How 9th could be AWESOME!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Speaking with my brother the other day, we realized that movement is quite important in WHFB, due to the Front, Flank and Rear characteristics that square bases offer, and it's an important concept to rank & file units of combat, as done in ancient days.

I'm interested in seeing how will all this be re-ruled, so that we still have the chance to use tactical advantage, while avoiding loop-holes in the rules like "can't close the door, can't engage in combat then" which seems un-realistic (even for a fantasy-themed game with "realistic" formations and rules), or the "sir there is a monster at our flank, should we turn left and engage it? - Nah, he is not on our front, but standing at arm's length from our spears, we'd better reform and let it charge us, that'll teach him!"

:D anyways, let us see how things unfold. Any new edition should hold the promise of a much better game, in both design and rules. Since smoke is all we see, let us try and see the better. None can see s$&t anyways.
 
@najo @The Sun King - I just don't see what you are both so excited about. This analysis amounts to wild speculation, as baseless as those who are calling doom & gloom, but to the other extreme. I'm not a veteran player so I don't feel the desire for a shake up, but I don't think we really have enough (reliable) information to not simply reserve judgement.

I thought the big not-so-secret was that the Old World of WHFB was located in the Eye of Terror. You know, until they retconned that and said that it's a completely separate universe.
My analysis isn't wild, I'm looking at clues with a company that I've been involved with as a fan for over 25 years and on a professional level for almost 20 years. Look at the facts:

  • Warmachine/Hordes is threatening Fantasy battle, it has a superior business model currently.
  • Players buying new miniatures from GW is better for the health of the company and game then players buying used.
  • 40k's new edition surprised everyone and its even more surprising it had a psychic phase. It also broke the normal schedule, giving 40k two editions in less than two years.
  • End Times is shaking things WAY up.
  • The lore is all there with Chaos, the Old Ones, C'tan, etc. They even started hinting at this stuff in the 8th edition Lizardmen book.
  • Fantasy's cost and learning curve got way out of control. Its entry point was to much for new players.
  • Fantasy allies (like in end times) sells more models and makes supporting army rules easier.
  • Scaling up from skirmish to regimental fighting (being both in one game) makes new players entry easier, keeps old players happy and allows a more natural growth of your army over time. It lets you use most of your collection as you acquire it but actually get playing sooner and for less investment in time and money than now.
  • They aren't going to flush away all of the IP that they own, they are going to make it more legally protect-able and visually competitive to other wargames, especially Warmahordes.
  • They need the product line easier for retailers to carry, for players to find product for and for them to support and sell.
  • The new releases with rules in the box, in the white dwarf and the way 40k codecies are going is likely the way fantasy is going to.
So with all of these clues, what is the end result? What is the game that comes out the other end?

I do know that End Times has been pretty intense so far. If they can keep me engaged and give me a solid fantasy wargame that is as good as what we've been playing or better and gets more people playing and still has tactics based around regiments, facing and movement. I'm sold.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Sun King
I agree with Najo's points above, especially with regard to retailers. If you talk to any FLGS owner one of their biggest gripes with GW is the amount of dead stock they have to carry. Having a rotating release schedule will allow them to carry only the newest and most exciting releases. The amount of stock that will need to be carried will go down, which ought to make their product turnover rate more efficient.

I still don't think things will go to a true "limited edition" release schedule. People go on and on about mold maintenance and storage but I can't imagine that those costs are anywhere near the cost of development. I find it hard to believe that this is motivated by anything other than making their product move more efficiently, and reducing the amount of deadweight they have in stores.

The signs of this have been clear over the past year and a bit. Lots of kits have been moving to online-only, and the criteria for this is quite clearly what kits sell faster than others. There is little precedent for "limited edition" models (outside of starter sets), and much more precedent for moving slower-selling kits to online only.

As for shrinking the number of factions...I'm skeptical of this as well. Diversity is crucial to any gaming company. There's not enough choice among 6 factions to appeal to all players, and that's what you really want to draw people in. Also to keep people playing, since facing the same 6 armies over and over again gets boring quick.

Thus why I think that the factions won't be truly merged, but merely grouped with the ability to take allied components from other faction members. Again...there's precedent for this in 40K, precedent in End Times.

Group armies together and you get efficiency gains. One fewer SKU for combining TK and VC skeletons. Two fewer SKUs for combining DE/HE/WE spearmen. Even if you add diversity through "upgrade sprues," those bits can be used to create cross-compatibility in multiple kits. A DE kit with some crossbows, spikey hats, and DE musicians and banner iconography could be used to turn reavers/glade riders into dark riders, archers/spearmen into crossbowmen, etc.

Not only would this demand fewer kits, but it could ALSO make it easier to create a consistent theme across a Legion/Host army. Creating an Undead Legions army without such a kit has been quite difficult, and the only way I've managed it is through cannibalizing underused kits and extensive ordering from bits websites. If GW were to make TK upgrade kits of their own I'd be throwing money at them.
 
You think retailers are unhappy with dead stock now? Wait until GW tells tham that their entire fantasy stock, which they were required to carry to sell 40k, is now obsolete, nigh unsellable, and non-refunded, replaced by a new system that their existing fan base will be too bitter to give a try, yet they'll be required to carry in order to keep selling 40k anyway.

This is not a retail friendly move. My own local store is livid about it, and likely to drop GW altogether if it comes to pass. GW was already on thin ice with them due to their obnoxious policies and requirements.
 
I suppose that tops my second hand knowledge, though it is coming from multiple store owners with the same kinds of stories. That said, do you expect GW to re-buy fantasy stock after discontinuing the current game to start a new one? And if not, do you really expect retailers stuck with a bunch of stock for a discontinued game to be any happier about it than players stuck with discontinued armies for the same?

I can see how a new, more streamlined game would be friendlier for retailers than the current game, I certainly agree with you there. What I don't see is any way to get from here to there that doesn't cause significant harm to retail relations in the transitional period.
 
I don't think GW is going to invalidate armies or models, even though rumors right now are saying otherwise. With that said, GW does do stock swaps with retailers on items that they are over stocked on. I find it unlikely they are going to leave retailers or players high and dry.

For what's it worth, a contact at GW told me today the rumors of the bases changing aren't true or if they are, it's not being told to any one at GW.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ohn
It was supposed to be white dwarf, and a bunch of staff are asking about it too. He said if anything happens with round bases it might go onto the war machines since it looks better. But he is 99% sure round bases for the units is not happening. No one at GW has heard anything about round bases changing though.
 
GW retail staff? I'm pretty sure they wouldn't know even if it were true.

I can easily believe round bases were tested somewhere in the development of this game. If it's the ground-up reimagining that it's rumored to be, then they could have and probably should have at least tried anything. So do I find rumors that 'the last version' Harry or whoever saw used round bases plausible? Sure.

I'm just hopeful that even if that was true it didn't make it through to the end. Hopeful enough that I'm still modeling my crypt horrors on square bases.

Again, big, individual stuff on rounds wouldn't bother me, and that's all we've seen so far, so... fingers crossed.
 
Your assertion that GW makes the best products is hilarious.
They're just huge and old, that's all. Gives them a big player base, but best..

Remember that scenario book thing, Empire vs Vamps? Where in the first scenario the Vamps get a Necro on a Corpse Cart and the Empire gets a damn cannon? Where the Necro's spells are pre-defined and CAN'T be Invocation? Where the Necro's "reward" for winning is the Master of the Dead skill.. which does absolutely nothing since he can't get Invocation? Yeah.

Cool settings, alright games, sweet (but overpriced) models, crap balance.. not the best in any way. Maybe once.. and maybe one day. But not currently. I do hope it all improves. It'll have to.
 
I don't argue they make the best games. But I certainly agree they make the best models. It's... It's not even close. I mean, I play warmahordes, I've owned mantic stuff, I have friends who play malifaux and I've assembled/painted models for it. I've worked with a lot of the alternative games, and there's really no comparison. You might like certain stylistic choices of other companies better, but the model quality isn't really arguable.

As for the models being overpriced, they're really pretty par for the course compared to everyone except mantic, whose entire gimmick is extra cheap, mostly somewhat terrible models. The prices are out of wack with the scale of game that WHFB has become, but that's the one thing more than anything else that the rumored 9e is supposed to address, and the one part that I can unreservedly get behind.
 
I just don't find the rumours in their current state to be plausible. I'm sure there's kernels of truth in there, but the upheaval they're suggesting just isn't indicative of the amount of effort they've put into the End Times.

These books took hundreds if not thousands of man hours to produce. The models are some of the best GW has ever done. They've put serious effort into cranking out armybook after armybook, all with several gorgeous releases.

And they're claiming they're going to throw all of that away? For a skirmish game, in a market flooded with skirmish games? And when they're the only mass-battle game on the market?

No...don't believe it. They're at worst trying to have their cake and eat it too.
 
Your assertion that GW makes the best products is hilarious.
They're just huge and old, that's all. Gives them a big player base, but best..

Remember that scenario book thing, Empire vs Vamps? Where in the first scenario the Vamps get a Necro on a Corpse Cart and the Empire gets a damn cannon? Where the Necro's spells are pre-defined and CAN'T be Invocation? Where the Necro's "reward" for winning is the Master of the Dead skill.. which does absolutely nothing since he can't get Invocation? Yeah.

Cool settings, alright games, sweet (but overpriced) models, crap balance.. not the best in any way. Maybe once.. and maybe one day. But not currently. I do hope it all improves. It'll have to.

You base your argument on an obscure and unspecified example... Sorry but that won't hold in court :D

Sure there are some flamers on the internet who desperately argue that anything GW does is evil. But let us be honest, there is an incredible amount of us who has spent years and huge amounts of money on GW - have we done this because they are old and huge? No, they are old and huge BECAUSE we like the game, not the other way around :D
 
The thing with the screaming bell and plague furnace is that they are NOT warmachines. If they are to be on round bases starting in the summer, how will they rank in a unit?
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Sun King
Your assertion that GW makes the best products is hilarious.
They're just huge and old, that's all. Gives them a big player base, but best..

Remember that scenario book thing, Empire vs Vamps? Where in the first scenario the Vamps get a Necro on a Corpse Cart and the Empire gets a damn cannon? Where the Necro's spells are pre-defined and CAN'T be Invocation? Where the Necro's "reward" for winning is the Master of the Dead skill.. which does absolutely nothing since he can't get Invocation? Yeah.

Cool settings, alright games, sweet (but overpriced) models, crap balance.. not the best in any way. Maybe once.. and maybe one day. But not currently. I do hope it all improves. It'll have to.
Of course on some level it's all subjective. Everything GW isn't perfect, but for the amount time they've been doing it, the consistency they've done it with, how they raise the bar every time competitors catch up and how good the worlds and stories behind the game are, plus the games as a whole are very accessible rules wise and the right level of detail, streamlining, tactics and scalability. That is what puts them on top. No other company has of that together.

Honestly, 40k needs to solve the gap in the player base created by players who want a classic scale fire fight game or the 40k with flyers and lords of war. Fantasy needs to solve its barriers to entry and make scaling and playing at any point value fun to do. They do that, and then keep the games updated with balanced rules and cool additions, and they will remain the kings.
 
What if a potential new player isnt interested in a small skirmish game, but in a battle game with moderate to large units. The only barrier to entry is price. GWs model of bigger, flashier, more expensive, fewer wont solve that.

Yet historicals and mantic dont have that barrier as they charge realistic prices.

GW USED to charge realistic prices when they started, but have consistantly increased by them by 6 times the amount of inflation, THAT is what has caused the barrier to entry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Seneschal
A game that can be played as skirmished and scales up to massive armies is likely what is coming. Its what is needed and most players want. Being able to throw down with casual friends for 30-45min or play full on battles with hardcore friends for 3 hours, with the same system. That would be awesome!

GW's prices are not 6x the rate of inflation, not saying some things shouldn't be kept in check (witch elves I'm looking at you), but its a fallacy that GW has cranked their prices up that far over time. Privateer Press charges the same amount for their miniatures as GW and both those companies are the leaders. Other top end miniatures like Avatars of War are in similar price range too. The quality of those companies compared to Mantic is night and day. Mantic has some great people working for them and I respect the difficulty and scale of what they are doing, but their miniatures were originally made as an inexpensive alternative to Warhammer and it shows. They have fewer posing options, the sculpts don't look as good, they are very static and some have poor scales. Not all fantasy miniatures are equal. With GW you get a lot more quality for what you pay for. Of course, that doesn't matter to everyone sometimes price and model count is all that matters. Some people buy 200 tablets others spend 600 on the latest from Apple. They both do basically the same thing, but have many distinct differences.

Regardless of Warhammer's cost, its still way cheaper than PC or console gaming in the long run and Warhammer is the only company making models of the caliber as Nagash, Glottkin, the Verminlord or the Imperial Knight. All those massive models are truly jaw dropping incredible.
 
UK inflation calculater http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/...tion-calculator-value-money-changed-1900.html

in 1991 what cost £1 increasing with inflation would now cost £1.98 (an increase of 98%)
skeleton horde box in 1991 was £3.99 for 24 figures (16.6p per figure) - i know because i bought some of them
today on GW site pretty much the same sculpt is £6 for 5 (1.20 per figure)
http://www.games-workshop.com/en-GB/Vampire-Counts-Skeleton-Warriors-5-models
Thats an increase of 620%, or around 6.2 times that of inflation.

If the price had kept pace with inflation that box of 24 skeletons would cost around £8 today, very manageable entry price compared to what we have. Even double that to allow for increased costs over inflation is very reasonable compared to the prices we do in fact have.

Yes thats just 1 example, used as its the most easily seen increase for the same figure (more or less) that i can give. Yes not all have changed by the same amount, but as an averge its increased by something close, even if you say 4 times the rate of inflation its still deffinately very much more than inflation no matter what anyone says.
 
Last edited:
UK inflation calculater http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/...tion-calculator-value-money-changed-1900.html

in 1991 what cost £1 increasing with inflation would now cost £1.98 (an increase of 98%)
skeleton horde box in 1991 was £3.99 for 24 figures (16.6p per figure) - i know because i bought some of them
today on GW site pretty much the same sculpt is £6 for 5 (1.20 per figure)
http://www.games-workshop.com/en-GB/Vampire-Counts-Skeleton-Warriors-5-models
Thats an increase of 620%, or around 6.2 times that of inflation.

If the price had kept pace with inflation that box of 24 skeletons would cost around £8 today, very manageable entry price compared to what we have. Even double that to allow for increased costs over inflation is very reasonable compared to the prices we do in fact have.

Yes thats just 1 example, used as its the most easily seen increase for the same figure (more or less) that i can give. Yes not all have changed by the same amount, but as an averge its increased by something close, even if you say 4 times the rate of inflation its still deffinately very much more than inflation no matter what anyone says.
The main difference is that kit quality isn't the same. The old kits are staticly positioned, cluncky, with fewer options and an amount of detail not even comparable..
So a direct comparison of price then and now is not possible.
Although I agree prices have gone up. But how much I can't say..
 
I would like to see their profit margin on the army books. I am a sales rep in the printing industry, and I can tell you that based on the materials and processes used in their books, the price point is ridiculously high compared to similar products in other markets. The major factors that I don't know, and it would be cool if someone could say if they know, are:
-Do they have their own press / presses, or do they outsource their printing? (same question with bindery equipment, etc)
-What is the wholesale price of their books for retailers?

I ask this because one of the rumors is that they want to combine lists into fewer books, but I would argue selling so many different books makes them a ton of money. Just yesterday my friend and I played a game of Undead Legions vs Legions of Chaos, and we used a whopping SIX books in our game... That's a lot of money!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu