High Elf Leak *First Image*

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Can they field an ice phoenix without a rider? Now,I will not fall for the HE, we must scheme to bring them down. Would you say Blood Knights are the way to go now? Seeing as Swordmasters lose their asf now (they have GW) and thankfully BK are i5 they could quite comfortably squash SM units. And they don't have magical attacks so there won't be no 2+ banneriness against them.
 
Aren said:
Can they field an ice phoenix without a rider? Now,I will not fall for the HE, we must scheme to bring them down. Would you say Blood Knights are the way to go now? Seeing as Swordmasters lose their asf now (they have GW) and thankfully BK are i5 they could quite comfortably squash SM units. And they don't have magical attacks so there won't be no 2+ banneriness against them.

I think the SMs are I 6. Two attacks each.
 
SM are i5 I am quite sure. They have ws6 but not I. Yes two attacks. All elves get martial prowess (I think) so they get an extra rank, which matters nothing if you get them in the flank.
 
Sword masters are I5. They are WS6.

It's the Phoenix Guard and Dragon Princes that are I6

And yes, you can field lone Frost and Fire Phoenixes as Rare options.
 
Zhatan said:
I think you are right that blood knights can be good against SM as they are often fielded in small units. It's not them I'm worried about though... I think white lions and phoenix guard will be worse.

I think they have the capacity to knock each other out, but 5 Blood knights gets you 19 Sword masters, at 7 wide, that is 26 S5 attacks (Army wide Martial Prowess = fight in 3 ranks) swinging at you with superior weapon skill. I'm pretty sure the Bloods would lose that match up
 
Oh they would lose yes, but not before taking out a substantial amount of elves. Plus point for point it is 5 BK to 17 SM not 19 (unless they lowered their point cost). With dragon princes it depends who gets the charge. They can't have more than 2 attacks each, surely (don't know their exact stats) but I am presuming s5 on the charge. So they hit on rerollable 3s (if they have higher initiative and ws) and they wound on 3s on the charge, then we get 4+ saves. Sounds not THAT nasty to me. And BK shred elves, all attacks wound on 2s, on the charge they would only get 6+ saves at best. BK have more attacks and our nightmares are better than their steeds, no, I am no concerned for BK vs Dragon Princes. The phoenix guard seem to be hard to put down, especially if they get a ward save increase but we can just grind them down, they are no swordmasters with 2 attacks and ws6. They are s4 (halberds) have 1 attack and ws5. Grinding them with GG should work or just mobbing them with zombies till turn 5 then multicharging everything into them. BK are not the answer to everything and can't be everywhere at the same time but they are solid vs elves.
 
I still don't see a place for Bloodknights in my army. GW screwed us on the IoN ruling. :(
 
Of course. Apart from that they are sexy models, have badass fluff and are the best cavalry in the game. Enough reasons or do I need to add more? Coupled with a blender lord they squash anything really, they are one of the few things with higher initiative in our army, for an army lacking glass cannons they give us some quite resilient damage. And I just like them. There. That is the best reason of all xD.
 
Aren said:
Oh they would lose yes, but not before taking out a substantial amount of elves. Plus point for point it is 5 BK to 17 SM not 19 (unless they lowered their point cost). With dragon princes it depends who gets the charge. They can't have more than 2 attacks each, surely (don't know their exact stats) but I am presuming s5 on the charge. So they hit on rerollable 3s (if they have higher initiative and ws) and they wound on 3s on the charge, then we get 4+ saves. Sounds not THAT nasty to me. And BK shred elves, all attacks wound on 2s, on the charge they would only get 6+ saves at best. BK have more attacks and our nightmares are better than their steeds, no, I am no concerned for BK vs Dragon Princes. The phoenix guard seem to be hard to put down, especially if they get a ward save increase but we can just grind them down, they are no swordmasters with 2 attacks and ws6. They are s4 (halberds) have 1 attack and ws5. Grinding them with GG should work or just mobbing them with zombies till turn 5 then multicharging everything into them. BK are not the answer to everything and can't be everywhere at the same time but they are solid vs elves.

Swordmasters are now 13 points each (apparently). And ploughing an expensive unit like that into a combat they would almost certainly lose while only killing (on average) 6 or 7 elves in one round does not sound like a good use of 250 points to me.

Against Dragon princes would probably be just as bad, because they will be ASF against you and almost certainly get the charge you. They are bringing back Ilthimar Barding so they are not restricted by barding. They run in there with 8 Princes to your 5 BK (assuming still 30 Points a Prince) and kill 3 of you (again on average) before you even get an attack. You would kill 1 or 2 in return, then you crumble and you still got 6 or 7 Dragon Princes to deal with. If you can get the charge then great but M9 Dragon Princes have a huge advantage over M7 BK

I am obviously over simplifying everything (no command, characters, etc) but I agree with Yorga in that Blood Knights just don't seem to have a place in our army. (they are sexy models though)
 
That's pretty much how I figure Blook Knights to fair against Hi Elf elites. Too many points to just give away like that. GW should have allowed up to rez 1 + level of caster. Then they 'might' have been worth their points.
 
Really? 90% of VC armies have a lvl4 caster in Vampires. Raising 5 BK per cast is just slightly on the OP side. They are powerful in combat, can take a hit or three and are not THAT slow. Usually with BK they either slaughter the enemy unit or they all die taking down many enemies. 5 wounds in a unit with only t4 is not the ideal for Undead unless that unit can slaughter the enemy. In most cases, it can.
 
While those are all valid points and I certainly respect the offensive capability of the Blood Knights, I really think that without that 1+ save they just aren't quite worth it. The biggest problem with them I think is not that they aren't a takable unit, but it's that they are Rare so compete with Terrorghiests and Mortis Engines, and most of the roles you would want to use them for are filled more appropriately by other units. Bus unit? Black Knights, Monster Hunter? Terrorghiest, Mobile shock unit? Varghiests.

And You're right, they aren't that slow, but they are that slow when compared to the new Dragon Princes (I assume you are talking about movement). Dragon Princes move 9" and you can bet that some players will put a banner of swiftness on that unit for M10 heavy cav *Shivers*. Also Blood Knights, being frenzied are more likely to make random unfavourable charges and get themselves into silly positions.
 
I've always thought if they just had two wounds each, making them slightly more durable and more vampre like then one wound "lesser" undead that would make them feel worth their 50 point cost.
 
If you want to lower the points of BK you have to lower the point cost of every other heavy cavalry as compared to others their point cost makes sense. I wholeheartedly agree that their roles are done better by other options but say you want to slay that dragon, it is going to be ld10 so shrieking is not going to down it (on average) and the Tbat is paste if that dragon charges it. How to kill it? Most people would then say 2 Tbats but is that really point effective? 450pts at least and the chances of them both being able to shriek and the dragon not being healed in between shrieks is slim. The only other effective way of bringing down that dragon is a Vampire Blender Lord. Which are all well and nice but can cost a lot (420 ish if only lvl1) and are very easily sniped if not in a bus (you want them to be movable) and that would devote something like 600+ points to kill this dragon, with possible casualties.
Naked bloodknights are 250 points, with luck that unit can kill the dragon (yes, a T-bat with an unholy slice of luck can too) but assuming we have very average rolls you would probably run 7 of these, 350 points. Still the cheapest option. These do 5.25 wounds to a dragon with higher ws and t7 and as far as I know there is only the one dragon with t7, the rest are a nice t6 (which is 7 wounds, definitely dead). 350 points of BK have just killed a dragon which on average you have to spend 450 points of Tbats on or a blendy lord. The advantage is clear.

Now of course that is VERY situational and Tbatd are generally the better hunters. I agree with that. It relies on none of them dying, getting the charge and the dragon (or other monster) not having regen (though the flaming banner would fix that). Is it versatile? No. Is it a must? No. Is it the most point effective option in that scenario and so possibly other similar ones? Yesyesyes! :)

Blood knights still have a place in our army and are not really over costed or underpowered. They are there when you need raw muscle, when the enemy has high ld units with good armour and good toughness. They are there for when you are finally sick of losing combat or winning it by a small margin with anything other than lords/heroes. And most importantly, they are there when you don't feel like squeezing that extra 1% out of your army power and want to field some fun, fluffy and gorgeous units......for £60 :P
 
On the subject of the Banner, I feel obligated to share this thread with you

http://www.ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=45198&sid=72eba22eb71b61ee9df6c5c9aa9e3a11
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu