Sweeney Todd said:VC may be the main culprits, but if you want to consider a character that is both fighty and a decent/good caster a crime, then let's not pretend that they are the only ones(I'm looking at you, Daemon Princes). Also, how much of an issue is Herohammer, and how many armies exemplify this issue? If you find VC to be the main one, then perhaps you object to the very concept of VC as they were meant to be more hero-reliant than other armies, and you might need to find another army to play.
I get the feeling that the blanket 25% limitation will completely kill off VC's competitiveness, not just lower it. It's possible that my VC army will join my Necrons in collecting dust on the shelves, and we'll see for sure come July.
* Power dice aren’t generated by the number of spellcasters. The pool is decided by 2D6. Magic users add their magic level to the score rolled. All Wizards have a chance to generate more power dice. - Avian
(edit: This could be 1 PD for lvl 1/2 and 2 PD for lvl 3/4).
Example: 2D6 roll gives you 3 and 6. You have 1 level 2 and 1 level 4. Power dice =9+1+2 = 12
* Giving irresistible force a downside
* Double 6 = a miscast
* Making miscasts much more devastating.
* Something rumoured is carrying over power dice, but holding too many could lead to a ‘magic backlash’. Wizard will recieve wounds or hits if he didn't use the excess power-dice (than originally allocated) at end of the turn.
* All the book Lores will have more supportive spells than they have now, and will all be getting a major overhaul. Each lore to get a mega spell.
* Spells can be chosen, not rolled for.
TeflonTron said:The Rules for VC crumbling will have to change if Magic becomes less potent and Character % limits are introduced. At 3000 I have a Casting Lord and a Combat Lord, but there is no way that you can use your General as a frontline fighter if he risks getting killed every time he fights and your army crumbling as a result.
)Vekarin the Dark Bladed said:Call me a negative Nancy, but I'm starting to think that this whole percentages thing is total crap. It seems like too large a change for Games-Workshop to make when all of the current army books are written to provide for a slot selection system, rather than a percentage one. In order to preserve balance (not that there is any now...) or even simple rules continuity, Games Workshop is going to have to re-write and re-print every Warhammer Army book that they have produced. Knowing our beloved Games-Workshop, that's not gonna happen.
Besides, where is the evidence for this claim? Has someone heard it from Games-Workshop itself or another credible source? There is a serious chance that the rumor might be someone wishlisting and hoping for an end to "broken" army lists and "herohammer".
Vekarin the Dark Bladed said:Call me a negative Nancy, but I'm starting to think that this whole percentages thing is total crap. It seems like too large a change for Games-Workshop to make when all of the current army books are written to provide for a slot selection system, rather than a percentage one. In order to preserve balance (not that there is any now...) or even simple rules continuity, Games Workshop is going to have to re-write and re-print every Warhammer Army book that they have produced. Knowing our beloved Games-Workshop, that's not gonna happen.
Besides, where is the evidence for this claim? Has someone heard it from Games-Workshop itself or another credible source? There is a serious chance that the rumor might be someone wishlisting and hoping for an end to "broken" army lists and "herohammer".
TeflonTron said:I agree, but it would be relatively easy and simple for GW to print an errata for the existing books until the time comes for their new editions. This is obviously not a likely or logical scenario, but GW have done stranger things.
Vekarin the Dark Bladed said:Call me a negative Nancy, but I'm starting to think that this whole percentages thing is total crap. It seems like too large a change for Games-Workshop to make when all of the current army books are written to provide for a slot selection system, rather than a percentage one. In order to preserve balance (not that there is any now...) or even simple rules continuity, Games Workshop is going to have to re-write and re-print every Warhammer Army book that they have produced. Knowing our beloved Games-Workshop, that's not gonna happen.
Besides, where is the evidence for this claim? Has someone heard it from Games-Workshop itself or another credible source? There is a serious chance that the rumor might be someone wishlisting and hoping for an end to "broken" army lists and "herohammer".
Danceman said:The magic system seems about wonky. Not sure what to make of it... Seems like some excess rumours have stuck onto the 'real deal' because as it stands now it sounds rather powerful. The more plausable version I heard was the roll 2D6 and the highest becomes your PD and the lowest your DD. Again though, still just shallow rumours.
Much like the Tomb King rumours things are too murky for me to speculate in the actual outcome. The only thing I feel is certain is that the magic phase seem to be made more 'individual' to the caster itself, infantry and ogre-sized models will get a boost. That's it. Like previously mentioned, alot of the rumours feels very "wishlisty".
Out of all of the changes they can make; this has to be the easiest. One FAQ/ERRATA to paste over the two charts in the army books changes this game by vast amounts.
Count Erick said:Vekarin took the words right out of my head.
Out of all of the changes they can make; this has to be the easiest. One FAQ/ERRATA to paste over the two charts in the army books changes this game by vast amounts.
Again, look at the Beastmen. I cant see GW making them with the slot system, only to waste paper and change it drastically. I also cant see them issuing a mass FAQ.
StirogiPerogi said:Sweeney Todd said:VC may be the main culprits, but if you want to consider a character that is both fighty and a decent/good caster a crime, then let's not pretend that they are the only ones(I'm looking at you, Daemon Princes). Also, how much of an issue is Herohammer, and how many armies exemplify this issue? If you find VC to be the main one, then perhaps you object to the very concept of VC as they were meant to be more hero-reliant than other armies, and you might need to find another army to play.
I get the feeling that the blanket 25% limitation will completely kill off VC's competitiveness, not just lower it. It's possible that my VC army will join my Necrons in collecting dust on the shelves, and we'll see for sure come July.
The percentage in character selections is not going to be the end-of-the world. A vampire lord is still a very potent character, and is more than capable of dispatching his equals in other armies, but with the changes to magic and character selection the VC general will not dominate by the sole fact that Vampire characters are awesome and that you can out character many an army list. By saying that vampires are more hero-reliant than other armies is rubbish; every army relies on their hero selections, as these models make the game what it is, a fantasy. ( You need heroes to slay dragons-demons-trolls, right?)
The character % cap, and the actual rumored number does not matter, will make it a lot harder for the VC general, but this can be said for other armies. (No stegosaurus spam and other craziness.) The Vampire will, and should be, a rare sight on the battlefield.
The lifting of the restrictions of the Special, Core and Rare slots is where I am thinking we can clean up. Spirit Hosts start to look real good when they are not competing with our other Special Choices. Small units of Black Knights are very powerful, and now we will have access to more of them.
VC have access to two flying units, Bat Swarms and Fell Bats, so with these proposed changes we could out fly a lot of armies.