WHFB - 7th Lance question

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Jan 5, 2010
2
Zombies
2
Ok at my store gaming area thing we've had a debate going for.a couple weeks their side is that you can only use a lance on the charge, for the strength I understand but for magic lances you would still get the benefit right? Like the dreadlance if you get charged you still auto hit just no strength bonus
 
Yes, you are right. Once you've decided which weapon to use in the first round of combat you're stuck with it until you enter a new scrap. It's the same with flails, they give you a strength bonus on the first round of combat but you'll still be stuck with their two-handedness for the duration of the fight. Neither flails nor lances say anything about being used in the first round only, therefore, you'll get to benefit from the lance's effect even when not charging and in consecutive turns.
 
Ok thanks

Ok I have another question I just didn't want to start another thread but the wristbands of gold state they give the bearer a 3+ ward against any ranged attack. What is classified as a "ranged attack" we've also had a debate over this they say if it doesn't have a range it doesn't work like master of stone or forked lighting
 
A ranged attack is anything outside of a close combat attack. So yes you would be protected from stone throwers, forked lightning and any other attack that is not a close combat attack.
 
Some oddball attacks:
Fanatics- not ranged
Screamers slash attack- not ranged
Terradons drop rocks - ranged (As per FAQ)

But basically any spell that is cast from a distance, ranged, definitely. Except maybe Bladewind, that's another oddball, maybe Kalandros has a better idea on that cos I dunno!
 
Bladewind and Hydra's Teeth are close combat attacks, done by a ranged weapon, but definitely should be treated as close combat attacks from no clear direction (thus no Parry bonus since its not an attack by an enemy to the front) as they are still distributed 'as shooting' but are not shooting.

That's how I see it anyway.
 
I agree with Kalandros' point of view here. Both the Bladewind spell and the Hydra's Teeth item classifies the effects as close combat attacks, which are worked out in base to base contact.
 
I know this is kinda threadromancy, but this is the earliest post of this kind that I could find, and I didn't want to make another post about it.

I had this debate with a guy too at a tournament yesterday, he said you didn't get to use it and I let it slide cause it wouldn't actually change anything.

But he's a REAL rule stickler and always scoffs at 'well I saw it on a forum'. I'm wondering if there's any FAQ or Official anything from GW that proves this? I mean, it's pretty clear to me: not only does it never say that lances cannot be used in subsequent rounds in the Lances rules, but also in the magical weapons rules it distinctly says that a character is now allowed to us ANY close combat weapon than his magical one. But if there's an official statement, that would be nice next time this situation arises.
 
Its simple, Magic Weapons MUST be used if you have one.

If you have a Magic Lance and you charged, you can use it.
If you did not charge, you have to use it, but you do not get its "on the charge" bonus.

High Elves' Star Lance is +3S and ignore armor save on the charge (both bonuses)
VC Dreadlance is "Autohit" whether charging or not.

And of course Bretonnians have special army rules that state, on the charge, they must use a lance even if they have a non-lance magic weapon.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu