Magic Question

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Mr_Marx02

Zombie
Nov 2, 2011
3
Zombies
3
Hey all,

I haven't seen a specific answer to these questions, and they've come up often in play the last week or so.

Does the 'forward arc' rule apply when casting Vanhel's and Invocation?

Thanks
 
Thanks for the response.

Are you basing that off the wording from the warhammer rulebook that older books use their rules for spells?

If that's the case, then can one cast Infernal Gateway sans the restrictions as well?

Thanks again.
 
Nope. The restrictions list on pg 31 of the BRB need to be used (Under the heading CHOOSE A TARGET)! So, it can't target a unit in combat (for example)

The reason that the VC spells that you listed don't have to is because they are specific in stating 'any undead friendly unit within X" '.
 
What in the book/erata/faq are you using to support your answer? Please understand I'm not trying to argue the point at all, I'd just like some demonstrable evidence that I can show other people.

My reading of the rules is that the necromancy spells from the VC book fall into the "older books" exception. With a fairly plain text reading, this means that I would be able to cast both IoN and Vanhel's absent forward arc, within the given ranges, and into combat. Is this interpretation correct?

I'm very new to Warhammer and am play testing in preparation of upcoming GT's so I'm just trying to get some consistency because my playtest group can't seem to come to a conclusion.

Thanks alot!
 
Sorry. I'm on my mobile right now. The VC FAQ does cover the necromancy spells.

There's a link to our forum FAQ in my sig. And a link to GW FAQ in ours.
 
Infernal gateway would count as direct damage spell as it inflicts wounds on the target unit. Direct damage spells need forward arc as in the BRB. I think thats right?!:rolleyes:
 
If infernal gateway doesn't use the words "direct damage spell" in its text then it doesn't use the direct damage spell rules. You could use similar logic to say van hal's is an augment and therefore follows augment spell rules, but it doesn't.

Essentially, spells that pre-date the 8th Ed rulebook are un-typed. You just follow the text of the spell directly.
 
Dan_Lee said:
If infernal gateway doesn't use the words "direct damage spell" in its text then it doesn't use the direct damage spell rules. You could use similar logic to say van hal's is an augment and therefore follows augment spell rules, but it doesn't.

Essentially, spells that pre-date the 8th Ed rulebook are un-typed. You just follow the text of the spell directly.

Correct. Spells which are from army books which are per-8th edition use the rules from their respective army books.

However, spells must still abide by the general casting restrictions listed on pg 31 of the BRB.

example: Infernal Gateway is not listed in the army book as being able to cast into cambat, so it can not be cast into combat because the general rules forbid it.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu