Ideas for balancing AoS (for friendly games)

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
@Draykorinee Yeah, It is really not nice to come here at get the feeling that people are negative. This should be the safe place for all of us and let us keep working towards that goal :) I am sorry that we have had to moderate as much as we have lately, hopefully the dust will settle soon and I can take off my moderator-hat and put on my user-hat soon :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Draykorinee
We're implementing a system, during our next games with our community. We're trying to keep it simple:

The "points" will be measured in Wound values, with 3 limitations:

HEROES up to 25% of our values, however:

Named Heroes will have an added cost for every ability they have and extra cast attempts (beyond the standard 1) too.
(this means Nagash would be worth 16+5+7=28 Wounds. The Fay Enchantress would be worth 5+4+1= 10 wounds, and so on. Since I'm the only one who plays Nagash, i'd like to have other kind of battles, so I don't think this will be an issue). Only 1 copy of them, just in case it wasn't clear.

Normal Heroes will only be restricted to 2 copies of the same one (up to 2 Necromancers, etc).

WAR MACHINES up to 25% of our values (maybe this won't be necessary, but will have to test it).

MONSTERS (non-heroes) be up to 25% of the game's values. MONSTER-HEROES will share both restrictions.

I think we can play this game fairly and fun.

Thoughts? =D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eyeless
Guys the above seems as a good start but from what i seen/played cavalry and ranged are a bit broken compared to other units. maybe a restriction on them too or it might be too much? I'm having a couple of games next Sat and will try this out =]
 
The only problem with any points system that I've seen so far is that they don't balance different powers of different troop types.

Goblins <> Warriors Of Chaos
 
Goblins are meant to be used beyond 20 models, because they gain bonuses. Plus, you use them as a one-hit unit when you can set them up for a nice charge.

Warriors of Chaos get a bonus from Legions of Chaos, to repeat 1's withe Save Rolls, which places the unit as a walking wall of 4+ saves, with Runeshields or dual-wield.

They are played very differently, so I'd really would say 2 Goblins = 1 Warrior of Chaos in terms of strategy. Wounds are wounds, and frontage is it's own form of advantage.
 
Well, the reason I bring it up is that most balancing systems I've seen say "Number of Wounds" or "Number of Warscrolls'.

I have 20,000 points (8th edition) of warriors of chaos. Most of this is in monsters/trolls/special characters but I still have hundreds of Warriors on foot....

If you even measure in wounds I don't see why I wouldn't be able to take my max number of monsters/characters and still have a good number of models pounding dirt.

I'd simply wreck them. Warriors may not be a good example either due to multiple wounds, but what about elf warriors? Executioners or Dwarven longbeards vs goblins?

There just isn't any variance for the power of the individual model. And even if goblins get a bonus for having extra models, try comparing Elven Swordmasters to Empire Swordsmen....
 
I just wrecked a Bretonnia cavalry formation with a unit of 40 Skeleton Warriors with spears (and 20 Grave Guard, but they only did a minor job in the flank)

Not going to lie, the Skeletons did not face-tank 2 units of 11 Knights of the Realm, 1 unit of 3 Pegasus Knights and 1 Paladin Standard Bearer, but I engaged them in combat (without them sustaining a single casualty to Spirit Hosts and Hexwraiths).

In 3 rounds of combat, there where no more of them.

Grave Guard, however, did manage to slaughter the Knights Errant, but were about to eat a charge from the 3rd 11-man Knights of the Realm unit.

And the skeletons survived in their ~30.

The Bretonnian lord was about to meet Krell when the game ended.

I believe wounds, as long as you plan ahead, are the best way to balance stuff still!
 
You'll have to expand on that because I have no idea what you mean... Based on armor saves? Like the number of saves? Or combining them with wounds?
 
Comparing by armour saves wouldn't be bad, yet it would require to account for certain "hidden" bonuses too, like Ushabti's +2 vs Rend - attacks.

I'm certain that, at some point if it hasn't already happened, someone will asign value to each warscroll, and come up with an automatized or complex system to quantify these parameters (in a really nice app, hopefully).

Oh and another thing:

we house-ruled that no player may have more than 2 summoned Units up and running at any given time. That way we got rid of what spells can you summon and left it "open", and limited.

It didn't go so bad, and is actually more balanced.

Of course, we didn't allow Bray Shamans to summon Nagash, or any other Hero-type Monster with their spell. Because that would just be ridiculous D:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu