Is AoS 3.0 too much?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

El Syf

Vargheist
Dec 4, 2011
673
Eastbourne
Zombies
418
As the title suggests, does anyone else think that the changes with third have added a bit too much?
I played a game the other weekend and the battle tactics went out the window after turn 3 as neither me nor my opponent were remembering them. Similarly the amount of things you can do in every phase now is slightly off putting without addressing the issues most people have.
Personally I think 2nd edition just need a bit more fine tuning, than the glut of extra stuff we've ended up with. Some stuff is undoubtedly really cool and thematic it just seems they went a bit overboard for my tastes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oppenheimer
I had to create a two sided reference sheet to be able to actually remember everything. It is a lot. I really liked 1e when you had everything on the warscroll. I was OK with a couple of the early allegiance abilities but once they started adding allegiance abilities, spell lores, command traits, artefacts and now all these universal command abilities, it just became a lot. I can deal with it but I miss the days of 1e.
 
Personally this is the best edition for me so far. But I also enjoy the extra focus on tactics - however, I can see how the added rules are a bit off putting for casual players. I do share your concern for rules bloat as I think there is a common misunderstanding that more rules means more tactical complexity. Which is not true. Chess is a good example - very simple game, but the options are limitless. They did do one very important thing to combat rules bloat though: They removed warscroll batalions - which was a real problem in terms of extra rules to keep track of and balance issues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sume
It's definitely more complex than 2.0 and (especially in the first games) you need to keep track of the various things. With more games under your belt you'll find much easier to cover all bases without overthinking too much.

However, the "entry level" is now higher and i'm not so sure it's a good thing if you want to lure into AoS new players. It's still manageable, but i hope GW won't push further this trend.
 
Welcome black cat ! Glad you like it here. If you have any questions don't hesitate to ask. I would recommend running games of 500-1000 pts when you start out. It is faster and there are less things to keep track of with smaller armies. In general I find 1000pts to be very enjoyable. Bigger is not always better. :D
 
Skip heroic and monstrous actions + battle tactics and focus on primary objectives + getting into your respective armies.

When you feel you've gotten into the groove of the game add in battle tactics and the rest when you've gotten the hang of the battle tactics.

In short, get a feeling how the games plays before adding in more layers.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu