Invocation --> Not for combat anymore?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I have the March issue of WD with a BR between VC and Empire, and I haven't read an instance in which this problem is covered. I will keep looking. I think it is common sense though. Until there is a errata I will clear it with my oponents before play, so there is no misunderstandings.
 
darknesseternal said:
I'm pretty sure that this little arguement (or hair splitting or rules lawyering or ignoring common logic, whatever you want to call it) will get settled by the first VC battle report that they do in WD for the new VC book.

Possibly, but on the other side battle reports in WD often have some mistakes, be they small, but still...
 
It's already been stated elsewhere that no raisings occured. Even then, it wouldn't be gospel, do you know how many things Adam Troke got wrong in the High Elves' first battle report?!
 
Personally I think that there has been a mistake made.

Two spells are worded in thier description of thier use in close combat, one (Vanhels) has a specific alternate use in CC.

Now this isn't on about the fluff description as we all now the the fluff never properly ties in with what the item does half the time but in the actual descritpion of how the spells works.

With all the previous statements, the wording especially the tense used and the fact that two of the spells are missing the statements(more likely that a little statement missing rather than two whole spell descriptions are wrong)its logical to assume that you can use the spell in combat. I think the only people who are going to argue you with you are people who are anal about the rules or bad losers / sports.

I do agree on one thing though, until an official statement shows that the spells can be used in close combat however much its logical and makes sense you will get some idiots who will refuse to accept and so the warning is recieved with thanks
 
Someone has posted on the warhammer forum http://warhammer.org.uk/PhP/viewtopic.php?t=39303&start=26
that he had e-mailed Gav about IoN and Gav confirmed than IoN could be cast on a unit in combat. Do you think we can trust this source? Sounds reasonable for me :)
 
In my experience, WD battle reports are more prone to cause rules issues, than to solve them.
 
Veland said:
Someone has posted on the warhammer forum http://warhammer.org.uk/PhP/viewtopic.php?t=39303&start=26
that he had e-mailed Gav about IoN and Gav confirmed than IoN could be cast on a unit in combat. Do you think we can trust this source? Sounds reasonable for me :)


Looking at the guy - he seems legit, as in high post count, so he has played a while, and attachment to a legitimate club, not just a GSK. I'm still wary of trusting "joe Bloggs on teh interwebs" who gets an email though... its just so easy to blag or fake it.

We WILL here about this, of that I am sure, but until then, I suppose you just hope your opponent is a good sport, not a lawyer, and that in a tournement, the judges show a trace of common sense, and an ability to read the rules.
 
Veland said:
Someone has posted on the warhammer forum http://warhammer.org.uk/PhP/viewtopic.php?t=39303&start=26
that he had e-mailed Gav about IoN and Gav confirmed than IoN could be cast on a unit in combat. Do you think we can trust this source? Sounds reasonable for me :)

Cool, this makes me happy. However until their is an official errata or ruling, that really doesn't count for much though. "Um I can cast it into combat, cause' some guy on the internet, said he talked to Gav Thorpe." Not exactly bulletproof for a tourney setting.

Nonetheless, good news.

G
 
Well, assuming its legit, it clearly shows that the intention is that you can. All we need now is an iron clad ruling, to stop the pickiest of laywers :D
 
Rafe said:
Well, assuming its legit, it clearly shows that the intention is that you can. All we need now is an iron clad ruling, to stop the pickiest of laywers :D

Well, if there isn't a definite ruling that allows you so, the pickiest players can also say that because it isn't mentioned, you still can because you could last edition.

It isn't the best of arguments though.
 
I think the source is definately questionable, unless he provided the e-mail that showed Gav's reply. Gav left GW before the book came out. Unless this character had some idea prior to that, or Gav's personal e-mail (very doubtful), I'm still not convinced one way or the other.
 
Aleraen said:
I think the source is definately questionable, unless he provided the e-mail that showed Gav's reply. Gav left GW before the book came out. Unless this character had some idea prior to that, or Gav's personal e-mail (very doubtful), I'm still not convinced one way or the other.

Well, I don't know the truth, but do you think one cannot post a fake e-mail said to be from Gav? What is your source of the news that Gav left GW before the book came out? Did you talk to him, or GW staff who know him? I just happen to know for example that people from Direwolf confirmed today that IoN works in CC and that they talked to Gav too and he also confirmed. But you cannot check me. Either you trust me or not.
 
Master Vampire said:
Well, if there isn't a definite ruling that allows you so, the pickiest players can also say that because it isn't mentioned, you still can because you could last edition.

Sorry if this sounds crass, but that is the worst reasoning you could possibly have. When a book is updated, the previous version becomes obsolete. Any reference made to it is pointless, because more often then not, it is written by different authors, in a different edition of the game.

G
 
Completely agree with Girathon on the last point.

Because something is NOT there is ridiculous. There are only rules which you can do, not what you Cannot do.
 
We just need to encourage Gav to post his decision on the Errata, should be as easy as a few (thousand) e-mails to GW.

I'll get the ball rolling.
 
VladtheLad said:
Whats their email? In their site they say they don't reply to emails anymore...

I don't know actually much about Direwolf, I just know that a guy from my country, who posts often on one of our fora and takes active part in leagues, judging, etc., contacted them and was given this answer. AFAIK this is a source different from the one who posted on The Warhammer Forum, but I don't know any better than this. A group of guys who analyse rule ambiguities and publish clarifications has already confirmed his version so to say "nationwide" :) so if on a tourney in my country, I'm supposed to play that way whether I like it or not.
 
VladtheLad said:
Whats their email? In their site they say they don't reply to emails anymore...

I saw that myself, I'm in New Zealand and we are under GW Australia so I sent them an e-mail and asked if it can be forwarded to UK, it was basically just basically asking to post on errata.
 
I asked my local GW manager what he thought of it, explaining both sides of the argument with the logic found here, and he claims it works on combat. And while it may not help the lot of you, it settles the matter for me. ;D He also claims Gav still works for GW, despite the numerous rumors, and so the e-mail may very well be legitimate.
 
Aleraen said:
I asked my local GW manager what he thought of it, explaining both sides of the argument with the logic found here, and he claims it works on combat. And while it may not help the lot of you, it settles the matter for me. ;D He also claims Gav still works for GW, despite the numerous rumors, and so the e-mail may very well be legitimate.
Gav probably has some time (days, weeks?) left in GW.

mi_whplayers at TWF was the one mailing Gav. He's the head honcho of the Direwolf FAQ team, and has been corresponding with Gav for some years now. I trust his word above any other 'internet guy'.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu