Grave Guards unit size and formation

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Just to weigh in here as someone who also uses TKs as his 2nd tournament army (VC being the first :D), good tournament TK lists do NOT take Tomb Guard, much in the way good tournament VC lists no longer take GG.

Can both "work"? Depends on your definition. In the local meta, maybe. But they are both clearly inferior choices to all of the other options internally in each book respectively. TG compete with the vastly superior Necroknights and Sphinxs, and need a huge investment to work properly. Think 35+ models, at least a Prince and probably a King, and/or a Necrotect. All of this for M4, maybe M5, Infantry unit, which doesn't even hit all that hard and still folds to Monstrous Cav/Inf, and Bloodletters.

Grave Guard are slightly better, because they hit harder, can get +1 to hit, and because most likely you have your Vampire Lord inside the unit to offset some of the beating they are going to take before they swing. We also heal a little better than TKs, as if you are building with GG as your center, you are likely taking a Level 4 Vampire caster, and probably another few backup LoV casters.

Bottom line - both are "workable," albeit inferior choices. I'd never consider bringing them with either book, as they're easy to score points off of and totally obliterate, while not offering the value on the offensive end to be worth the risk.

- Larry
 
Why? S5 doesn't cut through the 1+ AS at all, and they're still just as expensive and vulnerable to the 1+ Save armies. Add in high volume of attacks from things like Chocobos or Mournfangs, which are often run in duplicate, and TKs don't have the tools to grind down those units before they're ground down themselves. Even if you do manage to beat down one, your unit will be so depleted, and costs so many points with character support, that the Gutstar, 2nd unit of Mournfangs or DGKs, or the 1+ Save Bus of Empire Knights is on you. The odds are even worse when you factor in Gut magic, or Empire Light / Life magic or war machine fire.

On even footing, i.e. without the +200 points TKs get in ETC formats, they're in tough shape right now unless you go for Khalida. They can hang in a sliding scale format, and do fine at 2600 with -10% VPs, but the meta is rough on them at the moment, TG or not.

- Larry
 
Yeah but against the empire knight star killing-blow works wonders and even more ona 5+. Now yes TK has no answer besides Khalida to the Ogre Star but name one book that can go toe to toe with the gut-star and come out ontop besides Daemons.
 
O&G's Savage Orc Big 'Uns can do it too, if they don't get redirected into oblivion. In addition to the mandatory Great Shaman (of DOOOOOOOM!), you field a Savage Orc Big Boss BSB with Mork's War Banner to turn off a choice target's magic items, and to provide S7 beatdown on demand.

I'll also point out that my proposed TK list is planning to make said investment. My entire strategy revolves around funneling people in with shooting toward me, and then a big (like 50-men strong big) block of TK holding on to the vast majority of the points. You want to try your hand at squeezing out a minor win by popping 10-man Archer units? Be my guest. You won't get enough points, so you have to fight the Tomb Guard. And the Tomb King is built to kill the things the Tomb Guard cannot (so Monstrous Cav/K'daai/that sort of thing). It looks nice on paper, at least - it's still very much an experimental list, so it could all blow up in my face. :tongue:
 
Good luck Rothgar, but I predict disappointment, and way too many TG models sitting on your shelf / in your cabinet, until the next TK book when they become the new broken cheese!!

- Larry
 
What i'm hearing is the old uber cannonade type Empire lists are falling out of favor because those gunlines are eating into the Special points that could be filled with Chocobos. A Hellblaster and a Stank look like plenty enough heavy artillery.
 
Back on the topic of GG I find that a unit of 21(7x3) is useful as a support unit.As pointed out by others,they are not a stand alone unit at this size,but if you have the enemy pinned down with a large block of skellies for ranks,they can charge in and disrupt and win combat for you quite handily.
They are not so large an investment that you can't afford to lose them either.
When there are TG,VG,CH,and other big baddies on the field.They usually don't get targeted by alot of ranged fire.
 
Agreed with that - anything wimpier than a Ghoul will typically bleed so much CR that the GG's muscle might not even be enough to break even.

As far as Empire goes, there are most definitely some internal balance issues - Halberdiers are easily the best Core Infantry unit, for example. That said, there are several builds that the army can offer, though I am more fond of some than I am of others.
 
Does anyone every field grave guard with hand weapon and shield?

I have used graveguard with hand weapon and shield since 6th edition because I liked the models and the way I had painted them.

Is it still a viable choice or is pretty much assumed that they should always have great weapons?
 
Depends who their fighting. Against HE or Skaven, S&B is perfectly adequate, but Orcs or WoC need the extra bite of GW. I have a mix, just put the appropriate models in the front ranks.
 
I could see them working well with mindrazor, that way they would be a pretty tough nut to crack(backed up by Dual Engines) T4, 4+ AS, 5+ Regen(6++ parry against flaming)... and with mindrazor they would hit back with S9 or 10... ouch. Might wanna give this configuration a swing at some point.
 
Grave guard with great weapons = hammer.
With shield = anvil.

Choice changes role. But T4 with parry save can do well against most infantry and light units.

Interesting point made by Sunny, you can get both functions with a mind razor cast on the anvil GG.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu