Incoming! Warhammer 8th edition is official.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
The magic phase we'll have to wait and see, but it looks good, except for the 2d6 base power dice. It's just too random.

Far too random, considering our reliance on the magic phase. Overall though, I feel optimistic about the changes, It feels like quite the major overhaul. There's a lot of info to digest. I think the way I play VC will change pretty radically though, especially if the autobreak for fear is gone.

That said, bringing Ogres back as a viable army and doing something to tone down the Daemons gets my approval.
 
Hi a couple things, i noticed not on the list. These have been confirmed to me by several sources one of which is pretty high up on the GW chain. Who so far hasn't steered me wrong.

Magic phase, Is getting moved to before movement. The idea being that alot of the spells that sucked in some of the lores suddenly become alot more useful. This is the only rumor i've gotten any solid proof of, and i believe. Hell I could of told you every thing to a word that was in the Blood angels codex three months before it launched.

Chaos Dwarfs will once again hit the table with force. Now it gets sketchy in a few places.. One i've heard something that we might see them as early this year, two we were told at games day we would see A "New" army based one that previously existed.. Three! I heard rumbling that it might very well end up being a forge world army, and that FW has intentions of launching Fantasy army (This one has me pumped)

The power dice change to me seems like ten steps back, it allmost reminds me of the head ache that was WHFRPG biggest folley a magic system that made me want to bang my head into the wall. It reminds of the damn Card system where nothing ever got casted Or AKA playing dwarves. freaking Magic drain card...

Army creation percentages. I am pretty mixed on that, personally i thought they did a long time ago when i had to stop fighting 1000 point general models. It just invalidates to many codex's High elves, are in some deep shat if that occurs.
 
Magic phase before movement! Now that's one in out favour...I'm going to raise some zombies behind you now I don't even have to use vanhels to charge you in the rear! (would work even better with wind of undeath).
 
Chaos Dwarfs will once again hit the table with force. Now it gets sketchy in a few places.. One i've heard something that we might see them as early this year, two we were told at games day we would see A "New" army based one that previously existed.. Three! I heard rumbling that it might very well end up being a forge world army, and that FW has intentions of launching Fantasy army (This one has me pumped)

Chaos dwarves eh? Joy. I've been waiting a long time for the return of the stunties o' evil. Now, dare I hope they've lost the ridiculous big hats? I had heard a few years back that 2010 would be the year of the Chaos Dwarves. Coincidence? Probably.
 
Sorry Swissdicator but I don't believe that VC will drop down from top tier to bottom tier, that kind of thing would require a full on nerf attack directed squarely at us. Like if they put a paragraph in after the introduction saying "Dear Vampire players, we are changing you from the massacre machines you use to be to Edward Cullen. Your entire rulebook is invalid and you must remove your army from the table right now. Go suck a fat one!".
Unless I see that paragraph on page 4 I don't think we will be hit that bad.
Besides, our book is good enough to ensure that we can work around the innitial problems that 8th edition will throw at all of the armies.

Also on the beasts... well I don't think too much will change. You may have to worry about step up on Gor units but it wont be to bad, it will just allow us compensation for having no armour on our bread and butter units. But as long as they don't destroy our ambushing skirmishers the beasts will be fairly consistant I have too think.
And if our ambushing skirmishers fail theres always the Spiteful Shard. :perv:
 
Personally I think if the rumoured Fear / Terror, magic & step-up rules come into effect we will be nerfed. Perhaps not to bottom, but certainly a good drop down the list considering those parts will probably effect us more that others.
 
I'd REALLY be stoked on Chaos Dwarfs making a return. As much as I love the undead, I've really come to like the Dawi Zharr. They'd probably be mask style like the Hellcannon crew. Whatever style, fans of the other styles, will convert them to that style. I do believe they will return.


Copied from my post in a similar thread on CDO:

I see the movement thing like this: As long as facing has to stay the same... I can see "freer" movement. I consider it 'prolonging' or 'moving at an oblique' like I've seen in historical games.

As for the VC: Yes, they'll be gimped harshly. Between characters being limited AND magic being less reliable, they'll have to wait for a new book to be very competitive again. Still, I like my undead. I'll happily play my VC still, and people won't complain. :P I'll just play them focusing on my true love of the undead. Now to make more zombies... *chuckles*.


I did come up with a WoC for 8th list located here. It might be interesting to start tinkering with general army design philosophies now.
 
There is an interesting discussion going on over on Warseer at the moment. A foreign press release said that the new rule book will be 528 pages long :O

This is a huge increase on the current book, and there is a lot of speculation over what will fill the remaining pages.
Even with extended fluff, pictures and a bit of modelling advice, that is still not going to fill the additional 200 or so remaining pages.... current speculation is that it could be scenarios, naval warfare rules, siege rules or even a complete re-set of all the army books. Whatever it is, I am started to get rather excited.
 
Buck Dog said:
There is an interesting discussion going on over on Warseer at the moment. A foreign press release said that the new rule book will be 528 pages long :O

This is a huge increase on the current book, and there is a lot of speculation over what will fill the remaining pages.
Even with extended fluff, pictures and a bit of modelling advice, that is still not going to fill the additional 200 or so remaining pages.... current speculation is that it could be scenarios, naval warfare rules, siege rules or even a complete re-set of all the army books. Whatever it is, I am started to get rather excited.

Well that video they made did show pictures of castles and boats so its plauseable. I'm a bit doubtful on them putting all the army books in there however.
 
I could see SOME army books being in there *PLEASE HAVE CHAOS DWARFS*, as well as amendments to some existing, but still fairly up to date, books.

Naval rules would be interesting, as they were featured rather strongly in the one shot. Though I doubt seige, as they have shown LOTS of pictures with castles/holds being defended, etc over the years.
 
Swissdictator said:
I could see SOME army books being in there *PLEASE HAVE CHAOS DWARFS*, as well as amendments to some existing, but still fairly up to date, books.

Naval rules would be interesting, as they were featured rather strongly in the one shot. Though I doubt seige, as they have shown LOTS of pictures with castles/holds being defended, etc over the years.

I think if they've gone to the effort to put naval battles in then they will have done seiges as well.
 
:( 8th edition sounds like it going to be really disapointing. The magic rules look especially gruesome, the 2 failed spells in arrow = miscast rule looks bad. All those single casted IoN's would be a thing of the past. Im not very happy to hear that the new changes will hurt us as drastically as swissdictator says. Ive always felt that VC is a competivive army but not overpowered. Our units can be countered without much problem but in the hands of a good general the VC army could be a top Teir army. However it looks like our darkest days are upon us and its likely that we might be in the dog house for quite along time.
 
Capt Rubber Ducky said:
I think if they've gone to the effort to put naval battles in then they will have done seiges as well.

I suspect that both the naval and seige rules will be nearly straight lifts from existing WAB supplements.
 
I usually try very hard to stay away from these threads, considering that I generally get the near-undeniable urge to strip my clothes off, paint myself in woad and burn down a very important building while screaming like a maniac.
Maybe I should try to turn over a new leaf.

The magic changes are being introduced to go hand-in-hand with the change to the percentages in unit selection. With less points to spend on mages and wizards available, each one needs to be independently powerful in order to retain a similar level of magic offense.
The problem I see occurring with this has been brought up previously. More powerful wizards might be dummed down to the point of a Level 1 or 2 by a simple bad die roll, and those Level 1's or 2's might become unstoppably powerful with a good one. This might force us to round out our Vampires and hope for a good role, which is not necessarily a bad thing, but makes the game more about rolling good dice and not tactics, which is a bad thing. I think that I am no longer going to be taking those big, casty Lords. For Vampires, who almost have to have a Lord in larger games, I'll probably leave him at Level 3, and stop my magic upgrading there. It's not worth the randomness. For my other armies, I'll stick at a Level 2 and hope for a good roll.

As for the unit percentages - if these rumors are true then I think that Games-Workshop is instigating change simply for the sake of change. Many broken combinations (two Treemen for instance) are still possible, and even more are as well. You can fit two Varghulfs and a unit of Wraiths into the 560 points given to you in a 2,250 point game, something not currently possible. This rule will glorify Rares and cut down on Specials, which aren't the units that need the change. Notice also that there are a lot of max percentages, but nobody knows what the characters could be. Their maximum percentage could be higher than 25%, which would be most gratifying. I'm hoping for something more along the lines of 30 or 40%, because that would allow us to have a reasonable number of characters (perhaps a Lord and a Hero or three Heroes, depending on how you spend your points), while still imposing a much-needed limit.
 
I usually try very hard to stay away from these threads, considering that I generally get the near-undeniable urge to strip my clothes off, paint myself in woad and burn down a very important building while screaming like a maniac.
Maybe I should try to turn over a new leaf.
You paint an interesting picture Vekarin.

While I do agree with the idea of percentages, 25% is just lazy. Theres no thinking there, thats just "lets just make it 25%!"
I am unsure whether the percentages should be points based at all. Perhaps it should be a numbers or choices game.
 
Well the most reliable rumour for rares says 15% maximum, which would be very interesting, something like 330 points for rares at 2250- no double treeman or double hydra, abomination can't be combined with a second rare, etc. On the other hand... others say 25%. But as with many many many of the rumours posted, I expect that's guesslisting.
 
I'm going to wait until the book comes out rather than try to second guess what the changes are going to be and how they will affect VC. If I don't take that attitude to it, I'm just going to go crazy and knock back too many bottles of Tru Blood and go and pick a fight with a Maenad, which wouldn't end well, for anyone.

As it is, more than anything, I feel cheated about this new edition. Cheated that it is coming out already. I feel like I've just managed to get my head around all the rules for the current edition, and now they want to go and bring out a new one. I mean, you just have to look at the rules section to see how people are still hotly debating over the rules because GW made some of them so ambiguous in some areas, and in other areas, it's just gamers trying to bend things whichever way they can to get any advantage possible. :rolleyes:

I've been playing the hobby for around just under 7 years now, and this will be the third edition that I have had to learn or play by in that time. 3 editions, less than 7 years. It doesn't feel or seem like a long time to have a gaming system continually redo their rules, and it smacks of pure money grabbing. Sales are down on minis? I know, we need a new edition!! I mean, they haven't even updated some of the army books like the Tomb Kings, and they are bringing out another new edition?? It really must suck to be a TK player. Heaven help me if they come out with updated Orcs/Empire/Chaos/High Elves army books in the near to mid future.. :thumbsdown:

So yeah, not really happy or excited about this new edition at the moment. Of course, I'll purchase a copy of the new rulebook as soon as it's out! Hey, I never pretended to not be a hypocrite.. ;)

Oh yeah, the new cover sucks. The background/foreground detail is ok, the hammer is ok, the flames absolutely suck. Looks comical, and ridiculous, and for me, like what the f*ck were they thinking whoever designed that?? This is not 40K goddammit!!
 
I really dislike the cover, maybe if they got rid of the hammer it would actually look good.

I reckon this edition will be make or break for fantasy. I've spoken to too many players who've stopped playing because of the current status quo. Most said they would return if the new edition fixes the current problems(which are not with actual system, but rather the army books).
So Fantasy lives or dies with this edition
 
The change to "percentages" is a good change. I have been playing WHFB since 1987, and have been an active player in almost all of the editions. The big switch from 5th to 6th - was one I was not very fond of, because of the lack of diversity in the army lists. Sure the different armies all looked, and played, different, but the internal balance from each book was missing. Almost all players bring a few variants of a list that is basically the same; the same core choices, the same magic items, and in some armies, the same rares and characters. With slot selections removed, army compositions will be varied and different even amongst the same army list.
Personally, I find the current character selection system as rigged; A vampire is basically weighted the same as an Elector Count, e.g. they both take up one character "slot", but the Vampire is a caster, and thus, this kind of lopsided character selection enables the Vampire Counts to bring a massive and almost unstoppable magic phase due to the fact that magic is based upon the number of casters you can bring. These vampire characters are tough as nails fighters as well as decent magic users; which is vastly different and unfair if you play an army where you have to make decisions on whether you take a fighter or a magic user. The "slot" system exaggerates this problem, and only enhances the problem it was supposed to fix; HeroHammer. In a belt-and-suspenders approach, the actual point costs along with "slot" selections offers a perverse economy of choices to the players.

The reduction in the number of powerful Vampires that we can bring will hurt us, but this system will allow a cunning general to bring a different cocktail of units on the battlefield which will off-set the loss in character power. We will see a shake-up of what armies people run, and you will see many different styles of army builds. ( The days of, I will bring my 10 ghouls, in 3 units, are about to be over.) Some people will shelve their undead horde in favor of greener pastures, but these players will always head to greener pastures.

Vampires will get a reduction in power, but do not fear the rumored changes as they will free the vampire counts from cookie-cutter lists and sycophantic nerf calls.
 
StirogiPerogi said:
The change to "percentages" is a good change. I have been playing WHFB since 1987, and have been an active player in almost all of the editions. The big switch from 5th to 6th - was one I was not very fond of, because of the lack of diversity in the army lists. Sure the different armies all looked, and played, different, but the internal balance from each book was missing. Almost all players bring a few variants of a list that is basically the same; the same core choices, the same magic items, and in some armies, the same rares and characters. With slot selections removed, army compositions will be varied and different even amongst the same army list.
Personally, I find the current character selection system as rigged; A vampire is basically weighted the same as an Elector Count, e.g. they both take up one character "slot", but the Vampire is a caster, and thus, this kind of lopsided character selection enables the Vampire Counts to bring a massive and almost unstoppable magic phase due to the fact that magic is based upon the number of casters you can bring. These vampire characters are tough as nails fighters as well as decent magic users; which is vastly different and unfair if you play an army where you have to make decisions on whether you take a fighter or a magic user. The "slot" system exaggerates this problem, and only enhances the problem it was supposed to fix; HeroHammer. In a belt-and-suspenders approach, the actual point costs along with "slot" selections offers a perverse economy of choices to the players.

The reduction in the number of powerful Vampires that we can bring will hurt us, but this system will allow a cunning general to bring a different cocktail of units on the battlefield which will off-set the loss in character power. We will see a shake-up of what armies people run, and you will see many different styles of army builds. ( The days of, I will bring my 10 ghouls, in 3 units, are about to be over.) Some people will shelve their undead horde in favor of greener pastures, but these players will always head to greener pastures.

Vampires will get a reduction in power, but do not fear the rumored changes as they will free the vampire counts from cookie-cutter lists and sycophantic nerf calls.

VC may be the main culprits, but if you want to consider a character that is both fighty and a decent/good caster a crime, then let's not pretend that they are the only ones(I'm looking at you, Daemon Princes). Also, how much of an issue is Herohammer, and how many armies exemplify this issue? If you find VC to be the main one, then perhaps you object to the very concept of VC as they were meant to be more hero-reliant than other armies, and you might need to find another army to play.

I get the feeling that the blanket 25% limitation will completely kill off VC's competitiveness, not just lower it. It's possible that my VC army will join my Necrons in collecting dust on the shelves, and we'll see for sure come July.
 
If 25% is the arbitrary limit for Characters then that will be interesting indeed for VC. I have 1210 Points of Characters in my 3000 List and I do not consider that to be too beardy. That 1210 Points is spread over 5 Characters and there is not a Crown of Command to be seen (okay, there is a Book of Arkhan...) nor are there any Deathstar Units.. That is a total of 9 Magic Levels, and again, that is high but not extreme. The issue that VC players are going to have if the proposed changes are remotely accurate, and has already been said, is that changes to Character limits, Fear/Terror and Magic is a three-hit whammy that works against the three things that define our army in the first place! That is a HUGE issue. I am not a powergamer, but I have also played Warhammer long enough (20 ish years) to know that sweeping changes certainly have the power to cripple entire armies and right now, intentional or not, that looks as though 8th will put the hurt on VC.
 
Things look pretty bad for us at the moment. 25% character limit will be a heavy blow with how heavily our army relies on its characters to function. Wights and Necromancers will likely become less common - even if they're more points efficient then vampires, the army needs the vamps to move, and our only non character vamp options are in the also rumored to be heavily restricted rare slots. On the subject of rare, the prohibitively pricey blood knights and non-vampire wraiths are also likely to become less popular then the points-efficient, vampyric Varghulf.

Making standard-bearing core infantry the only objective claiming option is also going to hurt, as our most efficient core infantry cannot take banners, forcing a shift to the less-effective skeletons. Remember that those skeletons will also have less character support to draw on - both in replenishment and in melee support, and on top of that will no longer be able to rely on auto-breaking from fear. Things look pretty bad, there, too. At least we have standard-bearing block infantry options. Wood elves need to rely on T3, no-up save archers to claim objectives, iirc. Ouch!

Grave Guard and Black Knights are likely to be more important to try and win combats by enough to break something. Black Knights themselves may want to forgo barding. It was already expensive enough to be a questionable option - having to give up marching, too will likely push barding into the 'objectively bad' category.


'Course, that's all assuming these rumors are accurate, and doesn't even take the magic changes into account. All in all, I could easily see Vamp counts dropping from near top tier to near bottom. It looks to be a painful ride. Let's hope the next Vamp book is far enough out for GW to realize how powerfully nerfed we've been, but not so far out that we're stuck struggling too long.


As for daemons - I still think daemons will be at or near the top under these rules. Their heralds are cheap and powerful, so the character limit shouldn't hurt them too badly, their standard bearing core blocks are likewise very good for their points, giving them solid scoring options. Daemons are under pointed all-round, so there's not much core rules changes could do to fix them.
 
goulking88 said:
If they mess with charicters to much I'm totaly quiting Warhammer Lords and heros are the best part of Warhammer

They are the best part, but I have played Warhammer long enough not to miss 1000 Point Lords who are virtually unstoppable even if facing down half an army. Troops are what the game needs to be about, but not at the expense of forcing us to take certain units only because they are the most needed. I prefer Ghouls to Skeletons, both as models and for effectiveness, but under the new proposals Skeletons area much more logical choice.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu