How to kill Stanks

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
@ArchMagos:
ArchMagos said:
A Stank isn't a Chariot, S7 hits do not kill it automatically; you need to take all 10 of its wounds. In practice, once it has lost 4 - 5 wounds it is greatly weakened, but as a warmachine, you need to get all its wounds to earn any VP.

There is a really good counter argument to this found on Warseer.

The argument is thus: If it is, in fact, a Warmachine for all intents and purposes, then read under "close combat" for warmachines (pg. 86 MRB). If it has no crew at the end of any combat phase you automatically destroy it. Now, you may say it does indeed have a crew, but the crew for a warmachine are independant models, not the warmachine itself (under Models, pg. 84 "the crew are based separately").

I do believe the solution is to not treat it like a warmachine in respect to points given or obeying the rest of the rules for warmachines. If a player argues that it follows the rules for warmachines, then it must also obey the 'no crew at end of combat=dead warmachine' rule, in my opinion.

Cheers,
Mark
 
Fine if you can make that fly. I could not. It is certainly is not a Chariot because it explicitly refer to it as a warmachine.

However, I just read the RAW and the rules read:

If the machine has no crew left to defend it (because the crew fled from the charge, have broken from combat or are wiped out) the enemy automatically destroys the machine,....

The Steam Tank counts as a warmachine.

The engineer is either crew, or he is not.

If is crew, then he cannot be destroyed.
If he is not crew, then the warmachine has no crew to start with and then the crew cannot flee from a charge, get broken in combat, or be wiped out. The list of causes is inclusive and does not permit other options given the wording used.

Destroyed due to lack of crew ifa good argument which requires GW FAQ, but no player I know would agree with this, claiming GW's intent to be clear from all examples an rules given for the Stank.
 
Yeah, looking closer at all the rules having no crew would cause, the warmachine couldn't even be worked. Even if you didn't attack it all game, it would count as having no crew at end of game and so score full victory points.

I suppose I am just looking for a loophole to allow a steam tank reduced to half strength worth something. Without any warmachines, VC have a very tough time taking one out, and dual steam tank lists are just nasty. A steam tank reduced to a single wound cannot do anything anyways; for all intents its' disabled. But it's still not worth any Victory points...? Does not compute, does not compute... ugh. Maybe that's why there's DOW rules to give access to things to fill in loop holes.

I suppose its just as it is now. Which is too bad... for me.
 
My view is that Pit of Shades does not work, but Spirit of the Forge is extremely good. Now, if only I have that and can reliably get that off...

Really, not many lists use forbidden lore or blood knights, or frostblade, or wraiths.

Stanks are fairly common in an Empire players list (in my area at least). Just for the versatility, I think in the future I will be equipping my vampire with Forbidden Lore.

I think I'll do what I usually do; tarpit it and avoid it. I don't think its worth the effort to try and kill it.
 
My Lord always takes Forbidden Lore, coupled with Master of the Black Arts (or is it Dark Arts hmm) she has 7 spells, 5PD and 2DD, just on her own that's pretty powerful, the flexibilty it offers can really help in a battle and if I did see two Stanks looking at me I would be taking Lore of Metal and trying to get Spirit of the Forge off as much as possible.

Though I would like to note that Forbidden Lore isn't much use on a Hero except for fluff (like mine, a beastial vampire who takes it for access to Lore of Beasts which I think is fitting)
 
I play it that Pit of Shades does not affect the Steam Tank (In the same way it would've affect a unit of High Elves with the Banner of the World Dragon which grants immunity to spells) either. But yes, SotF is a perfect way of doing it. With Skullstaff, you have a decent chance of casting it on just 3 dice.

I think Wraiths are the only thing on my list that are common, and fortunately my army has three (including Banshee). It's a shame that her scream will not work on the tank, but I hope that they can chop through it by themselves.
 
Not a horrific idea, but very dice dependent. The Tank has T6, 10W and 1+ armour, so you can expect the Varghulfs to cause a wound a turn. Then in his turn he will grind one of the Varghulfs as well, causing D3 S6 impact hits for every steam point he uses (most likely around 3- if uses too many, it could overload and wound itself again). So if you got some good regeneration rolls, you might eventually destroy it. But that's using 350 points of model to kill 300 points, and will take 10 turns on average...
 
Disciple of Nagash said:
My Lord always takes Forbidden Lore, coupled with Master of the Black Arts (or is it Dark Arts hmm) she has 7 spells, 5PD and 2DD, just on her own that's pretty powerful, the flexibilty it offers can really help in a battle and if I did see two Stanks looking at me I would be taking Lore of Metal and trying to get Spirit of the Forge off as much as possible.

Though I would like to note that Forbidden Lore isn't much use on a Hero except for fluff (like mine, a beastial vampire who takes it for access to Lore of Beasts which I think is fitting)

7 Spells? how do you get it to that O.o

Doh, forget I said anything...
 
Posted by EvC - Today 04:52 PM
Not a horrific idea, but very dice dependent. The Tank has T6, 10W and 1+ armour, so you can expect the Varghulfs to cause a wound a turn. Then in his turn he will grind one of the Varghulfs as well, causing D3 S6 impact hits for every steam point he uses (most likely around 3- if uses too many, it could overload and wound itself again). So if you got some good regeneration rolls, you might eventually destroy it. But that's using 350 points of model to kill 300 points, and will take 10 turns on average...

Aah, I think not then, I'l be sticking with the Lore of Metal idea or maybe some Wraiths.

Posted by Jack of Blades - Today 04:54 PM
7 Spells? how do you get it to that O.o

One Lore of your choice (6 Spells) plus IoN which isn't actually part of the Lore of Vampires but just a spell that all vampires know regardless of what Lore the use.
 
It's always been my understanding that a Vampire with a great weapon by himself is probably the best way to drop a tank. Varhgulf might not be a bad second choice, but in any case, you want a mobile, individual model with a high strength, imo.
 
A steamtank is hit automatically in CC.

I use a unit of 5 wraiths to engage it , it's weapons and grinding are useless and 15 str 6 attacks mow through it in a couple of CC rounds.
Even on average you will knock 3 wounds of it each CC round.
(4's to wound 4's to save on 15 autohits).

Combined with some wolves and zombies in the area to keep support away and the thing does not do a lot anymore.

Worked wonders so far in my battles vs empire.

Search
 
searchonomicon said:
A steamtank is hit automatically in CC.

I use a unit of 5 wraiths to engage it , it's weapons and grinding are useless and 15 str 6 attacks mow through it in a couple of CC rounds.
Even on average you will knock 3 wounds of it each CC round.
(4's to wound 4's to save on 15 autohits).

Combined with some wolves and zombies in the area to keep support away and the thing does not do a lot anymore.

Worked wonders so far in my battles vs empire.

Search

It is actually 5s to wound, with a 3+ armour save, thus 5 Wraiths will do on average 15/9 wounds per phase.
It is still probably the best way we have to deal with a Stank, but it'll take about 4 turns (8 combat phases) for 5 to finish it off.
 
The only other thing I can think of that could do a ton of damage in one turn is a unit of 5 blood knights. If they get the charge off, 15 S7, Wound on 3's, AS on 5+, would do 60/9 or 6.7 wounds. Horses wouldn't do much. On average rolls, it would pretty much cripple the stank. After turn one, they would do same as wraiths, 15/9 wounds a turn. Horses would always do 10/36 wounds a turn. So with average rolls, it would take 3 combat round to take down a stank with a charge of 5 blood knights. Chances are, if you hit it with 6 or 7 wounds, it wouldn't even try to generate steam points. However, in that amount of time your BKs could and would be flank charged as they'd be tied up in combat for 2 full enemy rounds.

Other option for VC is to bring DOW cannons.
 
I killed 2 steam tanks in a game once. pretty much used 2 units of grave guard with great weapons and a vampire hero with great weapon. since impact hits are distributed as shooting you don't have to worry about him getting killed. you can also use small units of zombies all over the place that will get in its way, so it can only charge into them, when the stank will undoubtedly kill them all, then the stank will be unable to pursue because stanks can not pursue. that is ur opportunity to get any charge u want on them, be it grave guard or any kind of knights or a dogs of war giant can be really nasty to a steam tank.
 
You people need to read the rules before going on about what works and what does not against a Steam Tank:

Steam Tank has 1 crew to begin with - it cannot be 'spiked' (auto-destroyed when no crew) because you cannot single out the crew - the Engineer Commander has its own statline, therefore it IS a crew and because of the rules of the steam-tank, cannot be killed in any way unless the Steam Tank itself goes boom!

Pit of Shades does not work on the Steam Tank, if you read carefully both the Pit of Shades spell and the Steam Tank's rules, you'd realise that, but to help out, GWShop FAQ'd it properly: no PoS on the Steam Tank!

High Chance:
Dreadlance + Red Fury
Any other Lance + Red Fury
Spirit of the Forge
Blood Knights

Low Chances:
Frostblade
Grave Guards
Black Knights

You people need to read the rules before going on about what works and what does not against a Steam Tank:

Steam Tank has 1 crew to begin with - it cannot be 'spiked' (auto-destroyed when no crew) because you cannot single out the crew - the Engineer Commander has its own statline, therefore it IS a crew and because of the rules of the steam-tank, cannot be killed in any way unless the Steam Tank itself goes boom!

Pit of Shades does not work on the Steam Tank, if you read carefully both the Pit of Shades spell and the Steam Tank's rules, you'd realise that, but to help out, GWShop FAQ'd it properly: no PoS on the Steam Tank!

High Chance:
Dreadlance + Red Fury
Any other Lance + Red Fury
Spirit of the Forge
Blood Knights

Low Chances:
Frostblade
Grave Guards
Black Knights
 
Kalandros said:
High Chance:
Dreadlance + Red Fury

No offense, but you need to read the rules before posting something. You already autohit the stank, so dreadlance is pretty useless.
I say frostblade and beguile, one missed armour save and it's bye bye steam tank.
 
Quintus Maximus said:
No offense, but you need to read the rules before posting something. You already autohit the stank, so dreadlance is pretty useless.
I say frostblade and beguile, one missed armour save and it's bye bye steam tank.
No offence, but if you're not tooling both your list and your Lord just to fight Stanks (say, in a tourney), then there's nothing wrong with Dreadlance + Red Fury here. Sure, the main advantage of your uber lance is wasted against a Stank, but you still have 4-8 Str 7 attacks round 1: wounding on 3's, save on 5's - add a unit of either Black Knights or Blood Knights and you can easily chunk off a good number wounds in the first round of combat. If you're worried about "wasting" the Dreadlance here, then don't charge a Stank with your Lord! :P

The point here being Kalandros is still perfectly valid in saying that Dreadlance + Red Fury has pretty good odds of laying the hurt. Might not be worth the points in this case, but if you happen to be running your Lord with it anyways and wanna bash it in, it'll do the trick.

Personally, I'd say Frostblade + Beguile is a bad way to roll (Stank? roll? *ahem* unintentional, but decent :lol:). First off, does Beguile even work against a Stank? - i.e. the rule that it auto-passes all characteristic tests, does that include Ld tests? Second, assuming Beguile does work, you'll average 2 wounds a round (on 5+), and s/he saves on a 3+. A little bit much to be dedicating this Lord only to have a chance of killing one. :rolleyes:
 
okey, the word "useless" is a bit big to use here, I wanted to say the same as you.:)
Didn't realise the 3 plus armour save...and the fact that people don't throw 1's and 2's all the time, as I do;)
 
OKay I've heard a lot of people say that the dreadlance, charges with a Strength of 7, but......... in the main rule book (bfsp) in the magic items section it specifically says:

"MAGIC WEAPONS ALWAYS IGNORE ANY SPECIAL RULES THAT APPLY TO AN ORDINARY WEAPON OF THE SAME TYPE UNLESS OTHERWISE SPECIFIED IN THE DESCRIPTION OF THE WEAPON."

no where in the description of the dreadlance does it say that it retains the ability of the lance. so, I ask myself why does the dreadlance specifically say "lance"? well, it must be so that only a mounted character can use it. another reason I believe this is correct, is that in the dwarf rulebook there is a rune, called the master rune of kragg the grimm, and it states that a great weapon will retain all of the normal abilities of a great weapon. this rune specifically says that the item will retain its ability, the dreadlance does not.
 
Crusha, I think that what the rulebook is trying to tell us is that unless a weapon has it's weapon type written out in its rules, it will behave like a normal hand weapon (except no parry bonus with it!), even if it's described as the biggest, most bad ass sword in the world in the little story caption that all items have.

The dreadlance's actual rules says that it is a lance. Therefore it works like a lance with the extra magical abilities!
 
MasterSpark said:
The dreadlance's actual rules says that it is a lance. Therefore it works like a lance with the extra magical abilities!

Let's open the BRB ~ p.121 "Magic weapons always ignore any special rules that apply to an ordinary weapon of the same type unless otherwise specified in the description of the weapon." (emphasis added)
Crusha, the answer you're looking for is right in front of you. The first word under Dreadlance: 'Lance'. ;)

*ahem* So how about them S7 Red Fury attacks against a Stank? :D
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu