@ArchMagos:
There is a really good counter argument to this found on Warseer.
The argument is thus: If it is, in fact, a Warmachine for all intents and purposes, then read under "close combat" for warmachines (pg. 86 MRB). If it has no crew at the end of any combat phase you automatically destroy it. Now, you may say it does indeed have a crew, but the crew for a warmachine are independant models, not the warmachine itself (under Models, pg. 84 "the crew are based separately").
I do believe the solution is to not treat it like a warmachine in respect to points given or obeying the rest of the rules for warmachines. If a player argues that it follows the rules for warmachines, then it must also obey the 'no crew at end of combat=dead warmachine' rule, in my opinion.
Cheers,
Mark
ArchMagos said:A Stank isn't a Chariot, S7 hits do not kill it automatically; you need to take all 10 of its wounds. In practice, once it has lost 4 - 5 wounds it is greatly weakened, but as a warmachine, you need to get all its wounds to earn any VP.
There is a really good counter argument to this found on Warseer.
The argument is thus: If it is, in fact, a Warmachine for all intents and purposes, then read under "close combat" for warmachines (pg. 86 MRB). If it has no crew at the end of any combat phase you automatically destroy it. Now, you may say it does indeed have a crew, but the crew for a warmachine are independant models, not the warmachine itself (under Models, pg. 84 "the crew are based separately").
I do believe the solution is to not treat it like a warmachine in respect to points given or obeying the rest of the rules for warmachines. If a player argues that it follows the rules for warmachines, then it must also obey the 'no crew at end of combat=dead warmachine' rule, in my opinion.
Cheers,
Mark