Ignoring FAQs

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Deathless Dreamer said:
Vortaine said:
Calling me a drone is amusing, given this whole "discussion" has been your dismissal of anyone who plays it differently. I didn't even mention how I played and yet how I supposedly choose to play is mocked.

This isn't a discussion. You are telling me how I should play the game, just like GW supposedly tells you how you should play. If you and your cliche want to play without FAQs or with your own that's *fine,* and I encourage it, but your group becomes insular the more that happens.

I routinely play new people and that's where using the FAQs as official (which they are, even if they are only the official opinion) simplifies things since we start on the same page.

Case in point, two weeks ago I played 3.5 edition chaos vs 6th edition space marines, 5,000 points of nostalgia. I did it with a regular buddy of mine and it was cool because I hate current chaos (the book is garbage) but it was something we arranged. Would I bring it to my FOGS and just whip it out unexpectedly? No, and I'd argue for the sake of arguing that a better case is made to allow old codices and army books since nowhere (if i remember correctly) does it say I have to use the newest edition when organizing a battle.

The guy who posted about the social contract hit it spot on. If you want to play with your buds this way, go for it. Don't expect to walk in and get a game in with me if we aren't on the same rules-page otherwise.

Shutup Vortaine, I'm sick of your attitude. Stop trying to bait me into arguing with you.


Irony overload
 
[mod]Thread re-instated.

Forum rules will be amended to restrict threads being deleted where discussion has taken place.

In addition this is a final warning. No more further arguments / name calling, or even talking about the previous instances. Either carry on with the thread topic or do not post.

This applies to everyone
[/mod]
 
One of the things I see with using Faq is making sure they are the current edition. Our game store has a computer devoted to having links to the Faq's of many game systems. That way instead of many printed out sheets of faq's they can quick access the current ones. Most of the time the faq's evolve because somethings never came up in play testing. Others because it is pointed out a effect is too powerful and breaks the feel of the game.

Sometimes it nerf's awesome army idea's other times it makes fair play for everyone. But as already been said, if a gaming group or two people can agree on a set of rules, be they using or not using the faqs. Then that is as fair as both using them. As first and foremost most of us play the game to have the enjoyment and fun of the hobby.

Santa's thoughts now he will go back to his realm of painting.
 
GW FAQs are the only universal system that all reasonable gamers will agree on using. If you come up with a different ruling from the internet, or some other community, it will inevitably carry that unmissable feeling of being "unofficial".

If for, say, a tournament, the rules pack stipulates the way in which the games will be played in advance, then that's a different matter. But expecting to turn up to a friendly and use your own system, no matter how well-crafted or foolproof you believe it to be, isn't good gaming etiquette in my opinion. The vast majority expect to play by GW rules, and if you are trying to advocate using others then it will rarely be for your opponent's benefit.
 
A very good example of the above is the ETC comp system in some European tournaments.

Those are not official GW rulings, yet most armies are limited in one way or another (however once the army rooster has been aproved, they follow every new FAQ, Errata, etc I believe).
 
Exactly. I'm all for using different rules if they're appropriate and add something to the game, but I would never force them on an opponent unless he knew about it in advance and had time to adjust or request changes to the rules.
 
I think this entire thread has a lot more to do with player etiquete than it does with the faqs. Merely it is always good form to adhere to your meta if you expect frequent pick up games there. I can agree with the op in regard to irritating players, but it is up to you to exercise your right to decline a game with a troll. But if u accept u have to come to terms together to play. Roll off if u both cant agree on faqs or not. If he refuses that reasonable request. Walk away. He'll eithet change or not play at your flgs if its the practice to ignore official interrpretations of faqs. And i reiterate, if he is simply a troll. Dont play him .
 
Do we have a FAQ to address the grey areas around using the FAQ? Some kind of Meta-FAQ? xD


On a slightly more serious note, in isn't too hard to see how people could have some pretty strong feelings on this, given GW's track record at creating and interpreting their own rules. On the other hand, we all have to accept at the very least that we are playing the same game, to whit, GW's Warhammer Fantasy, and that as such, we are all already following the rules that GW wrote.


I personally believe that the FAQ's do provide needed guidance on many issues, but at times can be contradictory or downright absurd. At that point, I believe that if you have a group of mates you play with on a regular basis, you are well within the realms of reason to "fix", as a group, the areas that are problematic. An example of this for my local group is the "unmodified leadership" FAQ(s). They just don't make sense to us, so we choose to go with a definition that seemed more logical to us - that is, that unmodified leadership be defined as strictly the Ld characteristic of the model in question, with no modifiers, replacements or bonuses what so ever. Works for us, but is contrary to the FAQ.


Conversely, when you are looking for a game with someone that doesn't have the luxury of a common understanding of what amounts to your "house rules", you must default back to the common basis of understanding that does exist - the rules as written, and the published FAQ's (to include Errata, Amendments and FAQ's). Only by agreeing on the rules to be used can we actually play a game, and that starts with lowest common denominator, the rules GW puts out. To continue my example from above, I would not walk in to my FLGS and start a pick up game with somebody, and expect them to abide by my groups agreed upon rulings, nor would I expect them to believe I would just nod to their own groups rulings. I would expect we would both look to the published rulesets in order to proceed.


To each their own, and as long as you and your opponent are in agreement and having fun, then everything is right with the world and no need to get upset.
 
Worloch said:
Do we have a FAQ to address the grey areas around using the FAQ? Some kind of Meta-FAQ? xD


On a slightly more serious note, in isn't too hard to see how people could have some pretty strong feelings on this, given GW's track record at creating and interpreting their own rules. On the other hand, we all have to accept at the very least that we are playing the same game, to whit, GW's Warhammer Fantasy, and that as such, we are all already following the rules that GW wrote.


I personally believe that the FAQ's do provide needed guidance on many issues, but at times can be contradictory or downright absurd. At that point, I believe that if you have a group of mates you play with on a regular basis, you are well within the realms of reason to "fix", as a group, the areas that are problematic. An example of this for my local group is the "unmodified leadership" FAQ(s). They just don't make sense to us, so we choose to go with a definition that seemed more logical to us - that is, that unmodified leadership be defined as strictly the Ld characteristic of the model in question, with no modifiers, replacements or bonuses what so ever. Works for us, but is contrary to the FAQ.


Conversely, when you are looking for a game with someone that doesn't have the luxury of a common understanding of what amounts to your "house rules", you must default back to the common basis of understanding that does exist - the rules as written, and the published FAQ's (to include Errata, Amendments and FAQ's). Only by agreeing on the rules to be used can we actually play a game, and that starts with lowest common denominator, the rules GW puts out. To continue my example from above, I would not walk in to my FLGS and start a pick up game with somebody, and expect them to abide by my groups agreed upon rulings, nor would I expect them to believe I would just nod to their own groups rulings. I would expect we would both look to the published rulesets in order to proceed.


To each their own, and as long as you and your opponent are in agreement and having fun, then everything is right with the world and no need to get upset.

That sounds like a jerry springer final thought lol
Somes up the way the game should be pkayed perfectly. Nothing else needs to be said
 
Reading this thread has been rather interesting. I am ever so slightly tempted to err towards the OP, but I'm not going to, even after ignoring some of the earlier 'tude issues. I would agree if this were a defence of the concept of house rules, but it isn't, really. If it was at any point, it no longer is.

I'm sorry to slightly derail into the world of 40k, but as for a while that has been the system I have played the most, I have some examples to assert why I think firstly that the FAQs are fundamentally important, and also what is fundamentally important about gaming in general.

I'm an Ork player. Our relationship with GW has always been a tough one. As a rather unorthodox faction, we're used to running into problems from clashing faction rules, rules changes, and waiting far, far, far, too long for any kind of useful update. We have an Ork FAQ, and it's reasonably comprehensive. It's taken pretty much up until the start of 6th Ed to get that way and it's still short by about 5 pages. The amount of issues thrown up by the Shokk Attack Gun alone could take up all of the space of the current document.

Two major ones link well to the discussion here. The first is a case in point of why this "rules as written" thing, the whole legalese way of conducting oneself is open to massive flaws. The summary section of the 5th Edition rulebook listed Zzap Guns as having the ability to auto-hit. Multiple times, I've been involved in debates where people assert that this was the case for Zzap Guns. There is no mention of this feature in the current (4th Ed) Codex, and GW are infamous for typos in summary sections (anyone remember the "catch fire" debacle from Underhive?).

The conclusion was obvious, GW had copy pasted the summary from an old 3rd Ed one (where Zzaps did auto-hit - they probably used the summary they had for the 4th Ed rulebook!), but because it was in the rulebook, people start asserting it was fully intentional. In one of the debates, a forum poster offered to email GW and get a ruling, and the answer goblin replied promptly stating this was the case, indeed it did. In spite of the fact that it defied logic, the preamble in the rulebook summary section that stated in cases of contradictions between rulebook and codex, the codex takes precedence; yet still, he had concluded that way.

I dismissed it. Not because the others were drones, but because it was obviously wrong. But I was vindicated by the FAQ. The FAQ was contradictory, and it was probably included because the forum poster I referred to had asked if the answer goblin was sure and it was referred back to head office. It wasn't errata, it was an FAQ, so any person with a literal mind could, by the logic of the OP's argument, ignore it, because it was just GW's interpretation. Never mind that this interpretation in every logical way was wrong, and that poor answer goblin probably gets thousands of rules questions a day.

Another similar case was the Deffrolla, for a while, because its rule specified working in a Tank Shock, it was argued that thus it wouldn't apply in a ram. All sorts of arguments occurred over it, but eventually it was FAQ'd, stating it could be, because rams are a type of tank shock. Most of us tried to play it that way, as we felt it aught be. Some of us couldn't manage it, because no official source supported it. Fundamentally, much like the Zzap Gun example, the FAQ offered something that was really needed: an external, neutral, consistent and reliable stance on a debatable issue.

Whilst I sympathise with the OP to an extent, I would never argue against the FAQ. I've argued against clarification emails, but not FAQs. I expect FAQs are more considered, but the fact is, that's why they exist. The email goblin is there to try and solve an issue quickly, but the FAQ is there for consistency. Sure, GW use woolly, evasive language on to what extent it is to be taken, but much like the "rules as written" phrase, it's largely meaningless. Notwithstanding that the entire internet ignores that Jervis rescinded his catchphrase a mere 3 months after coining it (i.e. he did so immediately). The Head of Black Library also said "there is no canon" ignoring the fact that this makes no smegging sense in any universe.

Taking things literally, dismissing GW's FAQs because they aren't assertively official is a road down a very slippery slope. Where does anyone draw the line with that? It opens so many cans of worms as to cause more problems than it solves. Aside of the fact that "rules as written" is typically viewed as "I can read things too literally" is anathema to any linguist, but there's no stopping the momentum of problems that will occur. If you give a mouse a cookie, it'll want a glass of milk (a statement so good it's cooler than Gary Oldman with a Russian accent). If one really pushes this "it's official" thing, you can easily undermine the entire ruleset: it only takes a quick trip to the page 5 where it discusses the rules as a guide. If anyone is determined they could undermine everything of what makes any GW game what it is.

But the fact is that all of this is completely missing the point. The FAQs are not about whether they are official or not. That is utterly, utterly meaningless. I apply the FAQs, not because I am a drone, or a moron, because I don't apply RAW, or legalise either. I don't agonise over which bits are explicitly stated to be official, as that'd be closer to being a drone. I follow the FAQs, because I respect my opponent. This is a social hobby. People can write essays on what wargaming is about, but much of it falls down to a few simple things. The first is respect. Sure, if one tries hard enough, one can undermine absolutely anything with the right amount of analysis and prodding. But society as a whole functions because of concessions, compromise, respect, and logic. We know everything isn't perfect, but we accept simple conventions because they're convenient, or fair. They may not entirely be fair, but at least they're shared. Because they're shared, that's fair. I get screwed over by one change, you another. It all comes around sooner or later. My bank sometimes cocks up, but I haven't started shoving all my money under my mattress.

The FAQs could be flawed, but they are known to all GW enthusiasts: they are accessible, their updates are numbered, ordered, and they come from a much more solid source than my angsty, cynical and bitter frame. I might know more about linguistics than the Dev Team does, but that doesn't matter. My opponent probably doesn't know me, and probably doesn't care, nor do they need to. But they will know of the GW FAQs, and in the case of a moment where two players cannot reach agreement, there will be an acceptable and unspoken gentleman's agreement that if the FAQ covers it, all players will accept its findings. Because the last thing I want is to make my opponent feel cheated. I can't change them, I can't change the fact that I might be right, but at least I know where I stand, and it is the same for everyone else with the FAQs.

It's that structure that is fundamental to appreciating the FAQ. You can tell me it's not official, and I don't care. Sportsmanship, is that official? Maybe it is, maybe it isn't, but it's more important than the handful of grey areas that exist in the game. I also don't buy that interpretations can always be easily hand-waved as "just another one". Always makes me suspect some people don't know how language works.

Besides, is the OP's way any better? Not really. There is probably a singular, correct interpretation of a rule out there, but there is no fool-proof means of reaching it and having it unequivocally accepted (as this thread shows). Every single approach has its issues. To take a contrary one, just because GW isn't perfect defies the point of having a neutral indicator, because one side of the fence is declaring themselves "god" in its place. Every decision has consequences. The consequences of picking and choosing the bits that work is throwing out consistency and potentially fair play. So a few decisions seem unfair? How is it more fair to dismiss people who prefer to adhere to a consistent structure on the basis that it's dogmatic to do so?

It isn't about dogma. It's about consideration. I've considered the alternatives, and as far as I'm concerned, they're worse.

House Rules is a different matter, but that's just our house in the middle of our street, I might be in the corner shop, and then it stops being so simple.

I would say sorry for the huge post, but it wont be the last, so I'll just say: thanks to all those who took the time to read it.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu