Justify my Nostalgia; Can the Barrow Army Work?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Dec 20, 2013
3
Zombies
6
Just as the title says; do you think a barrow army could work? I am not too fussed about making an optimal list, but would not mind playing an army which would work for casual games and- perhaps every full moon or so- a tourney.

Regardless, can hordes of Skellies and Grave guard work, especially without Vampires? I mean, something about a ton of skellies and wights being driven forward by Necromancers screams "awesome" to me. Perhaps I am ill...:)

My own thoughts on the matter lead me to conclude that the army lacks serious killing power. A preliminary draft of the list I made included three units of skellies and two units of grave guard (one with sword and board, one with great weapons), though I was lost as to what complimented this core well and still kept the theme going strong.

Hope to hear some interesting musings!

Skeleton Warriors.
 
It can work, but you just need to accept that it's going to be a battle of attrition. Grave Guard do better with great Weapons, because 4+ Armour Save isn't much (especially with how Armour is negated) and S6 will be needed, as Grave Guard and Terrorgheist will be the only heavy hitters in this type of list.
 
Count Vashra said:
It can work, but you just need to accept that it's going to be a battle of attrition. Grave Guard do better with great Weapons, because 4+ Armour Save isn't much (especially with how Armour is negated) and S6 will be needed, as Grave Guard and Terrorgheist will be the only heavy hitters in this type of list.

What do you think of multiple Grave Guard units? Perhaps two units of thirty; one with sword n' board and one with great weapons?

Also, what about black knights? How do you feel about them as potential hammers?



Skeleton Warriors.
 
2 units of GG can work fine for sure, but from my expirience they really REALLY need vampire support in order to wreck face like they need to. Banner of the Borrows is almost an auto include in any list with GG over like 1,500pts. Them hitting on 3's with S6 killing blow is amazing! Also you're probably going to be really tempted to take a wight king, and they are okay but not great. If you do, then give them a regular great weapon and thats it. Keep them cheap and dirty.

I would agree with Sunny on only running 1 unit, and only using Great Weapons with them. S&B just doesn't do damamge, and you have skellies to soack up hits instead of your hard hitting, expensive, elite unit. However I've had pretty good success with a 35 man, 7 wide, but that was with a blender lord in the front making up for the fact that they were missing like 10 attacks because they weren't in horde formation.

As far as black knights go, they pretty much exist only to bring a mounted blender lord from point A to point B saftely and maybe get a few lucky kills in there. They can't really do anything by themselves. It's also tough to make an effective GG unit and an effective BK unit in anything less than 3,000 and even then it's iffy.
 
Corien Sumatris said:
I would agree with Sunny on only running 1 unit, and only using Great Weapons with them. S&B just doesn't do damamge, and you have skellies to soack up hits instead of your hard hitting, expensive, elite unit. However I've had pretty good success with a 35 man, 7 wide, but that was with a blender lord in the front making up for the fact that they were missing like 10 attacks because they weren't in horde formation.

What about using smaller units of 25 and keeping them as flanking detachments or such. 25 Grave Guard hitting the side of a unit engaged frontally to skeletons is surely going to leave a mark, no? In this situation, Grave Guard are pricey, sure, but not cripplingly so; they would cost the same as any "medium combat" unit.

I suppose what I am proposing is something of a Many Medium Units concept (MMU?), where your bricks of skellies cannot simply be run over, as ranked semi-elite infantry have also come along for the ride. Certainly, this isn't optimal, but it cannot be discounted, no? If nothing else, they are plucky and not so valuable that loss is inevitable should they 'spload.


Skeleton Warriors.
 
Multiple units in the same combat tend to hurt VC more than help. As a flanker, your opponent will still slaughter skeletons, plenty more than you can make up in combat rez against the unit by flanking. Thus killing your GG with crumble.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu