Roys: I started my whole
VC army using the Mantic army starter kit. Paid $80 and it's a lot of models! 110 to be exact, I stretched my zombies to make 120 models total.
Here's my break down on all the guys:
Zombies- wayyyyyy better than GW. Hands down in my opinion.
Skeletons- less bulky, and I am a fan of GW's wind-blowing theme. However, Mantic skeletons are much more uniform, if that's what you like, GW are more dispersed and do not all match in terms of armor. Depends on what you like.
Ghouls- I prefer mantic only because GW ghouls are too mutated for me. Mantic are more like actual people who look very blood thirsty and have cool weapon options as well. And some clothes too- helps if you want a more uniformed theme.
Grave Guard- Mantic Revenants seem a LOT less bulky than GW GG. I actually really like the GW models a lot. Mantic revenants do have a cool knightly look to them though, with feathers and more ornate armor.
Comparing both manufacturers I say GW has bulkier models with bigger weapons. Mantic has more realistic sized weapons. Especially if you get mantic cavalry, they will look a lot skinnier than GW or other cavalry- I guess that's in the price, since they are roughly 1/2 the price or less...Manitc will give you a great overall uniform look. To me- mantic is an undead army, GW is an undead congregation lol. But they both have great models. I think Mantic will save you money, no competition. GW does kind of have cooler models I think (for some of their models).
Now I guess I eluded your actual question; can mantic revenants have GWs? Well yes and no. You can manage to cut off their shields, but both their shield and shield-arm are grafted to their bodies, so it is unlikely you can get it all off neatly and put on GG arms holding GWs. As a matter of fact, there isn't really an arm under all the shields. Now if you take the time to cut off their shields, it does kind of look like extra armor- like a beefed up gauntlet and pauldron- without the full shield look. You can even shave their shields down a little more until it just looks like an arm (skilled modeler option only) but it is still stuck to their body.
What I did was a happy medium. I kept their shields intact (except for my champ) and made scratch built GWs out of spears and axe, hammer and mace heads (from my chaos kits). They have little open hand slots, so I just stuck the spears from their kits in upside down, and then glued on the weapon heads from warhammers, maces and axes. These weapon heads came from my old Chaos warriors, so they were very bulky indeed! And viola- great weapons
