Mannfred's magic sword

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Ogul

Ghoul
Nov 30, 2011
175
Zombies
122
Hey!

About Mannfred magic sword, does it generate power/dispel dice only to him, or to the army pool?
 
No they are right in this case. its only for Mannfred.

The rule reads:

Sword of Unholy Power:

Magic Weapon: For Each Unsaved wound caused by the sword Mannfred gains an extra dice at the start of the ensuing magic phase (this will be power dice in his own magic phase, and a dispel dice in the enemy's magic phase).


As it says by name that he gains an extra dice, not the army power pool.
 
No it says he gains you a extra dice. Read power of Darkness, in which it states the caster gains dice that may only be used by them. No were in Mannys entry does it talk about him being the only one to use it. It is the exact same wording as channeling. On a roll of a 6 the wizard generates a extra dice. Never says the wizard has to use it.
 
Page 30 Paragraph 3 BRB
"Roll a D6 for each wizard in the army, on a roll of a 6 the wizard has been able to siphon blah blah blah"

Please note the underlined section. This is the exact same wording as Manfreds sword and unless all of a sudden wizards only get the dice they channel and dont share I am afraid Manfreds sword just adds to your power pool.
 
It says he gains it, if it reads a character gains something it does not mean it gets passed about.
Certain characters in game have rule which say they gain this effect or that bonus, does not mean the army gains it.

7th Edition Vampire Counts book.
Page 61 on Mannfreds Profile.

Sword of Unholy Power:

For Each Unsaved wound caused by the sword Mannfred gains an extra dice in the following magic phase.
This will be a power dice in his own magic phase, or an additional dispel dice in the enemy's.


8th Edition Vampire Counts book.
Page 56 on Mannfreds Profile.

Sword of Unholy Power:

For Each Unsaved wound caused by the sword Mannfred gains an extra dice at the start of the ensuing magic phase (this will be power dice in his own magic phase, and a dispel dice in the enemy's magic phase).




Both have been copied word for word.

The only difference is in the new on is says "Ensuing" instead of "Following" and they have added brackets.
It still reads as "Mannfred Gains", in our 7th only he would gain the dice and the rule has not changed at all, it is almost the exact same and clearly states himself and not the army.
 
Johnny-Crass said:
Page 30 Paragraph 3 BRB
"Roll a D6 for each wizard in the army, on a roll of a 6 the wizard has been able to siphon blah blah blah"

Please note the underlined section. This is the exact same wording as Manfreds sword and unless all of a sudden wizards only get the dice they channel and dont share I am afraid Manfreds sword just adds to your power pool.



It is not the same as the sword as it clearly states in the rule for channeling power dice that any channeled dice is added to the power pool, no such rule or mention is made on that of the Sword of Unholy Power.
 
Yes they do, on page 30 of the BRB it states that under the rule for power limit that you can never have more than 12 dice in you're pool.

It goes on to states this is Regardless of the source and includes dice gained through winds of magic, channelling, from magic items, special abilities and so on.

As the Sword is a Magic item it would be included, its a fairly all encompassing rule.
 
This is not correct though. No where in the entry of the sword does it say only he may use them. Unlike power of darkness, jagged dagger ect Manfreds sword does not have that clause.
 
It reads that he gains the power dice per unsaved wound.
Not the army but Mannfred gains.

It has named him, it does not say another dice is added to the pool, only that he gains a dice.



The rules you pointed out for channelling say all channeled dice are added to the dice pool so any may use them, the sword does not work like channelling and the rules are not applicable to each other.




It has stated it in the most straight forwards way, it does not say that he can't use the dice to then make a jonty magic hat either.
The point is you will not get a clause covering every possible outcome, most rules like this are normally straight forwards, some are obvious, some create confusion so we end up with erratas.

If the dice was to be added to the dice pool it would say that an additional dice was added to the pool, it however says nothing of the sort and his personal magic item only benefits him.
 
It does need to have a clause though because other items like it DO HAVE the clause stating that only the user may use the dice. They state it in the entry. And once again NO WHERE in Manfreds entry does it say he must be the one to use the dice.
 
"Magic Weapon. for each unsaved Wound caused by the sword, Mannfred gains an extra dice at the start of the ensuing Magic phase (this will be a power dice in his own Magic phase, and a dispel dice in the enemy's Magic phase)."


"this will be a power dice in his own Magic phase", I'm guessing it would add to the power pool, since he doesn't have a magic phase only for himself?
 
It says Mannfred Gains a Dice, not the army, not the power pool but Mannfred.
It only belongs to him, no on else, no one else has access to his sword, it is personal use, not a army buff.


Ogul said:
"Magic Weapon. for each unsaved Wound caused by the sword, Mannfred gains an extra dice at the start of the ensuing Magic phase (this will be a power dice in his own Magic phase, and a dispel dice in the enemy's Magic phase)."


"this will be a power dice in his own Magic phase", I'm guessing it would add to the power pool, since he doesn't have a magic phase only for himself?


He gains a dice at the start of the magic phase or dispel depending on which is next.
For instance its you're foes turn, he causes 2 wounds so when it comes to you're turn and you go into the magic phase he would have access to another 2 dice for himself personally much like the old Master of the Black Arts used to work in our 7th edition army book.






In our old book Johnny only he could use the dice he gained by causing wounds.
The rule has remained the same since then, this was the way the rule worked when we had our 7th edition book with the 7th edition rules and it continued to work this way even after the 8th edition rule book came out.
our 8th edition army book has the rule almost word for word and there is not mention of the dice being added to the dice pool in the rule, our army book or the BRB but in the rule it says HE gains power dice, not the army, not the guy next to him and not his BFF but Mannfred.
Tell me how can you say that dice generated in this way be used by the army when the item is only usable by himself?

Personally I think you just want the rule to work this way and are trying to find any loophole to justify it at this point.
Perhaps a fresh perspective on it from other forum members on this would be useful.
 
Can you say 'FAQ'?

I think I'm going to side with The Duke here. It does say he gains a dice next turn, not the power pool.

Sure Johnny, it states in other items and powers when only you can have them, but in channeling it also specifically states they go to the pool. This doesn't state either so...they don't go anywhere. They stay with the guy that generated them, Mr M.von Carstein
 
Revisiting this. If the ruling is that the dice from the sword are not added to the pool, why do they count against the pool limit? Because the pool dice are for the army to use and his dice are not for the army. Ruling they cannot be used by other wizards leads to more contradictions that need to be addressed. Having them as pool dice leads to none. And if only Mannfred can use them, does that mean he must be the one to use the dispel dice as well? What about the Black Periapt, can Mannfred's dice be saved in that item?

Additionally, if they are just Mannfreds, why not just use them to cast spells from him before using any from the pool of dice, much like one would use a Power stone. Example: Mannfred casts raise dead and uses only dice generated by the sword. Once he uses all his dice, then he or the rest of the army can tap into the pool dice. Since the Power stone dice are not added to the pool, but simply used when the user pops the item's ability it seems very similar.

What happens if Mannfred miscasts when using "his" dice, are any lost dice removed from "his" private pool or are they removed from the army pool or both?

It seems to me that all of these issues are avoided if the dice are part of the pool and thus limited to the 12 dice at any time limit at the start of the turn and excess are wasted/lost.
 
If you play it like only Manfred can use the dice then:
- I would say only Manfred would be able to use the dispels
- No, Manfred does not have a Black Periapt and the going out assumption was that only he can use the dice.
- Of course Manfred can use his own dice first.
- His personal dice are still in the pool. (but you might use a different color dice)

On another note, I agree with the view that Manfreds dice are not personal, but just added to the pool for the following reason:
Personal power/dispel dice are not covered in the core rules, so any instance where personal power dice are handled, it must be spelled out how it works, otherwise it should be assumed that dice are added to the pool like with channeling. Furthermore it seems GW in 8th ed has moved away from the entire concept of personal power dice, at least within the core rules and then army books I am familiar with.

Also, you may get a few frowns for brining back such an old thread :P
 
Thanks Smogg! I hope I don't get any frowns!

I'm new to Fantasy and Vampires and the gaming group in my town is primarily new as well. Those that have played before are mainly previous edition players and don't have any solid answers.

I have looked for answers in older threads because that gets fewer frowns than asking a question again that has been asked many times before.

I'm gonna talk to our local shop owner (he's well respected and tries to make decisions in the spirit of the rule when he can) and I think he will agree that they go into the pool.

I'm curious if anyone has played in major tournaments where this issue has come up and, if so, what were the tourney official's rulings?
 
Oh Jeesh this again.

If Manny is my army being a bad ass lvl 4 LOREMASTER on Death AND Vamps... Then isn't all a moot point bc you'll be slinging all your spells from him anyway??

Just use the Manny-generated dice first by him, and if he breaks concentration then who cares the dice are the used anyway. Also, and let's face it, if Manny would break concentration then the magic phase is over bc your backup lvl 1 isn't gonna do much if anything.

Though if i had to choose between the debate, I'd side with Dukey Von MacCrassbre :)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu