How much MR is needed?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Mikael.K

Master Necromancer
True Blood
Feb 25, 2008
2,643
Eskilstuna
Zombies
947
Lore of light and death are very popular lores around here (and elsewhere too I reckon! :D) and I was thinking how to best protect my precious BK bus. Most armies that rely heavily on lore of light (or death) usually dont pack all that much power in the combat phase, at least not when compared to the BK bus.

So, on to my question: how do you guys protect your Bk bus investment from lores such as light/death?

I was thinking scroll on my baby vamp and have a necromancer on a steed with the MR2/3 item and perhaps with the scroll of shielding. The lichebone pennant also comes to mind. I´m really confident that when my bus arrives into combat, it will get the job done! You can find my current list in the "BK bus + 2ME" thread.

:)
 
I'm not sure if you mean Blood Knights or Black Knights. But, Blood Knights are made almost invulnerable to ranged magic with a the MR 2 amulet (black opal?) and the banner of blood keep.

Never had much of a strategy with black knight buses short of just raising them when they get knocked around.
 
I disagree with Johnny completely. There's nothing else to spend your points on anyway.

Take for example, a 4-character BK Bus. You will get 1 additional support unit that can do heavy lifting, besides the 12-15 BK models, regardless of what else you spend your points on, due to the 600 point Core tax.

Blender Lord is fairly standard setup, and even if you opt for the OTS on the Lord instead of the Charmed Shield, you still need 1 guy to carry a Scroll, which leaves the other guy(s) to do what?

For 45 points, you get either MR2 + Scroll of Shielding, or MR3, both of which tremendously help keep your Characters alive from Sniping, while also helping the Bus preserve models.

At 2500 points, I can run the Lord, baby Vamp, 2 mounted Level 2 Death Necros, all in a unit of 14 Black Knights, with Core + a Bat Unit, and 10 Crypt Horrors. The characters have space to take the Nightshroud, OTS, Dispel Scroll, and MR2/Scroll of Shielding, all while the Lord is totally safe with Charmed Shield, 4+ and OB.

For 30-45 points, I don't think there's a better way to spend your points at all, particularly in a world so dominated by Death Magic, and Lore of Light dual Banishment covens. The Scroll of Shielding alone is like a 2nd Dispel Scroll, effectively giving you a 2+ Ward vs. a Banishment of your choosing if it targets the Bus.

- Larry
 
That is a very exciting idea Larry, I might need to tweak it a bit to fit the swedish comp system. How exactly would the items be placed within the unit/characters? Also, character placement in the unit seem vital. Would feel great to have the bus immune to virtually everything the opponent can throw at me in the magic phase :)
 
Under Swede Comp, I'm not sure what you're looking for re: a Score, but you can score ~7-8 with the following:

Blender Lord w/ usual setup, mounted
Vampire w/ LoV (level 1), Lance, HA, Shield, Barded Nightmare, Nightshroud
2x Level 2 Death Necros - 1 w/ MR2 + Shielding + Ironcurse, other w/ Dispel Scroll

20 Swede Comp Points worth of Core

1 Bat Unit
14 BKs w/ Full Command, +1M
8-10 Crypt Horrors

You can even drop a Level 2 Necro with Death entirely if you wanted to save another ~15 points and get your Score to an 8.1, and the Bats make it an 8.6 (9) if you cut them.

You can even remove a few BK bodies if you want, at 3 pts. per model. Lots of flexibility.

- Larry
 
I'm on Johnny's side. A 5+ Ward won't stop Lore of Light from tearing up a Black Knight unit, particularly if you're facing an Exorcism coven. If you have a character with nothing better to carry in the BK bus, drop the character or buy more BKs. VC struggles with point efficiency in its kill units, and if you have to invest that much you'll end up sacrificing games to enemies that excel against deathstars.
 
Wight Kings can carry the Obsidian Amulet while being useful in a Black Knight bus. They are super-black knights / grave guards!

Scroll of Shielding can be carried by any necro. He doesn't need to be in the unit, however you are fosaking Cursed Book / Forbidden Rod at the very least.

Dispel necro is always wanted everywhere (if I was a Warhammer character and couldn't be a vampire, I'd mine my gold by carrying a dispel scroll and reading it when commanded! easiest job ever! :D)

I'd usually say that a char with MR is better here... but I can see the wisdom in Johnny's words:

Knights are armoured, which means they have a save of their own. More models means equal fighting punch, even if the knights are only left with a 5+ armour save against say, banishment.

Hmmm interesting...
 
This is what I´ve come up with so far:

Vampire Counts

Vampire Lord – 518pts (-65)
General, Level 3 Vampires, Heavy Armour, Shield, Barded Nightmare, Ogre Blade, Talisman of Preservation, Other Tricksters Shard, Quickblood, Beguile, Red Fury

Vampire – 270pts (-25)
Level 2 Death, Barded Nightmare, Lance, Heavy Armour, Shield, Dispel Scroll, Dawnstone, Red Fury

Necromancer – 165pts (-15)
Scroll of Shielding, Obsidian Amulet, Ironcurse Icon, Level 2 Death, Nightmare

40 Skeleton Warriors – 230pts (-4)
Full Command

40 Skeleton Warriors – 230pts (-4)
Full Command

13 Skeleton Warriors – 85pts (-1)
Standard, Musican

10 Dire Wolves – 80pts (-3)

10 Black Knights - 295 (-20)
Full Command, Barding, Lances, Banner of Swiftness

8 Crypt Horrors 314 (-30)
Champion

2 Fell Bats 32 (-5)

5 Blood Knights – 270pts (-8)
Standard, Musican


Total: 2489

Dispel Scroll -7

Komp 11,3

Could easily trade those blood knights for a mortis engine and 1-2 black knights and keep the comp around 10.
 
I don't think Red Fury on the Hero Vamp is worth the 50 points or the Comp ding. It makes him super expensive while still being easy to kill at T4 2 wounds.

You guys are missing the point about the MR - it is LESS about the Light Coven, and more about Death Magic, and Magic in general.

Death Magic is everywhere; at least in ETC, it is. Sniping a Hero Vampire is not hard to do, and definitely worth the effort, at 200+ points apiece, especially in a list with few other good targets. MR2 effectively gives your Vamp Hero a 3rd wound, enough to survive a poor roll on a Spirit Leech most of the time, enabling you to heal him up with LoV spells next turn.

More importantly, having built this list with Empire Light Coven in mind, realize that your opponent may not ever even get a Banishment off, let alone a powerful one.

Banishment tends to be S6 when hard-cast by the Level 4, and S7 from the Altar. The Altar is a Bound Spell, therefore much easier to shut down, and should be the focus of your dice. You shut down the Bound, and then either Scroll or Scroll of Shielding the one cast by the Level 4. You then do the same thing in their 2nd Magic Phase. End result? You make it to their line almost completely intact, and are in combat. Plus, their Magic has done little to nothing to your Crypt Horrors and the rest of your army.

I'd much rather have Magic Resistance over the Book of Arkhan or Cursed Book in a BK Bus list. Using your dice for Death Magic spells is almost always a priority, and getting nuked and *hoping* to get off your 1 Level 4 Invocation, is a bad strategy in a relatively low-model-count Death Star. Your opponent can always stop your Invoke, and then what? Best to preserve models when you can. It's the same reason I always take the Ironcurse. For 5 points, if it saves 1-2 Knights from a Cannon or Doom Diver over 6 turns, I'm thrilled.

- Larry
 
RarerMonsters said:
VC struggles with point efficiency in its kill units, and if you have to invest that much you'll end up sacrificing games to enemies that excel against deathstars.

VC Deathstars aren't built to be efficient, they're built to hold onto 1300+ points while demolishing the equivalent in the opponent's army. Your Core will bleed its points regardless; there's no way around that. The best you can hope for is that your Bus + whatever other Combat unit you pair it with (Vargs, Hexes, Horrors) do their work, which is why you *need* a ton of deployments. I tend to operate with 11+ drops, usually 7 in Core and 3x Fell Bats before I ever get to the Bus and Support, which most of the time means I can drop my Hammers right across from the meat of their army.

- Larry
 
Mikael.K said:
Could easily trade those blood knights for a mortis engine and 1-2 black knights and keep the comp around 10.

I like the idea of a few more BK bodies, definitely, and would cut the Bloods. Not sure if I'd opt for the Mortis, over say, 2 more Crypt Horrors and something else. I prefer avoiding Cannon-able targets if you don't need to bring them, though 1 Mortis could prove useful and could survive a decent while vs. non-Flaming cannons if deployed sideways, and directly behind Crypts, from the start.

- Larry
 
Well... if resources are limited in that particular comp... why not use a Wight King with such goodies and better T, armour and wounds? and still purchase more Black Knights?
 
All depends on if you want a 4th Character, a 4th Caster/Channel attempt, and take the extra Comp Hit for additional Non-Necro mounted models. Swede Comp makes it tough.

I love the Wight King, don't get me wrong. I'd sooner include a Wight King and 2 Level 2 Necros with the Blender. This way you still only have 2 Non-Necro Mounted Characters so don't incur additional penalties, and gain T5 and a 3rd wound. You lose a Channel and level 1 Caster, but that could be mitigated.

Under a Swede Comp setup, I'd consider Blender Level 4, Wight King, Level 2 LoV Necro, Level 2 Death Necro. You can run dual Level 2 Death if you want, but I always like a backup Invoke caster for the Bus.

- Larry
 
Oh, I see!

Those special comp rules are non-existing here, so I don't take them into consideration
 
Even without Comp, I find it is a very potent setup. A bus of 10-14 BKs with 3-4 Characters and 8-10 Crypts do wonders. I also like pairing the Bus with 6+ Vargs, or even 10 hexes. They all synergize, it just depends on the matchup.

- Larry
 
Thank you so much for your valuable input Larry, it really is helpful and you really make your point come across. I´ll be up against TK with arkhan, coven of light and dual caskets, hence why im a bit worried about my poor bus xD. I´ll play around with those ideas, dropping the vampire for a WK will surely make a big difference in comp. I´ll probably go for the 2 level 2´s of death since I really want those snipes, bjuna in particular. I could add a few more CH´s and black knights in there aswell. If i´m lucky I could perhaps get another unit of fell bats in there too.

The mortis engine has another nifty thing going for it, and it is its aura effect. The regen is only really viable when having two of them, but the damage effect is pretty good at dealing with enemy chaff trying to hold up that bus. Still, I would probably kill the chaff, reform and if the opponent wants to charge my bus, go ahead. I´m pretty confindent it can hold its own, even without charging.
 
Sooo, this is what I came up with :)

Vampire Counts

Vampire Lord – 553pts (-80)
General, Level 4Vampires, Heavy Armour, Shield, Barded Nightmare, Ogre Blade, Talisman of Preservation, Other Tricksters Shard, Quickblood, Beguile, Red Fury

Wight King – 164pts (-5)
Barded Nightmare, Lance, Shield, Nightshroud, Dragonbane Gem, Potion of Speed

Necromancer – 165pts (-15)
Scroll of Shielding, Obsidian Amulet, Ironcurse Icon, Level 2 Death, Nightmare

Necromancer – 140pts (-15)
Dispel Scroll, Level 2 Death, Nightmare


40 Skeleton Warriors – 230pts (-4)
Full Command

40 Skeleton Warriors – 230pts (-4)
Full Command

13 Skeleton Warriors – 85pts (-1)
Standard, Musican

10 Dire Wolves – 90pts (-3)
Champion

10 Black Knights - 295 (-20)
Full Command, Barding, Lances, Banner of Swiftness

8 Crypt Horrors 314 (-30)
Champion

3 Vargheists 148 (-8)
Champion

5 Fell Bats 80 (-5)


Total: 2494

Dispel Scroll -7

Comp 10,3
 
I was very pleased that I managed to get those vargheists in there. Gives me a fast way to handle whatever warmachines or wizardbunker my opponent brings :). Also, the 4 levels of death and level 4 vampires is more than I hoped to get into the list, so that´s awesome! I´ll take the list for spin and we´ll see how it does.

Feels like the list is very good at conservig points and as long as the bus is alive, I should be pretty ok. Everything else I can afford to lose :).
 
I'd probably drop the Vargs in favor of a few more BK bodies, but you're also looking at a decent Comp hit if you do that. (-16 + -3 per Knight). Still, it's more to my style. I'd rather have a few extra BK Bodies and 2 less comp points, just in case.

In any event, I think it's absolutely a solid list and you got a great score with it! Let me know how it goes.

- Larry
 
Yeah, more BK´s would probably be ideal, but I´ll test the list and see how it does. Tried to keep the comp score around 10 since 10-15 is what most tournys over here run with (even though some more unusual spans are starting to pop up, comp 15+ etc.). Will try to test this list on either tuesday or thursday the coming week. Really excited about this actually :).

Any tips vs TK running arhan the black, light council and 2 caskets perhaps? :) I think that once I hit combat it´s all over for him. He only has 4 snakes and 2x4 chariots as his combat units.
 
You hit it on the head. Get to combat, and its gg. Just stay out of Killing Blow threat if possible, meaning only charge and engage with your Bus against things you can definitely pop in your 1 combat - which is pretty much everything TKs have.

- Larry
 
Ok, so faced off against my regular TK opponent. I made some slight tweaks on my list, taking a vampire instead of the WK, all skellie + wolfs in core to save comp. My opponent had Arkhan, council of light, archers, 6 snakes, double casket, titan and a ton of chaff. He conceeded on turn 2. Some highlights:

- I push up my list in my turn 1 (got to go first) and bubbled vanhels for the coming turn 2 charges. He couldnt stop curse going off on his archer bunker with characters and I wound 1 of the light casters and Arkhan himself!

- His turn, bad placement takes the snakes out of play. He rolls 3PD with additional 1 from casket and no channels. He goes for purple sun instead of stopping curse and failes to cast it! His chaff blocks him up.

- Turn 2, charge on of his chariots units with the bus, horrros goes into chaff a and manage a charge with my vargheists on his unprotected bunker! He failes to stop curse again, even with arkhan and 3 dice! I manage to get both bubble vanhels and raise dead off. Curse takes a heavy toll on the archers and the characters. My vargheists kills arkahan and and additional lightcaster (another died from the curse) and my opponent calls it.

So a crushing win. Felt a bit bad for my opponent since he basically failed everything he attempted and I was very fortunate with my dice this game. He made some critical errors in deployment that cost him the game. Curse of years is deadly when left unchecked and he had no MR on his character bunker along with not beeing properly bunkered up! He surely learned a valuable lesson from this.

As for the topic, I belive MR is crucial in keeping the bus alive so that it makes into combat. Facing arkhan, light council and caskets is rough since my opponent should net 10+ dice a turn (7 average, 1-2 channels, 2 average from casket).
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu