Helm of Commandment Sequence.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

tommoxyz

Skeleton
Oct 7, 2009
52
Zombies
45
One of our best ways to play is to combine our magic items to impart a significant amount of synergy between them so what do people think of this.

I charge with a unit and contact the enemy. I have a vampire lord with Helm of commandment I declare that I will use helm of commandment on the unit that has just charged. I then cast Staff of Damnation which gives me an additional attack from each model. The attack takes place in the magic phase but the helm states that it's effect takes place in the combat phase so do I get to use the the Vampires weapon skill in that attack?

Lets say the combat continues and in my next turn I cast Staff of damnation again and I have already stated I intend to continue with the use of the Helm on the same unit. Does the Helm stop working for the magical attack and then start again in the combat phase?

The same issue applies to Vanhels danse as it's effect only applies in the next close combat phase so the attack allowed by the staff of damnation doesn't gain the re-rolls.
 
While my friend above isn't terribly helpful in his answer, he is right. If you read the FAQ (which everyone should do), there is a question about special rules and the Staff. It answers thusly:

All rules that would apply in the next Close Combat phase also apply to the attacks made by the Staff of Damnation.

Note that I would still argue that you cannot use the Helm, for the simple reason, that the wording of the Helm's rules make it pretty clear that you may not choose to use it until "that Close Combat phase."

That is my interpretation of the wording for the Helm at least.
 
I did not spell it out to encourage looking it up. In the time it takes to post a thread on the internet you could have looked and answered your own question. Point being, check for yourself all the FAQs then if you are not sure ask people.
 
I still think its a valid question as to when you can declare your using the helm of commandment. I know you can declare at any point in the combat phase, but can you declare it in the magic phase?
 
Poxous said:
I did not spell it out to encourage looking it up. In the time it takes to post a thread on the internet you could have looked and answered your own question. Point being, check for yourself all the FAQs then if you are not sure ask people.

You should always remember that in a forum of this nature there are people who have different levels of knowledge and people who do not always spend their life immersed in the WHFB universe. So you should bear in mind that I asked because I have looked and either missed it or wasn't looking in the correct place in either case that is/was my fault. However in all replies you should bear in mind several things:

- Never say things on line that you would not say to that individual in person.
- The tone of a post can be not what you really intended it to be.
- The purpose of the forum is to help and support other VC players and a reply of go and look it up is neither.

So many thanks to belgarath97 for, gently, pointing me in the right direction which is the way this forum is meant to work and no thanks to you for being unpleasant.
 
belgarath97 said:
Note that I would still argue that you cannot use the Helm, for the simple reason, that the wording of the Helm's rules make it pretty clear that you may not choose to use it until "that Close Combat phase."

That is my interpretation of the wording for the Helm at least.

That was, broadly, one of the the purposes of the question.

As I play more 8th edition games it is becoming increasingly clear that the sequencing of the magic phase and the order of the application of magic, and it's effects, is going to be absolutely critical to winning a game or just being blown off the table.

So the combination of effects from the Helm, a corpse cart and Vanhel's danse is becoming very important.

In this specific case I usually try and cast Vanhel's danse on the unit when it has charged in, then declare the unit the helm is allocated to and finally cast staff of damnation. If that sequence comes off then all the effects combine and a unit of 30 Ghouls becomes very powerful.

Reading the last page of the FAQ, to my mind, indicates that the so long as I declare who affected by the Helm before I roll for the staff of damnation it's affects apply - but do other people agree?
 
This thread should probably be in Laws of the Night...

Note that I would still argue that you cannot use the Helm, for the simple reason, that the wording of the Helm's rules make it pretty clear that you may not choose to use it until "that Close Combat phase."

I see nothing to indicate the above. The full quote:

If the wearer is not in combat, one friendly Undead unit within 12" (not mounts) may use his Weapon Skill instead of their own for that Close Combat phase.

There is nothing about when you chose which unit gets the benefit. Only that they "use his Weapon Skill" in the close combat phase, which only makes sense. I'd say you can declare which unit gets the benefit anytime, as long as you are not in combat when you decide.

On a separate but related note, if what I said above is true, could you choose one unit in the magic phase and another in the combat phase?
 
Well, you can only pass on the bearer's weapon skill in the close combat phase. Definitely not the magic phase.

There's nothing to say when you must choose, so the only possible answer is to choose at any point you like, so long as it's before you've rolled the dice for attacks in a round of combat have been made.

And indeed, I have moved the thread :)
 
The rules do not state when you must appoint the helms use, therefor because of the sequencing rule you may use it whenever you want on your turn. The FAQ does indeed say anything that happens "in the following Close Combat phase" applies to the staff of damnation.

your all clear buddy, your tactic will work and I must say its absolutely devastating with GG with GW's

have fun!
 
That is how I read it.

I have used it 3 times now and on each occasion it is a killer. I use a unit of 30 GG with great weapon. The great weapons give them the ASF rule so to help them survive I give them a Wight Lord with the Drakenhof banner. The unit banner is the Banner of the Barrows. Overall, when all the items work in concert you get:

- Grave Guard hit on 2, using the Vampires weapon skill via the helm.
- They have re-roll missed hits, from Vanhels danse.

Generally I get ~27 hits followed by wounding on a 2, which translates to ~22 wounds with no save unless the target has regen or ward saves.

The problem is it's a one go tactic once someone at the club has seen it they never fall for it again. They keep their dispel scroll or all their power dice in reserve but when when it works it's the best death star in the game...but them I would say that wouldn't I......
 
how are you casting VHD? And what other magic do you bring? You need to present your opponents with a dilemma:

-Have a death mage cast 24" Soul Blight. Now he probably can't hope to even do damage back.

-Have a light mage cast Timewarp. Yay, extra attack!

-Use the Book to repeatedly cast VHD on the unit until it goes through, or expires.
 
And let's be honest here, if you're hitting on 2+ anyway, I think you're going to be okay against almost anything in the game :)
 
If I'm throwing 12 attacks, I'm unsatisfied with just 10 hits. I want that 11th hit! (If all wound, that's another rank taken off of a 5-wide unit!).
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu