Legions of Chaos Troll Horde Deathstar: let's break it

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Macarian

Vampire Insomniac
Jan 19, 2014
153
Netherlands
Zombies
182
So, in my past few games using the End Times ruleset (including the new magic) at 2,500 points I have been coming across a gnarly Death Star from the new Legions of Chaos army list:

Throgg
Doombull, Warrior Bane Blackened Plate, Chalice of Dark Rain, Crown of Command, Shield
8 Chaos Trolls, Additional Hand Weapons

This unit is Stubborn on Ld 8, comes from his Core allowance, always has a 4+ save (regen against normal attacks, Ward against Flaming Attacks), can get a one-of -1 to hit or 4+ to hit against shooting (relevant against Screaming Skull Catapults) brings a boat-load of S5 attacks and can use vomit attacks against anything well armoured and last but not least is Immune to Psychology.

The rest of his list is a lvl 4 Nurgle Sorcerer Lord (so the regen sometimes gets boosted to 3+) in a Halberd Warrior bunker with a Wargor BSB with Beast Banner (+1 Strength), 2 Skullcannons, a Chimera with regen, 3 Skullcrushers and 2 units of 2 Beasts of Nurgle.

I have dealt with it successfully by redirecting and feeding it summoned units ad inifitum since literally nothing in my current list* can take it down.

Which brings me to my question here: what can we do to destroy this unit? I am very curious how you guys would attack this army with your lists.

*My current list:
Mannfred, Mortarch of Night
2x 30 Skeleton Archers, Full Command
3x 5 Skeleton Horse Archers
4 Morghast Harbringers
2x 2 Morghast Harbringers
2x Mortis Engine
Casket of Souls
 
Last edited:
No magical attacks? I can't recall if Throgg has some kind of mystical magical puke or not? If he doesn't and the DB is only use a handweapon then...This looks like a job for Spirit Host! (cue music)
Keep the beasts of nurgle away and just heal the host every couple combats.
 
You could try combo charging a killy unit with a unit of chariots that have the flaming banner. If one impact hit goes through he loses regen then your vamp lord can deal a ton of damage.
 
Gadzooks! I read it all too quickly.

(Sits in corner)

Honestly, I would just feed it a zombie brick and keep it replenished during the game. Db's can be risky opponents for vampire lords and it's far better to have your general kill rank and file.

I would strongly consider using a standard VL instead of a Mortarch to save some points for more support units.
 
You could try combo charging a killy unit with a unit of chariots that have the flaming banner. If one impact hit goes through he loses regen then your vamp lord can deal a ton of damage.

I am pretty sure impact hits do not benefit from any special rules, which means no flaming attacks on impact hits, sorry.
 
I am pretty sure impact hits do not benefit from any special rules, which means no flaming attacks on impact hits, sorry.

There is no rule to support this. Impact hits, stomps and thunderstomps do not benefit from a weapons abilities but if something applies to a models attacks in general like flaming banner or red fury it works.
 
I've taken on the throgg troll horde deathstar of puke during the pre-end times era and had a lot of success, but I don't know if this will still work as I have yet to play a chaos opponent in end times....

A Block of 50+ Skeletons with spears, flaming banner, Blender lord and 2 Lvl 2 shadow Vamps eats a throgg troll deathstar alive. With 4 levels in shadow you have a very very good chance of rolling mindrazor and a potential 40 strength 10 flaming attacks(If fielded in horde formation, which I usually don't do, but the potential is there) will cut through those trolls like cheap imitation butter. Even if you don't roll mindrazor, or cant get it cast for some reason, 1 Blender lord and 2 support vamps(who still have red fury) put a ton of attacks through and will still get the benefit of flaming to negate the regen and start chewing through the unit.

Like I said, I don't know how this holds up in the end times era, or with the doombull(which I've never fought). If you use this strategy, you could always have the unit champion lock the doombull into a challenge, freeing up the vamps to go after throgg and his trolls.

Downside is your using a deathstar (and yes the above mentioned skeleton unit is north of 1K points) to kill a deathstar which is never the best way to go. Too inefficient. Great tactic for the shock value though. It is really fun to see your opponents jaw hit the floor when your lowly skeletons delete his precious troll horde from the table.
 
That chaos list is almost word for word the best list I could think of while looking at the chaos legions. Nasty nasty stuff.

If you got him I'd say take nagash, just because "fu*k you and your crazy list". On a more serious note I'd try LD shenanigans with death magic.

Regarding holding him up with units.. Are you guys playing with the new magic phase? Has anyone tried to invocation spam zombies yet? I guess the new magic phase helps out spirit leech as well.
 
You could try combo charging a killy unit with a unit of chariots that have the flaming banner. If one impact hit goes through he loses regen then your vamp lord can deal a ton of damage.

I like this alot, not sure how effective this would be but maybe a Blender Vamp on a Coven Throne with a magic weapon amongst the Skeleton Chariots could do it.

Regarding holding him up with units.. Are you guys playing with the new magic phase? Has anyone tried to invocation spam zombies yet? I guess the new magic phase helps out spirit leech as well.

Get Death magic and snipe Throgg and the Doombull off the board, then sit back and watch as the trolls slip in their own drool.

We do play with the new magic phase, which has been lovely making sure Mannfred and the Morghasts stay topped off against the double Skullcannon (Invocation of Nehek spam woohoo!) and Deathsniping is made all the better because of it. Sniping Trogg is unfortunately not so important since the Doombull also provides Ld 8, Deathsniping the Doombull and then attacking the unit with flaming attacks is a good way to deal with the unit though so good call :)

That chaos list is almost word for word the best list I could think of while looking at the chaos legions. Nasty nasty stuff.

The list is indeed tough as nails, it's also really simplistic and requires little skill to play (it's basically point and click) however a good general can certainly beat it. I've taken my list against it and come out on top after dancing around and flying over his Troll Horde for 6 turns. Crucial here were the Morghasts as they strike a happy medium between Vargheists and Crypt Horrors in terms of sturdiness and manouevrability. Also, we better embrace End Times magic because we need the Invocation of Nehek and movement spells spam to function against lists like this.

The sad conclusion is though that these games aren't really fun. The first two turns are tense (and random) dice-rolling to see how much damage the Skullcannons do and how much can be healed back and the rest of the game revolves around running for the Doom Hordes of Trolls and Warriors by flying over them, turning around with a movement spell (brute-forcing an augmented Van Hels'), the Horde turns around, rinse-repeat. Winning against this list reminds me of playing against Banner of the World Dragon lists where victory was determined not by killing the enemy but by staying alive, which led to weird wins where three or four units in totall had died over the course of six turns.
 
Coven Throne with Doom and Darkness!!

Just win combat by... anything, and they test on Ld 5 (maybe 4 if there is an Aura of Dark Majesty nearby, 3 if you also cast Iceshard Blizzard with lore of Heavens) and they go poof.

EDIT: Also, mentioning new magic phase... go Iceshard Blizzard all the way!

cumulative -1 to Hit will make the unit just fail. Cumulative -1 to Ld means they will break + flee, no matter how stubborn they may be.
 
Are you using the new magic phase? Then Purple sun that unit into oblivion: the trolls are I1 and Throgg I2. Easy ;)
 
I may be missing something since I'm not overly familiar with each of the Chaos army books or ET: Glottkin, but even with Throgg making trolls a core choice, that's not enough points from core at 2500. Just built this list in BattleScribe and it only comes to 519/625, using both najo's catalogue and an alternative with same result, so unless there's a pricing mistake in both catalogues, the list either doesn't have enough core, or is over the point limit. Seems like the list is using 20% core instead of 25%. Am I missing something?
 
Flaming chariots + two blender lords (OTS and nightshroud between the two) + vargheists + dogs/spirit hosts + skeleton warriors.

Feed the unit some chaff so that the doombull revs up, making the unit frenzied. Now you can feed it more chaff and force it to overrun into position.

So when charging in the goal is to mitigate the doombull / throgg. You can tag them with throgg/spirit hosts to prevent them from making way, protecting your vampires/vargs and limiting CR. Nightshroud will take the tooth out of Throgg, but you also want a vampire killing the Doombull to knock off stubborn. Finally the chariots and skeletons crash into wherever they can take the least amount of return damage (skeletons probably in the flank, where their 3 ranks, flank, negated ranks, and banner will largely offset whatever damage they'll take from attacks).

So first up is impact hits. Chariots deal 3d6 hits that wound on 4s (S4 vs T4), and he gets a 4++ against them. So 10.5 average hits, 5.25 average wounds, 2.125 average unsaved. Flaming, so no more regen.

Now the vampires go. Try to kill the Doombull to get rid of stubborn, or just lay wounds into the unit. Since their attacks aren't flaming, and regen is gone, the unit gets no saves. So hitting on 3s with a reroll wounding on 2s no saves. You should do ~14 wounds, of which 5 will be killing the Doombull.

Next up is vargheists (assuming the doombull is dead). I run 4 at 2x2 with champ, which is 16 attacks. Average another 7 wounds.

If your bus is BK they go next (as do the dogs), whereas if it's horsemen they go at the same time as Throgg and the chariots. He's got 5 attacks hitting on 3s wounding on 2s, while you've got 18 attacks from the chariots (12 at S4 6 at S3), however many from the bus, and however many from the spirit hosts/etc.

Trolls don't go until I1, by which time they'll have lost a very significant portion of their number. Beat them in combat by a whack, break steadfast with the skeletons, and pursue with everything.

Now what about the rest of his list, you'll say? Well...they're already dealt with. You can feed the trollstar chaff all day while you pick apart the rest of his army, then go in for the kill and smash them with everything. His army is...what...three big threats and a bunch of little things?
 
So, in my past few games using the End Times ruleset (including the new magic) at 2,500 points I have been coming across a gnarly Death Star from the new Legions of Chaos army list:

Throgg
Doombull, Warrior Bane Blackened Plate, Chalice of Dark Rain, Crown of Command, Shield
8 Chaos Trolls, Additional Hand Weapons

This unit is Stubborn on Ld 8, comes from his Core allowance, always has a 4+ save (regen against normal attacks, Ward against Flaming Attacks), can get a one-of -1 to hit or 4+ to hit against shooting (relevant against Screaming Skull Catapults) brings a boat-load of S5 attacks and can use vomit attacks against anything well armoured and last but not least is Immune to Psychology.

The rest of his list is a lvl 4 Nurgle Sorcerer Lord (so the regen sometimes gets boosted to 3+) in a Halberd Warrior bunker with a Wargor BSB with Beast Banner (+1 Strength), 2 Skullcannons, a Chimera with regen, 3 Skullcrushers and 2 units of 2 Beasts of Nurgle.

I have dealt with it successfully by redirecting and feeding it summoned units ad inifitum since literally nothing in my current list* can take it down.

Which brings me to my question here: what can we do to destroy this unit? I am very curious how you guys would attack this army with your lists.

*My current list:
Mannfred, Mortarch of Night
2x 30 Skeleton Archers, Full Command
3x 5 Skeleton Horse Archers
4 Morghast Harbringers
2x 2 Morghast Harbringers
2x Mortis Engine
Casket of Souls

Well,

Death Magic takes trolls off the table awful quick. Also a big block of skele's with okhams can really bring hurt to him while being relatively expendable to you. They are just skeletons after all. I am surprised no one brought up blood knights. Blood Knights make everyone very aware of their flanks. And elite armies like elves and chaos don't usually have a lot of chaff to get in your way. Another idea is 40 GG with a lore nehekhara caster. 5+ ward and righteous smiting to give them extra attacks and if you really wanted you could have a defensive caster vampire, give him the re-roll winds of magic vamp power, armor of silvered steel and tali of pres, or just a ward save and give him the rod of damnation for another +1 attack. If you got off the rod and righteous smiting, your str 6 GG would get 30 attacks from the front rank alone in horde, then another 20 from the back two ranks. Leaving you a potential of 50 str 6 killing blow, and if you have BoTB +1 to hit to boot.
 
Blood Knights die to troll vomit. I can imagine the Str 6 DB would also make way to fight them if they were on the flank.
 
Blood Knights die to troll vomit. I can imagine the Str 6 DB would also make way to fight them if they were on the flank.
Yes, they do die to troll vomit. But to put them into the flank of a troll deathstar means the DB can't make way because he'd already be in combat. Then you have an awful lot of high str, high ws attacks pouring into that troll unit. The best counter for this unit is magic, but I was just pointing out that it's not like the undead armies have nothing for those chaos trolls to think twice about. DB's are scary, but not as scary as VL's.
 
Any veteran chaos player will see the knights coming and plan accordingly, placing him on the flank a turn before combat ensues with anything.
The fact that the OP says trolls are core in that list leads me to believe that Throgg is also present and therefore able to contribute as well.
 
Is there a way to snipe the characters? Sacrifice something hitty in the front and kill off the character(s). Then you could just scream them off. I'm a bit rusty, but trolls have what, ld 5?
 
Random question - what is the standard base size for Throgg and the Doombull? I saw Throgg plus some trolls last night, and Throgg's base was slightly larger than the trolls. This is awkward because I guess it means if he is attached to the unit, he just sits on the outer edge...
 
End Times Magic works great against Regen - as long as you have at least one fire spell to break Regen then you can cast anything else and it cant be saved. Unfortunately a Doombull puts a stop to this. Luckily the unit is dependent on the Doombull which isn't that hard to take down.

Spirit Leech is likely first choice, and you can just spam it over an over until that Doombull comes down. Then the unit is easy to take down with a fire spell, hammer unit with flame banner, hexwraiths etc.

Alternatively you can beat down on the doombull with a blender lord and if you're lucky you can make them break. Doom & Darkness helps but this would typically be on the general making them take stupidity on 8ld. D&D will help with snipes, stupidity and break tests so its a great spell. In the end times you can even cast it multiple times.

Of course you can just cast purple sun but that spell is cheese and the end times magic makes that difficult. Although when somone casts spirit leech on you 5 times in on turn, it doesn't feel any less cheesy.

My best advice is to just remember to bring a fire spell. At some point you'll be able to use it to obliterate regen. If you get a lot of dice you can squeeze one fire wound on the trollbus, then they won't have any saves versus every other spell you cast at them for that phase.

EDIT: Take a unit of BK with lances & flaming banner and a blender lord with QB+RF, Ogre blade, OTS, 4++.

He has to challenge with Throgg, have your unit champion accept, absorbing throggs hits and possible puking.

Your VL can then erase the Doombull with ease - his magical OB negates flaming and thus the bull has no saves. I can't imagine a scenario in which you don't obliterate the bull.

Next up comes your BK. should be 8 Str6 flaming attacks on the charge. Combined with VDM you are going to take a sizable chunk out of the trolls.

Next at I2 you got your flaming steeds, to do some more hurt on the trolls.

The trolls will probably make some puking attacks now which is scary for your lord, but 5T and 4++ will likely get you through. Then Throgg will kill your unit champ and get to roll on the chaos table.

Since you are mounted there are no stomps and its time to tally up.

The trolls might break, given you charged and have a banner and likely more ranks. If not, another round of beat down with your lord forcing Regen re-rolls with OTS should do the trick. If you really want to make sure victory is assured throw in a vampire with RF and armor of destiny and you wont lose.

Afterward, Nehek back your wounds and watch your opponent cringe.
 
Last edited:
Wery cheesy combo. Doombull personally have 2++ against flaming attack, and also gives 4++ on entire unit against flaming attacks(Blackended Plate). Trolls and Throgg have regen and horde of attacks - so it should be natural target to flaming attacks. Unfortunately, Doombull will negate most of them. Also - whole unit have frenzy(+1A) and have to test to restrain from charge, and pursue and overrun only D6, so it slightly negates another downside of the frenzy - auto pursuits/overruns.
It also gives whole unit Stubborn....he need to die.

Fortunately - we can kill that big bull and mop up the rest.
This in fact can be countered with quite standard army, provided that VC army have 10+ unit of hexies with champion(important) and some mobile blender with ogre blade. QB+RF with ogre blade - very common build.

Simple recipe.
Charge frontally to be in base contact with DB and preferably only with him. Charge hexies into flank(important, but should be doable cause they have frenzy and can be redirected properly). Do not throw challenge with vamp.(important - if you have Dreadknight on VL, it will be unsuitable in this combo)Throgg must issue the challenge, and it should be accepted by our hexie champion. No CR here, cause Throgg is unable to do any harm to etheral. Hexie champion will not kill Throgg, so our blender will be save from his enormous puke.
Kill doombull with blender - attacks will be resolved at ASF priority. 5W without save is not demanding (Doombull save will be nagated by S7 from ogreblade - with red fury VL should inflict about 6-7W on average=dead doombull). If Doombull will not die(bad rolling) - he have 6 attacks(frenzy) but only on S5. Mobile blender will probably be on barded nightmare or winged nightmare and should have decent save or ward. Also VL can have beguile I`m not suggesting any specific build here - but VL will probably not be killed either. Trolls will be able to attack VL - if VL will be positioned well, max 7 attacks at S5 (hit on 5+) or 2 pukes(only 4 or one puke if enemy formation is 5models wide) Risk that we must accept. Hexies will follow with their attacks, probably inflicting some W - without regen and wards on trolls. Lack of Stubborn, naked CR should do the rest.

Interestingly - thouse hexies and that blender can kill that halberd armed bunker in similar way - since they also dont have magical attacks. Rest of VC army should deal or redirect the rest of the support - as deathstar based armies tend to have one eggs in one basket, their support is quite fragile, and without it, they will be unable to bring thouse deathstars into favourable combats.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu