Graveguard. Wortht their weight in gold or not?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Darkfeast

Zombie
Jan 10, 2014
18
Zombies
25
Want to start playing warhammer again after uni tones down a bit (almost there, i can already feel the dark, uncontrollable energy that comes with free time beginning to pulse through my veins).

So iv started looking at my army and what i want to invest in it. As of now nearly my entire army is made up of infantry. Zombies, skellies, a small selection of ghouls, a wraith unit, GG.. With the exception of my varghulf, corpse cart and varghiests (mortis+terror incoming) i have pretty much got an infantry only army.

I decided tonight to expand upon this and perhaos imoulsively purchased some more ghouls and graveguard on ebay. Once i add them to the twenty gg that I already own I will have forty graveguard. Problem is, do they really fit in an army below 2500 points? I want to put a vampire lord/sgk with a bsb or another (baby) vamp in this unit. I wanted to have fun with a necromancer on corpse cart with a forbidden rod backed up behind them. This all sounded good on paper. Graveguard can shit on things they get in combat with after throwing miasma or some buffs their way.. But my rather small unit of 30 (20+10 proxies) dies very easily because it gets focused and i play smaller games. However 38 w/full command and banner of barrows is ridiculiously expensive for a unit that is going to have my vampire lord hidden in it.

Would i be better scrapping them and just loading up on varghiests for heavy hitters? Or run a sgk with less upgrades. This feels very unwieldly for a 2000 point army :s
 
Darkfeast said:
However 38 w/full command and banner of barrows is ridiculiously expensive for a unit that is going to have my vampire lord hidden in it.

Why don't you make a big ass skellie bus for your VL and instead put a WK or two with the Graveguard since WK also get the -1 to hit by the banner. This way you have 2 scary units and will be more able to choose who the Gravegaurds should fight with.

Against the right targets, a couple of GG + a WK is really scary. Oh.. and sword of strife on the wk for 2 more attacks with killing blow at -1 to hit. I'ts a must have :P

Combine that with your T-bat you where planning on adding and your opponant will have a hard time deciding what to be more afraid of.

Thats the way I mostly play it anyways :)

Cheers!
Juljima
 
I'm going to try 38gg with barrows and a wightking with a bound spell next week. It was the one unit that proved its worth in my game yesterday.
 
I ran that unit a few times, porting over the Tomb Guard unit that I've been using for a long time with my TK. I found them to be essentially crappier tomb guard, so many of the same lessons apply:

1) Keep them as cheap as possible. That doesn't mean skimping, but it does mean going easy on character support. A Wight King sounds cool but he's not going to do any better than a bunch more grave guard would. At best he's just a little harder to kill.

2) 35 is probably the right number for the unit. 36-40 sounds better on paper, but not when you factor in what you're losing to pay for the extra bodies. I run 33 tomb guard and it's plenty fine...but then they're frenzied so half the attacks are coming out of the front and the supporting attacks don't matter quite as much.

3) Assume that the unit will struggle to see combat. Your opponents will focus on the grave guard, so you can feel free to bring more fragile units to back them up. Things like vargheists or hex wraiths for instance. Every shot or magic missile that is directed at another squishy hammer is letting your GG go unmolested.

4) Bring lots of chaff and anti-chaff. You're going to need to clear the way to get them into combat, so keep in mind right from the start how you're going to do that.

5) Always run them in the centre of your line. Infantry are slow and unwieldy, so you have to put them where their threat potential is maximized. It's easier to draw a unit away from the fight when it's out on a flank, and much harder to do that when it's coming right down the middle.

6) Don't always jump to commit your block to combat. Think of where they'll be once the fight is done, and how depleted their numbers will be. Also what they're likely to be up fighting next. Sometimes holding that big unit back until turn 4 is the better call, then throwing them in to just crash through a couple depleted units.

7) Remember that high-volume attacks are their bane. They're slow and fragile, so stuff like Chaos Warriors will churn through them. Same with witch elves. You want them against tough things with low attack volume.

8) Sometimes it's worthwhile to offer the enemy a flank or rear charge. A big brick of grave guard are scary, and smart opponents will be smarter than to engage them. Show them a rear charge and they will often times get greedy. Remember that as undead we can combat-reform on unmodified leadership ALWAYS (which people forget). Just calculate how many models you'll lose to crumble to do so (disrupted, rear, charge, fewer attacks back) and consider it a cost of doing business. It's also your turn next up, so you can get plenty of models back.

9) And finally, know when NOT to throw your unit away. When you've been whittled down to 10 guys left that unit is useless, so don't throw it at something just because. Hold it back and preserve that ginormous whack of points that they represent.
 
Interesting advice. Maybe I should stick my wight king with a couple of other characters in a spearmen unit, to give me an additional threat. I can't really afford to take it out of the armylist completely, because I love the sculpt.

It is funny that you mention chaos warriors, I won combat in the first round against them, then put them on snake eyes the second round. Didn't seem that bad at the time.
 
helemaalnicks said:
Interesting advice. Maybe I should stick my wight king with a couple of other characters in a spearmen unit, to give me an additional threat. I can't really afford to take it out of the armylist completely, because I love the sculpt.

It is funny that you mention chaos warriors, I won combat in the first round against them, then put them on snake eyes the second round. Didn't seem that bad at the time.

Oh you'll mulch them no problem...but that's not the issue. The issue is that they strike first and have 2 S5 attacks a pop, and are typically run in smaller (cheaper) units. So 18 run 6x3 is throwing out 12 attacks along the front and 6+6 supporting, hitting on 3s killing on 3s, so about 10.8 on average. Not a big deal for a full-sized unit...but what if they've cast final trans on you once or twice? What if they hit you with a hell cannon? What if they threw a chimera into your flank? If they knock out enough grave guard the unit is in big trouble, as they start struggling to generate enough wounds back to offset the CR and they'll just pop. That's why you need to run lots of models. Question is just when lots becomes too many.

Also, for the wight king, don't be afraid to turn him into a simple unit champion. Nothing wrong with overly pretty unit champions ;P
 
Pirate Robot Ninja of Death said:
8) Sometimes it's worthwhile to offer the enemy a flank or rear charge. A big brick of grave guard are scary, and smart opponents will be smarter than to engage them. Show them a rear charge and they will often times get greedy. Remember that as undead we can combat-reform on unmodified leadership ALWAYS (which people forget). Just calculate how many models you'll lose to crumble to do so (disrupted, rear, charge, fewer attacks back) and consider it a cost of doing business. It's also your turn next up, so you can get plenty of

Sorry off topic question:
Why can undead reform on unmodified leadership? Cant seem to find that rule the boom.
 
dongilles said:
Pirate Robot Ninja of Death said:
8) Sometimes it's worthwhile to offer the enemy a flank or rear charge. A big brick of grave guard are scary, and smart opponents will be smarter than to engage them. Show them a rear charge and they will often times get greedy. Remember that as undead we can combat-reform on unmodified leadership ALWAYS (which people forget). Just calculate how many models you'll lose to crumble to do so (disrupted, rear, charge, fewer attacks back) and consider it a cost of doing business. It's also your turn next up, so you can get plenty of

Sorry off topic question:
Why can undead reform on unmodified leadership? Cant seem to find that rule the boom.

Because they're unbreakable. The wight king does help with this.
 
dongilles said:
Pirate Robot Ninja of Death said:
8) Sometimes it's worthwhile to offer the enemy a flank or rear charge. A big brick of grave guard are scary, and smart opponents will be smarter than to engage them. Show them a rear charge and they will often times get greedy. Remember that as undead we can combat-reform on unmodified leadership ALWAYS (which people forget). Just calculate how many models you'll lose to crumble to do so (disrupted, rear, charge, fewer attacks back) and consider it a cost of doing business. It's also your turn next up, so you can get plenty of

Sorry off topic question:
Why can undead reform on unmodified leadership? Cant seem to find that rule the boom.

BRB p. 55
REFORMING AMID DEFEAT
If your unit loses the combat, but does not flee, it can still attempt a combat reform.
In this case, your unit must pass a Leadership test to muster the necessary discipline to alter its formation. Note that this Leadership test is subject to any modifiers from having lost the fight, just like a Break test. If your unit is steadfast (or has the Unbreakable special rule — see page 78) the test is taken on the unit's unmodified Leadership. If the test is failed, your unit cannot make a combat reform. If the test is passed, the combat reform can be carried out as described above.
[Emphasis Mine]

All undead are unbreakable, ergo all undead always test to combat reform on unmodified leadership. Most people don't know that rule, which is why you can often "buy" getting your nasty unit into combat with a flank or rear charge. Just tally up in your head how many guys you're likely to lose from attacks+crumble and work with it.

For instance, I once beat my friend's Bretonnians because I charged my tomb guard into some chaff, knowing I'd be forced to overrun and show his lord's unit my ass. He saw what he thought was a juicy target and charged in. It cost me the CR that 8 supporting attacks would generate, plus my two disrupted ranks. So 10 tomb guard, essentially.

...but now it's my turn, and I'm S5 AP KB while he's S3 (or s4 ASF HKB on his lord). A few buffs later and those lost models are back and his lord's unit doesn't have long for this world. He hasn't made that mistake again, let me tell you.


Though funnily enough, I *have* seen him use the same strategy with his black knight bus now that he's playing VC. Overruns to give up a flank charge, enemy blindly careens in. WK+nightshroud and blender vamp make way, and are the only things he's touching. Not quite such a juicy charge now, is it? :P
 
helemaalnicks said:
dongilles said:
Pirate Robot Ninja of Death said:
8) Sometimes it's worthwhile to offer the enemy a flank or rear charge. A big brick of grave guard are scary, and smart opponents will be smarter than to engage them. Show them a rear charge and they will often times get greedy. Remember that as undead we can combat-reform on unmodified leadership ALWAYS (which people forget). Just calculate how many models you'll lose to crumble to do so (disrupted, rear, charge, fewer attacks back) and consider it a cost of doing business. It's also your turn next up, so you can get plenty of

Sorry off topic question:
Why can undead reform on unmodified leadership? Cant seem to find that rule the boom.

Because they're unbreakable. The wight king does help with this.

Thanks, Great tip!
Also found it in the rules, its only under combat reform and not under unbreakable
 
helemaalnicks said:
Because they're unbreakable. The wight king does help with this.

I think combat reform is taken without IP so the Wight King gives the group LD 9 instead of LD 6 for combat reforms.

My gaming group have played it wrong for years. :slapface:
 
There's always a rule that you realise at the end of a battle was missed or slightly done wrong.

....at least that is the case with my group of friends anyway! Fortunately only minor more obscure ones these days.

However I remember when we started we used to keep forgetting the steadfast rule for having more ranks which of course was ridiculous seeing a 6 ranked unit fleeing from 10 chaos warriors.
 
The Grave Guard is actually GOOD Tomb Guards...

I've played with them a lot and I would say that this is the prime setup for a GG unit:
40 GG: FC, Banner of the Barrows, GW and backed up by two mortis engines. Also you want to utilize that they are so easy to raise so get a level 4 necro near them og have more level 1's spamming Invo.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu