Matt Ward - Hero or Villain?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
RE: The Lol Thread

Harland said:
ah yes, I heard about him. Not sure what he did, but I know it was bad.

He writes good rules. He gets a lot more flak than he should, in my opinion. But the one thing he did that put a void where my heart should be:

He retconned Necron fluff into the stone age by changing the C'tan from the invincible all-powerful rulers to the shattered servants. He changed Necrons from faceless, deathless machines of doom serving Star Vampires into Tomb Kings in space.

That is all I have to say about Mat Ward.
 
RE: The Lol Thread

Count Darvaleth said:
Harland said:
ah yes, I heard about him. Not sure what he did, but I know it was bad.

He writes good rules. He gets a lot more flak than he should, in my opinion. But the one thing he did that put a void where my heart should be:

He retconned Necron fluff into the stone age by changing the C'tan from the invincible all-powerful rulers to the shattered servants. He changed Necrons from faceless, deathless machines of doom serving Star Vampires into Tomb Kings in space.

That is all I have to say about Mat Ward.

'Nuff said really.

Cheers, Wolfie
 
RE: The Lol Thread

Count Darvaleth said:
Harland said:
ah yes, I heard about him. Not sure what he did, but I know it was bad.

He writes good rules. He gets a lot more flak than he should, in my opinion. But the one thing he did that put a void where my heart should be:

He retconned Necron fluff into the stone age by changing the C'tan from the invincible all-powerful rulers to the shattered servants. He changed Necrons from faceless, deathless machines of doom serving Star Vampires into Tomb Kings in space.

That is all I have to say about Mat Ward.

'Writes good rules' is a gross understatement. He is responsible for 7ed Daemons(remember that?) and the current Grey Knights book. That speaks for itself IMO.
 
RE: The Lol Thread

The thing that he seems to get the most hate for that I've seen is ruining the BRB lores with overpowered spells like dwellers and the lore of shadows.
 
RE: The Lol Thread

Thats Matt Ward....the Guy who $#()!ed 40k and Fantasy

Of the codex writers (Phil Kelly, Cruddance and Matt Ward) who would you prefer write your codex?
Cruddance made the Imperial guard crappy, except for one overpowered build. He made the tyranids... just plain crappy.
Phil Kelly just makes codexes a bit below average.
When Matt Ward makes a codex, he makes it only as powerful as any other Matt Ward Codex, and he makes every unit/option in the book useful and useable, which means you can actually build fluffy themed lists that work. If every codex was written by Matt Ward, we would have near perfect codex balance.

The necron fluff changes were actually a good idea. The C'tan still are all powerful star gods, but now there just are a whole heap more of them in the form of those who got defeated and split into shards, as far as I know the original 4 are still at large. (The old system had the nightbringer and deceiver being somehow in every necron army at once)
He also added some actual depth to the necrons.

What if he hadn't done those things?
1# There would be no way to justifiably field any kind of C'tan in your armies UNLESS only 1 in 100 necron players used them.
2# Every necron Lord would be more or less the same- a nameless, faceless necron lord just like every other one
3# No necron special characters other than the C'tan- see 1#
4# Necron units would be completely without personality, or even something remotely explaining why the exist (an emotionless, personalityless legion of machines would not have police or royal guard units or anything special like that)
5# The fluff would only justify necron warriors, immortals, tomb spyders, necron lords and monoliths... heck, the old fluff barely even justified destroyers or wraiths or flayed ones. It just said what they did on the battlefield with no real explanation why they existed.

edit: as for the over the top spells in fantasy- I welcomed those. 7th ed fantasy seemed a bit bland and boring to me without the over the top, insane magical/monstrous elements that the ORIGINAL fantasy had.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

I would rather they keep major characters out of the books. All special characters should be 'believable' as far as that goes in Fantasy. If you can't see Mannfred falling to common swordsmen, then have it that he can't, or highly unlikely. The rules to accurately reflect these characters would put them too high to be used in most games, and I think that's how it should be.

How, in keeping with the fluff of 40K, would a C'Tan be slain? The old ones, not the new. They should stick to that, and if it makes them unplayable, just don't include them. Sometimes it just detracts from a character to put them into a collection of stats that you can quantify.

To the topic on hand, Matt Ward, personally I like over the top rules. I do not like the overpowered spells, but I do think the fluffy rules should stay in. What I have always advocated for is that GW not be afraid to change the point values of their units. Just put the rules and abilities for all units in the book, and keep the point costs all online (with an army builder web program as well). That way, they can be more focused on the interactions, and less focused on balancing with points in a snapshot in time. If they miss something, they can always go back and tweak the points.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

That is a very good idea Grish, however it would never be done because if you don't need to look up the points of something in the book then you would probably never buy a new one. You'd just look at the rules of stuff and remember them; rules are a lot easier to remember than a different points value for everything in the army.

As for the overpowered spells, I like having them as an option to liven up a game, but they get used too much and abused into dictating which lores are competitive and stuff. I really like SoM for the cool uber powerful spells, and I play it now and then to liven things up. However I always see people either taking lore of life for dwellers or lore of shadow for pit of shades and the hexes of doom, or death for purple sun - other lores get overlooked because of these few spells.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Mr. Ward was, as I recall, responsible for the Army of Sylvania, which I enjoyed playing; he has successfully made Necrons interesting enough for me to collect them, and if the current WFB rules are anything to go by, he likes Dark Omen, so he can't be all bad. And he was involved (at least, his name was, although I hear rumours that that might be the limit of his involvement) with making the Lord of the Rings game significantly more fun for the bad guys.

However, he was also responsible for the Daemons book (the moment at which seventh edition nosedived), and he is apparently responsible for the Grey Knights and the subsequent homogenising of competitive 40K. So he can't be all good either.

Plus I'm told he's a bit of a knob to deal with in person. I wouldn't know, although I didn't think much to his promo video for the Necrons. He sounded bored, and that's never a good sign in a professional things-creator.
 
RE: The Lol Thread

Overpoweredness may be relative, however that is irrelevant to the issue at hand. GW don't seem likely to make Matt Ward(or anyone else for that matter) the sole codex/army book writer. Therefore as long as Matt Ward's armies are more powerful than Phil Kelly's, they are overpwoered.

Also, I have to disagree with Sanai's assessment of Phil Kelly and Matt Ward. My 'main' army in 40k at the moment is Dark Eldar, written by Phil Kelly. It is powerful, but by its very nature it isn't broken because it has a built-in Achilles heel, and IMO that's the way it should be. But more importantly, it is a codex where almost everything is viable. The only real stinkers, in terms of viability, are Grotesques and Mandrakes. Contrast this to the Grey Knights book. Matt Ward has apparently forgotten to give Grey Knights a weakness. I definitely don't mind what Phil Kelly did with the Dark Eldar, and I wish he would give CWE the same treatment. Also, don't forget that Space Wolves and Orks are both Kelly books, and he did pretty well in terms of power for both of them.

I do agree with Sanai's assessment of Cruddace though. Either he's overcompensating for what he did with the IG codex, or he just hasn't got this whole codex writing thing figured out yet. Besides Tyranids, let's not forget the travesty that is the current SoB codex. IMO he really crapped all over the new Acts of Faith system.

Also, I don't mind some of the new magic, but there are certain spells that just shouldn't exist in the form they actually came out. I'm referring specifically to Dwellers and Purple Sun, and Final Transmutation to a lesser extent. Same goes for the pre-errata Power Scroll, fortunately GW in a rare moment of clarity errata-ed that.

Sanai said:
1# There would be no way to justifiably field any kind of C'tan in your armies UNLESS only 1 in 100 necron players used them.

I wouldn't use this argument, because this logic can be extended to many, many things in 40k. How is Creed present at so many battles at the same time? What about Marneus Calgar? You could even say the same thing about Space Marines themselves. There are less loyalist Marines than there are planets in the Imperium, so only 1 in 10000 Imperial players should be allowed to play Space Marines, yet that certainly isn't reality.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Let's not forget the Tomb King book. There were some great ideas in it but they were poorly executed. Some units were made all but unplayable.
It appears Mr. Cruddace has gotten the hang of writing fantasy army books with the new Empire release, however.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Oh we get to talk about Cruddace?

Well having looked through both of his 8th ed fantasy books I must say TK is the better book. But this is not the place for this.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

On Mr. Ward,

The Daemon book was an abomination. I played against it and played with it (short lived mono slaanesh list) in 7th and it was grossly overpowered. Even under 8th edition rules which were created to nerf them, vampire IoN spam and lizardmen (so it was said), they still dominate most other armies and they won the last few 'Ardboyz tournaments.
I have never understood why the author of a book couldn't just look at the current line of codices (look at that! we learned a new word! xD ) and create something that was at the same power level as everything else.

On Mr. Cruddace's Tomb Kings effort,

I have to disagree, Johnny. I play both armies and the Empire book is a much better creation than the TK's. The Khemrians suffer from a LOT of issues while the Empire is a pretty solid list where you won't get crushed for taking something fluffy or for using whatever models you think look cool.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Matthew Ward is currently tied for best codex author with Phil Kelly. The only reason people complain about him is because they jump on the bandwagon. He turned Necrons into one of the most interesting and intuitive armies, and if anything, turning the C'tan into the servants only increases how terrifying the Necrons are when you realize that they are strong enough to turn reality altering gods into their slaves. And out of all of the books, what is complained about the most? Space Wolves and Imperial Guard. Matthew Ward is the reason this game is still fun. Not anything against Phil Kelly, of course, as he is still an amazing author and gave us Dark Eldar.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Coming in joint first isn't much of a feat when there are only 3/4 authors (I think, not so hot on 40K stuff). But anyway, I have heard him criticized in the context of fantasy a lot more than 40k. Perhaps it's something to do with getting carried away with how much better fantasy is than 40k...
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Ehm...we aren't jumping on any bandwagon. Speaking for myself, I voiced my opinion based on my own personal observations and gaming experiences. I've played in casual environments, local tournaments and 'ardboyz events for years so I've been able to look at each army book from different levels of competition.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Rules-wise he does some very nice and interesting stuff and his armies are only "OP" because there's one thing that is entirely GW's fault as a company. It's the way they handle writing new books.
They should work together more closely ie. all the codex and army book writers should come together after a new edition and start writing whilst exchanging ideas.
Also, what happened to play-testing?

When it comes to fluff however yes I really do "hate" Matt Ward but fluff is a personal affair. Also people say they hate him are just being stupid, I mean did they even meet the guy IRL? The fact that somebody does something you do not like doesn't mean they are complete you-know-whats immediately. But yeah I absolutely hate the new fluff, hating Matt Ward, not at all. Never met the guy.:)
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

A little from Column A and a little from column B.

He's both depending where on the fence you are.

remembering some of the folk that have worked for G.W.....cough*Gave Thorpe* Cough... the BRB, Army Books etc could have been a LOT worse!!!!
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Chaos_Born said:
I too am very against over use of 'hate'. As Dr. Cox said, it removes the power of the word

But as Yoda said "Fear leads to Anger, Anger leads to Hate" And trust me I fear that Ward will touch my armies fluff....
 
I personally feel that Warhammer is a hobby first, and anything else .. like fourth.

It's always surprising to me to hear that this game has tournaments, considering the lack of concise rules (Wording changes from book to book, and plenty of rules are left in a state of 'Is this really how it works?' without erratas or even with the erratas), and the generally agreed un-balanced armies. Granted many of the complaints of an army being better than another may be because of a poorly played game, or list, and not realizing such. And I've certainly seen just as many players boast that they can defeat most-to-all opponents even given their 'Broken status'; But again, player skill must factor into there somehow, and it's nearly impossible for most players to look at their flaws as a tactician many times, focusing on 'Special rules' or 'Bad rolls' that crippled them, and sure maybe sometimes bad rolls really do screw you over, but it's a hard game to learn with all those things thrown on top of each other.

I just recently got back into Warhammer (FB, no 40k as of yet) after many years away, but I'm not too displeased with the majority of things. I think the 'Over the top' spells are a mixed-bag, but I generally lean towards the idea that they don't really make the game more fun. The only time I truly find the gaming part of Warhammer all that relevant or fun is when both players are into their personal fluff and making a story of a battle, rather than a soulless roll-off. The rules in general are pretty wack, I mean, they hardly have base-line points values for effects of common items (100 Pts for wizard had seems pretty radical), and plenty of units can get lost in the mire of being forced to take optimal builds just for the sake of not throwing the game?

Naw, I like Matt Ward. He helps fuel the company that, IMO, makes great minis, but I don't give too much thought to their rules. I haven't seen this 'Necron fluff re-vamp', though I have heard plenty; I'll reserve my judgment instead of basing it on hear-say (Although the Angels/Necron alliance does sound a bit.. off the wall..).

As for Special Characters in general? Yeah, I think the rules don't represent them fully, but I also think the rules for Warhammer are a bit too watered-down/mechanically light (I mean D6s only, really?) to allow any better than two children playing solider and saying "NO I shot first, you're dead!". Either give them god-mode status (Can't die/ kill hordes every turn or such) or just slap a different name on their 'Rule set'. But that goes back to how the story of an individual game matters to me; I would never play a game with special characters mostly because I don't believe they should be portrayed as they are, although I wouldn't not use their rules, I'd just call them some other low-life. Where as I would, and gladly, set up an elaborate scenario where two armies are fighting and making rules to govern the near god-like powers of special characters ripping through an army whilst some other objective is being fought over, obviously not a Death or Glory sorta thing.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu