad time as we just got a new book. I don't think anyone knows what they are going to do yet, and may be a debate until out next book.

Hand weapon shield means they have 4+ armor and a 6+ parry. They are Str 4 so they are good vs normal troops. Combine that with the Corps Cart and they get to hit first and likely reroll hits. So if a necromancer casts Hellish Vigor near a corpse cart, they will be ASF, reroll hits and reroll wounds.

GW means they have 5+ armor and loose parry. However they are Str 6. With the corpse card they are simply I3. However with a Mortis engine they can get a 6+ regen, or more if you have couple.

Seelen has the same suggestion I would have said, use half and half and see what works for you. Try one, then the other. Add support then see what works better. Myself, it would depend on the list I was bringing. If I had lots of magic to support them and bring them back to life I would use GW, if I went low magic and focused on other units, I would use handweapon/shield.

One thing is for sure, these are the best infantry we have and are a mainstay of the army.
 
It really depends on your army build and what role they will have to fulfill. I personally go for GW's especially because I use a corpse cart as backup and now have bat swarms to boot.

With their mediocre initiative you will find them striking last a lot anyway. With the above mentioned combo fun things could happen but I'm not counting on it.
My save rolls are so abysmal the one point increase and ward save won't save them anyway.

If you use the new monstrous units you'd already have some high strength units though possibly small in size. I would go for a block of grave guard with hws option if you use them; use them as a strong anvil backed up by cheaper core and use the monsters as a hammer.

Neither option is bad but you should look at what role you want to assign them. In this new book we have a lot of high strength critters we hadn't before.
 
As it has been lined out by others, there is a place for both options. If you want something to hold the line in the center and other killy things are floating around your list (I'm thinking of Knights or Vargheists here) then you can justify the HW&S combo.

I personally run them with GW as they are a main source of the killing power in my current army although that might change with the new kind of army lists I play under the new book.

When it comes to modelling I'd suggest going 50/50 and just put whatever equip you want the unit to have in the front rank - or the first 2 if you have enough models. As long as you explain this to your opponent, most people shouldn't care. I don't know how such things are handled at tournaments though as I only play fun games with friends and not competetively.

Cheers
 
The 50/50 thing didn't quite satisfy my wysiwyg leanings, so I took it a step further and hung shields on the back of the models holding great weapons and great weapons on the back of the models holding shields (I had to replace the handles with lengths of brass wire to get rid of the skeletal hands on them, just gluing the blades to one side and the pommels to the other). I'll probably hang some scabbards on their sides as well before I paint them up.

Makes them a bit harder to rank up, but then at least they all have all of the equipment. I still put the ones with the equipment I'm using in the front of the unit the way the others do.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu