WHFB - 7th Interesting thread - breath weapons

  • Thread starter Thread starter Oronare
  • Start date Start date
  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
O

Oronare

Guest
Hey all,

I saw this on another forum and thought it was interesting, so I thought I would ask for your opinions :)

Someone asked if they could convert a monster (Dragon, hydra, whatever) to have a much larger neck than the original model has, thus increasing the range on its breath attack.

As it is measured from the mouth of the creature, someone suggested having a 20" hydra and just attacking the enemy lines from pretty much turn 1 in their spawn areas.

Legal? Douchbaggery? How would you react if someone tried it?

thanks :)
 
I would ram that elongated neck up the offending persons arse.

I mean really, in what world would people think that would be ok? If they use that, then I am going to introduce my new giant model, which is me jumping up and down on their models until they learned to stop being such idiots.
 
I think that such an effort could be seen as "modeling to advantage". "Modeling to advantage" is grounds for disqualification at any GW sanctioned event or in any GW store. Tell them to have fun with it at home.
 
The Inspector said:
This is why we have a strictly 'from the base only' house rule among my gaming club.

I agree with this, although I've been under the (apparent) misconception that this is how it's done in the actual rules. o_o
 
i would just wait till he wasnt looking then snap the mouth of and hide it that should be funny

anyone who tries this is probably a 7 year old who always plays to win ITS A GAME
 
I'd probably go with something civalized at first:

As that has a 20" neck and hydras don't have massive elongated necks it can't be a hydra so can you get the correct model out please.

If they disagreed about that this would work well
Disciple of Nagash said:
I would ram that elongated neck up the offending persons arse.
 
MasterSpark said:
The Inspector said:
This is why we have a strictly 'from the base only' house rule among my gaming club.

I agree with this, although I've been under the (apparent) misconception that this is how it's done in the actual rules. o_o

Unfortunately, no. I think the practice of letting a potentially altered metric determine the effectiveness of something in-game is entirely flawed. If I modelled Glade Guard with larger bows, can I get strength 5 at short range? What about more impact hits for a Steg with more horns? No? Then don't let me extend the neck of a Dragon to get a larger flame range.

Off topic, but this is actually one of my greatest peeves about the 40k rules system: true line-of-sight has lead to hunched models (yes yes, such extravagances such as wings or standards don't count), and firing points determined by the actual placement of guns on a tank has lead to the infamous 'drive by' Land Raider variant (all the lascannons are modelled on one side of the tank).
 
best modelling i have ever seen someone stuck all his baneblade guns on a long pole above the tank and claimed it could see everything but couldnt be shot at and of course the rules let him get away wiht it the staff and the players did not
 
Oronare said:
Hey all,

I saw this on another forum and thought it was interesting, so I thought I would ask for your opinions :)

Someone asked if they could convert a monster (Dragon, hydra, whatever) to have a much larger neck than the original model has, thus increasing the range on its breath attack.

As it is measured from the mouth of the creature, someone suggested having a 20" hydra and just attacking the enemy lines from pretty much turn 1 in their spawn areas.

Legal? Douchbaggery? How would you react if someone tried it?

thanks :)

And

I would ram that elongated neck up the offending persons arse.

I mean really, in what world would people think that would be ok? If they use that, then I am going to introduce my new giant model, which is me jumping up and down on their models until they learned to stop being such idiots.

And that giant would have a huge fall over template... xD

And when you think you've heard it all... :lol:

best modelling i have ever seen someone stuck all his baneblade guns on a long pole above the tank and claimed it could see everything but couldnt be shot at and of course the rules let him get away wiht it the staff and the players did not

I just want to thank you all... You've made my day!
I laughed my ass off!!! :lol:
Can't remember when I had so much fun reading a post
 
how does it work for cannons as well? where is it measured from? I have a friend who uses the whole length of his great cannons to improve accuracy, if he rolls slightly short range is measured from the cannon ball release hole (why cant i remember what thats called) and if he rolls too far, he measures from the 'breach' he also does this with the earthshaker in 40k, we let him do it in 40k because 40k rules are retarded anyway, but we tell him off in fantasy.

For his imperial guard he even modelled a whole squad of guard with their arms in the air holding their rifle over a wall (the exact height of all of our walls) so they could claim to be out of sight of the enemy, but 'apparently' could shoot over the wall. I wonder how many people have had eye injuries due to 40k line of sight rules, i know i got some terrain in the eye once, luckily it was a round topped tree, but we have so nid terrain so that could have been worse.
 
I'm pretty sure that you'll measure from the cannon's muzzle (if that's what it's called... the exit point!) since it isn't provided with a base.

@Plopke, it's a bit unnecessary to bring up an older topic just to post something like that (what's with the large font-size, by the way?). Good thing that Campbell came in here with a new question. ;)

Do check the Forum Rules (point 13) for how to interact with older topics, please.
 
And where ever he picks to measure from make him stick with that spot the whole game. None of this sliding measure up and down the barrel crap.......:rolleyes:
 
MasterSpark said:
The Inspector said:
This is why we have a strictly 'from the base only' house rule among my gaming club.

I agree with this, although I've been under the (apparent) misconception that this is how it's done in the actual rules. o_o

That IS a 40k rule.

It should be a rule for Fantasy as well... especially if you see a lot of the above example in your area.

Also, there was a comment about guess range measuring... I always (and always make others) specify from which point they will be measuring from on the first turn.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu