RE: The Lol Thread
Thats Matt Ward....the Guy who $#()!ed 40k and Fantasy
Of the codex writers (Phil Kelly, Cruddance and Matt Ward) who would you prefer write your codex?
Cruddance made the Imperial guard crappy, except for one overpowered build. He made the tyranids... just plain crappy.
Phil Kelly just makes codexes a bit below average.
When Matt Ward makes a codex, he makes it only as powerful as any other Matt Ward Codex, and he makes every unit/option in the book useful and useable, which means you can actually build fluffy themed lists that work. If every codex was written by Matt Ward, we would have near perfect codex balance.
The necron fluff changes were actually a good idea. The C'tan still are all powerful star gods, but now there just are a whole heap more of them in the form of those who got defeated and split into shards, as far as I know the original 4 are still at large. (The old system had the nightbringer and deceiver being somehow in every necron army at once)
He also added some actual depth to the necrons.
What if he hadn't done those things?
1# There would be no way to justifiably field any kind of C'tan in your armies UNLESS only 1 in 100 necron players used them.
2# Every necron Lord would be more or less the same- a nameless, faceless necron lord just like every other one
3# No necron special characters other than the C'tan- see 1#
4# Necron units would be completely without personality, or even something remotely explaining why the exist (an emotionless, personalityless legion of machines would not have police or royal guard units or anything special like that)
5# The fluff would only justify necron warriors, immortals, tomb spyders, necron lords and monoliths... heck, the old fluff barely even justified destroyers or wraiths or flayed ones. It just said what they did on the battlefield with no real explanation why they existed.
edit: as for the over the top spells in fantasy- I welcomed those. 7th ed fantasy seemed a bit bland and boring to me without the over the top, insane magical/monstrous elements that the ORIGINAL fantasy had.