Invocation --> Not for combat anymore?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Hi everyone (first post here and first time VC player, although I have been playing Warhammer for almost all of its 25 years).

I'm not sure that there is really a problem and I will happily argue that Invocation of Nehek can be cast into combat until I am blue in the face.

The rule book specifies, 'Wizards cannot cast spell at units engaged in close combat, unless the spell only affects the caster himself or the spell's description specifies otherwise'. Essentially this forces us to look to the spell's description for an answer.

The pertinent part of the description for the Invocation of Nehek reads, 'Models that are resurrected within a unit that has charged that turn do not gain charge bonuses in the following Close Combat phase'. So, checking the tense we are clearly given a situation where a unit has already charged prior to having the Invocation of Nehek on it.

If it isn't possible for the Invocation of Nehek to be cast into combat the last sentence of the spells description (where the rulebook tells us to seek guidance on casting into combat) is completely superfluous.

regards,
Severan[/b]
 
Severan said:
If it isn't possible for the Invocation of Nehek to be cast into combat the last sentence of the spells description (where the rulebook tells us to seek guidance on casting into combat) is completely superfluous.

We already went through this, technically it is possible to cast IoN on a unit, then Vanhel's Dance them into combat, which would validate that last line.

G
 
Severan said:
So, checking the tense we are clearly given a situation where a unit has already charged prior to having the Invocation of Nehek on it.

Exactly, the tense used makes it 100% necessary for the unit to complete the charge move prior to having the IoN cast on it. And that's the major point.
 
Did we, Girathon? If we did, then someone's messed up, as the text is specifically past tense, i.e. it talks about a unit having new models raised to it after it has charged. Veland has it covered :)
 
Girathon said:
We already went through this, technically it is possible to cast IoN on a unit, then Vanhel's Dance them into combat, which would validate that last line.

G

Sorry but I don't agree this sequence of events explains the spell description. This last line describes the opposite sequence of events.
Since one caster may use IoN on an unengaged unit, then another may cast some other spells, and another caster may cast Vanhels on the first unit, it does not give any reason for the invoked models to lose their charging bonuses, since they will all be going with the unit/galloping to reach their charge target. Why should they lose any bonus then?

But the tense used is most important. The unit "has charged".

*cries silently...Oh Gav why, why did you leave this that way... :(
 
Completely agree with Severan and Veland. It does not say 'Models that are resurrected within a unit that will charge<snip> that turn do not gain charge bonuses in the following Close Combat phase'

It says 'Models that are resurrected within a unit that has charged that turn do not gain charge bonuses in the following Close Combat phase'.

So, they have already charged and are in close combat. If you resurrect and then Danse a unit into combat, they will gain charge bonuses.
 
Cool, thats all good and great. Perhaps you are all forgetting I am on your side (as I have stated several ****ing times), I want to be able to cast into combat, and for friendly games, sure I would allow it . Prove it to me all you want, but until their is an errata, have fun telling your opponent in tournaments that you are going to cast it into combat.

Where you can argue that the tense implies you can cast it into combat, if I were a real douche, I would say that the tense is the misprint, seeing as you have no proof that a sentence allowing the spell to be cast into combat ever existed.
"But what about last edition?" you may cry. Indeed, another edition of the army book. If someone said this to me, I would turn to the High Elf player to my left and say, "Hey, last edition you guys struck in initiative order, lets play with those rules."

Alas, I digress. I should have named the thread something else and perhaps we wouldn't be having these round table arguments that, well, go in a circle.

G

p.s. Anyone found an instance where it was cast into combat in the WD battle report yet?????
 
Well, as long as you have a valid argument, it's fine to play devil's advocate. But if you're misquoting rules to do so, you'll certainly be corrected and should not take offence at it! Your latest post is a valid argument however, as is the simple fact that the magic words are not there, which is a shame.
 
It doesn't explicitly say that you can, therefore, you can't.

However, and a big however, that paragraph about chargers would make no sense without it being able to be cast into combat. That whole sentence doesn't make sense.

So something isn't adding up here. I think an oversight that it can be cast into combat is easier for me to accept than a random paragraph implying it can be cast into combat when it was intended that it couldn't be.
 
Synthesis said:
I seem to have missed somethingm why are you referring to raise dead (new zombie units) and combat together, as it's not designed to create units in combat (hence the 1" away restriction) ... unless I've missed something

Well it is possibly me that has missed something. I haven't read the new book you see. However, it was my understanding that raise dead either created 5d6 zombies in a new unit or healed 3d6 wounds in existing units (of anything).

I believe that was the rumour anyhow. In which case you might be able to heal 3d6 wounds in units that are currently in combat, and have lost the wounds in that combat (or any combat).

Could be wrong though.
 
Well, sadly as Girathon, and some others have mentioned, the "magic words" aren't there. That is truly a bummer. In our friendly games here in my "guild" we've decided to go with allowing it into combat but there is a tourney coming up in april as a pre 'ard boyz type thing and I guess I may get owned there on the spell ruling.

It is truly too bad that there isn't some form of "feedback" or "community" forum to let GW know directly. Although it seems these "GW stores" might be a good answer.

Oh BTW sorry if I offended anyone I really did not mean to go in circles and such. The problem we're having is that we're all right. It doesn't say the magic words. But that last sentence is contradictory. In truth we simply have a problem and that sucks.
 
Can someone contact the authors directly and enquire with them regarding some clarification, perhaps on behalf of this site (MV or Voltaire), Im sure they will be happy to give the y/n and then that may give them the urge to post their decision on the Official Errata.

It obviously wasn't explained well enough in the book.
 
I'll argue until I'm blue in the face that it's allowed for combat.

All it needs is "cannot be cast into combat unless the description says otherwise.". So does the description say otherwise? Not directly, but I would say yes it does.
 
I still think, based on the wording of the final paragraph that it is obviously intended to be used as such, but a design mistake has led to clear definition being left out.

Last paragraph reading: "Models that are resurrected within a unit that has charged that turn do not gain the charge bonus in the following close combat phase"

Bold by me. This seems to be the key point in the matter - to acknowledge this part of the rule, the unit MUST already be in combat - there is simply no other way that it can work. People have mentioned Vanhel's, but even using that will not fit - as you would raise, then charge. This paragraph is talking about charging, then raising, and there is no way to meet this unless you have already charged, and are engaged in combat.

It really does seem clear, with this paragraph that it can be cast into combat - however it is missing the key words which some tourney lawyers could argue against.
 
I discussed this one with the store I game at they said by the main rule books own criteria that IoN would be able to be cast into combat (by the discription of the spell). I am so glad that the store that I attend shows some common sense, not trying to talk down to anyone that believes otherwise, I can see both sides but there seems to always be the points of argument that are farely easy to resolve, by a pre-game/tournement discussion. Just my thoughts
 
A "funny" thing is that also the description of Vanhels spell does not contain the "magic words" (can be cast even if target engaged in close combat, etc), but it gives a description how the spell works if cast on a unit in combat :)
So, one may argue that Vanhels cannot be cast on a unit in combat as well :)
And the part of IoN description also describes how the spell works if cast on a unit in combat, though it only refers to a unit that has charged that turn, so both these descriptions are similar.

OK, the word "mislead" was incorrectly used. I'm not mislead. I'm confused :) But I don't want to argue in any way. I'm for the IoN to be allowed to be cast on a unit in combat, as well as Vanhels. But I would also like to play not breaking any game rules. hence the discussion over the subject.
 
It's not misleading at all is my contention it is very clear it's just that some people want to be rules lawyers and try and stretch the limits and lack the common sense to read the discription and work it out, if someone say for instance during a game told me I couldn't use it as the example says it can be used in the army book, they would get a very strange look from me, FFS it has the example in the army book discription. I just don't know how people can not be sensible anymore?
 
I think everybody here is really thankful to Girathon because of his role as Devil's lawyer. Trying to think the smallest point of argue which can be used against us is not easy, specially if you don´t agree with it. Obviusly everybody want to be right and be able to make others mind up, but that´s an utopia, and we have to be ready to argue and use our best arguments to defend our army not only on the battle field.

BTW, another lance broken in defense of combat-castable IoN: Who could be so absent-minded to use IoN after using danse macabre to charge in the same unit?? a complete description of an exceptional case would be necessary to cover up that mistake?? weird, isn´t it?
 
Danse opens up a new look on this argument. Those with the book look and see if it states it can be cast into combat... doesn't have the "magic words" but again explains the effect that it has if the unit its cast on is in combat.

The only difference between the 2 spells is that one states if the unit is in combat and the other states if the unit charged that turn, when referring t0 the effects it has on the unit in combat

Ryan

EDIT: Damn should really read a little higher next time. Agree with Veland's points though.
 
As much as I hate it, I would have to argue in favour of the Invocation not being able to be cast into combat.

1. Main rulebook says that spell can not be cast into combat unless specifically listed in the spell description. The invocation does not list this.

2. The reference to the spell's effect on chargers does not provide the 'out' for being cast into combat as it is possible to cast the invocation prior to a magical charge happening.

From a game mechanics point of view, it makes very little sense why a unit that has models raised and THEN charged into combat magically should not get a charge bonus but from a rules logic point of view, the presence of a specific mention of chargers in the spell description is NOT in conflict with a the general rule that a spell can only be cast into combat if the spell description specifies that.
 
I suppose it could refer to an occasion where unit has had models restored to it through the Tomb Blade or Blood Drinker... but only if those weapons say that they work in the same way as Invocation of Nehek.
 
EvC said:
I suppose it could refer to an occasion where unit has had models restored to it through the Tomb Blade or Blood Drinker... but only if those weapons say that they work in the same way as Invocation of Nehek.

Those weapons' descriptions indeed state the models are resurrected according to the rules for IoN. Should I put the complete description here? I do not get the idea though, what's the connection?
 
Count Homogenised said:
1. Main rulebook says that spell can not be cast into combat unless specifically listed in the spell description. The invocation does not list this.


Spell specifies an example, and ruling of what happens when it is cast into combat - about the charge bonus'. Following the main rules, the spell specifies "otherwise"


2. The reference to the spell's effect on chargers does not provide the 'out' for being cast into combat as it is possible to cast the invocation prior to a magical charge happening.

Um, no, as casting IoN THEN charging with Danse does not fit with what the last paragraph says - specifically "that has charged that turn".

The only way to ressurect into a unit that has charged that turn is to raise in a unit that is in combat.
 
Veland said:
Those weapons' descriptions indeed state the models are resurrected according to the rules for IoN. Should I put the complete description here? I do not get the idea though, what's the connection?

Because this does give a possible situation where a unit has charged and then has models raised to it a la Invocation of Nehek- by being raised into combat with the Tomb Blade/ Blood Drinker. They refer you to the rules for the spell, which includes the ruling that newly raised models do not get a charging bonus.

However it also states "the following close combat phase", which wouldn't really follow if we were talking about the Tomb Blade or Blood Drinker. Oh well.
 
You know what guys??

I'm pretty sure that this little arguement (or hair splitting or rules lawyering or ignoring common logic, whatever you want to call it) will get settled by the first VC battle report that they do in WD for the new VC book.

Wait for the report and see how they play it. I'm willing to wager anyone on here $20 that you will see a VC unit that is in combat have some of it's fallen re-raised at some point during the game.. and then we will see an end to this nonsense finally.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu