I've only posted on this site a few times, so take my opinion for what you will. I love these guys. My initial thoughs after reading this thread is that many of you are simply using them wrong.
Never vanguard them
Raise dead is the best friend of the HW. Raise a unit of zombies infront of the unit you want to ride through then set up to walk through them once they kill the new zombies. I run 2 units of these guys. 1 to ride through if the enemy unit reforms after victory and 1 to ride through if the enemy blows through. Sometimes I get lucky and can hit them with both.
They have single handedly won me the watchtower scenario on numerous occasions. This may spark debate, but in my group riding through the corner of the building after a reform counts as riding through the unit.
I've played about 15 games with the new book against 7 different opponents. I've brought the HW in every game, and based on the negativity surrounding the unit I've kept track.
They have killed. Karl Franz on death claw, 3 steam tanks, 2 hydras, several cannons and hellblaster volly guns, I've paniced a detatchment of halbadiers and in doing so caused the parent unit to panic off the table. The took out a unit of salamanders, a great unclean one, and 2 units of chaos knights. I also killed a fully kitted out strigoi after he failed a charge out of his GG into them. The last one was a fluke as he needed a 6 on 2 dice to make the charge and rolled a 4 and a 1. I was able to reform into a line, clipe the ghoul king then reform out of the charge arc of the GG.