Krell as he should have been (NEWCHANGES)

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Jan 16, 2010
7
Zombies
8
no fluff so far
HERO CHOICE
Krell. = 450pts
M WS BS S T W A I Ld
4 5 0 4 5 3 4 3 10

Chaos Armour.=4+armoursave

Killing Blow on a 5+

Battle Standard Bearer.

Black axe of Krell, same as in Vampire Counts 7th ed.

Crown of the Damned, same as in Vampire Counts 7th ed.

Banner of the Lichemaster, Heinrich made this Banner, Grants its unit
and all characters in it a 4+ Regen and Hatred.
 
RE: Krell as he should have been

The first question that pops into mind here... would you want to play against this incarnation of Krell yourself? He looks grossly powerful to me and nothing I've read about him would justify such a massive potential for carnage.

Also, you shouldn't strive to emulate Skulltaker's rules for killing things in challenges, he's generally accepted to be one of the more broken things around at this point. Krell takes it one step further though, he doesn't even need to be in a challenge. :vampire2:

I'll have to give you a 'No' here. What makes you say that this is 'Krell as he should have been'? According to what, or who?
 
RE: Krell as he should have been

I agree that this proposal looks very overpowered. I think a wight king with Black Axe of Krell, chaos armour, and maybe a couple of +1 stats (say to WS and I) would suffice.

Skulltaker is a lame enough character, but a 5+ non-challenge monster kill is unwarranted. The banner is even better than Drakenhof, which is also seen by many as too powerful as it is. The Crown of Command is not useful, since the banner already gives a 4+ ward, so the crown just gives him stupidity.
 
RE: Krell as he should have been

4+ Ward Save & Infinite hatred to the unit is like the Drakenhoff banner only better. Drakenhoff should be around 150pts, and a ward is better than regen, so this banner alone is probably worth 225 pts at least (probably closer to 250). Infinite hatred and 4+ Ward to a unit??

And why would he need Crown of the Damned, which grants a 4+ Ward save, when he has a banner that does the same thing? EDIT: Squig beat me to it.

This character is probably worth 500pts+, is way over the top, and I would never play with or against anything like this.
 
RE: Krell as he should have been

ok ill change, LOOK UP! I added this up and it all comes out to 450pts
heres an example
wight king=75
+1 ws=10
+1A= same as sword o battle.=15
+1Ld=10
5+Kill=Same as sword o kings.=25
blackaxe=50
crown=35
BSB=25
hatred= same as banner o strigos.=35
regen=same as drakenhof banner.=125
for all the combinations.=45
total=450pts
 
Just because individual components add up doesn't mean that's an accurate points cost, since he effectively has 3 magic weapons and a magic banner. I think he's still way too good. Now he has a 4+ AS, 4+ ward, and 4+ regen. And he still has that monstrous banner. I know it's tempting to make unstoppable characters for the named/classic ones we all love, but if they're too good no-one will consider them valid.
 
I think for a start you should drop the banner and the crown, and make his own armour a unique armour. Something along the lines of 5+ ward should be right.

Remember he is meant to be a hero level character, which you are currently trying to give lord level stats and powers / items to.
 
I would agree that these rules are very overpowered, this would be my attemp at a Krell.

hero choice
about 200 points

KRELL
M | WS | BS | S | T | W | I | A | Ld
4 | 5 | 0 | 4 | 5 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 9

Weapons and armor
Black axe of krell
Black armor

special rules
wight blades
undead
champion of the lichemaster
lord of wights

black axe of krell
great weapon, each unsaved wound done by the black axe of krell is multiplied into D3 wounds. black shards break off and dig into the victims heart. any model that loses a wound to the black axe must pass a toughness test at the start of each of its subesquent turns or suffer an additional wound. such is krell's skill with his axe he does not suffer the always striking last penalty for great weapons, instead striking in initiavive order.

black armor
full plate armor, this armor is made of the material as the black axe. Its hardness protects krell from the worst of the enemies blows. All attacks made against krell are at -1 strength, this includes all shooting and magic missile attacks

champion of the lichemaster
Krell was resurrected by the lichemaster and serves as his bodyguard in battle. If Krell is in base contact with heinrich kemmler, his base is treated as if it includes kemmlers, allowing him to fight anything his master could fight. in addition, any attacks allocated to kemmler outside of a challenge must be resolved against krell.

lord of wights
Krell is a dark champion and one of the most powerful wight kings ever raised, a measure of his power extends out to other wights around him. All wight models (graveguard, wight kings and black knights) are able to march if they are within 6" of krell, treating him as if he had the vampire special rule.



I think these rules would be workable, he is powerful, as an undead champion should be, but I think he still fits into the hero level of power.

I have not changed the way magic weapon removes killing blow from wight blades as i think that coupled with the ability to strike with the black axe using his initiative would overpower him, any thoughts?

I hope also that people are happy with my custom special rules and magic armor, i saw him more as a damage mitigation sort of character, rather than magical avoidance (ward save).
 
I quite like that Campbellstein. I would say he should still be able to keep the KB on his axe, it shouldn't be too OP, and he should also probably be S5. Other than that perfect.
 
I did consider whether i thought STR5 was appropriate but i think for a hero level character, hitting on a str 7 is pushing it as I have removed the always strikes last rule from his great weapon.

thinking about it, i think killing blow could go back on as well, it would however give him quite a few rules, but then as a personal champion, he is meant to be nasty against characters.
 
Hmm, the previous WD Krell rules were very similar to what you've used, only he had 4 attacks as well as the black axe, crown of damned and chaos armour etc...

Though the rules for the black axe were different back then too (enemy player rolls a dice at the start of their turn for any model wounded but not killed by the black axe) on a roll of 1 or 2 they lose an additional wound.

I think keeping him at WS 5 with 3 attacks is more than sufficient but I don't think he should have the crown of the damned as it just makes him a bit over the top in terms of a hero level character.
 
I am considering adding both Krell and Kemmler to my Legions of Nagashizzar army list (as Krell is a Dark Lord of Nagash after all), and as such I have some other thougts on Krell, some based on the fluff found in the latest books where he is included (the Sigmar Triology and the latest Gotrek and Felix novel).

Now, I have to say that I am considering Krell and Kemmler to come from the LORDS section in 8th ed. It just seems a bit odd to me that a nearly indestructible Dark Lord of Nagash should be a hero choice, but in a VC list in 7th I can fully understand why he is considered a Hero choice because of how the character allowance system wored.

I'm not going to argue on point costs as such, just add some thoughts on using Krell as a character in WHFB (8th ed).

-Giving his long history vs. Dwarves, I would give him hatred vs Dvarves and all dvarves hatred vs him in return (he is listed in the book of grudges numerous times after all).

-Considering that he was a former champion of khorne (and I imagine that once you have sworn your soul to a chaos god, it is not that easy for a necromancer to usurp it), I would consider giving him Freny, even though he is undead.

-Black armour should be some sort of Chaos armour in my opinion. In the novels he is described as near indestructible, even Gotrek struggling to wound him. If I'm not mistaking, an organ gun was needed to kill him outside the walls of Altdorf. I'm thinking some kind of Ward save here, although I liked the -1 to all Strenght attacks vs him as well.

-Ridden Monster option? I know the model is on foot originally, but in the latest Gotrek novel he was on an undead wyvern if I'm not mistaking. Just a thought.

-I would not let him be the BSB, as it is not according to the fluff, and A Dark Lord of nagash carrying the army banner around seems a bit odd to me. Besides, such a tough character being the BSB is a bit unfair in 8th ed. A normal Wight King is already mopre than tough enough.
 
I forgot one thing.

I don't think he should have any sort of "bodyguard" function for Kemmler. Yes, they are a dynamic duo, but nothing in the fluff gives the indication that he acts as a bodyguard for Kemmler, or indeed anyone else. In my mind he is as much a frontline fighter as you can find in an Undead army, and Kemmler is not. He acts more as a front figure for the army, while the true general (Kemmler) stays safe behind the lines doing his thing.
 
Even under 8th edition rules, though, he'd be easier to field if he were kept a Hero choice. Even in a 2000 point game, it would be hard to field both Heinrich and Krell, if they were both under the same choice, especially if Krell's priced over 400 points.

With Mannfred the Acolyte and Konrad both as hero choices, I think Krell still fits as a Hero slot option.
 
I certainly agree that it would be hard to field them both in a 2000 pts game, but I don't really see this as a major problem, as fielding 2 such iconic (and dangerous if the fluff is something to go by) characters in such a small army is a bit of a stretch anyhow. Especially if Krell is allowed to be the BSB as well.

I don't see why Krell has to cost in excess of 400 pts either quite frankly. Krell is not THAT much more powerful than a normal Wight King in any of the above versions presented. It is quite hard to justify a fighter character costing 400+ points in 8th, when 400 points of core choices (with steadfast) can easily keep that character from doing more than potentially earning back his own cost in a game.

So I would make tha argument that they should both be lords choices, on account of the fluff presented in the new novels etc. It would also allow Krell to have options for mounts, even monstrous ones typically reserved for lords.

I see Krell as a second Lord choice that you can only field if you choose Kemmler to be your army General.

Granted, people are always going to have different opinions on issues such as this, and that is fine. It is hard to really try to make rules for characters portrayed in novels etc, as people are always going to have varying opinions on their actual power levels.
My personal opinion is that Krell is so much of a unique character in an udead army that a Hero choice wouldn't do him justice, or at least if one were to restrain him to an hero-equivalent point cost. I personally think Krell's cost should be 250-300 points (+mount option) to reflect the fluff and that he is a Dark Lord of Nagash after all.
This would also allow for more special rules for him, which would make him a bit more than just a Wight King with more magic items and better stats, something I believe a Special Character ought to be.

I am a firm believer that special characters are there to grant the army some sort of bonus or new option which allows the army to be used in a slightly new way etc; not just a tougher and more dangerous character than you can normally make when creating your own. The above versions of Krell doesn't have that in my opinion, and I think it would be hard to do much with him as an already very expensive Hero Choice...
 
I think we need more special characters other than the von Carsteins, and Krell seems perfect to be a pure combat orientated Lord character, but I don't think you should have to use him only in an army with Heinrich, as two Lord choices is far too expensive to be in an average sized army. And he should obviously be almost indestructible (T6, armour save 4+, ward save 5+ and probably some magic resistance)
 
Narp said:
I think we need more special characters other than the von Carsteins, and Krell seems perfect to be a pure combat orientated Lord character, but I don't think you should have to use him only in an army with Heinrich, as two Lord choices is far too expensive to be in an average sized army. And he should obviously be almost indestructible (T6, armour save 4+, ward save 5+ and probably some magic resistance)

In a VC army list I think he should be used together with Kemmler, as he is not a vampire or Hierophant of any kind, and pairing him up with another necromancer of some sort just seems wrong to me.

I agree that it could be hard to put two lord chices in one average sized army, but that also depends on how powerful Kemmler is made in the first place. I would perhaps go for reducing Kemmler's cost a little, removing the chaos sword he used to have back in the old days for one thing. what's he going to do with something like that anyway? Kill a poodle perhaps?

Giving Kemmler the Loremaster rule, and hust the Cloak of Mists and Shadows and his own skull staff (with some new rules), with the option to take more magic items for a larger gamer (the same as Mannfred) should be more than enough to begin with. It shouldn't make him overly expensive. Having your general on the field, with just ethereal to protect him is a risky buisness when facing many armies out there. I remember him being slain by a lone friggin uniocorn once (rider was already dead) in the last round of one game. You simply can't get him into close combat (unstable) and nearly any magical shooting attack is going to kill him... Or magic for that matter... He could be given a points "discount"because of theese major drawbacks, much in the same way that Mannfred the Acolyte is much cheaper than his abilities would make him if you take a look at what you get for the points.

So I think it is doable to at least get them both in a list of 2500 pts without any problems at all.

The Kemmler model is just awsome, so it is a shame that Kemmler and Krell are not to be found in an army book any longer btw. I definately agree that more special characters are needed in the VC list, but only if the old bloodlines were also returned.

Aslo, there could be some unit limitations with Kemmler as the General, such as no "vampire" units etc.. That could shave some points off him as well. But then Krell would have to be treaded as a "vampire" or perhaps another general for the purposes of marching units etc...
 
Kemmler would have to be very weak (WS 2 and T3 methinks) for that to work, but it seems like it could work very well. I expect Kemmler would be around 300 pts, and Krell around 200, so 500 pts for the pair.

I recall reading somewhere somewhere that when Nagash raised Krell the first time, then Nagash himself got killed by Sigmar, Krell simply fled instead of collapsing like a normal wight does, so this implies that Krell isn't going to crumble if Kemmler dies. It would be pretty cool if Krell's unit didn't crumble either, and he and his unit had frenzy because of his dedication to Khorne.

I have no idea what Krell did for 2000 years before Kemmler decided to get off his ass and do something constructive, and it seems unlikely Krell decided to go back to his tomb and have a massive nap, so he must have done something in that time on his own, but he wouldn't be able to raise an army without necromantic assistance.
 
Narp said:
Kemmler would have to be very weak (WS 2 and T3 methinks) for that to work, but it seems like it could work very well. I expect Kemmler would be around 300 pts, and Krell around 200, so 500 pts for the pair.

I recall reading somewhere somewhere that when Nagash raised Krell the first time, then Nagash himself got killed by Sigmar, Krell simply fled instead of collapsing like a normal wight does, so this implies that Krell isn't going to crumble if Kemmler dies. It would be pretty cool if Krell's unit didn't crumble either, and he and his unit had frenzy because of his dedication to Khorne.

I have no idea what Krell did for 2000 years before Kemmler decided to get off his ass and do something constructive, and it seems unlikely Krell decided to go back to his tomb and have a massive nap, so he must have done something in that time on his own, but he wouldn't be able to raise an army without necromantic assistance.

Well, both Yes and No.
Yes, according to the old Krell information in the army book, (or GW released special character for v5 or v6) this is true. He survived, and continued to plauge the empire afterwards. He was finally cornered and defeated at Glacier Lake, and imprisoned in a magical tomb.
No, according to the lastest Book in the Sigmar triology. Then he was defeated when Alaric the Mad (the name should be familiar to most people) and a company of 100 dwarf warriors attempted to slay him (without much success I might add). He was however destroyed in that fight, by the first Empire produced (or should that be repaired) Organ Gun...
So, the stories don't quite match up, but since the triology has much more details etc, and is the lastest one, I for one choose to think this is the real representation of Krell as he should have been.

As far as him being a more powerfull Wight, I agree with you completly. A mere normal Wight would never have the status of a Dark Lord of Nagash. Normal Wight Kings would be a dime-a-dozen for the Undying King.
The frenzy thing is absolutly something that would fit with krell and his latest description, but also something thay one sees a bit to often. I have actually been working on an outline for Krell today, and I'm soon done. I'll post my idea here afterwards for you to have a look. Note that it is based on the latest version of Krell though...

Krell is in no way a Necromancer, but I wouldn't rule out the idea that he could sustain at least a sizable army himself, even though he'd need help raising it in the first place.

Regarding Kemmler, I imagine he'd be quite pysically weak after his decades of madness and hard life, not to mention the typical nastyer side effects of dabbling with necromancy. I have no problem seing him as quite physically crippled, but yet a dangerous necromancer.. Can't really see him having the toughness of an Orc...
 
I'll just post what I have so far on Krell, and add some of the reasoning behind my choices etc. Feedback is most welcome.

Krell - Lord of the Undead (pts not worked out yet)

M 4; WS 5; BS 0; S 5; T 5; W 4; I 4; A 3; LD 10

Troop Type (Infantry (special character; Wight King)

Special Rules:[/u] Legions of Nagashizzar *

Ancient Grudges: Krell suffers from Hatred towards all models in the Dwarf Army book, and they likewise suffer from Hatred against him in return

Duo of Destruction: not finished...

Slaughtermaster: When he is not fighting in a Challenge, Krell’s great axe is used to butcher troops on a scale rarely seen in the Old World. His axe cleaves through men, armour, steeds, often several with each swing of his fearful great axe. When fighting against Infantry, Cavalry or War Beasts, he gets an additional hit against rank-and-file models of the unit he is fighting, for each original attack that hits and kills a model. These new hits are resolved at -1 Strength , with a further -1 to Strength for each further model hit etc; and they continue to do so until they fail to wound, or are stopped by any kind of a saving throw. Only the initial rolls to hit are needed, and it works pretty much like hits from a Bolt Thrower thereafter, except that one doesn’t have to consider ranks, facing etc.
Because of his immense strength, untiring form and his skills with his axe, the Always Strikes Last special rule doesn’t apply to him. He strikes in normal order of initiative

The Doomed Legion: not finished...

Black Axe of Krell: see p.84 of the VC book... add Wight Weapon in the hands of Krell.

The Butcher's Armour: Krell's armour is the very one he wore in life; his blood-soaked Chaos Armour, blessed by Khorne, the Lord of Skulls. It grants him a 2+ Armour Save as well as a 5+ Ward Save against magic, or any magical attack, including that of magic weapons. All successful to wound rolls of 5+ must be re-rolled against him as well.
Finally, in a Legions of Nagashizzar army, the armour grants him the Necromantic Nexus (2) special rule.**

* First of all, I should state that Krell is part of a personal project I'm working on, the Legions of Nagashizzar (hence the special rule name). Started over a year ago, but put it on hold while waiting for the lastest Nagash relevant novels to come out, so I don't want to hear anything about any similarities to be found here. Just discovered that there was a similar project here recently while I was searching for informattion on the Terrorgheist. Didn't even know about this site, as I had put WHFB on hold for many years. I've done to much work on it not to finish it, even though it is obvious that I'm not the only one wishing for the Legions of Nagash to make an appearance (about time I think). :twisted:

** The Necromantic Nexus works much in the same way as the Vampire rule in the VC book, as well in the same way as the Magical Resistance Special rule, except that it just works vs. wounds from unstable (i.e. Necromatic Nexus (2) means a 5+ save vs. Wounds caused from unstable). Yes I do know that according to the rulebook, one cannot save vs. Unstable wounds, but I have chosen to ignore this to help make an army conscept that differs from the VC and Tomb Kings in more ways than just new units and spells.

Anyway, about Krell:

I have done my best to make him as he is portrayed in the latest Sigmar Triology Book (and Zombieslayer), while at the same time trying to balance him, by give him certain weaknesses etc.

Stats: gave him a slightly increased WS (Chaos Lord of Khorne after all), Strenght (always portrayed as a huge monster of a man (as a former chaos lord aougth to be, and I don't see him being weaker as an undead that never tires), as well as one more Wound (went with a wound instead of toughness, as T 6 should be reserved for Monsters etc, and the Massive Monstrosity consept from the old Strigoi bloodlines seemd a bit more accurate). Lastly, one point more of LD, to represent him being more than just a off the shelves Wight King, and a Dark Lord of Nagash.

Slaughtermaster: I wanted him to be the kind of character that could absolutly massacre lesser troops with his axe (with some lucky dice rolls that is), just as he is described in the lastes Sigmar Book; while at the same time I saw the obvious need for some limitations as well. Challenging him is one way to stop him, as this ability only lets him strike in normal initiative order (4) in a challenge. I quite like the idea of a hero stepping forth to protect his fellow soldiers from this walking beast of a corpse. I didn't want to add any ability that gave his D3 Wounds axe even more of a benefit, thus I chose to not give him Frenzy.

Regarding his armour: I wanted it to come across that he was a former champion of Khorne, and thus being quite resisant to magic and magic weapons. I also thought that if Alaric the Mad didn't have the tools to deal with him, this would fit nicely as well. The re-roll all to wound rolls of 5+ was to make him slightly tougher against most "low level" strength attacks, while still leaving him more vulnerable to S5 attacks or more (as they can wound on 4+; S6 3+ etc). This would also make him vulnerable to cannons and the like, as he was in the book. The same goes for the armour save.

He shouldn't be impossible to handle for a decent hero/lord if kitted out properly, but he could potentially be horrific against lesser troops.

As a last thought, I know the model is on foot, but I imagine him being able to select a mount if he so wishes (as in Zombie Slayer), for the appropriate point cost offcourse...
 
Seems pretty good to me. I assume that the "Duo of Destruction" (sound like evil batman and robin) and "Doomed Legion" special rules detail his relationship with Kemmler and his khornate undead soldiers respectively. He does seem to have been slightly underpowered on his profile compared to his beasty special rules. OK, so it's just the fact that his WS 5 and 3 attacks seem a bit low, especially considering he's a lord choice. But still, he could probably wipe out an entire core choice unit on his own.
 
Narp said:
Seems pretty good to me. I assume that the "Duo of Destruction" (sound like evil batman and robin) and "Doomed Legion" special rules detail his relationship with Kemmler and his khornate undead soldiers respectively. He does seem to have been slightly underpowered on his profile compared to his beasty special rules. OK, so it's just the fact that his WS 5 and 3 attacks seem a bit low, especially considering he's a lord choice. But still, he could probably wipe out an entire core choice unit on his own.

The "Duo of Destruction" rule is to tie him to Kemmler yes. I also want to be able to field Krell in a Legions of Nagashizzar List without Kemmler, but then he would be prised normally.

The Doomed Legions was based on the idea that he had his own unit to lead, which at least acted as his own unit of khorne followers from huis days before Sigmar. He fought as a mortal long before Sigmar's time, so we are not talking about the actual same warriors, but rather that he has a measure of control over them, as long as they fight in the manner of his ancient tribal warriors (hand weapons and shields).

It was quite intentional to give him WS 5 and A 3 yes. The reasoning behind being:

-A Normal Wight King has Ws 4
-I wanted him to be far better against rank and file units than heroes
-With the armour "upgrade" (he used to have 4+ armour, 4+ ward if I am not mistaking, as well as +1W, he will be harder to slay in challenges, so he may potentially get to strike back much more often than previously(assuming his opponent is faster than him in the first place). The old Krell has S4, T 4 also btw.. As well as WS 4. Not really impressive...
-Krell striking back with 3 S7 attacks that causes d3 wounds (pluss further wounds with no saves) seemed enogu to me. He can potentially deal with any character that doesn't kill him quickly. Undead can also be healed, so this is not as easy as it may look).
-I really wanted him to be a monster against troops, the way he is portrayed in the latest Sigmar Triology book. He is not portrayed as someone of great finesse at all, but rather a butcher of men (with no equal that I can remember reading about in any warhammer novel, including Gotrek).
-To save one's troops, one has to be willing to risk one of ones heroes against him, and I quite like this idea. He is somewhat vulnerable to heroes, but most og all to pure high strength attacks.
-Giving him 4 attacks would be a bit much I thought, as he would be too powerful ws characters, especially Low I ones. He would also become too much of a monster ws rank and file troops, with an average of 2 bolt thrower hits each close combat phase. I'd rather step a bit carefully and have him tested with the special rules, before upgrading him if needed, although I don't think it will be neccessary.

As a final though, I'd like to see him take 1 Wound less of damage from Unstability if he is on a loosing side in combat (commulative with battle standard) in a VC army.

I have started on Kemmler, but there are many things to consider. All "Vampires" are out of that list, so there is a bit of wok to do.

Thanks for your feedback. Much appreciated. :thumbsup:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu