Larro
Grave Guard
Just to weigh in here as someone who also uses TKs as his 2nd tournament army (VC being the first
), good tournament TK lists do NOT take Tomb Guard, much in the way good tournament VC lists no longer take GG.
Can both "work"? Depends on your definition. In the local meta, maybe. But they are both clearly inferior choices to all of the other options internally in each book respectively. TG compete with the vastly superior Necroknights and Sphinxs, and need a huge investment to work properly. Think 35+ models, at least a Prince and probably a King, and/or a Necrotect. All of this for M4, maybe M5, Infantry unit, which doesn't even hit all that hard and still folds to Monstrous Cav/Inf, and Bloodletters.
Grave Guard are slightly better, because they hit harder, can get +1 to hit, and because most likely you have your Vampire Lord inside the unit to offset some of the beating they are going to take before they swing. We also heal a little better than TKs, as if you are building with GG as your center, you are likely taking a Level 4 Vampire caster, and probably another few backup LoV casters.
Bottom line - both are "workable," albeit inferior choices. I'd never consider bringing them with either book, as they're easy to score points off of and totally obliterate, while not offering the value on the offensive end to be worth the risk.
- Larry
Can both "work"? Depends on your definition. In the local meta, maybe. But they are both clearly inferior choices to all of the other options internally in each book respectively. TG compete with the vastly superior Necroknights and Sphinxs, and need a huge investment to work properly. Think 35+ models, at least a Prince and probably a King, and/or a Necrotect. All of this for M4, maybe M5, Infantry unit, which doesn't even hit all that hard and still folds to Monstrous Cav/Inf, and Bloodletters.
Grave Guard are slightly better, because they hit harder, can get +1 to hit, and because most likely you have your Vampire Lord inside the unit to offset some of the beating they are going to take before they swing. We also heal a little better than TKs, as if you are building with GG as your center, you are likely taking a Level 4 Vampire caster, and probably another few backup LoV casters.
Bottom line - both are "workable," albeit inferior choices. I'd never consider bringing them with either book, as they're easy to score points off of and totally obliterate, while not offering the value on the offensive end to be worth the risk.
- Larry