Matt Ward - Hero or Villain?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Zephyr said:
Also people say they hate him are just being stupid, I mean did they even meet the guy IRL? The fact that somebody does something you do not like doesn't mean they are complete you-know-whats immediately. But yeah I absolutely hate the new fluff, hating Matt Ward, not at all. Never met the guy.:)

I know him, or knew him, not seen him in a few years, but he was part of our gaming circle prior to working for gw, he is a nice bloke, an old guard player (hence the return of a load of the old things we used to have, % organisation charts, shed loads of common magic items, insane spells, I mean do anyof you remember assault of stone as it used to be? Pick up a hill or simmilar terrain and drop it on the enemy army ;) ) the bloke signed the online petition to get himself fired! I think the wardie bashing is kinda sad tbh.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Seneschal said:
On Mr. Ward,

The Daemon book was an abomination. I played against it and played with it (short lived mono slaanesh list) in 7th and it was grossly overpowered.


^
This. Matt Ward ruined competitive play in 7th edition with the release of this OP piece of crap.
 
How is Creed present at so many battles at the same time?
You can easily justify it by saying that your creed is another clever imperial general- There are alot of those in the universe, but there are only a very tiny amount of C'tan.

Also, Phil Kelly's Dark Eldar book is okay, but all of its special characters suck. The Grey Knights book is not as overpowered as the majority of people think- there are several armies capable of giving Grey Knights a run for their money, its just a matter of knowing how to put together a competitive army.
The same goes for Daemons of Chaos- they only really appear overpowered to the player who doesn't know how to play competively.

If you want a real overpowered army, look at meltavet chimera manticore executioner guard, which are a Cruddance army.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

hornywingythingy said:
the bloke signed the online petition to get himself fired! I think the wardie bashing is kinda sad tbh.

Heh at least he still has a sense of humor about it though I can imagine it must be hard to read what some people write about him online.
Negative whining is not helping but some constructive criticism will, though tbh I laughed myself silly at a cartoon with a Blood Angel and Necron doing a brofist.

As for special characters I only use them against my friends in specially made scenarios. I think most of them are so mythical they cannot be represented well stat or fluffwise for reasons already given. Options for normal characters should have be a lot more diverse or some option to build your own special char; extra choices not normally available and only able to include one such build in an army.

Don't agree that all Dark Eldar special chars suck, a lot of them do suck (oh the images), but depending on your build there are two that really shine.
I love special chars but would rather see them removed now that I thought long and hard about it. Nostalgia makes me say keep em though...
 
The thing I like about special characters is they can be used to represent your own characters that do not fit the normal *insert normal unit here*
I.E. I can use Al'raheim to represent a platoon commander who is skilled at raiding or Creed to represent the presense of a Guard General as opposed to a Colonal/Major or Marbo to represent an Imperial Commando.

Or I can take Mogul Kamir in a unit of Rough Riders JUST to make my opponent fall on his face laughing his ass off at my choice of unit.
 
On the topic of Matt Ward...

I cannot lift my opinion on him in terms of who he is (never met him) so can't take him on personally.
But why oh WHY do games-workshop let him anywhere NEAR fluff? And as several people have pointed out
the issues revolving around the deamons debacle, and the necrons, I won't go near it. But let me ellaborate
on my experience on Matt Ward.

I was a lizardmen player since around 5th edition (the edition with lizzies/brets starter?) and once they
got an upgrade in terms of fluff in their previous edition. I LOVED IT! The had this fluff of saurusses
not being smart, but having an instinctive feel for strategy/tactics (depending on age/spawning). It was
so greatly written! I loved it! My win/lose ratio was crap, but I enjoyed it so much....
until...
That man was allowed to touch their fluff. Have anyone ever bothered to read their current fluff?
One of the slan essentially died because he was thinking of a deamon. One of the special characters
is a SC because he stood still in a slann's chamber for thousand years... Doing NOTHING but drooling.
I'm sorry that is just ridiculous. And he just dropped of ALL the spawnings? Why oh why?!

I actually sold my Lizardmen army after reading the book and playing a few games. Since fluff is a
great part of warhammer (at least for me). I can only enjoy an army's mechanics if the fluff
support it. Now try to imagine what our list would have been if Matt went near it.
 
Actually, you know what one of the worst bits of fluff rape ever was?
Having the C'tan in the necron army book as anything other than shards.

These are the FIRST beings to ever exist, that fed on stars and devoured entire species. The orks were created just to fight of their minions, and the eldar were created so that their psychic powers would subconsciously create the eldar gods to fight them.
Yes, Khaine, Cegorach, etc, were all created out of desperation by the old ones (by creating the eldar) so they could have something to go toe to toe with the C'tan.

Having the Nightbringer in non-shard form on the tabletop would be like having Khaine on the tabletop. Did the eldar ever have Khaine on the tabletop? No, they just have Avatars of Khaine- which are shards of Khaine.
If the Nightbringer isn't a shard, he should cost 10 million points and be able to wipe out all of the armies of the planet by devouring earths sun.
So we have C'tan shards, which is a much more reasonable way to field them on the tabletop without their stats failing to do them proper justice.
 
RE: Matt Ward- Hero or Villian?

Zephyr said:
hornywingythingy said:
the bloke signed the online petition to get himself fired! I think the wardie bashing is kinda sad tbh.

Heh at least he still has a sense of humor about it though I can imagine it must be hard to read what some people write about him online.
Negative whining is not helping but some constructive criticism will, though tbh I laughed myself silly at a cartoon with a Blood Angel and Necron doing a brofist.

yeah, no its never easy to see people slagging off a mate just for doing his job, especially when they forget the other things he has done (wood elves for example, and the previous orc and goblin book.) the thing is 8th is a bloody amazing set of rules and well and truly sorted out 7ths problems, but its only with time we see how broken the 7th stuff is as the new 8th stuff starts to Fill out.

If you don't like the fluff stick to the black library books, the fluff in the army books is a chaser to the main thing which is a set of wargaming rules!
 
Fluff is so personal but once something is established and pretty much covered in multiple books (be it gaming or stories)I like to see things you know...NOT CHANGE AGAIN!

GW is famous for doing this ever since day one but it's not small but dramatic changes and it's no wonder people are angry with it. Matt Wards is certainly not unique in changing fluff trust me. And BL books can be horrible as well, I recall reading about a murder scene where somebody was shot through the head with a bolter *wait for it* silently and a clear bloodless hole through the head.:slapface:

Now how they use the (please let it be for once truly) established fluff in army books is a different matter. I agree that C'tan on the tabletop is just nuts. That is not a fluff-rape IMO but just a horrible way of applying it to tabletop.
Like I said some chars are ridiculous and should stay mythical beings rather than "yeah my army general!"
 
Why are people on this forum (and other warhammer related forums) so negative?

When I walk into a gaming club or games workshop, I see a bunch of people enjoying themselves, socialising and having fun, enjoying their hobby. When I look at the various warhammer related forums such as this one, I see a seething mass of discontent and negativity with a few people who actually like the game defending games workshop against ten times that number who speak like games workshop is the archenemy of all mankind.

Why are those two different views of presumably the same people so jarringly different?


No, games workshops latest price increase or new range of paints is not a greedy price gouge designed to alienate you or pauper you.
No, games workshops latest army book was not written with the purpose of making your current army useless on the tabletop in comparison.
No, games workshops latest bit of fluff is not a personal attack on you designed to ruin the style of your army.
No, winning the game of warhammer/40k is not the only way to enjoy the game (Would a hobby in which the only one who enjoys themselves is the winner be worth playing? That would mean the only way you enjoy the game is by making someone else not enjoy it)

Sure, games workshop makes mistakes- but that is because the guys who write/sculpt/design/market for warhammer are human beings like the rest of us.



Also, if you were a Blood Angel, on a planet with necrons and tyranids on it, and the necrons offered not to attack you if you dont attack them while you both focus on the tyranids, which would you choose-
Option A: Fight a battle on two fronts, leaving neither the Necrons or the Blood Angels strong enough to survive the tyranids.
Option B: Temporarily stop attacking the necrons so you can wipe out the tyranids and survive the battle. You can always purge the necrons later.

Option A gives you- 1 dead force of imperials, 1 dead force of Necrons, 1 alive force of tyranids.
Option B gives you- 1 alive force of imperials, 1 alive force of necrons, 1 dead force of tyranids.

Both options purge one force of xenos from the galaxy (option A has the necrons killed by nids, option B has the tyranids killed)
So its simply a decision- are the Blood Angels more useful to the Emperor alive, or dead? If they are alive, they can purge more Xenos for the Emperor, and protect more imperial worlds, and probably hunt down those necrons, giving us the potential for 2 dead forces of xenos.
 
I think it comes down to what you want from the hobby, I'm primarily in it for the gaming, the fluff doesn't bother me too much as I tend to use homegrown characters with their own fluff (though I did once have fun running vlads vampire circus vs empire armies, but if you are putting all the carstein vamps in its less horrific as its themed.) other people like the fluff more than the gaming, oh and then there are just the people who like to moan! ;)

I can't really comment on bl quality, its really not my cup of tea, I prefer hard sci fi.
 
I don't hate Matt Ward, I only dislike some of what he has done(neutral about the rest). I think the whole idea of Matt Ward hate is a misnomer actually, I doubt the vast majority of so called 'Matt Ward haters' actually hate him in the literal sense of the word. A man isn't his work; thus I say I dislike some of his work. I have nothing against him in person, so I wouldn't make any ad hominem attacks.

Sanai said:
No, winning the game of warhammer/40k is not the only way to enjoy the game (Would a hobby in which the only one who enjoys themselves is the winner be worth playing? That would mean the only way you enjoy the game is by making someone else not enjoy it)

If this is what you really think of 'competitive players', then it seems that you don't understand the mindset of such people. Yes, there are people like those mentioned above. They are commonly known as 'asshat' or 'douchebag' or <insert equivalent term of your choice> . 'Competitive' players don't enjoy winning so much as they enjoy the challenge involved in trying to win. If there is no challenge, then there is no entertainment. WAAC jerks are not 'competitive players'; there is no 'competition' involved in the curbstomping that ensues when a WAAC guy bullies a newbie with a tournament army. A competitive player would attempt to avoid the situation as much as anyone else would, because he derives no enjoyment from it, unlike 'that guy'.

It's the journey, not the destination that counts.
 
Sweeney, I don't think that all competitive players are like that- Its just that many are, and many, many of them feel negative about losing a match/ about anything that impedes them winning a match.
 
@ sweeny Todd, you have to accept there are a lot of people with a 'whatever it takes' attitude to play, they are less concerned with the enjoyment and more concerned with the win. I was in a games workshop on thursday, where players were advising wraith walls in zombie units as valid for everyday play. I'd feel dirty using it in a tournie, let alone a game at your local club/store. Its heavily prevalent on the net too, one player on the tyranid hive actually said that anyone talking about taking a fluffy list wanted to lose to have something to moan about.
 
Sanai said:
Sweeney, I don't think that all competitive players are like that- Its just that many are, and many, many of them feel negative about losing a match about anything that impedes them winning a match.

I may be oversimplifying things, as I don't know the details, but I get the impression that you're implying that the people you're talking about are whiners/moaners. If that's the case I'm skeptical as to whether they can be considered as 'competitive players'.

hornywingythingy said:
@ sweeny Todd, you have to accept there are a lot of people with a 'whatever it takes' attitude to play, they are less concerned with the enjoyment and more concerned with the win. I was in a games workshop on thursday, where players were advising wraith walls in zombie units as valid for everyday play. I'd feel dirty using it in a tournie, let alone a game at your local club/store. Its heavily prevalent on the net too, one player on the tyranid hive actually said that anyone talking about taking a fluffy list wanted to lose to have something to moan about.

That's more a matter of the local meta. If it's considered acceptable to play that way within that club, then I guess there's nothing wrong with it. 'When in Rome do as Romans do' and all that. It only becomes a problem when someone intentionally brings a 'hard' list against a 'soft' one.
 
I'll say this about Matt, the power gamers seem to love him. Both our fantasy WAAC players worship his throne often, to the extent that when I first voiced interest in 40k and SoB they picked up the Grey Knights book to flip through. :frown: Also the 'known cheating'(weighted dice and edited FAQ's) shop nearby is flush with his thralls.

Bad players aside, not impressed with his work. He errs too often on the side of OP even if just by a little, his fluff reeks of ego and many other foul smells(see: Grey Knights), and if its not his army (as in one he plays) they're screwed(in more ways than one, see: 5th ed SoB Codex and yet more Grey Knights) I know most of my examples are 40k, but he's had more time to show his colors there.

For more info: List of Matt Ward's War Crimes
 
Zanos said:
Wow, posting 1d4chan links. Those aren't filled with bias or anything.

Bias doesn't equate to falsehood.

Most of what I linked I knew before I discovered 1d4, they just put it so nice and neat with a pretty marine bow on it. xD
If I wanted REAL biased hatred I would have linked to 1d4's 'Smurf' page, they hate Ward's Ultramarines with a passion only the Blood God could comprehend. :devil2:
 
If you take 1d4chan seriously, then you have not been on the internet long.

However, I think this topic can be summed up with one phrase: I see you have an opinion. That's cool, but mine is better.
 
Zanos said:
If you take 1d4chan seriously, then you have not been on the internet long.

Never said I took them seriously, but the majority of their distaste in Ward is by no means unfounded. Also the particular links I gave are embellished a fair bit but by no means untrue. The 'incident' on Van Horne is canon (the truth is more messed up than half of the stuff on 1d4), the "history of violence" is also crap he really did do, and he really does OP anything he likes while screwing anything he doesn't. I'm just happy he HASN'T done much with fantasy recently. Seriously, he writes anything similar to some of the abominations he has for 40k for fantasy and it might be my reason to pack up and bow out for 5 more years.
 
I'm pretty sure nobody else in the industry generates as much nerd rage as Matt does. :mad2:
 
1d4chan is full of a bunch of overexaggerating whiners. Their rage about the Blood Angel codex is unfounded beyond belief, as there is not a single thing wrong with that codex. The Ultramarines being looked up to, and spiritual liege and all that -- Ultramarines provided the gene seed for at least 50% of the successor chapters! Of course most of the chapters would look up to them!

He took two armies that previously had next to no fluff (or ability to win, at all, besides some stupid gimmick list) and turned them into great codices. People complain about Grey Knight fluff. What about it, exactly, is so bad? Grey Knights killing Sisters to use their blood in a ritual of warding? You know, because Grey Knights don't do rituals to ward corruption away or anything. They've never done that. Kaldor Draigo? Oh, well excuse me, I don't want the chapter master equivalent of the most elite variation of the most iconic army in this game to be awesome, we'll just have him kill an Ork warboss or something.

Necrons? There is not a single darn thing to complain about in that codex, other than their elite section being underwhelming as heck. It's extremely balanced, has great fluff, and basically pulled a Dark Eldar off because it brought an army back from the grave and did it good.

Most of the people I see complain about playing against Space Wolves and Imperial Guard. Why? Because they've got some really stupid builds that scale really well with points. Grey Knights definitely aren't unbeatable, and I'm sure most people just complain about them because they're a rather easy army to play, (as all space marine armies should be) and because so many people play them. People play them, because they are a cool army, with a fun play style and cool mechanics. Ward is where it's at.
 
I would listen to Zanos, he is possibly the best competitive 40k player I have ever known. If anyone knows about army power levels and balance in a competitive environment, its him. (After his tuition, I am not really too afraid of Grey Knights, but I am bloody terrified of space wolves. So many missiles!)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu