Master Necromancer in Black Knigths

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Jan 17, 2012
43
London-ish
Zombies
46
Was wondering what everyone thought of the idea of placing a Master Necromancer on Barded Nightmare in a unit of Barded Black Knights?

The main Con is that they will of course lose their Spectral Steed rule, but I was thinking that if you also included two Wight Kings in that unit you'd end up with a powerful, resilient and still quite mobile unit.

In a unit of say 12 Black Knights, with full command, and the 2 Wight Kings deployed 5 models wide, the Master Necromancer could then hide in the second rank, healing the unit safely by 4-5 models every casting of ION.

With 6 Attacks from the Wight Kings, 8 Attacks from the Black Knights, 1 swipe from the Master Necromancer, and 5 Attacks from the Skeletal Steeds, you have a pretty decent number of attacks.

The main Pros are, it's cheap compared to tooling up a Vampire to lead the unit (buying the equivalent magic levels are expensive); you can use that Vampire elsewhere; it is safer as the Master Necromancer is cowering in the second rank; and, compared to Blood Knights, you will be healing the unit by 4-5 models per casting of ION and one of the Wight Kings (with the Curse of Undeath), which should make the unit incredibly difficult to get rid of.

You can then of course start tooling them up, Banner of the Barrows for the unit, Screaming Banner or War Banner Battle Standard for one of the Wight Kings, and of course up to 150-200pts of magic items depending on whether you take a magical Battle Standard.

What do you think?
 
I have a few thoughts about it.

Firstly I think it's a really interesting idea and one which I had not considered. The problem of reliable healing for the Black Knights was one which had troubled me. I hadn't considered making it so the Necro is forced into the second rank. There would be two awful scenarios to consider however - one of the Wight Kings, or the unit Champion, is killed, meaning the Necro will move up and surely die to enemy RnF attacks. Secondly, some fast flyers or cavalry could get a rear charge and allocate their attacks to the Necro, almost certainly killing him.
It does seem to make the unit pretty expensive, at least 650 points, and the unit still doesn't have any 'god-mode' option which a Red Fury vamp offers. A Hero Vamp in the unit can be made very resilient and would still be able to heal a couple of knights every turn. I suppose the advantage, as you pointed out, is that your Vampire Lord is free to be elsewhere and the unit can still be healed effectively. Part of me wonders whether the Master Necro might be a bit squandered being relegated to this role, though.
On the whole I think it's definitely interesting. Please bear in mind that I speak only as a Warhammer player, I don't collect Vampire Counts (yet) so I probably lack the experience required for a true insight, but I know enough about them to have a good idea of their capabilities etc.

On further reflection I also considered a small unit - 6 black knights, one Wight King, and a lvl 2 Necromancer, deployed 4 -wide. You lose the rank bonus but the Necro can still stay in the back rank, can heal 3 Knights per turn, and the whole unit is much cheaper but still very resilient (okay, nowhere near as resilient as the first unit, but still...)
 
Vampire Count said:
I have a few thoughts about it.

Firstly I think it's a really interesting idea and one which I had not considered. The problem of reliable healing for the Black Knights was one which had troubled me. I hadn't considered making it so the Necro is forced into the second rank. There would be two awful scenarios to consider however - one of the Wight Kings, or the unit Champion, is killed, meaning the Necro will move up and surely die to enemy RnF attacks. Secondly, some fast flyers or cavalry could get a rear charge and allocate their attacks to the Necro, almost certainly killing him.
It does seem to make the unit pretty expensive, at least 650 points, and the unit still doesn't have any 'god-mode' option which a Red Fury vamp offers. A Hero Vamp in the unit can be made very resilient and would still be able to heal a couple of knights every turn. I suppose the advantage, as you pointed out, is that your Vampire Lord is free to be elsewhere and the unit can still be healed effectively. Part of me wonders whether the Master Necro might be a bit squandered being relegated to this role, though.
On the whole I think it's definitely interesting. Please bear in mind that I speak only as a Warhammer player, I don't collect Vampire Counts (yet) so I probably lack the experience required for a true insight, but I know enough about them to have a good idea of their capabilities etc.

Great points. Yeah, the [true] death of a Wight King would leave the Master Necromancer very vulnerable and it is a great deal of points. Perhaps I'm over thinking it, as you say, a resilient Vampire adds both to the combat potential and the raising of the Black Knights. Also, the Master Necromancer would be vulnerable to rear charges, once they'd thinned out the back rank somewhat.

Vampire Count said:
I have a few thoughts about it.
On further reflection I also considered a small unit - 6 black knights, one Wight King, and a lvl 2 Necromancer, deployed 4 -wide. You lose the rank bonus but the Necro can still stay in the back rank, can heal 3 Knights per turn, and the whole unit is much cheaper but still very resilient (okay, nowhere near as resilient as the first unit, but still...)

That sounds a much better idea. Could we even drop the Wight Knight, just have 5 Black Knights with full command and still place the level 2 Necromancer in the middle of the back rank if we go three models wide? If so that would be a nice unit to counter chaff/fast cavalry on our flanks. It would fit the theme nicely for a dead Bretonnian/Mousillon/Blood Knight army.
 
ChildoftheNight said:
That sounds a much better idea. Could we even drop the Wight Knight, just have 5 Black Knights with full command and still place the level 2 Necromancer in the middle of the back rank if we go three models wide? If so that would be a nice unit to counter chaff/fast cavalry on our flanks. It would fit the theme nicely for a dead Bretonnian/Mousillon/Blood Knight army.

Yes I guess once we lose a rank anyway we could go three wide, it would mean we could take such a small unit of Black Knights and still be reasonably confident that they'll have access to healing regardless of where they trot off to. I believe the Necromancer could still chill in the back as you suggest. I think the best thing about it is that we lose no attacks (well, apart from the horses' attacks) by reducing the frontage, as they only have one attack each anyway!
 
Little torpedo units of black knights bunkering necromancers sounds pretty hilarious to me. The healing offered proves an interesting tradeoff for the lost spectral movement.

I think the larger unit is trumped by a vamp lord, though. For around the same cost as the necro lord and two wight kings you could have gotten a level four red fury lord, which would add a lot more killing power, I think.

Or you could have grabbed Manny on a steed. I'm going to be trying manny in a biggish unit of black knights as a central battle line unit myself, but I'm not yet sure what the rest of the army should be to support him.
 
Since im using gamezones bretonian maid as a mounted (master)necromancer in my noble-lady themed army i realy love that idea.
Finaly a nice idea to put that model to good use and my enemys to shame with superior style.
Thanks for that idea. :D
 
Two major flaws come to mind
1) Relatively expensive unit (not sure of cost offhand but 12 knights, lvl 4 lord and 2 mounted wk can't be cheap :D?) This makes the unit attractive for multiwound/AoE type attacks/spells.
2) Survivability is reliant upon the necro getting IoN off. Basically, you're trading off the ethereal movement to guarantee IoN hits the unit. If you need those 5 wounds pretty badly, then I would count on your opponent dispelling IoN, kinda foiling the whole point of the setup. As a minor note, I think this would also mean if your necro rolled winds of death, then using it would hit his unit (since he has a rank in front of him).

I also think that the movement of the unit would decrease by 1 (since barded nightmares are slowed by barding)... in fact can master necros take barded nightmares? I don't have the book onhand, but I seem to think only vamps can barded ones. (Then again, Master necros can ride an AT so why not barded nightmare).
 
Can you force a necro into the second rank? Would he not be forced on to the end of the unit due to command and characters always in the front rank?

Wi.Mu.Sb.Ch.Wi.Nec
Xx.Xx.Xx.Xx.Xx
Xx.Xx.Xx.Xx
 
@ATP485: Yes, you can force characters to go into the second rank if the first rank is also entirely formed of models who have to be in the front rank - meaning command models & other characters. There is no rule forcing you to widen the front to fit all characters that are in the unit in the front rank. It's a pretty common tactic among ogres to hide their bsb.
 
Malisteen said:
Little torpedo units of black knights bunkering necromancers sounds pretty hilarious to me. The healing offered proves an interesting tradeoff for the lost spectral movement.

I think the larger unit is trumped by a vamp lord, though. For around the same cost as the necro lord and two wight kings you could have gotten a level four red fury lord, which would add a lot more killing power, I think.

Or you could have grabbed Manny on a steed. I'm going to be trying manny in a biggish unit of black knights as a central battle line unit myself, but I'm not yet sure what the rest of the army should be to support him.

You're right, the more I think about it, the more you may as well put the points for a Master Necromancer and 2 Wight Kings into a powerful Vampire Lord.

If Mannfred is going to be sitting in the middle of your line in the Black Knights, could you just use solid blocks of Skeletons either side? As you're basically forming an arrow/wedge with your attack. Would you try then to breakthrough their centre and then attack their rear?

Gurthaur said:
Since im using gamezones bretonian maid as a mounted (master)necromancer in my noble-lady themed army i realy love that idea.
Finaly a nice idea to put that model to good use and my enemys to shame with superior style.
Thanks for that idea. :D

That would look great ;)

Dklyn said:
Two major flaws come to mind
1) Relatively expensive unit (not sure of cost offhand but 12 knights, lvl 4 lord and 2 mounted wk can't be cheap :D?) This makes the unit attractive for multiwound/AoE type attacks/spells.
2) Survivability is reliant upon the necro getting IoN off. Basically, you're trading off the ethereal movement to guarantee IoN hits the unit. If you need those 5 wounds pretty badly, then I would count on your opponent dispelling IoN, kinda foiling the whole point of the setup. As a minor note, I think this would also mean if your necro rolled winds of death, then using it would hit his unit (since he has a rank in front of him).

I also think that the movement of the unit would decrease by 1 (since barded nightmares are slowed by barding)... in fact can master necros take barded nightmares? I don't have the book onhand, but I seem to think only vamps can barded ones. (Then again, Master necros can ride an AT so why not barded nightmare).

You're right, as Vampire Count and Malisteen have pointed out, it is a very expensive unit. The only time it might be useful is in very large games, where you might want that Vampire Lord elsewhere perhaps, say a unit of Blood Knights.

Yeah, ION would be key and based on that opponents would throw everything at stopping it, destroying the unit over two turns of shooting or combat.

As for movement, it's an odd one with the Nightmares, as Master Necromancers can only have Barded ones, while Necromancers can only have unbarded ones.

I'm pretty sold on the smaller unit idea, 5 Black Knight and a Necromancer on a Nightmare, seems like it could work quite well. Although, I have just realised he wouldn't get a Look Out Sir with 4 Rank & File plus the Hell Knight. Hmmm...
 
"As for movement, it's an odd one with the Nightmares, as Master Necromancers can only have Barded ones, while Necromancers can only have unbarded ones."

It's funny that, like they thought "better make sure the lesser Necromancer doesn't have access to the MIGHTY AND PRESTIGIOUS MOUNT THAT IS A BARDED STEED!"
 
Vampire Count said:
It's funny that, like they thought "better make sure the lesser Necromancer doesn't have access to the MIGHTY AND PRESTIGIOUS MOUNT THAT IS A BARDED STEED!"

I guess, in the long dark nights, as you slowly decay, hoping that you will either be turned into a Vampire or discover some ancient ritual to prolong your undeath, before the inevitable mental oblivion of becoming a Wraith sets in, having a Barded Steed is one of the only comforts you can have as a Master over your lesser Necromancer rivals ;)
 
I just want to say that I do not think that characters are ever supposed to go in the second rank. I think that this idea of putting 3 heroes into the unit with 3 command models so that one of them can be "forced" into the second rank is kind of an exploit. I do not think that it was meant to be like this. Even thought it is kind of fluffy (Necromcancer protected by the black knights), I don't think my gaming group would look too kindly at me if I used this. On the other hand this unit is not that good. Looks to me like will cost 800+ points. If you ever face dwarves with this setup (which I do), It will get shot to pieces and your invocation WILL BE STOPPED unless you irresistable force it.
 
Wojmir Von Carstein said:
I just want to say that I do not think that characters are ever supposed to go in the second rank. I think that this idea of putting 3 heroes into the unit with 3 command models so that one of them can be "forced" into the second rank is kind of an exploit. I do not think that it was meant to be like this. Even thought it is kind of fluffy (Necromcancer protected by the black knights), I don't think my gaming group would look too kindly at me if I used this. On the other hand this unit is not that good. Looks to me like will cost 800+ points. If you ever face dwarves with this setup (which I do), It will get shot to pieces and your invocation WILL BE STOPPED unless you irresistable force it.

As an Ogre player and VC player that exploits this rule quite often, I'd have to disagree with you. It's a rule for a reason. If you're willing to pay the points to make it so, I see no reason why you shouldn't be able to do this. It's not cheese or anything. Kill a character and then your necro must go to the front rank.
 
Xander said:
Wojmir Von Carstein said:
I just want to say that I do not think that characters are ever supposed to go in the second rank. I think that this idea of putting 3 heroes into the unit with 3 command models so that one of them can be "forced" into the second rank is kind of an exploit. I do not think that it was meant to be like this. Even thought it is kind of fluffy (Necromcancer protected by the black knights), I don't think my gaming group would look too kindly at me if I used this. On the other hand this unit is not that good. Looks to me like will cost 800+ points. If you ever face dwarves with this setup (which I do), It will get shot to pieces and your invocation WILL BE STOPPED unless you irresistable force it.

There are other exploits that people use that are against the spirit of the game and my player group frowns upon it. For example, in the old edition people would "over guess" their range with cannons to be able to hit something that they could not see. People declaring charges against units which they could not possibly reach, ie. the unit was 30" away but the charging player claimed that "they think" its 16" or less :O.
As an Ogre player and VC player that exploits this rule quite often, I'd have to disagree with you. It's a rule for a reason. If you're willing to pay the points to make it so, I see no reason why you shouldn't be able to do this. It's not cheese or anything. Kill a character and then your necro must go to the front rank.
 
Wojmir Von Carstein said:
Xander said:
Wojmir Von Carstein said:
I just want to say that I do not think that characters are ever supposed to go in the second rank. I think that this idea of putting 3 heroes into the unit with 3 command models so that one of them can be "forced" into the second rank is kind of an exploit. I do not think that it was meant to be like this. Even thought it is kind of fluffy (Necromcancer protected by the black knights), I don't think my gaming group would look too kindly at me if I used this. On the other hand this unit is not that good. Looks to me like will cost 800+ points. If you ever face dwarves with this setup (which I do), It will get shot to pieces and your invocation WILL BE STOPPED unless you irresistable force it.


As an Ogre player and VC player that exploits this rule quite often, I'd have to disagree with you. It's a rule for a reason. If you're willing to pay the points to make it so, I see no reason why you shouldn't be able to do this. It's not cheese or anything. Kill a character and then your necro must go to the front rank.

There are other exploits that people use that are against the spirit of the game and my player group frowns upon it. For example, in the old edition people would "over guess" their range with cannons to be able to hit something that they could not see. People declaring charges against units which they could not possibly reach, ie. the unit was 30" away but the charging player claimed that "they think" its 16" or less :O.

Well that rule was never stated, so it's a bit different. This rule is clearly stated that character models cannot displace command, and any extra characters are moved to the back rank. During combat these characters may use the 'make way' rule in order to move to the front of the battle. It's much different from exploiting a flaw in the rules and using a rule as it is clearly written and meant to be.
 
Wojmir Von Carstein said:
I just want to say that I do not think that characters are ever supposed to go in the second rank. I think that this idea of putting 3 heroes into the unit with 3 command models so that one of them can be "forced" into the second rank is kind of an exploit. I do not think that it was meant to be like this. Even thought it is kind of fluffy (Necromcancer protected by the black knights), I don't think my gaming group would look too kindly at me if I used this. On the other hand this unit is not that good. Looks to me like will cost 800+ points. If you ever face dwarves with this setup (which I do), It will get shot to pieces and your invocation WILL BE STOPPED unless you irresistable force it.

It might feel like an exploit, but it is also the rules. It also stops the reverse; having command, but screening the unit behind a wall of characters or bringing all of those character attacks into play.

I agree that there are a lot of points invested in the unit, but I was just trying to think of an interesting and new approach to using Black Knights with the new rules we have.
 
Malisteen said:
Actually, it doesn't stop the reverse, since characters may opt to 'make way' during combat, displacing even command models. It is an option, however, so if you want to leave the character in the second rank, you may.

Oh, good point, I'd forgotten about make way, which means you can still have characters pushing to the front regardless of command models.
 
This seems to come up alot....

Command models only push characters back when the character joins the unit BRB pg 97. When close combat starts characters must displace command models in the front line. On page 100 it says they displace command models in a fight. I used to use this trick when I played OnG to put my squishy goblin bsb in the back but they put it in the BRB errata that.....

Q: Must a character be moved to the front rank of a unit as soon as
a space becomes available? (p100)
A: Yes.

So no hiding character in close combat unless all the spots in the front line are already filled by characters.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu